High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4829/2005dismissed

Deepak Jain v. Hukam Chand Sharma And ORS

2018-08-09Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu4 pages

!"# $#%&'&() ##*!+!&( ,**#--!(" .#/'0'

0+!1 2!($32!/1!!($"2#/' ,#'*($#("' /#'#(") '32& !-& 4!-5$6%!"# / /.!/0(''!/5$6%!"# /"2#!**#--!(" /##*!+70($05$6%!"# //#'*($#("'!($ 3#/6&%# /#'*($#(" 8 $&'*#('#$ 9&"2 6&$# /$#/ $!"#$ : /306&/#9!(5$6%!"# //#'*($#(" ;;; <= **#!- &' / '#""&(> !'&$# $&'1&''!- "2# %-!&1 *#"&"&( !' /$#/#$ ?4 "2# -#!/(#$ "/ %%&$#("' -!&1' /&?0(!-5 !>!$2!/& 2#/#&(!

"#/ /# #//#$ " !' @"2# /&?0(!-A5 / !--9&(> "2# %-!&1 !($ !9!/$&(>%1*#('!"&(!'%-!&1#$ <= /&# !%"' "2# %!'# !' '#" 0* ?4 "2# !**#--!(" ?# /# "2# /&?0(!-!/#"2!"("20(#552#9!'>&(>"#-2&&(2&'%!/

BB B C:92&%29!'?#&(>$/&6#(?42&'$/&6#/5!1701!/D2#(

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

("!-''0'"!&(#$&(E0/&#'G#!/(#$%0('#-%("#($' "2!"'&(%#%!("#/9!'*!/+#$("2#9/(>'&$#5"2#/# /#5"2#!**#--!("9!' #("&"-#$"?#!9!/$#$%1*#('!"&(%-!&1#$ < = #/%("/!5-#!/(#$%0('#- /"2#/#'*($#("'%("#($#$"2!" "2# !**#--!(" -$>#$ ! ( C &( /#'*#%" "2# !

"$# 1#("&(&(>"2#/#&("2!""2#!%%&$#("9!'!%2!(%#!%%&$#("52!$%%0//#$!-- ! '0$$#( !($ (?$4 9!' !" !0-" 9#6#/5 !

"#/ "2/## 4#!/'5 %-!&1 *#"&"&(9!' &-#$&(?4"2#!**#--!("%-!&1&(>%1*#('!"&(G#!/(#$ %0('#-%("#($#$"2!""2##6&$#(%#(/#%/$/#6#!-'"2!""2# !0-"& !(4 9!' #F%-0'&6#-4 "2!" "2# !**#--!("H' %!/ 92&%2 9!' (" ?#&(> $/&6#( */*#/-4!($"2!"2!$*/*#/$&'"!(%#?##(1!&("!&(#$?4"2#$/&6#/ "2# !**#--!("H'%!/ /1"2#"/0%+?#2&($92&%2"2#!**#--!("H'%!/9!'>&(>5 "2#!%%&$#("90-$("2!6#"!+#(*-!%# <C= $1&""#$-45"2#!%%&$#(""+*-!%#(C!($! 9!'/#>&'"#/#$?4"2#!**#--!("1#("&(&(>"2#/#&("2!""2#!%%&$#("92&%2 2!$"!+#(*-!%#9!'!(!%%&$#("?4%2!(%#!($"2!"(?$49!'!" !0-" %-!&1*#"&"&(92!"'#6#/9!' &-#$&(/#'*#%" "2#!%%&$#("#F%#*"!

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

/!>/!*22!'("&%#$"2#'"!($ "2#*#"&"&(#/"2!""2# %!/9!'!"!$&'"!(%# " ##"?#2&($"2#"/0%+ <= 2!6#%('&$#/#$"2#'0?1&''&(' -#!/(#$%0('#-!($!1 "2# *&(&( "2!" "2# $&'"!(%# ?#"9##( "2# !**#--!("H' %!/ !

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

+#'5 "2# 6#2&%-# %0-$ (" !6&$ '"/&+&(> "2# %!("#/ < = ( "2# %&/%01'"!(%#'5 "2# &($&(> "2# -#!/(#$ /&?0(!- "2!" "2#!**#--!("9!'("#("&"-#$"!(4%1*#('!"&(#F%#*"0($#/3#%"&( "2# "/.#2&%-#'%"5 &'E0'"!($*/*#/!($$#'("9!//!("!(4 &("#/ #/#(%#?4"2&' 0/" <= %%/$&(>-45 &($&(> ( 1#/&" &( "2# !**#!-5 "2# '!1# &' $&'1&''#$ 3D!-&! 0$># !1&" D2#"2#/'*#!+&(>J/#!'(#$ ) #'J D2#"2#//#*/"!?