Rajesh Kumar v. Ranbir Singh Rana And ANR

  

 

 
        
  




  



! "  #
$%

&


'& (((((
 

 






 ((((( !"#$% &'  
 
)  *+
,&- 


'
.

'&
.

((((( 



( 


 /
 
'
 
#
*&
#0

'1 &
& $
2
!
3%
4

%

 *
 
. 1 
& &
5 
1
  2
 #
$%

-
 


&
$
 2

.% #*
6


,
7

8.6 ,9:
'&%


 

* &
;

& *
 % 
6
* + , &


*
7,< 
!:
&
**

4  '&%
%

* &%


%
&
& &

5 
7,< 
!:



 /
 
'&%


'
=
 0&
-&
& & &
5
=#0



= 
 &

 '&

6
'


 &
+
 1'& .
'



''


 %

 *+
=*
'&
. = 
'&
#0

$ 
 *
&
'*0
= 
*&

# *
 
$  ,
>"6 
'

& 
= 
-+
=

 
= 
<&
 % 
 %+

 
'



''



# *

'& .  /
#
 


 

 
 1'&
.
*&  *
 
&
$
 2

.6
,


' =

= **%&
 

 
*%
=


' 3
* &
 '&


.
& %
 
4

&


&


*

* 

+5

1

?

@ 3 ) &
-&
* 
&&
& &
 

/ 

' '
&

,*


3

 &
* &
 

* 



 +

+

1


 

& -
& &  

/
'
'
'

&



+

+

1

 

&


# 
'



+ +

1+
'
 &
 4 

4 
.

2
& &
  

 %

55 A
4 
.

25
& &
  
=
55
* A
&
4 .

2
& &
  

 %

 +

1
&
**
 &
4 
=
& =

B
) 3

6&
# 
!

'


 




 

>
' 

 &
4 
=  &


 
=


3
8)*'+$,- .-/))$%
&'



%!*0$!9
-&

& &
2 

/ 
 0


&
$
 2

.6
,
= 
 &
# 

'
 *&


3

'



4 

 
&


 '

%&
  
= 
*&
#0
'&
.


'

  
& 5 >
* 


'* 0
-&

* &
 *
 '

&
&
7,< 
!:
=
&





' 
 
 *
&
$
 2
.6
,  )%
%%-&+

'
 
*&

'
'  /
 *


'
  *&

 
7,< 
! :
&


%
&
7,< 
!:





% &
 
 '

%&
 



 #*






* %
  
# &
&#
&
 

4 
=

 & 
& %

0
*% **0
 #*
* #*0 2 /
 *


'
 
&&
 
'&
.
&  

'
3
* &

4 

* 

?

@ 3 ) &
-&
* 
&&
& &
 
7,< 
!:
&
'& .
=*
'%
 *

#

=


 &
* &
  &1* &






'
-&
& -
7,< !5:+

-* 


 &
&

* 
&&
7,< !:
=
= 
< &
#0

'&
.
=
?

@ 3 ) &

'
=
'&
.
= 
 -%

%

 #*  
''0

4 

0
*

/
 *


'  
 
 # &
 

''0

4 


% -0 &
&






 &
''0
 *&

#
 %&
#0

*

/ 
 &
 
=

# %





' =

''0

4 
= 
 #* &


#0
'& .

6
 
#
 
&&
 


 
 '
 &
4 

'&
.
=
% & 
% 

 #* 

/
 *


'
 
 

&
 
=

'




3=

 
 
% &% 
 


''0

4 
&

 
 

 *&

#

&

6*


'

'
&
 
 
'&
.
=  -%

%

&'


''0

4 +

' 

& *0
3&

# 3

'

'



4 
 

/
 *


'
 
 
&&
 
 
%-


 


4 
=
 &

*



* #*0
=
= 

*% **0
 #*
&
= 
- =
 
# &+

 '

%&
 



 #*

&
 * *0
**

 #4 
'&%

*
* #*

#

&

6
 ''


+

 *


'  
'* &
* 
'

    

   

                   !  "#$! $ 

 % "#$

& '(    )*+   !  

,-  " !

'.(    (/(+   ! 

6
 -
&&

 # 

&
#0

 *

 '

 

/
'
'
 
#
*&
#0

'
 **%%
  
7,< 
!:
*&
#0
'&
.


& $
 2

.6
,

>
 *&
 *0


%
 
' &

**%&
  
=
% &

* &
#*%%

@ 3 ) &+
=
'
0

C 

'
 

&&
 % 

4 

>

< 

4 


& &+
$


.6
,

& 

'

'
 
 4 
= 


& %

0
&#


* #*0 !

'
'-&&
&
$


.6
,

''* #*

  
 

$


.6
,
 &

**= $1-2/, 

2, 3$

$"/-2*&4$

,.-!#+$,-.

1-( 55 
!

'

 - 

*&D6
 **
#
'

&+
*
  0

'-&+
 

*&


4 
-&

4 

 
&



 2


& %+

=*


'

+


0
&#


* #*0  /
?9#*
$ ' 
 
  00 "!' ( 2 (*.*
*&
 
<

*% **0
- #*
&#

* #*0




'

'
&
$


.6
,

/
 & '

'
 
#
# &
#0
&& %
%
-&
#0
 '
=
= 

# 

 &
'

'  

   3!(..'( ( (!4(5'

      !   "  

    !  &&&
 (*(5+

= 
*&
#0
 ?9#*
$ ' 
 
 
*
%
-&

*&
#0


&


&+

'

'
&
$


.6
,  
#
# &



  6
-=


#-+


*&
'
 

 

'


&

 #*
 

4 
=

 &
 & %

0
*% **0
 #*
* #*0  +


*&
'

* =
 
'=
&
$
2 !
 
#
<&
=

**% 

4 &

# '-&

 

* =
&
**
 
-*-
&'

&
4 
  
&
* =
&
 
#
&&&
*
&
*
'


%



&
* &

'-
-&

6

<
* 

'* & 

&

?9#*
,'<
 

  3!/)(#( &&&

(.5( '"6    "

 7  !

 '=
4 
 &
#0

&
'

 ' 
=
& &
#0

# 3
=

& + 8)*'+$,- .-/))$% &'

-3$ %!*0$!9
&

&
3
'*
 
 &
4 
=
%-

 0
&

?9#*
,'<
 =*
**=%

'' *
*&
#0

 
*&
 

?%  
 


&


* =

4

%

 *
  *&
#0

''** 

'


'

 #*
&
$  2

.6
,

<

'=
&
$
2
!
#0

'%
 

*
&


&
=
=
&'

&
 $ 
&+

 3
#

 *
 +

&%

 -&+
 
#
#
'' &

5 *0

?9#*
,'<
 

   3!()89 ()8(9&&&

((:!

- 2   *&
 


4 

 &
&
'
%%
& &+
 0


 &+




&

&*&%

*%



'

'
- * #*
&
$
2
&

.6
,
& =

4 

4 
 &
#
 &


 
# & &#

+




-&
&
 *&

#
& & &

'
*&
#0

&
&
$
2
!  6

*%


 &
*&
'

* =+

 
 
% 
 &
&
$
2
!

& & 
 
 4 
=
 &

& %

 
# &
&#

 & %

* #*0
=
= 

*% **0
 #*  C

 
 &
#-+

'
'

#0
& & #%
&-&


&

'

&&

'' 
# 
* &
 *
 


& 
* &0
<&


 &
  ?=-+



&
* 
 
#- 

&
 #-+

 
#
 &

<'

'






 
 +
=

'&%
#

* &
 *
 



7   *#!*8 /!/- Whether reasoned / speaking?

Yes / No Whether reportable?

Yes / No