Vijay Dev And ORS. v. State Of Punjab

   

       

!"#$#%&'&()

* +&,!-#.!($"/#0'

#.&'&(&'"'

+#0'1'

2"!"#1(,!3 #'4($#("

)  56  2 7 62  0#'#(")8 0219##"!/!,!(:$.%!"#:0:

07;!<&!:$.%!"#:00#.&'&(&'"' '(&=!!<"!: 1(,!3  ;/#"/#0"/##40"#0'<%!<(#>'4!4#09!-3#!<<>#$" '##"/#,1$?9#("@
 3#0##00#$""/##40"#00("  ;/#"/#0"/#,1$?9#("'/1<$3#0#40"#$&("/#$&?#'"@ 88 88 62 

6 /&'&'0#.&'&(!?!&('",1$?9#("$!"#$

 :4!''#$3-"/# <#!0(#$  $$&"&(!<  2#''&('  1$?#:  !"&!<!:  !&09&(?  "/#  ,1$?9#("   %(.&%"&(!($0$#0'#("#(%#$!"#$AB
A:4!''#$3-"/#<#!0(#$ 1$&%&!<!?&'"0!"#'" <!'':!"&!<!:.&$#>/&%/0#.&'&(&'"'>#0#%(.&%"#$ 1($#02#%"&('
 0#!$>&"/2#%"&(A :A:A:A:B

!($>#0#'#("#(%#$!'1($#0)8 C #(%#%99&""#$1($#02#%"&( 2#("#(%#!>!0$#$"!<<!%%1'#$

($#02#%"&(
0#!$>&"/ &?01'&940&'(9#("0'&D9("/'

2#%"&(A

!($"4!-!&(#'
 8!($&( $#!1<"4!-9#("&(#0&?01'

&940&'(9#("0$!-'

($#02#%"&(A

&?01'&940&'(9#("0'&D9("/'

!($"4!-!&(#'
 8!($&( $#!1<"4!-9#("&(#0&?01'

8
8 &940&'(9#("0$!-'

($#02#%"&(A

&?01'&940&'(9#("0(#-#!0 !($"4!-!&(#'
 8!($&( $#!1<"4!-9#("&(#0&?01'

&940&'(9#("0$!-'

($#02#%"&(B

&?01'&940&'(9#("0(#-#!0 !($"4!-!&(#'
 8!($&( $#!1<"4!-9#("&(#0&?01'

&940&'(9#("0$!-'E <<"/#'#("#(%#'>#0#$&0#%"#$"01(%(%100#("<- 0#'#("  %!'#  >!'   0#?&'"#0#$  (  "/#  >0&""#(  %94<!&("

D;
 :'139&""#$3- 0 104!<2&(?/:"/#"/#(''&'"!(" D#%1"&.# (?&(##0: !'"&.&'&(:!"&!<!("/#%94<!&(": 0 104!<2&(?/'"!"#$ "/!"(
*:/#>!''&""&(?&(/&' &%#  02#"/&:2#(&0 D#%1"&.#  (?&(##0  (0%#9#(" :  0  !0,&"  2&(?/:   :  !'"  213 &.&'&(:!"&!<!: 0!92&(?/: :213&.&'&(/!0!?&0>#0#!<' '&""&(?>&"//&9">!'!31")>/#("/#<&?/"/&'09>#(" #&(F1&0#$09/&'2"#(!.&($#02&(?/!'">/-"/##<#%"0&%&"-/!' !&<#$!.&($#02&(?/:2"#(:>#("1"'&$#!($"/#0#!"#0&(09#$"/# %94<!&(!(" 0 104!<2&(?/"/!"+&,!-#.!%%1'#$/!''>&"%/#$"/#

 "#0'9#"&9#:%94<!&(!("  0 104!<2&(?/>#("1"'&$#!($ '>&"%/#$("/#  #>!'0#"10(&(?"/&'09>/#( +&,!-#. !%%1'#$!%%94!(&#$3-/&'%94!(&(''1001($#$"/#%94<!&(!("!($ $&$("!<<>/&9"?&('&$#"/#09#>!'41'/#$!($"!=#(1"'&$# ("/#9#!(>/&<#: 0/14&($#02/!09!:2#(&0 D#%1"&.# (?&(##0:>/ >!''&""&(?&(!0944'&"#"/#31&<$&(?:!"#0/#!0&(?"/#(&'#:%!9# 1"#>!'!<'41'/#$!($9&'3#/!.#$3-!%%1'#$%%1'#$9!<"0#!"#$ "/#%94<!&(!("!($3#!"#(/&9/#-!<'1'#$&<"/-<!(?1!?#!?!&('"/&9

88 ("/#9#!(>/&<#:%94<!&(!("#<<$>( &'"103!(>!'!<'0#9.#$

(##93#0"/#1(&(!<'"0&#$"/&"/&9>&"/!4<&#0%%0$&(?" %94<!&(!(":   +&,!- #.:   :  !(!0!'&   !'':   !,&($#0  2&(?/:  &0!"/ !/!$10:!9#'/>#0!'':  9!0#.:!92&(?/:!<<#94<-##' 1(,!32"!"# <#%"0&%&"-!0$>#0#409&(#("<-&(.<.#$&("/#%0&9#" >!'10"/#0'"!"#$&("/#%94<!&(""/!""/#<#!0(#$ &.&<1$?#:2#(&0 &.&'&(:!"&!<!:4!''#$!(&(,1(%"&(0$#0!?!&('"#94<-##'1(&( 090?!(&G&(?!(-0!<<-1($#09#"#0'"/#&%#/#0#0#:40!-#0 >!'9!$#00#?&'"0!"&("/#%!'#

( 0#%#&4"%94<!&(":"/#4<&%#9!$#"/##($0'#9#("

D;  !($!%%0$&(?<-: !%!'#1($#02#%"&('B: :A:
:

A:A    >!'  0#?&'"#0#$  !?!&('"  !%%1'#$  !"  <&%#  2"!"&(  7">!<&: !"&!<!/#'&"#4<!(4<!%#%%100#(%# D;  >!'40#4!0#$ %%1'#$>#0# !00#'"#$ "#0%94<#"&(&(.#'"&?!"&(:%/!<<!(>!' 40#'#("#$!?!&('""/#9  <<!%%1'#$>#0#%/!0?#'/##"#$1($#02#%"&('A:B: :


:A:A  ('1440"&"'%!'#:40'#%1"&(#D!9&(#$ 0!0,&"2&(?/

; : 0 104!< 2&(?/:%94<!&(!("  ;
:!=/'/&'/2&(?/:0#"&0#$ ('4#%"0   ; :  0  !9  2&(?/  ;A :   (!("  2&(?/:  0#"&0#$ 214#0&("#($#(":2 6:!"&!<! ;B :&0!!<<!3/ ;

#9!&(&(?

40'#%1"&(#.&$#(%#>!'%<'#$3-0$#0' ;/#(#D!9&(#$1($#02#%"&( 0 :!%%1'#$!,&($#0 2&(?/4<#!$#$"/!"/#&'&((%#("  (
*:/#>!'>0=&(?!'!

6&(#9!(&(0"/213&.&'&(:!"&!<!0>/<#"/#$!-:/#0#9!&(#$ 40#'#("&("/#0"/213&.&'&(#>!'"/#"/#(0#'&$#("213

8A8

03!(&.&'&(#%/(&%!<2#0.&%#' (&(#40$1%#$/&'4!-<#$?#0

DH  %%1'#$   +&,!-  #.  %<!&9#$  "/!"  /#  >!'  "/# "/#(  &0%<# 0#'&$#(":1(,!3#%/(&%!<2#0.&%# (&(:1(,!3#/!'3##(!<'#<- &94<&%!"#$!""/#/!($'9!(!?#9#(" %%1'#$!(!0'&!''%<!&9#$"/!"/#>!'"/#"/#(0#'&$#(" #%/(&%!< 2#0.&%#' (&(:2 :;#'"&.&'&(:!"&!<!:!($/!'3##( !<'#<-&94<&%!"#$ %%1'#$ 9!0#. %<!&9#$  "/!" (  
*:/# >!'  "/# 40#'#("&(0"/213&.&'&(:!"&!<! #>!'"/#(&(" 2#%0#"!0- #%/(&%!<213 03!( (&(2 :!"&!<! #!<'40$1%#$    /&' '!<!0-<#$?#0 DI   %%1'#$  &0!"/  !/!$10:  %<!&9#$  "/!"  /#  /!'  3##(  !<'#<- &(.<.#$!'/# >!'"/#"/#( 0#'&$#(" #%/(&%!< (&(0"213 &.&'&(:!"&!<! %%1'#$!92&(?/4<#!$#$"/!"0>/<# $!-:/#>!' 40#'#("($1"-!"  #("0!

<2"0# #>!' "/#"/#(0#'&$#(" #("0!< 2"0#&.&'&(#%/(&%!<2#0.&%#' (&(:2  #/!'3##( !<'#<- &94<&%!"#$#40$1%#$!""#($!(%#0#?&'"#0 DI  %%1'#$!9#'/>!0!''4<#!$#$"/!"/#>!'"/#"/#(2#(&0 +&%#0#'&$#("#%/(&%!<2#0.&%#' (&(:1(,!3:2 :!"&!<!# /!'3##(!<'#<-&(.<.#$ ($##(%#:!%%1'#$40$1%#$$%19#("' DH: D: DI !($ HI !($%<'#$"/##.&$#(%# "#0  /#!0&(?  "/#  40'#%1"&(  !($  !"#0  ?&(?  "/01?/  "/# #.&$#(%#:"/#<#!0(#$1$&%&!<!?&'"0!"#'" <!'':!"&!<!:%(.&%"#$!

8B8 '#("#(%#$"/#0#.&'&(&'"':!'!3.#("#$ /#,1$?9#(">!'14/#<$&( !44#!< /!.#/#!0$"/#<#!0(#$40D-%1('#<!44#!0&(?0<#!0(#$ %1('#<00#.&'&(&'"':<#!0(#$2"!"#%1('#<!($/!.#!<'%!0#1<<-?(# "/01?/&<#!($<>#0 10"&<#!'>#<< /#<#!0(#$40D-%1('#<!44#!0&(?0<#!0(#$%1('#<0 0#.&'&(&'"'/!' .#/#9#("<-!0?1#$ "/!"&( "/&'%!'#:('!(%"&(1($#0 2#%"&(B 0 >!'3"!&(#$040'#%1"&(1($#02#%"&( 0  /#9!""#0/!'!<0#!$-3##($#!<">&"/3-"/#<>#0!44#<<!"#

10"!($&"/!'3##(/#<$"/!"#(%#1($#02#%"&(B &'%?(&G!3<# ("/&'%!'#:"/#0# >!'!>0&""#(%94<!&(" 0 104!<2&(?/ /# %(.&%"&(&'1($#02#%"&('B:A
:A:A :0>/&%/( '!(%"&(&'0#F1&0#$ /#<#!0(#$40D-%1('#<!44#!0&(?0<#!0(#$%1('#<0 0#.&'&(&'"'  /!'  .#/#9#("<-  !0?1#$  "/!"  &(  "/&'  %!'#:  %94<!&(!("  /!' (>/#0#9#("&(#$"/!"!"#0/#!0&(?"/#(&'#: 0!0,&"2&(?/!<'%!9# 1"09/#0#0#:"/#'"!"#9#(" 0!0,&"2&(?/ ; %!(("3# 3#<&#.#$ "&'10"/#0%("#($#$"/!" 0!92&(?/ ;A /!$ "10(#$ /'"&<#/#0#0#:"/#0#&''<#"#'"&9(- 0 104!<2&(?/:>/&%/ %!(("3#0#<&#$14( !9"/#.&#>"/!"09"/##D!9&(!"&(&<#:!$&#0#(" 4&%"10# #9#0?#'      0 104!<  2&(?/  ;
 /!'

 1<<- '1440"#$ "/# 40'#%1"&(%!'#:"/1?/:/#/!''"!"#$"/!"/#%1<$("0#%!<<"/#(!9#' '9#!%%1'#$:31"/#&$#("&&#$!<<"/#9&( 10"#/!''4#%&&%!<<- '"!"#$  "/!"  >/#(  /#  >#("  1"'&$#  "  '>&"%/  (  "/#  #<#%"0&%&"-:  /#  >!' '1001($#$#>!'$0!??#$09"/#.!0!($!//#0#>!'

>/9&'3#/!.#$>&"//&9/#-9&'3#/!.#$!($!31'#$/&9#>!'!<' 3#!"#(14!($"/0>(("/#?01($!($/&'"103!(>!'0#9.#$#/!' '4#%&&%!<<-'"!"#$"/!"!""/!""&9#:&%#0'&(%<1$&(? 02#"/&: 0 !0,&"2&(?/!($ 0!92&(?/>#0#!<'40#'#("&(/&'&%# 0!0,&" 2&(?/:>/&<#!44#!0&(?!';:/!'!<''1440"#$"/#'"0-41"0"/3-

104!<2&(?/:'"!"&(?"/!"!%%1'#$9&'3#/!.#$>&"/ 0/14&($#02/!09! !($?!.#3#!"&(?'" 0 104!<2&(?/ /#-1'#$&<"/-<!(?1!?#  0

104!<2&(?/#<<$>(!($/&'"103!(>!'0#9.#$3-'!&$!''!&<!("' ;/#( 0 104!<2&(?/>!'<-&(?$>(("/#?01($!($'1001($#$3- * 4#0'(':/#9&?/"("3#&(!4'&"&("'##!'">//!'%9#1" 09/&'&%#!($>&"(#''#$"/#%%100#(%#/#0#0#:'"!"#9#(" 0 !0,&"2&(?/"/!"/#%!9#1""/#&%#!($>&"(#''#$"/#%%100#(%#>!' 0&?/"<-3#<&#.#$3-3"/"/#  10"' 3#<> 0#.#0"/1?/: 0!9 2&(?/ ;A "10(#$/"&<#!($40,#%"#$"/!"/#%!9#1"'&$#(<-!"#0"/# %%100#(%#/!$"!=#(4<!%#:31"/#'"!"#$"/!"'#.#0!<4#4<#>#0#0!&'&(? '<?!('!($"/#-/!$ '>&"%/#$"/#<&?/" &%#  /#0#!"#0:  0

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

8*8 %94<!&(!(":'1440"#$3-"/#'"!"#9#("' 0!0,&"2&(?/!($ 0!9 2&(?/"/!"!%%1'#$/!$?!"/#0#$1"'&$#"/#&%#/#-9&'3#/!.#$>&"/ 0 104!<2&(?/!($(#/14&($#02/!09!/1?/:/14&($#02/!09! /!$("!44#!0#$:31"'"0-F1! 0 140!<2&(?//!'3##(1<<-40.#$ /#<#!0(#$40D-%1('#<!44#!0&(?0<#!0(#$%1('#<0 0#.&'&(&'"'/!'!0?1#$"/!"&("/#$#4!0"9#("!<40%##$&(?':0#.&'&(&'"' >#0##D(#0!"#$#/!'!<'0##00#$"!44<&%!"&(4<!%#$>&"/40#'#(" &<#>/#0#&(#<#%"0&%&"-3!0$/!'>0&""#(! <#""#0">&"/$0!>09"/# 40'#%1"&( !9"/#.&#>"/!""/&' 10"%!(("<=&("!(-$%19#(":

>/&%/&'("4!0""/#<>#0 10"&<#(->!-:"/#!%"0#9!&('"/!"

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

3#<>$("&($!(-?01($"$&#0>&"/&($&(?'0#%0$#$3-3"/ "/# 10"'3#<>/#!%"&(!%%1'#$&(!''!1<"&(?"/#&0&%#0!($ 0#9.&(?/&'"103!(&'!'#0&1'9!""#0!($$#'("%!<<0!(-<#(&#(%- ''1%/:"/#40#'#("0#.&'&(&'1($"3#>&"/1"!(-0%#!($&'

88 $&'9&''#$6#"!<<!%%1'#$3#0#!00#'"#$!($%99&""#$",!&<"1($#0? 0#9!&(&(?4!0"'#("#(%#

62   



* ',=' ;/#"/#0'4#!=&(? 0#!'(#$ ) #' ;/#"/#0#40"!3<# ) #'