← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2230/2015disposed of

Manju Aggarwal & ANR v. Dharmender Kumar And ORS

2016-12-08Mr. Justice Dr. Ravi Ranjan14 pages



      



                   



                      !"#$   !"

 #  #    % &          ' (  ( )

  *

      % &  (

 #$ +  *   

  *    , 

           * , *    

 -   !#(".(!"#. ,

   

   /  0   1 ( 2  

 

      )  ,  *     

      * ,

   "3("4(!"#3    0     # )   1  *



 ,   *    

    ,

     )  (+   0   #)   

             *       5       

     !"". %      6 7&        (8 """-9     (. """-9        (#("" 

  

            

 

     



('

*    )  

     

(#" """-9    * ,  

       

          



( /   

       

    *,  ,   :     (        *                  ( )

   *

       

(2      ,         *    *     0

:

"$("!(#44  

:   ' 0

  

  "$(#!(#44 ( 2       

                     /

      , /(;(( 0%  &        

    / 0

  (+ ,  

    

     </    , * 

 ,         

 

      # , (+ 

          = *  )      



 9

 * >

   ( 5,     *   



         

     *      

 *     

    ( /     *

     

 -    ? 

  )  

*  

    



%#&''()*) +),)-.#&+/0)1(! #2 )1-% )345)*)15)(+)/ 6/).#()('37)8! 9:# 9

   *   / 3"#) (()( 



 ? *  :  ,  * ,    

 

 , 

   

     (+           :     %,&5)* #/14& 0)&)/ . )3)1;''( 0)&)/!  +/3/1)* 22<%&)1-+)=)1(/.+6(/>)4&

 (&'+, . )1/,&)  >)4&  )1(&'+! >+/( '(/(/1 :?$-'@/-'-12278/4&6+(37)8 <%#

+)7&)=)+)1 . #()('  0'+)*)! 9   +/3/1)*  9A< % );=63)+ )35)* )1-'8 . #)+/() );=63)+ )1-'8! 

 /./* <% +''(/#)(/;). );063)+/)1-)1(&'+!2

 +/3/1)*  < %#)+),B)(&8 . )76! +/3/1)* 55')* 999-'@/-'-1781!7*'#65+'3'6+( < %#6#)1-&8) )1;>)1=&)-'. )1;&/3+)>)1=&)-')1- (&'+,!   # A< %C &)1( . #)./() &)1(! 

  +/3/1)* :2< %  )76 )1- (&'+, . )1/!  )-+), /4& 6+( D +* ,2: )1- 2:  :     :$ -'@/-'- 1 :

< %)4)+);)1 . C'11/*)!   +/3/1)* 2<% +3/(#)(/,&#&)&. +,+@&)1)3/(#&)&

 )1(&'+! 37)8 /4& 6+( E >+/( '(/(/1 A:   -'@/-'-122 <%+0 )(&/8)*)4)1 )1(&'+. /,, &/.8)! )-+),/4&6+(D+* 9A-'@/-'-1  < %0+/,&1) &)()@&)+;'' . #)+)(&/ &6-&6+8 )1-

)1(&'+!A  +/3/1)* <%#6=+/(C'+3))1-)1(&'+ . #()('  );),(&)1 )1- )1(&'+!    +/3/1)*  A< % )&)-'.''*)B)(/F +)-18))1-(&'+,!  :< %0)+)3@&)1- (&'+,.#()(''*&/ )1(&'+!

 +/3/1)*  < %#&)&/- #&'/=& . #&)7)1)G  )1(&'+! 37)8 /4& 6+( D  >     -'@/-'- 1 A <%6.'+/)7-6* );/- )(1/.(/H7)* )1,+/)1- )1(&'+!22  /./* <%C/;)8C'+3).#/()'./)*/), #/() C'+3)! 2   /./*  :< %#&)*6 ;&) . +),&)1( ;&)!1!7*'#65+'3'6+(D 2-'@/-'-1 :92 < % +)(/3) #/14& . + 7&/3)186 #/14& )+/&)+! 9:A "

2:<%)+3/1-'+0)6+.#6=&B/1-'+#/14&! "

<%#6-&/+0)56+.''* )1/! ")B'+)*-A< % );''. +''1;) . #)+/=)! 99  " AA< %#&)37&6 +),)- #/14&. )1;)+/!2  +/3/1)* A:<%&)(6+7&6;.#/() )/! :   +/3/1)*  A   % )1,/ C&+) . )3',& C&+)!2  +/3/1)*  *    *  / #@ # #4 !" !!    9  

       

    *  



         

   

      

 

 

                   * , *

 



 

*

  ,   ( +   

 *   ( )



 

>          ,                

> 

    ,       

    , 

  

   7 

     )  ,*   *  ( +

         ?           , *

*       

       , 

               ,   >    



      

               

 )  (          

 ,* 

 * +A B  )   ) *  C   

 D    5          /

    

*

 ,: ,  

 ,           *  

          *    

  

     ( /  

     , ,  >    6

 *

 7 

, * 

   

   

  >*   E  

,

 , 

            2  )

)

)  

        )*    

               ( +   

*  

*,*         * *    



 * ,  6

 *

 7  *  

    

, ?  *  



,,  * (+* ,      ,  )     

 

 

    , *   /  #$        *

         

   

  )            ,  

        - *   *   , *       *   )       

   :    

  )    : *          

       ,(C*  

  

  )              

      ,      *           ,*

,                

       ,* 

 *  , * :     

,      

   (5,   

     

=   C     ) 92 = *  )          %

 &

:    C? * C      

            ( ;                 )

( +  

   * , 

:  *     (   

      

    



 *      )  

 :      

    

   

         *           

    0  /

          

  

                 



         



           

  

             C*       *  

  )  )9B (#3 .. !"#3

  

   0<  #3(".(!""3    ? ,        

       

 

:   8"("4(!""!( +  , 

      

 

         ,            

 , ,        

     

      )   

      * 

  /

         99  

     



     9 >     ,     99 ( +        )   *  ,  

        *          

      )  

    %# )(+) )1(&'+.)+61))(+)!   # A9          

     *   

 )      :9     ,      )       9

*

 (           *             

     ( 0    

,   

, !"""(   )           *   

 

        

  ,  :         / #8 '     #4..  ,  

 

     *      F

 ,   

  *   

   ( +

  *   

       ?     ,  )          , *  C?(5!-3FC?(5!-.FC?(5!-$FC?(5!-4FC?(5!-##FC?(5!-#$F C?(5!-# F C?(5!-#4F C?(5!-!"   C?(5!-!#  

  

  

 , !""49#"     ?

  (."(""  %&    

   , 

  0      (/  

, 

        ,     ,        , 

*

  

 

 

,(    ?

*  ,         ( /   * ,         

  ,  

,

(+   

  , !"".   *       

     

       *  

       ,               *    , *  / 8 

  , )  

 

  ,   ,   ,  

 *

 ,   ,                 -     

 

 

 *  

      

     )   :     %C &)1( . #)./() &)1(!    +/3/1)*  :2 )1- %0+/,&1) &)()@&)+;'' . #)+)(&/ &6-&6+8  )1(&'+! A  +/3/1)*      

 ,   1

  0+/,&1) &)()@&)+;''!,@),'/7/- )   *   *   , *    *     (   * 

        9   * , 

    

     , *  *

     

*     ,  ,           , 

   *          

 )   ,  * ,       : 



 (        

      

:   

 

 



 *   , 

  ,,*     * ,        )       

*         

       : ,?  *       

  

      



    :*   

 

   

 

   

 (." """-9             ,       >    

 

    ( . """-9    

         *       ,         

    '

7  ' )        

   (#" """-9     

       ,  +       

 (* 

     

   

  

     

 *  ,

         ,    )       7

*,  

 

          >      ,       ,    

  ,     

    , 

  

 

 

  ,     :        

        /  !"         (#" "" """-9( <          



 *      / #4            

  >



   ,      

*     ,

 * ,    * > (+     ,  

  )  

 

 ,     

        )                   ;               ' 

/

            

   )     *      / 4            , :         



   

 

 (

 2           ,           ) B (!!8"  !"#.  

      

,

  ?    ,            ) B (88@.  !"#.          ( 5   

*  

      

 *       (    #   '@'37'+:$A

 5 :-     G-B 5    G-B