Tarun Kumar Tyagi v. State Of Haryana






      
  

 !"#!$%&%"'()) *+',+-*./% )))! % %"'!* 0!*&+&

 !"#*.' !&2"'3!'

 


    *!&!' ( *)4!'3!*"*&%534"$ !5#"* 6!2! % %"'!*) *) +*%'3!* %'/655*.') 

 !

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

 &2!* 6!$&!"# 6!%'4!& %/ %'//!'$.

) 6"+/6 6!9!*'!3$"+'&!9#"* 6!2! % %"'!**!#+ !& 6! #"*!&%3$"' !' %"'5:% 6"+ -@%'/'.$"--!'   6%&& /!"':6 %& $"' !'3!353="+*'!3 ")))
' !*%-"*3!* "$"' %'+! %99 6!'!B 3 !"#6!*%'/"'9. '3&2!$%#%$99.) 
# 6!2! % %"'!*:%&6!& "29$!"'*!$"*35%' 6!-!':6%9!5

 '.3"$+-!' & " *.'32*"4! 6 6!:&'" %*!$ "*3+*%'/ 6 2!*%"3'33%3'" #%9!'.&+$6%'$"-! B*! +*'&56!:"+93;! 9%;!* . "3"&"5 :% 6'.&+$6229%$ %"'#%9!3 ";!$"'&%3!*!3"'% &":' -!*% &)C D!*'!3$"+'&!9#"* 6!2! % %"'!*6&'" 29$!3"'*!$"*3 '. 6%'/ "&  ! " 6!$"' **.5;+  "3.56!&+;-% & 6  6!99!/ %"' ;!%'/ 6 -"'!.:& @!';.6%&$"$$+&!3%' 6!.!*5:6!'6! :&3-% !39.'" %*!$ "*5 6!
/%'& 6%-%''.$&!%&'"

-%' %';9!5'3&&+$66!3!&!*4!& 6!$"'$!&&%"'"#' %$%2 "*.;%9) *!29.6&;!!'#%9!3%'$"+*  "3.;. 6!9!*'!3  !

$"+'&!9 " 6!2! % %"'5:% 66%-&+;-% %'/ 6 !4!'3+*%'/ 6! !'+*!"# 6!2! % %"'!*&%*!$ "*5'-"+' "# &)5A55?A?E:&3!2"&% !3 :% 6 6!$"-2'.;.6"'!& %'4!& "*&5'3 6  6!$"-2'.% &!9#5%)!)E&

% -+%93 !$6D%-% !35:&<'" *!/%& !*!3%'
:% 6 
'3


C5'3$"'&!F+!' 9. 6!$"-2'.:&'" !9%/%;9! "$$!2 -"'!. +'3!*G
G "99!$ %4!
'4!& -!'  $6!-!

) 
:&#+* 6!*&  !3%' 6!

##%34%  6 % :&#"+'3 6 '-"+' "# &)5?585A??E:&*!#+'3!3 " 6!%'4!& "*&5:% 6 6!*!-%'%'/-"+'  " 6! +'!"# &)??5?A58>5AE & %99*!-%'%'/ ";!*! +*'!3) 6!*!# !*5% %&&  !3  6 %' 6!2! % %"'!*&G$$"+'  E$ '")>AA?> :% 6 6!B%&'@56!/"  *'&#!**!3'-"+' "#

&)?9$&#*"- 6!$$"+' "# 6!$"-2'.%':6%$66!:&3%*!$ "*)
 6&  ;!!'  9& 9.  &  !3  6  6!  2! % %"'!*  6&  ="%'!3 %'4!& %/ %"';+ 6!%&'" $""2!* %'/5%'&-+$6& 6!+ %9%H %"'"#



&)??5?A58>5E -"'!."# 6!6"'!& %'4!& "*& 5%&'" ;!%'/!B29%'!3;.

6%-) D!*'!3  !$"+'&!9#+* 6!*&+;-% & 6 >" 6!*$*%-%'9 $&!&*!#"+'3 "64!;!!'*!/%& !*!3/%'&  6!2! % %"'!*%'3%##!*!'

 !&5%'$9+3%'/66 %&/*653.*3!&6'3 **3!&6) D!*'!3  $"+'&!9  #"*  6!  2! % %"'!*  6&  6":!4!*  #+* 6!* $"' !'3!3 6 6!:&"'9. 6!2!*&"'%':6"&!$$"+'  6!-"'!.:& *'&#!**!3;. 6!$"-2'.5:% 66%-%' +*'64%'/ *'&#!**!3 6!&%3 -"+'  " 6!" 6!*%*!$ "*&E!-29".!!&"# 6!$"-2'.5:6%$6$';! 4!*%#%!3#*"- 6!3"$+-!' &&+;-% !3;.6%- " 6!%'4!& %/ %'/"##%$!*) &*!/*3& 6!" 6!*
&&  !3 ";!*!/%& !*!3/%'& 6%-5 6!&+;-% & 6  6!*!%&'"&2!$%#%$99!/ %"'/%'&  6!2! % %"'!*6%-&!9# %'99 6"&!
&5%':6%$6 6!*!*!&!4!*9$$+&!35'3$"'&!F+!' 9. &%-29.;!$+&! 6"&!
&64!-!' %"'!36%-&'$$+&!35 6 $''" ;!6!93 ";!/%'& 6%-) 4%'/  $"'&%3!*!3  !4!'  6!  #"*!&%3  */+-!' 5  6"+/6 9!*'!3$"+'&!9#"* 6!2! % %"'!*6&4!*.4!6!-!' 9. *%!

3 "3!#!'3 6! #$  6  &)??$*"*!& 29+& 56&'" ;!!'!-;!HH!93;.6%-56":!4!*5 $"'&%3!*%'/ 6!#$  6  6!2! % %"'!*+'3"+; !39.:&%*!$ "*"# 6! $"-2'.:6%$6:& *'&#!**%'/-"'!. "6%&$$"+' 5#*"-:6%$66!:& *'&#!**%'/-"'!. " 6!;'@$$"+' "#" 6!*%*!$ "*&E!-29".!!&E$" $$+&!35
3"'" &!!'./*"+'3 "/*' 6%-$"'$!&&%"'"#' %$%2 "*.

> "'&!F+!' 9.5 6!2*!&!' 2! % %"'%&3%&-%&&!3) ":!4!*5'" 6%'/&  !36!*!%';"4!&699;! @!' ";!' ";&!*4 %"' "# 6%& $"+* "' 6!-!*% & "# 6!$&!5#"*"*/%'&  6! 2! % %"'!*5;+ "'9.%' 6!$"' !B "#2! % %"'&!!@%'/' %$%2 "*.;%9)   ))    !

4$/*/ "