← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/25722/2024dismissed

Manjit Singh @ Manna v. State Of Punjab

2024-09-09Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri14 pages



  



  !"!#!$!!! !# ! 

#%&'(#&)*+*',--

 .*%/*012  

/%%&'(3.4  

  

 5*+1625*+13  

/%%&'(3.4   -----&+7'&% +

 8&./*01#1*66'  

/%%&'(3.4  

 

5

39&&7/*01  

/%%&'(3.4



 

!,  :";- / !/

/        

    !"  # $  % &'(     ' )*'( 

    ++$# # $  '*  

    ++!, # $   - 

    "#". # $  - '(/ / 01 !/

/    < -

96    3    1    (     4 $! 5        & 6 4 $!     10 0 4   *)+&+ 7      (       6           

   &5% )      (   ( 1     1  ' $., 

 &     ( 1 



5%  87$$    ,7# # #    '   7  7   !9 "  " ,9+79:! 8;'  (   ''35 %  ;   ''8(    . 3  5%6 (1   &   1)              &)  0  '(  <  < ( 0'(611 ((  1  )    1 1    &&

 (           &  1 1(  6  6  6 =  6   >(?)

 1 1 > & 6 3   6 =   6  #777 # #   7:( 

+(  % =(   

6 & & =    66  (  

  &)0'(<6     (6   7:(  @ + (  % =      0'(< 1  

    '  " % =         6         )    .  (      3    0'(<#777 # #   6) #.77 # #   &) >6   &   6   7#( 

  6 6    &  &) ( 0'(   <    

 

++$# # $ 3 ( 0'(  )1(  ( 11)  4 $ $    (1  0 '(<  !"  # $ 1&  )

&#777 # #6  & .) 7#&   &   8;' 6  6    )

7::(  (   7::(  6  & & 0'(<16 & 1 

   & 

 (   3 5%6  (     (     5%@ 1&6 1       1  )&    @

1&  &1 6  6

 1) 6   1)    

     )1&   

   6 &1) %  (      5  1  ) 6      

   &        &    1 @ 1&  

&)' '(( 0'('(< <&'(<&&*6*  0  <  0)*& </)</ )1(  ( 1 1)  4 $ 1( )6

   ( 1@



1&   ((    )   6

14&  ":

6

       ( 11   (   !    (1   <

   ++$# # $ 1&  ) & #.77 # #6  & .) 7#&   &   8;' 16  )&           6)  & 6   1)      6 

=     &)0'(< 6   &6& 6   7:( 

   ( 6)  >  6    6  )&    @ &

  

1)  4 $   

&)( 0'(66 1 (  >  (6      )1(  ( 11)  4 $    

4 ) )6

&)( 0'(    ( 1)(   ) 1 (  ( )1    )  .

) 7#)     ( 

( +    (1  /  '(   "#". # $  1&  ) &



#.7  # #6  & .) ,&    &   6    8;'  

    %     6  &    1     

  

& 

&)0'(<       )& &1) 6(   ) $7:( &

 &&@ 1&    1 6    6  

  

6& 

   & 

 &

1         0(& @A1' &

 

 

  (  

 )1(  ( 11)   4 $@    1& 

  ( 1)1     1 1  ( ) )  6  

61(  ( 11)   4 $4 

( 0'( "     (1  0 '(;  ++!, # $ 1&  )

&#!77 # #6  & .) 7#&   &   8;' @ 1&     0'(;  6 & 1 

   & 

&)0'(< 1 1   ) &  0'( ;   ( 1)( 



 )6 

61(  ( 11)   4 $1 (  ( )  ) (   :                  

1&  6  )   ( 6  & #!#7 #    1 & )  1& 1)     (  6  (  &  "#$ # .     6

6 4&  & )  6 )6 

   (   ( 11      6 ( &     ( ( 6  

4&(  6

  6)   6

14& & 6

  66      ) 14&(6   ((  1 (         &)1  

( 13) 1&   

 6      6  1(

 1)     3) 1&   

 1  6   6  )(        6     (6

 16  6     &        5%6  (    (  6)    &       (   ( 1

=

, B  - '(/   / 01 1&;   /    '35 

        

1)        ) (6

@ 1&   

     1.) 7#& 

   &

&)' '(( 0'( '(<<&'(<&&*6*   0  < 0)*& </)</ ) 1(  ( 11)  4 $( 

  (               (          6

6 4& &@ 1&6

  6

14&  

((              (    ?)      &    )   ( 1

&()  )  )6

1   &  6

6 4&@6   ( 

 1);    /   '35 1& )6  ( 6  & #!#7 #    

 

  &&   6

 1 7) 6      & )  &(       (          

   

     6

6  &&@ 1&  

 1) ;    /   '35  



 && 1)       

   

 &&    & &&    

1)   

 #$ # $   7##! # $ @ 1&6 (   6  

    0   0 6 

 

6 (     6  6  6  6 

 (&1   11)   



 )&0      

 @ 1&   &

(  1 & -           &  6       (6

 1 &     ( (6   5% 6  (    

 ((      

@ 1&6 1    ) &    6

 1      &  

 1) ;   /   '35 1 

 %   /   ' 3 5 ( 1

 )  ;'B

 66(&

   )6

61 &&

&  1        & (     )  1      ;   /   '356      

  

%   /   ' 3 5 ( 6   ) &)6  

1);   / 



   01  6 1)        1  

          &  (     6

1            1  1 )   )  (   8;'  (6 ) 1 )1   

&   /  1&6

   &  6   ((

      

( 1 )  )6

@

1&  ((  ?) @  7 (  &  0'(<7#(  &   < 6 6 (   6) 

&  ( ) ( ) && ?)     )    1)1   ' ."  8;'      

( 1 7# %        77 3       ? 1   )    

 ( 6 ) 

 ( 1 '    / '(

  1 )  .) ,& 6

   6    )

 &&  6 &5%%6    

   &



&)0'(<6  



&&() 6   $7:( &

@6

&1 

   & 

 &) ' '('(<<&'(< &&*6*  0  < 0)*& </) </4 

( 0'(66  & 1 

   & 

614 1   ( 11)  6 0(& @A1 ' &  

  !"   0(&

@A1' &   ( ( ) "

#"$ "

"%"&'   "

( ) ) *+

 "

 ,  -$&.



/0 1, "2#" 3' 4"5" !  6'$!! " 

//7  .85"3 "

 9 1! 6'$!! " /7-3 

 1(  ( 1  & )(   (   )6 

   &     

 6 / '(  )6

      ( 1 7  '    0'(;  

 &1 

   & 



  )  .) 7#& (  &   8;' ( &1                6   )

 && 3     ) 0'(;  )6





)(   )1  (  ) (    (   ( 1 7. '     <   

1&   8;'  

)  1.) 7#& '     <

  (  &5%1  6

    6)  (6& 6   

( &)( 0'(1  < ( 0 '(6 &5% && 6 ( 

7#(  1

( 0'(  ) 1( 1   ( 11)  4 $ 3       )      <

  )6

( 0'(

116   ) 6  ( )        (   ( 1 7$ '    0'(<     1 )  1.) 7#&  &   8;' 6 6  (   & - ) # #  6   7::( 

 & 

6 &1



    &       (              3  0'(<6 &5%  



5%   (   &6  

   #777 # # && 6   ( ?) 7:(  @ +(  % =(   

    66   ( 6   .(  @     6    7(   + (  % =     0'(<

 (  )6 

6 )1 (  ( 11)  4 $1   

 6   &) 0'(<

1 &1 )6

6 1(  ( 11)  4 $1    0'(<6       #777 # # 6 &5%  (&  1)       1  )&     1 &( 

 (  11    6 6  )&   ) &  6   3  0'(<  )  1.)  7#& 6   6

14&3 ;   /   '356 

1           6

    ( & (616 (       6

 61((      6

   (1    6&3     

 

 6     0'(<       ( 1&  &(    &1   ' ." 8;' 6  &&    6   ( ?) 7:(  +(  % =(   

    66   ( 6   .

(       6    7( 

 7! %6  1 1  1)

/ '(0'(; <  63)

1   ( 1 10    (11  )



     9;)(     7+ '    0'(<       

  ( 1   1

1)&  &

 7" @6 )(1   1 1 

4 

 &   &     (   ) --   !/

/   

#  C  (  D 98 C   1  D 98