High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/6361/2017allowed

Rakesh Kumar Gupta v. State Of Punjab And ANR.

2019-10-18Mr. Justice Manoj Bajaj9 pages

"#$#$%&"' ()"*+ ,-(' ,.#(+(*/$0"1#+$*."#$#$%&,&1"'

"2#$%& 3 '

/%' 4,(*+$&5 #+" '"6$*$%&(0 %,'# %'1"' 1(#"1 7 89&&":,'";<+"'"=>#+"%'1"'/'(-$&5%/2+('5"=>#+" #'$(0 %,'# 1(#"1 ?

@ 9&&":,'" ; $& 2(*" % 1(#"1 ,&1"'"2#$%&@ %0$2"#(#$%&$6$*$%&% 7 ,1+$(&( 9&&":,'";<(*,.+"01

+"/(2#*$&='$"/0"(1$&5#%#+"."#$#$%&('"(*,&1"' +"*,=A"2# % 1(#"17 ,&1"'"2#$%&@ %0$2"#(#$%&$6$*$%&% 7 ,1+$(&(<(*'"5$*#"'"1,.%&(&(..0$2(#$%& 5$6"& =>'"*.%&1"&# % &(-"0>"A$&1"'(0 $&5+<+"'"$&$# <(* (00"5"1#+(##+"(22,*"19."#$#$%&"';<%')"1#$00#+">"('$&+$*%#"0

&(-"0>+$6(B'$6(#" $-$#"1(*(.('##$-"22%,&#(&# & #+"(22,*"16$*$#"1#+"%#"0#%*""#+"1%2,-"&#*(*#(:'"#,'&/%'#+"0(*#7 >"('*<(*'"4,$'"1#%="/$0"1<$#+ "5$*#'('%/ %-.(&$"* ,'$&5#+(# 6$*$#(*$5&"12+"4,"%/#+"2%-.0($&(&#="('$&5% ?3$**,"1/'%- 22%,&# % 83 &1$(& 6"'*"(* (&) <(* /%,&1 -$**$&5 & $&/%'-(#$%&$&#+$*'"5('1<(*5$6"&#%#+".%0$2"<+$2+<(*'"2%'1"1(* % @8 1(#"1 $-,0#(&"%,*0> %& 7 #+"

2%-.0($&(&#+(1$&#$-(#"1#+"=(&)'"5('1$&5#+"-$**$&5%/2+"4,"(&1 $**,"1$&*#',2#$%&*/%'*#%..$&5#+".(>-"&# &8 16%2(#"

$)(* ,.#(*"&#('"5$*#"'"1&%#$2"%/1"-(&1%/70()+*(*#+"2+"4," /%'(*,-%/70()+*.'"*"&#"1=> ()"*+ ,-(' ,.#(*#%%11$*+%&%,'"1

22%'1$&5#%#+"2%-.0($&(&##+"*($12+"4,"<(**#%0"&(&1-$*,*"1%& => ()"*+ ,-(' ,.#(#+"'"=>2(,*$&5<'%&5/,00%**(&1#+" =(&) %//$2$(0* <"'" +(&1$&50%6" <$#+ #+" (22,*"1 & #+"*" ='%(1 (00"5(#$%&*#+" <(*'"5$*#"'"1,&1"'"2#$%&@

/#"''"5$*#'(#$%&%/#+"2(*"$&6"*#$5(#$%&<(*2(''$"1%,#(&1 #+"'"(/#"'(/$&(0'".%'#,&1""2#$%&?@ '

<(*/$0"1="/%'"#+" %,'#

.%& .'"*"&#(#$%& %/ #+" 2+(00(& #+" (22,*"1 9."#$#$%&"'; /$0"1 (& (..0$2(#$%&,&1"'"2#$%&@C37 '

/%'1$*2+('5"

#<(*.0"(1"1#+(# (/#"'1$*+%&%,'%/#+"2+"4,"(2%-.0($&#,&1"'"2#$%&@"5%#$(=0" &*#',-"&#*2#<(*/$0"1(5($&*#"A$&1"'(0$&5+92%-.0($&(&#; <+"'"$&2%5&$B(&2"<(*#()"&=>#+" %,'#(&1#+"#'$(0$*(##+"/(5"&1 # <(*.0"(1"1#+(##+" $*&%#+$&5=,#(2%&2%2#"11"/"&2"*"#,.(5($&*# #+"*($12%-.0($&# '"/"'"&2"$*-(1"#%#+"'".0>/$0"1#%#+"0"5(0&%#$2"

@ =>'"*.%&1"&#% "A$&1"'(0$&5+<+"'"$&$#<(*20"('0>-"&#$%&"1=> +$-#+(##+"."#$#$%&"' ()"*+ ,-(' ,.#(<(*<%')$&5(*(&22%,&#(&# <$#+ C*+$6(B'$6(#" $-$#"1#$00#+">"('(&1(/#"'#+(#+"+(1&% 2%&2"'&<$#+#+"*($1."'*%& &#+"0$5+#%/#+$*2(#"5%'$2'"*.%&*"#+"'" <(*&%%22(*$%&/%'#+"2%-.0($&(&##%5"# "#,'&/$0"1<$#+#+" "5$*#'('%/

%-.(&$"*$&#+">"('#+'%,5+ ()"*+ ,-(' ,.#( &#+""&1$# <(* .'(>"1 #+(# #+" (22,*"1 =" 1$*2+('5"1 $& 2(*" % 1(#"1

+"#'$(0 %,'#6$1"$#*%'1"'1(#"1?

@1$*-$**"1#+"

(..0$2(#$%&(&1.'%2""1"1#%/'(-"2+('5"*(5($&*##+"(22,*"1/%'#+" %//"&2".,&$*+(=0",&1"'"2#$%&@

55'$"6"1(5($&*##+"*($1%'1"'('"6$*$%&<(*2(''$"1="/%'" #+" %,'#%/110 "**$%&*,15" ,1+$(&((&1#+"'"6$*%&(0 %,'#(0*% .'%2""1"1#%1$*-$**#+"(..0$2(#$%&(&1,.+"01#+"%'1"'%//'(-$&5%/ 2+('5"*(5($&*##+"."#$#$%&"'

"&2"#+".'"*"&#."#$#$%&

"('&"1 2%,&*"0 /%' #+" ."#$#$%&"' +(* 2%&#"&1"1 #+(# #+" 2+"4,"$&4,"*#$%&<(*1(#"1 (&1<(*1$*+%&%,'"1%&@

#<(*.%$&#"1%,##+(#(/#"'1$*+%&%,''"*.%&1"&#% (*)"1#+"."#$#$%&"'

#%.'"*"&##+"2+"4,"(5($&$&#+"#+$'1<"")%/%6"-="'<$#+#+" (**,'(&2"#+(##+"*($12+"4,"<$00="+%&%'"1.%*$#$6"0> %<"6"',.%& .'"*"&#(#$%&$&#+"#+$'1<"")#+"*(-"<(*(5($&1$*+%&%,'"1(&1#+" -"-% 1(#"1 '"6"(0"1 #+" 2(,*" (* D ."&$&5 (0(&2"

&*,//$2$"&#E "('&"12%,&*"0+(*('5,"1#+(#%&1$*+%&%,'%/#+$*2+"4,"

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

&#+"%#+"'+(&1#+".'(>"'$*%..%*"1=>0"('&"12%,&*"0/%' #+"2%-.0($&(&# #<(*('5,"1#+(#(##+"*#(5"%//'(-$&5%/2+('5"*%&0> *,*.$2$%&$*"&%,5+(&1$&#+".'"*"&#2(*"#+"/$&(0'".%'#20"('0>$&1$2(#"* #+(#*$5&"12+"4,"<(*-$**$&5(&1<(**#%0"&=>(22,*"1 ()"*+ ,-('

,.#( #<(**,=-$##"1#+(##+" %,'#*+(6".(**"1#+"*($1%'1"''"0>$&5 ,.%&#+"0(<%&#+"*,=A"2#(&1#+"(..0$2(#$%&/%'1$*2+('5"/$0"1=>#+" ."#$#$%&"'<(*'$5+#0>1$*-$**"1 22%'1$&5#%+$-<+"#+"'#+"2+"4,"<(* 5$6"&1"0$="'(#"0>=>#+"2%-.0($&(&##%#+"."#$#$%&"'<%,01="(-(##"'%/ "6$1"&2"

".'(>"1#+(#&%$&#"'/"'"&2"$*2(00"1/%'=>#+$* %,'# ."',*(0%/#+"%'1"'1(#"1?

@.(**"1=>#+"#'$(0 %,'# '"6"(0*#+(##+" %,'#.'%2""1"1#%/'(-"#+"2+('5"%&0>%&#+"5'%,&1#+(# 2+(00(&+(*=""&/$0"1=>#+".%0$2"

+"#'$(0 %,'#+(*&%#"6"&&%#$2"1#+"

/(2#*2%-.0"#"0>(&1.'%2""1"1#%/'(-"#+"2+('5"%&0>%&#+"5'%,&1#+(# (*#+"/$&(0'".%'#+(*=""&*,=-$##"1,&1"'"2#$%&?@ '

#+"'"/%'"

7 %//"&2"<(*-(1"%,#(5($&*##+"(22,*"1 +"'"6$*$%&(0 %,'# (//$'-"1#+"*($1%'1"'%/#+"#'$(0 %,'#%&#+"5'%,&1#+(#(##+"*#(5"%/ /'(-$&5%/2+('5"**#'%&5*,*.$2$%&$*#%="*""&(&1'"0$(&2"<(*.0(2"1%& 6('$%,*%#+"'.'%&%,&2"-"&#*.(**"1=>#+"%&F=0",.'"-" %,'# /#"'+"('$&50"('&"12%,&*"0/%'#+".('#$"*#+$* %,'#/$&1* #+(##+"2+"4,"$&4,"*#$%&2(''$"*1(#"%/ <+"'"(*$&$#$(00>#+"

<(*5%#'"2%'1"1=>#+"2%-.0($&(&#%& +"2+"4,"<(* /$'*##$-"1$*+%&%,'"1%&@ (*."'-"-%$**,"1=>#+"(&) +"

2%-.0($&(&#9'"*.%&1"&#% ;+(*'"0$"1,.%& % @81(#"1 #%2%&#"&1#+(##+"$&/%'-(#$%&<(*5$6"&#$-"0>#%#+".%0$2"'"5('1$&5 -$**$&5%/#+"2+"4,"

#$*#+"2(*"*"#,.=>'"*.%&1"&#% #+(#+"+(1 5$6"& $&*#',2#$%&* #% #+" (&) (0*% '"5('1$&5 *#%..(5"%/ .(>-"&# %& 7 (&1'"4,"*#"1#+"-&%##%+%&%,'#+"2+"4,"$&4,"*#$%& +$* 6"'*$%&$*&%#*,=*#(&#$(#"1.('#$2,0('0><+"&#+"2+"4,"<(*1$*+%&%,'"1 *"2%&1 #$-" %& <$#+ #+" '"-(')* D ."&$&5 (0(&2"

&*,//$2$"&#E (1$#=""&(2(*"%/*#%..(5"%/.(>-"&##+"2+"4,"<%,01 +(6"=""&1$*+%&%,'"1<$#+#+"'"-(')*D(>-"&##%.."1E %#%&0>#+$* #+" 1(#"17 2(-"#%="'"5$*#"'"1(/#"'*"2%&1$&4,$'>,.%&#+" 2%-.0($&#5$6"&=>'"*.%&1"&#% #$*(0*%20"('/'%-#+" #+(#/$'*#0> %& #+"*,=A"2#2%-.0($&#=>'"*.%&1"&#% <(*$&4,$'"1=> #+" %0$2"#(#$%&$6$*$%&% 7 ,1+$(&(<+%+(1&%#$&1$2#"1#+"

."#$#$%&"'/%'2%--$**$%&%/#+"(00"5"1%//"&2" #&""1*#%="-"&#$%&"1 +"'"#+(#/'%-#+"6"'>="5$&&$&5#+"2%-.0($&(&#(00"5"1$&6%06"-"&#%/ #+"=(&)%//$2$(0*<+%+(1(0*%2%&&$6"1<$#+#+"(22,*"1+%<"6"'&%&"%/

8 #+"=(&)%//$2$(0<(*(''(>"1(*(22,*"1"$#+"'$&#+" %'$&#+"$&(0 '".%'# & ?

#+"'".%'#=>#+" <(*(..'%6"1=>#+" @ ,1+$(&(<+"'",.%&#+"$*#'$2###%'&"> ,1+$(&(%.$&"1#+(##+"2(*"=" '"5$*#"'"1(5($&*##+"."#$#$%&"'(&1$&2(*"(&>"6$1"&2"$*/%,&1'"5('1$&5 /%'5"'>#+"%//"&2"/%'#+"*(-"="(11"1 +"'"/%'"$#$*20"('#+(##+" '"5$*#"'"1%&#+"%.$&$%&%/$*#'$2###%'&">&%#%&0>1$//"'"1/'%-#+" 2%&20,*$%&%/ =,##+"*($1%.$&$%&%/#+"$*#'$2###%'&"><(*0(2)$&5 2"'#($&#>'"5('1$&52%--$**$%&%/%//"&2"9*;

,'#+"' ( ."',*(0 %/ #+" /$&(0 '".%'# '"6"(0* #+(# #+" %&0> -(#"'$(02%00"2#"11,'$&5$&6"*#$5(#$%&$*#+"2+"4,"$&4,"*#$%&="('$&5 % ?31(#"1 $**,"1/'%-22%,&#% 83G % @8 1(#"1 (&1.+%#%2%.>%/'"4,"*#0"##"'#%&1$(& 6"'*"(*(&)/%'

*#%..(5"%/.(>-"&#%/#+"2+"4,"

&#+"*#'"&5#+%/#+"*"1%2,-"&#*( /$&(0'".%'#<(**,=-$##"1%&0>/%'#+"%//"&2",&1"'"2#$%&@

+"/(2#*(&12$'2,-*#(&2"*%/#+$*2(*"-()"*$#(=*%0,#"0> 20"('#+(##+'%,5+#+"$-.,5&"1 2%-.0($&(&#+(**"#,.(1"/"&2"#% #+" 2%-.0($&# ='%,5+# => #+" ."#$#$%&"' ,&1"' "2#$%& @ "5%#$(=0" &*#',-"&#*2# #+(*(0'"(1>=""&&%#$2"1#+(#&%&"%/#+"=(&) %//$2$(0*$*(&(22,*"1<$#+#+"."#$#$%&"'.('#$2,0('0><+"&#+"2+"4,"$& 4,"*#$%&<(*&%#'"#,'&"1<$#+#+"'"-(')*#+(#F(>-"&#<(**#%.."1F

1-$##"10>#+"2+"4,"<(*.'"*"&#"1#<$2"<+$2+<(*1$*+%&%,'"1/%'0(2) %/*,//$2$"&#/,&1*<+$2+5(6"(6(0$12(,*"%/(2#$%&#%/$0"(2%-.0($&# ,&1"'"2#$%&@%/#+""5%#$(=0"&*#',-"&#*2# +"*"4,"&2"

%/"6"&#*1%"*&%#-()"%,#2%--$**$%&%/%//"&2"%/#+"/#'"5('1$&5#+"

? 2+"4,"$&4,"*#$%&.('#$2,0('0><+"&#+"."#$#$%&"'+(*(0'"(1>.0(2"1#+" *($12+"4,"="/%'"#+" %,'#%&#+"5'%,&1#+(##+"*(-"<(*1"0$6"'"1 6%0,&#('$0>=>'"*.%&1"&#%

&6$"<%/#+"(=%6"#+$* %,'#/$&1*#+(##+"-(#"'$(0%& '"2%'1$*&%#"&%,5+/%'/'(-$&5%/#+"2+('5"*(&1$#<$00=",*"/,0#%'"0> ,.%&#+"A,15"-"&#%/#+"%&F=0",.'"-" %,'#$&

!" #"

# $%&

& (&

)

*# + & $

() *

&+& !

! )

(, !

! -

( )

! !

( !

* !

! !

(

! (

% *

(

* #

"*,0#(&#0>#+"."#$#$%&$*(00%<"1(&1#+"$-.,5&"1%'1"'* 1(#"17 89&"&:,'";.(**"1=>#+"110 "**$%&*,15" ,1+$(&((&1%'1"'1(#"1?

@9&&":,'";.(**"1=>#+",1$2$(0

(5$*#'(#"*# 0(** ,1+$(&(('"*"#(*$1"(&1#+"."#$#$%&"'9(22,*"1;$* 1$*2+('5"1/%'#+"%//"&2",&1"'"2#$%&@ $&2(*" % 1(#"1 '"5$*#"'"1(#%0$2"#(#$%&$6$*$%&% 7 ,1+$(&(

2#%="'

,0(#$ ! !+"#+"' ".%'#(=0"

"* !+"#+"'."()$&5C "(*%&"1 "*