High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/523/2018dismissed

Surjit Singh v. State Of Punjab

2018-01-22Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma5 pages

!" #$%$!&'(( )*+,$)$&-.

$$!& + / +%*% ) !" %1!&2 &

+ % &' +()()( .3425!# "!+. 1 $$!& +( +( *+ 5 +-.*+$6 4223(((4 0( +(&7!3

&)$2.*4)+(25!# 6$. +( 7) .$425!# "!+. #!713 &(

$$!& +4 6.! .

% + $+ 2 "+!7 . 1!% !" ) &$!+ )*1 +$& &2 &!" !3$# 4.

%"$3 2. $&% &1 $$!&% 9$&-#!&# %%$!&!"

1+ ++ %0 $3$&# % (( (!(2 2((:*&2 +% #$!&%

26$.% #$!& !". + 5 &$!&!"!++*1$!&#4+ -$% + 2

!3$# ) $!&4/$-$3

( +$ "3;&!$# 24 .

%0 &+ -$% + 2!&. $!&%!"

1 $$!& + %%$&- 1+!1 +; &2 6 3. 2$%1+!1!+$!& ! .$% 9&!6& %!*+# %!"$&#!7 &20;+ %!+$&-!#!++*17 &%( !*&% 36!*32#!& &2.

% 0 &"

3% 3;

$713$# 2( $%%*07$ 2.

. 1 $$!& +,!$& 2

!&% 03 $&. ;

+<: &20;2$&!".

+26!+9 &2!*% &2$&- 1 +"!+7 &# 4 1 $$!& + +& 2 1+!7!$!&% *1 ! . + &9 !" ) &$!+ )*1 +$& &2 &!" !3$# (/ +$!*%#!77 &2 $!&# +$"$# %6 + +2 2 !. 1 $$!& +2*+$&-.$%% +5$# &*+ ( 6 &. ; +%: 1 $$!& +$%% 2!.

5 1!% 2 %)*1 +$& &2 &!" !3$# 4/$-$3 &#

=*2.$ & 4 +!> 1*+ &2 &2.

+($%"*+. +*+- 2.

. % +5$# + #!+2!". 1 $$!& +.

%0 &6$.!*03 7$%.( $$!& +$%% 2!

5 %*1 + &&* 2!&(("+!7. + &9!") &$!+)*1 +$& &2 & !" &2. + " +-+ & 2 ? &%$!&$&% +5$# "!+ 1 +$!2!"6!

;

+%(!*&% 3 +-* %.

. $&@* %$!&$%. + %*3!"5$#$7$> %7*#. %. 1 $$!& +.

2$& ++!- 2!& ).(.

&2 +)$&-.

346.!6 %.!32$&- $&$% +A%+ &9 &26 %25$%!+!. .$ "

$&$% +4) !" 02*+$&-. 1+ 5$!*%!&-+ %%+ -$7 $&. )

2*+$&-. ;

+%!: &2&!6.

. !&-+ %%

+;.

%+ *+& 2 !1!6 +$&. ) !" 04 "

3% # % .

%0 &"!$% 2*1!&.

1 $$!& +%! %!% 3 %#!+ %(!*&% 3"*+. +#!& &2%. . .

0 &+ -$% + 2$&1*+%* &# ! #!713 $&.

5$&-0 &"$3 26$.. .$ "

$+ #!+4/$-$3 00;) 0,$)$&-.+ 6 34 1 +7 & & + %$2 &!" ()( &26.!$%+ 3 2!.

&2 +)$&-..

3(!*&% 3

+-* % .

5 & .!*-.4 5$-$3 &# $&@*$+; $% % 2 ! .

5 0 & #!&2*# 20*. 1 $$!& +6 %!&3;# 33 2!&# 0;. &@*$+; ""$# + &2

6. + $& #!713 $&"!+7 $!& .

2 0 & "*+&$%. 2 0; . 1 $$!& + + - +2%. 2 $3%!" %% %!6& 20;.$7 3%!.$%"

7$3;7 70 +%($% *+- 2.

. 1 $$!& +$%+ 2; &26$33$&-!,!$&$&5 %$- $!& &2*&2 + %*#.#$+#*7% &# %. 0 1+! # 26$. &!+2 +!" $3( !*&% 3"!+. 1 +$ %.

5 0 &.

+2( 1+ 5$!*%2 !".

+$&-$( (!&((.$%!*+.

9 &&!$# !". "

5$-$3 &# $&@*$+;.

20 &#!&2*# 2$& 1*+%* &# ! 1+$5 #!713 $&.

5$&-0 &3!2- 23 5 3$&- $!&%

$&%. 1 $$!& +(##!+2$&-3;46.$3 1*$&-3 #!*&% 3!

&!$# $&. 1 $$!&4$6 %2$+ # 2.

. + 1!+!". 5$-$3 &# $&@*$+;

6 %#!&2*# 21+$!+!+ -$%+ $!&!". 40 1+!2*# 20 "!+ .$% !*+( *+$&-. #!*+% !"+ %*7 2.

+$&-43 #!*&% 3 %"*+&$%. 2#!1;!"+ 1!+%*07$ 20;. )()( (4/$-$3 *4

&- 4

3!&-6$.%*11!+$&-2!#*7 &%(. + 1!+.

0 &1 +*% 2( 11 + &3;4 . /$-$3 &# 1 +7 &B&@*$+; ""$# + .

+ #!+2 2. % 7 &%!"5 +$!*%+ 5 &* !""$#$ 3%40 &9!""$#$ 3% &2!. + 1 +%!&% &2.

3%!#!33 # 22!#*7 & +; 5$2 &# (5 &. 1 $$!& + %# 33 2*1!&!"*+&$%.2 $3%!". 7!5 &2$77!5 %% % . 32B #@*$+ 20;.$7 3%!.$%$77 2$ + 3 $5 %(. #. #91 +$!2.

0 & 9 &!0 (C(<<<!((C( = +& 2 ) #!*&% 3 .

% 5 . 7 &3; !11!% 2 . $&% & 1 $$!&0;#!& &2$&-.

. 2 $3%!" %% +% 7!5 &2$77!5

"*+&$%. 20;. 1 $$!& + + #!713 5 +$ &# !. $&"!+7 #!33 # 20;. /$-$3 &# 1 +7 &2*+$&-. #!*+% !"$&@*$+;(.

& $5 #!&#3*%$!&2+ 6&2*+$&-. #!*+% !"$&@*$+;$%.

. $&#!7 !"

. 1 $$!& +"+!7.$%9&!6&%!*+# %!"$&#!7 "!+. #. #91 +$!26

%(44<4<B6. + %. 1 $$!& +.

%% 21+!1 +; &2$&#*++ 2 ?1 &2$*+ !" %(4<4:4B(. ##*% $!&#!7$&-"!+.$& &*%. 33 $%.

%% 26 3.B$&#*++ 2 ?1 &2$*+ !" 7!*& !" %(4D4::4<(1 $% $& ?# %%!".$%9&!6&B2 #3 + 2%!*+# %!"

$&#!7 &2"!+. #. #91 +$!2( = #!*&% 3.

%*+- 2.

%+ # &3;

+ $+ 2"+!7 % &$!+1!%$$!&$& &2.$% +%6.$3 #!33 -* %

&2%*0!+2$& + %$33$&% +5$# &2*&2 +%*#.#$+#*7% &# %.

C 1 $$!& +6!*320 $& 1!%$$!&!.

71 +. #!*+% !" "+ &2"

$+ $&5 %$- $!&4$"4$&%*3 20; &!+2 +!" $3( . !&A03 )*1+ 7 !*+$&# % !"

0!+ 2*1!&. "

#% &21 7 +%!0 9 &$&!#!&%$2 + 6.$3 2 3$&-6$. 113$# $!&B1 $$!&% 9$&- $3(6 !0% +5 2.

6.$3 #!&%$2 +$&-. 1+ ; +"!+ $3 0 &# %!0 %+*#90 6 &6!"

#!+%& 7 3;4&!1+ ,*2$# %.!*320 # *% 2 !. "+ 4"

$+ &2"*33$&5 %$- $!& &2. + %.!*320 1+ 5 &$!&!"

%%7 &4.*7$3$ $!& &2*&,*%$"$ 22 &$!&!". ##*% 2( 6 "*+. + !0% +5 2 .

. #!*+ $% !03$- 2 ! #!&%$2 + . + %!&

11+ . &%$!&!" 71 +$&-!". 6$& %% %!+ 11+ . &%$!&!".+ !.

#!713 &( . $!&% $&%. 1 $$!& + + % +$!*%$&& *+ (.

1 $$!& + 33 - 23;$%% 2!.

5 7$%*% 2.$%!""$#$ 31!%$$!&6.$3 .!32$&- % &$!+1!%*&2 +. !3$# %! %!#+ 5 % %% %0!.

7!5 &2$77!5 03 ( 1!+!". )()( (4/$-$3

&- 4

&2!&. 0 %$%!"6.$#.. $&@* %$!&.

20 & + -$% + 24 $&2$# % 3 +- &*70 + !" + &% #$!&%( . 7 + @*$+ % 2 1 &2.!+!*-.1+!0 (. 5$-$3 &# + 1!+$% 3%!$&2$# $5 !". "

%&!#!7 #3 &2+ 5 3 2. #!713 +*. % + - +2% . %% % . 32 0; .$7 % 3%! .$% $77 2$ "

7$3;

7 70 +%( . 13 !"1!3$$# 35 &2 + $% 20;#!*&% 3+ 1+ % &$&-.

1 $$!& +2! %&!$&%1$+ &;#!&"$2 &# ( &%*#.+ - +23

#!*&% 3.

%7 2 # -!+$#% 7 &*1!&$&%+*#$!&%"+!7&%1 #!+

+$1 3)$&-.4/$-$3 &# 1 +7 &4

. 1 $$!& + &!% 2 $& ++!- 2 +( .

&2 + )$&-. .

3 2*+$&- . 1+ 5$!*% !&-+ %%+ -$7 &2 6.!% 0 . %$$% 33 - 2.

. 1+$5 #!713 20 &7 2 3 2$&-!. + -$%+ $!&!". ( &. !

3$;!"#$+#*7% &# %4.$%!*+$%!". #!&%$2 + 2 5$ 6.

. + $% + %!& &2,*%$"$ 03 -+!*&2!0 3$ 5 .

$&# . #!&# %%$!&!"1+ ++ %0 $3$% ? &2 2!. 1 $$!& +4. 7 ;7$%*% %*#.#!&# %%$!& &2$%3$9 3;!#+ %$* $!&6.$#.6!*32&!0 #!&2*#$5 !.!32$&- "+ &2"

$+$&5 %$- $!&(

!+. + %!&%+ #!+2 2 0!5 4.$%!*+2! %&!"$&2$!0

"$# % !-+ &#!&# %%$!&!"1+ ++ %0 $3!. 1 $$!& +(

$$!&4 ##!+2$&-3;4$%2$%7$%% 2( $%4.!6 5 +4#3 +$"$ 2.

. !0% +5 $!&%#!& $& 2$&.$% !+2 + + #!&"$& 2!&3; %+ - +2%#!&%$2 +$&-. 1+ ; +!". 1 $$!& + % 9$&- $3 &2. % 7 + &!!$&"3* &# . #!*+% !"

$&5 %$- $!&$&. 7 +(

3*#9;

E. . +%1 9$&-B+ %!& 2'

%B!

E. . + 1!+ 03 '

%B!