High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/9798/2007allowed

Puda v. Sher Singh And Another

2025-01-21Mr. Justice Sureshwar Thakur,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

"#"# $ %& '

()) % *% ", -

/0 .# 1 11

2 /0 .1# 1 1

"#$#

%&' ( )&&

* "

+&' ( )&

%&& #!' ( )&- #

# "## %

' ( )&

/ "#0 '

%'!

/&1 11

2, # . #

#& 1 , % )%& + "#

# 2 &) % ,

!& ) , & &

& - '

)

) &%%4&- &!

5!& "#

67688669

(

, % 14

<;= , # !

/&1 "

&% &

" &

)' .>>; &"&

..6>8667

14#

&%# ,

( -# )##&

% )&

:&%% + & /!

+ ,# #& 1

!& ,&- &!

5!& "#

.@678669

" % + # ( -

, % 14 #

<=.'%&

!& #( ! &

%%&" #& &'& 1& @;'$#-& 98.'986$#&

& 98.9

'.<. #&1& # %%&"&?# &!

'-& &)5!

14# &

)5!

%%)

97 =6'&

,## 2 #&%

.#& , % 1/)

;: ,#&

)5!

)'.=><#

A#) ,.=><B&

&+- #&

#) &

1& (%

# 1/)

, % 14

1)&+ /) 14) & 4'

1& (%

'( % ..86.&

#%&

&)5!

@ #&)5!

-& #/

?#&&' 14, ( #& :

+& 1&)#& $&!

- , ,!

( "#'#

"#'& -& "#'& / "#&

C& "#'& !)#

.'#& .;# #&

4%%#, #& :# %

.') %%) #&

&+ '

-# '#)

&+ , >'<9'8>;:'#!

,&%% #&

.' %4

- ##%&

, ) <

., % ( %D

;767 ,866@

&4 ",

5!& "# , )&

! !

< ,#) .=><'1

#+&?

)

:&%% %&

&%# # +

.@..866@'

E1% "# ' ( % 1 4

. +&?&

% )&

- # @-?

- 1

- #

7-?

"#)& &9 %4 ; !

.@..866@' . !1+ #

% )&

, )

" # &

% )&

' #!

% )4 876>866.'# !

#&% '#!

(

8;6@866<' /) #)%& + ,

+& %4

"( :&:(

97'#!

.,&%%

#..;B-

-# !

&+ &1 % 4,

"##

&)5!

( '

& % #&

)# !1/)%&

) :

14 ) :

-# # ) :

#& &%

) (

1 %& %(&

-# ,1) 2 &) # "According to the Oustee policy, the petitioner can apply in the office of Estate Officer, PUDA, PUDA Bhawan, Sector - 62, Mohali for allotment of a plot. As per the policy, on receipt of his application within the stipulated time, can be considered for the allotment of plot."

. , % & &

&% &"&

8;6@866<1,

#) & 4

1& (%

'-# &,

( "#&#&

% )&

.'#& 1

% )4&

&%% +

& , )

" # &+ ,

% )4 876>866.'

( #

6;.6866<'#) & 4

' &

8;6@866<&

#)&

&%# ,

#&% '

#)& &))

- ##

)

.@..866@&

- # 8+

# &, #&

. 9

.-& #&

14#

&%# ,

@66=8667& "! #&& ## ,&%% ?&% &+) %

))!

#%,

#&% :&

#&(1 /!

1& /!

&+ +&

"! #&#2

&%(%

#& " +&41 )#& " F 8%&) &) & #& 1

#)& ,& #&-&+ & "0& = &

' #&% '&, " "&

+#&

)5!

%%)

) %&

&, ?

" # ++ ,

+# , ' '&

G '

/) #)%& +

.14

<;= ,# !

/&1"

&%&

.>>;#

A#) ,.>>;B'#!

&"&

..6>8667'& 1)&+

14#' #&% '# )1,

&%) & 4

1& (%

.6 #

&%) & 4'

1& + '(

67688669

:;&%% - #(

) # # ,

' :&%% # # #

H& -# 1&

I !1/) &4+ ,)#& "

!1/) )

) , # !1% ) )

876>866.' %(& &"

#-# ,1) 2 &) #

"Since the said consideration has not taken place at the level of PUDA, I am of the confirmed opinion that a material irregularly patent to the fact of record, in the impugned order dated 25.3.2004 has accrued. As such, I have no hesitation in accepting the revision petition, setting aside the impugned order dated 25.3.2004 and remanding the case back to Additional Chief Administrator, PUDA, Mohali to consider the application of the petitioner strictly in accordance with the directions contained in order dated 13.11.2003 passed by the Hon'ble Punjab and Haryana High Court in Civil Writ Petition No. 5606 of 2003. The Additional Chief Administrator, PUDA, Mohali shall pass a speaking order within two months after affording the petitioner a reasonable opportunity of being heard. With these remarks this revision petition is disposed of as partly accepted. The petitioner is directed to appear before the Additional Chief Administrator, PUDA, Mohali on 18.10.2004." .. )#(

&%%4&%% - '& !)#

# , % & ( -

)

+ ( 4 ( &% &

,&) ' & & %

#.<&

#.; ,#-

'-# )## -(

!"#

)&# + ,#&

,#(

% + '#( -

, % 14

'-# )##& %

# 1*45)) '

&6 7%

(* 7 '

&6 8&)&)

.8 #%&

#& !1+ #&

##&

,&1!

)# , ( %D

"- #D >>8@ 866<'14# '& ,, &( .@6<8669-& , %

1#&%,

"# #&)

-# #& "

,&( '5!&#&)5!

'- ) &

&)% #%&4

% ,

#- &"%& ,

97 =6, &% ,#&,, &( '# -&

%& (&)&# &4 &%%#

)& -# )#- ) "% ?%4

+ #-&4 ,%&4 - &" % #)

% ,

&%% !)#

( -#

'# - &" % -&

'#& " ( !

"#&

#&%%

# %&4 , #- &" ' #

!"# # %&

' &

"&)5!

'#+& - 1& "!

#& /

&, )

"#!

"" ( 14#)

'# 1!

)# ,D

-& /

6=6=8669 .@

1#&%,

'#& )& # + !"

67688669

8 &

" , #

.@678669

#( -

'#!

1) (&% !

1!) % & )- 1) +

67688669'&

8'-# ##

) 1& /!

:&%% '-# - (

%4&,,)#

" , # & &' 1

- % & %%

)

( -

1% %#%&4 - &" - #

) , #&,, &( 6.688669'

'1) +

14' #&%

1#&%, , ' #

D >>8@ ,866< % A

B .<

# ( )&

+ %&

<;= ,#) ,.>>;'#!

-& &+ :

)

.; #

!"##2

- ,+

)

'#!

&)5!

, )&

1) +

! !

< ,#) ,.=><'&

1)&+ !)) 14& )%&

1) "+& !

7 ) ,.=><

( '&

!1 5! %4& &-&

.. #) ,.=><1)&+

'-# #)

# !

#& 1 ) ( 14 &%% ) :

. .7

5! %4' -# # &%% ) :

.'1!&)5! ) #+&?

,&(&% &-&

) !1/)%&

!%& %4'#

.&%

&" &&"&

#+&?

,(&% &)5!

,#&)5!

!)!

(

)& #

& ' # -# # &-&

&)5!

)%!

( 4&"&

# :

'-#

# !1/)# 1 " ) :

!%& %4' 4 # ,,) , )

)%!

( 4 1) "&

5!&#

&-&

( :&:( #) :

1!-

1) + "& "

, )& %4& !

&)) "#

.B %&

# ) :

( :&:( # !1/) # - &%

1 &1%4 + )%& +#

) ( #&

%4#&-&

) !1/)%&

#4& 866.

( '-#

#& 1 &"&

'#!

14#&""

( %&

' ,&%% - '1!' , 1%&-,!%%4 &%% - -# )

&1% 45!&#

.'#!

4 4&

8= ,#)

.=><'#& , % "#

5! %4'- # #&1 (

41)

1 )

.1! +&?

4 1&+ :

( ? 4 .=

%4' # !1/) %&

& ) :

14 , ( #& :

'-# #)&

4 , %&

++!

&%%#) :

'#!

% )&1%

!1/)# ,#

%1)

!"#"

% ,

.'# - # !& 4%&-,!%

++1

,#/

%&)' - 1& +

-+ "#' %&

( !1/)%&

. + #& J "%4 &%

' -# ,

&%% #

& &)5! :

1) +

.&%

)%& +&

"#' %&

( !1/)%&

# .>

.#&

)#&%% " #%&!

)# &)5!

)

' #!

# "

#& # %&!

&)5!

&'1)&+%&

'& ( &" !

8<8 "# 3&

)4 &

)5!

#&1 % &

%+ )'86.@#

A#)

,86.@B'#

%4%&!

)# &)5!

)

+ 1%&-,!%%4%&!

)# '1

1 % 4

.' +&?& 4,,) (

&%',

)&!

!%% , )&

%&-,!%%4%&!

)# &)5!

)

86 # !"# # -

D:;767:866@ 1)&+

)

.@..866@ -( '&

& (

)

+& #

& ( -# , 1) 2 &)

# ' !

( % #& # !"# #

. +& &

!))

,!%)#&%% " #&)5!

)

'1!4

)

- +&

)

' ,#

+ (

% )&

- # # -?

+# &)

'5!&# &+1

#-&? %(&

% )4

:.'&

&%&-,!%

'1!& 2 %4&

1%&

&1%4- # 2-?

+# & ,+&?

!)#

% )&

"In view of the statement made by the learned counsel for the parties, we direct that if the petitioner moves an application within three weeks from today, the same shall be considered in the wake of policy Annexure R91 and appropriate orders in accordance with law shall be passed therein as expeditiously as possible and preferably within six weeks from the date of making of such application"

8. !

!& % 1 41) ""

.'#+& &

-# )## -( 1)&+ /) #

!"#

:8# !"## 4&(& %&1%

. -&

)#&%% " # /)

:8 #

!"# # , % " & -

-( '#

&(& %# 4#)

. + &(& %# 4' #&'#

/) )%& +'#!

&)5!

)%!

(,,) 88 -

.'#&

4#& &(& % 4!

<;= ,#) ,.>>;'

#&(& %+ 4,

# &+ :&(& % 4

)%!

,&)5!

)

!1/) %&

' &

' &%

-# ,

)%!

( 41) &)5!

14#

% )&

#,,)

)%!

( 41) "&)5!

!"##

:8' #!

14 # ) &!#

4'-# % , :&%% + :& /!

+ '

.' 1! 1) )%

5! %4'#

.1)&+

)

&!'-# )# 1( %4

)

) &%&

% )&1% &!

+!)# & ' # ) , .=><' -# !

&)5!

)

- %&!

1)&+)

)%!

(%4&

,,) (%4)

)%!

& 4 %&,

&%% + :& /!

+ '#!

1)%& + 8@ ,# 4&"

#&(& %+

.'# -

, +

1%%"&% &( ! # %&

)

' -# &, ) ( " 1

" &

)%!

(&-&

'#!

%(& &! %&

#+ % 4+

)

,eminent domain14#&'#!

)& #

&+ % 4+ ( :&:(

) (%&

# - !% #

)

,,, )&)4'#!

)%!

(&-&

1) +

14#&!#

+ %& &! #) ,.=>< 8< # ,

& 1&(

&, +&#'# &! -# !

& 4'#!

-& 1) +)& (&

'-&

!))

,!%%4)#&%% "#

:8 )#

&(& % )

,& +

1% 4&

.' &+ :&(& % 4&#

. 8; # ,

- ##

' # &+ &%% - + !"

67688669

:;' 5!& #

911

"# "# -

1.:

&676

6&6

8%;) <= % !

6&6

8 &%47!