High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/30902/2021allowed

Varinderjit Singh @ Goldy v. State Of Punjab

2022-04-07Mr. Justice Vikas Bahl25 pages

!"#"

$ % &'('

!" #

$% &" !"

'()*)+'+)+,

- !"

'((+.('+)+,

% / - # # "1 1" " 2(* 34 ,5 ,()++)+, " +, 6 +* 7" " - "

" " ,*89 : ;7- " <= "

# - "

'()*)+'+)+, ;

! < " ((+.('+)+, ;

! < >

'()*)+'+)+,

% " "

" 1

$ "

1 "

! 1" 1

!1 "

# ?00 "

!1 ?1 "

- &"% - " 0 0 #

# ?00 "

!1 ?1 "

@ @ 1 ! "1 "% !! "1 " 1 " " 11 7 "

# ,2)++)+, # & $! A" " !

!1 "

# # " "" B" %# # # # " "

1 1 C 1

"" # " 11 "" 1 ,()++)+, )8 ,)

% &

" #1 " #

: '((+.('+)+,= " " 4! A" 1

4" 4

# ""1 " " "1

1 % "1 & " 4! " " 1 # "

4 # #

: = # 1 4! " " " # # 1%

4! "

# " &'25'

'8(8) # % !

! # " # 1 #

# 4! " #

1 " " " "

0 "1 % & " 1 1 ! ! )9)(+)+, " 1!

0 B B '2 ! 1 #! ! )+)(+)++ " " 1

" 1 D 11 ! 1 : 1= $ "

++).+)+, ! # " 1! " # "

( ( " ! 1 ! "% 1 ! " 34 D # " 34 # # 1 ,, 28 34 # 1 0 - 0 $% $%

1 ,) () $ " 1 """ 1 34 ; 1 1 +),)

++() < 1 1 )8 ,) " #

% # "% )8 ,) 1 & " #1 4 1 34

" 1 1

# #

!1 "

1 1% " 4 1 1 "

" " 1" "

" 2+ 7- " " " ! " 2+ 7- "

! "1 # 1"

" 1 "!

% # # " ! 34 " % " # 1 1 8 ,) ,) () ! " 2+ 7- " # # D # # 4 1 "

# %

)

# # # " " ! "

# " # "" !" " $ "

1 " &"

!" #

$% && '( )* + ,-.,/

,/12 " "

" "1 " " "% # # "

# $ " 1 " ! " ! " ())

1 # # ! 4 " 1

% # " " " 1 # " 1 " ! " &" )+)8+)+, 3344-53,-,. 6 & * # " & * %&&'()* +

* # 7'! % && '( )* + ,-,.8

8/- %9

!"#%%*%&&'()* + ,-,.,

581 +8)++)+) 335-,/3,-,-

9":

!"# 9"%&&'()* + $ "

! 1

! " " ,()++)+, !! " "" % % 1

$ " ! 1

4 """ ! " " 1" 0 "

# # 1 " " # 1 1 " # # 4 1 "1" " 9) 7-

" ""

# E " # 1 "! " # "

" E " ! " 11 $ " !

11 " 1 #

"" " '+,,8+'+)+, #

% ! 4 ! # # " " # # "" " 1 ( 2 ! 4 1

# " " "! " 1 " 1 % # # ! # "

&25'

'8(8) "1" !

" 9) 7- "

# !

E " "

E " "" 1

& 11 " - " ! 1 # D "1 "

" 9) 7-

" "" " 11 # 4

# #

" 1 "

# "" ! " # "

()) 1

# ! # "! 1

" 4 1

" 1 "

!1 "

" @#

# "1

+),+ " #

: = '

" # 1

" +),8

%# %

"1 4 1 " 1 " 1 # " "

"'""

'((+.('+)+,= " "

1 1 %# # # $ 4 1 "

" D : % " % = #

1 " 34 ! D ! ,) () D : 34= # ; "

+ # 1 % < ! 1 ! " 2+ 7- "

! " 1"

D 1

% # 1 "

$ " B '( #

% 1 " " 1 1 $ " 1

&" '*!" ;'& ;% '

& ' * * *;9 ': $% : " ,-,.8 1,.

# " " 2+ 7- "

1 D " 4 1 " "! ()) 1 " 1 "11" D !

" (. 7- " # # "" "

" (. 7- " $ "

" "

" " 1 # "

! "

$ "

1 ! " # D ! # D #

" # 34 1 "

% "

# # #

" "

! "

# "

! 4 1 1 ! 1 D C 34 "

"1"

" 2+

!! " 4 "

# !1 "

# ?00 "

!1 ?1 "

- &"% - " 0 0 # # ?00 0"

!1 ?1 "

@ @ 1 31 !1 1 "

& $! A" " ! 1

!1 "

# #

" " 1 # #

" # # " 1 # * 0 -" 0 0 " 4 "

"" 1 11 1" 8

'()*)+'+)+, #

" "" "

! " # $ %

& ' ( % ) * ) $+* ,%

# ' - . %# # &

% / % , (

'! *

% " # $ * ( #

'! ), (!

) 0 ' % % ) . 1

2342*!2 #

' ! ( ) ), * !!/ ! % * ) ) ' ' 5

), 6% ! % *

' ), * , 5

0 *

! # # # "" ! # )8 ,) ,()++)+,

# "'""

! % & " #1 # " &'25'

'8(8) 4 "" 1 " " 1

A" 4" 4

# "

4! "

# 1 4! " 4 ! #

# " # 1 #

# % 1 4! " "1 "% 1 B % ! ! # " #

4! " 4 ! " "

0 "1 % & "

B '2 )9)(+)+, #

0 " 0 " # #

0 " & " % # ! " # " # " 4 1

4" 4

# # ! 1 ,()++)+, ,2)++)+, ! ++).+)+,

" 1 " &"

! )+)(+)++ "

0 "

,.)(+)++ A ,.)(+)++

# 8 $ !% *'

$ 9', %*'

!..1

3 %!.$2$2

!.$2$2 :

$ /'%*'

$ 9

" % *'

!..1

3; %!.$2$25553 !.$2$2

;

$ $ 6 %9*"% &) $

%*'

$ /

%*'

! , <<<< -

% 2

! 82 ) '

+ ) , = ,) ' ), > &) % , , $+*> ) - %

' )

$ 9)&

+ . % * !!/ % * , ,

%* !!/ % ! 5

% ' & *& ;

$ % >9??

*@# *+ 6, 6A9"?7 #

% ) !!/ 9' ) ' ),

), 6% ! % * 5

# % (

$ 2 % 9)& + . % * ,

$ % * # ' ) '% ) '2 9 6% * ' ) 9 6% * ) '2 !!/ ) 82 > ., ! , !.$2$2 : B / & C " , /

&) % !.$2$2

2 B & @ / &) % 2 - 9 D 6% * )

! , , ) ) 9 6% * ) 9 6 ) E > / & " , ( % )

,% ) 9 6% *

8 * $ ' '

)

% . % #% !#* % *% /

% ( !

) !#* % * # & # !#* % * ) 9 6% * 3

8 * $ ) '2 E > ' ! ,% " . % * 9' 9' ) 9 6% * 3

8* $E >' 9 6% * = !!/ 3

% / & ( ) ' ) >

% ) / & " , (

% * % !!/ ) E >' #

% ) 9 6% * !!/ 3

9 6 , '

' !!/

) !!/ 9 6% * = !!/

) '2 )

) ) ' ! 3 3 *& 3 3 9 6%* - F ., , 9 6% * ,

* , )

.1-8,-,, <7 = 4 " +8)(+)++ # 1 - " / 1 0 !

(

" #' !!/

$ G% *'

/ & C " , 6 6 @% *'

% 0, % *'

% ( % /

% % * '& % * )

# !!/

' ) ' H !!/ ' I- "I

,% ')

$% ' ( '% '

) ' ')

!!/ ' ) % ' ) ! %

) / & C " , ( % * ' ' %) 8

$% ' 0 % * % ' ' ') '

) ' ') ,% ' ) ) !!/

% , ' J%)

$ % '

%) ') * % ) % !!/ % ' I GI > ' , ' ) 4

$ % 0 ' ' ') ?' , ' ) ' J %

) ' ,% ' ) )

) !!/ % !!/ % ) / & C " , (

% *% !!/ ) ! ), 9 @% ' %* ! # # ""

0 "% # 1 " " ! " " # "% ,()++)+, 8 ,)

#! " )8 )8 % "1 & " 1!1 1 # 1 # % % $ "

1 "" #

!1 1 "

)8 ,)

% " " " 1 4 # ! ,, (* # # # B $ " !1 1 4! ! " # # "

" " # B 3 # # 8 ,( #

" "! #

# # # % % " # !

0 ! # 8+5 # # # B $ "

!1 #

# " # #

# % # !

""! !

!1 1 1 ! # # 1

" ! " " " 1 # "! " ,) () # 34 : B ',= "1 ( 1 1 8 ,) # 1 "" #

1 1 # " # "% 1 % & " " # 1" # "

!" # # "

4 1 "

" ! "! 1 ; !< !

11 " '+,,8+'+)+, #

" # # ( 1 ()) 1 # # ; !< 0 ! (

! "

# 9 %

, ' ' ) ) '

% ) '

/ & C " , >) (

), # .

& ! " &"

% # "11 " # " " " 1 " &"

& * # " &

* % " :=

! ) ' J#. 1

% ! % 9 % 19 * % 2

, , )

) K! ' L + ) , ) ) ' ' , , , , ,

) , ) ' %

- %

) ' )

, ) ( '% ) '

) 3 K L , K = ,L +

'% ' ' , , ) ) )

) : ;, # '

' ) ) ! #

) ' )

), , ) # ,, ,

)

F ') !,

) , ) ,

+ ') , ' ',) , ), #

, ' ' ) '

' , ) ) )

) : # ' , , ' '

' %

)

) )& ) )

! F! 6 $F9, $

>"A./#19?.#1"("#++ 6A9"?7 1 # #

" "! # "11" D # " "! # " 1

1 1 " " # ! #

% # "11 " # " " # " "

!" # %%* % " := "

! 1 1

"" " !

1 " . ! + + ' &) >!.$2$ 1 4 ! 2

@ " '

&) >!.$2$ 1 353 $ ' &) >!.$2$ 1 5 :

) ')0

, , ) )') ,

% ) )

', = ,

)

,% & ) ) % )

, ' ' , * %

) ' 5

:% % ,) )

+ ! F9, $%

7 &"

* # 7'! % " :=

+ ' , ) , ( , , , % ' , ( , ' ' , (

J#.% , )

(, % , ) + , ), 0

) , ,

) ') ) ( J#. )

, ) ( )

000 + , ), , ' .& % 9, % ! % J

* , , ;,

( ) ' % ' ) ),!

* ) ' ' % )

)),

, ' ' , ' # ' , )

# ' , '

, ) ! ) 1 ,

% , 0

% )

) )& = ) ) F,) ! ! 1 # # " # " # "" # " 1 1 9":

!" #

9" % " := &"

+ ! ! 2

! I!.$2$ 1 353 2

@ " ' &)I%

)') ) 9 % ,

) % % '

' ' , 19 * , )

)% ) ),

), ) % ) ' ' , 19 * ! , ) ) * %

, ),

% ) ) + !

9 ! # D # # "1" " 2+ 7- " # 1

> " " (. " ,*89 # ! ! 1 F

1 #

>> '?/2 '( ,-,. 6<"

= F

1 " # "

# # " ,+) % " ;

< "11" D #

"' &"

1 ; 9*%" *0 # '

* $ && '( )* += ,-.5 4

54 " ! " (. " ,*89 B " # !! "11" D !

1 "

; > >) >% ! ) )'

I ,

% ! = ) ), % ) )

) , * ) '% !

)% ,% ) % !

)

, I ,

I I

19 * I ) )%

% % ' , ) ) , ,

) (

% ! = )

" $! :

1= - 72+5)* +),8 1 ' &"

# 1

3 ! +9)++)+, '+),..'+)+)

' &"

"" # # !! " # "! # (8 % ;"

< :"11" D = " , . 1 0 # F 1 ! +2)8+)+, " $! :

= 7989+C+)+, 6 ;'& ;'

& ' * *$ > ''

'&" =

F 1 4 ! ,+,)+)+) 1 7558 +)+) 60 &

!" # '

$ 0;" ) %"= # " !! ( % 8)) 1 ;"

< 1 " "

# % % 1 ""

4 1 78+. +)+, ;*9 0 *%%

$ && '( %&"

'&" = F B ! 1 ,58+)+, # # D

" # "11"

' &"

,)(2('+)+, ;@ *0 #

* $ && '( )* += "" 1 ! A (,)(+)+, % "

" (. " ,*89 # " !! "11" D " # 1 #

" # " +,

1 #

( '% ) )&

, ,

19 * )

)% ) ) ) )

) ), 3 -! &"

! 1 (,)8+)+, '8+5+'+)+, '

'(.+,'

& +),9 ; >

!" $% & $%& !&

! !

'&" = " " # "! # "11" D 4 !1 -! &"

% "

! # "" C"!" " +, 4 # 3 1 F 1 && '( <"

$ '9%"

" " ,-,. 2 1,4 # % "" ! " (. " ,*89 # " " " ' # 1 "

" " '

# % " # 1 -! &"

1 <

!" $ && '( )* + ,--1 .

8./ !# % -

F " := # # 4 ! 1 # "

(

" # "!" " -! &"

'(..('+),* 1 :-=',*8'-&'+),. ! 1 ,+),+)++ " 1 ! " "" 1% " #

1 " +, 4 !

"" " ! " " (.

7- " 0 ! ! 1 1 "

" "!" # "

1 4 1 D1 " (. " ,*89 ! ! % " 1 " " # " 1 " D G 1 # !

! ! " !! "11" D 4 "

! " " ,()++)+, :, , 1 +2 = !! " ! "1 "% " &"

" #

! " "

! % % 1 !

" #

! " ! !

1 "

" # 1 "

" (.

" ""

) " C " C- " 1 D " 0 #

, # 1 #

+ # EC 1 " # := ( # B " B1

2 "11 " 1 " #

"" "11 #

9 " " 1% "1 1 "D #

" " 1C 1 "

" " " 1 #

#! 1 " " "

# 1! " ""

7 ! " B 1 " # " ! 1 " # "

,- ./ 01

23"4 &5 9' @ > %

HC7 > HC7