High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRA-D/340/2020disposed of

Vijay Moulik Dass v. State Of U.T Chandigarh

2024-02-20Mrs. Justice Lisa Gill,Mrs. Justice Amarjot Bhatti15 pages

# $%!"

!((

)*!* + ,-.- /!

0!/ ! 1234 )- 5,).64 36) 1234 )- 5,).64 5 .

..6 " # $%&$%'(%)!& * + ( # %! )!!%% ) ) ( ,,,,, 5 .

..6# 5- -* &%* ( +%! ( '% .!'/ +* &%*% !!01123131! + *!!

14153131

! 67 ! !!%% $

% !'*/!')

(%!

) (%$

% 6 %' 9 +312 !!1212312)%! :$

%.7# %;

<&%!=(%*( -*(%!%* +%*=%(=>+ ( ?

@8A= *!

! "

++ ,8( ) *

0 ( 69:( 9 *

013

@%+%/ /=%(

%6%%7 +

% )* //% *

41)111-

++%%/ ! @)

4)111-= ! 6 %! ($! /%%'

94)111-= ! 6%! ' (%

+!* !#(% 3 %++* +(* ( 11231B)$ .) *( ')90) ) ( '=%($&%! $%'()

&%! $%'()$% 6$%C/ ) *%&%'/

'+ / $ ) $0B) *(! = ) $* 93) ( !% *% +* * !$ )$ . !%& %'% ! !!

( / + +!* !#(%(* /%

!((= ! %' %&. 6 +6= $* 93 )

(6=+ ( 25/ ( % +( /7#(%) '!447

!7 ' 6 ( /7 %! )'!6 34 7

(!6 %'(6!. %%'(= + = )$*

93 ) (+ ( /77

(7 ! =%(%( /% + = 7 % +( (! 6 '( 6 7 >- @%(% * A +$

- &%'C( .()9 @%)$%6 ' ()

/+ /(% &%'6 31!7 ' +

= ;%'(% (6!& %*)(= = ;%'%((6 +(%

+( ( 7 ' 6 7 = = ;%' ( ( @ (!

( (!(7 ' 6 7= ;%'( %!(6=( 7+ (% )(! '/ ;*6=* /%8

+( !( @ 011B31B%( &% %'()( @!

* /%8 +( (!* /!%D !( + ) )+

* %'(6)(% +( ! @ % %!( = ( E!7%11231BB4/)* /%+ =%*(%' ( 6== ( = ! *(%'( )( =((%

0 +( ( = %=%(;%+> ((

A!( = / ;

+ %.

7 (% +*= 7%'!! (6! (% )(!%! %* (% 11= '!(( @(! =7 '=%((%

6 '%'

% +( = / !67( @ ( (!'

!' = !

(% +( + * !%'(%/% ' ! (%*%!D7 '

6 7= ;%'(!(6 00!!11231B! $*% 013 +!% !)5B1>+ ( ? 8A= '% ! %*$% $* 0B) ( (6 + %! / +* /%& %'% = ! ( %'(*

+%& %'% )= + ++*!= !(!( += * & !+ /( ! / = ;% %*

% ( '

( +( * +* %/= *%*;! 67 & / ( '

( / / !! 6 !7 + #(% = ' * !*! + / #$B) ( / /

% E2 * & ! %* = !7! %!%(/;( %'+ ( %& %'% ) (6 + %+ /% ) @=

!+ / ..)% %*%6 ' ()

/ 341531B!+

6%%' (% % /!) ( = 6 '( ( %'

'% ) ++ !!% *

/ 3F1531B!%

*( )6'* %%' !* 6 ! %! (% )

* %%'!( !!

%G( +#(%)= * & !

+ /$ $!)$* 90) (!** !%'7)( %!

%* = ;% %*

% $/ +=%

- B

= !!!+ * /% +*

7+ /%% ) *(= !6+ &% %* !) (

9 0 ( &% %* !) ( &%! !!

91B312) ; &%= ( @ (! '( / ! (7 %* **%7 * //% ( '! ++* ! (! ( 6%%7 !

!* D* ( +)(*%= 6 &!(( =

! + % + @ !) $*% 5>0A +(&% %*> ! *% + (%!

A)*)314)** !%'7 % +

@= ( (%!

@= %!* / +* 7 +*(

&%!!! $*% 312 +

4 @ !!!%% $

% !') ()+ ( %'

'/ )+ /!*( ' ('% @! $*% 013 + ) =(%*(= ! & !E%! (%/% %/'' =(%*(( !! '%7!*%/! % B &(+* +* )

*% E/%!

&%! $%'( H)$$;(=%! $%'( H3) (

H0)%%C/ H9)

%/ $%'()#!%* ++%* ) #$B)

( H4) &%! $%'( HB)$/ (! H2) . (C/ H5) .7C/ HF)$&! $%'(

H1) % !C/ H) $/% C/ H3)

%/;(% (( H0) # .C/ H9) ( C/ H4)$$;(=%! $%'( HB) !

(C ) #!%* ++%* ) / + #!%*%) #$B) (

H2) H5!$ . HF 2 $/ + @= !!! $*% 00

=(%*((!!% **!+ %/%*% =& ) &%!* = !!*!%!+*

4 5 + ( %' '/ !&*! 67 ! !!%% 6%*

* + ($! !* %'( @) (= (!'%7!* &%*!! $*% 013 + ) +

6 &%'''

%&! +(% .!'/ +* &%*% ! +

*) ( 6+%!67(* &%* F H( ! '/ !&*!67 !* + ( ! !* %' (!(&' ( '(( !* +7=%((% 6

* @ !* + ( '!(%(% * ( !% *&%!* ' !%'/ +!* !#(% +(

*% % 6 ! *% */ %&%!*:@ $<( 7(

!% &%*( % %/ 7 + H5 =( ! !( 7((! (% +( #(%=%(( ((6%'(%/! (E!7%(/ %')(+ !(%

+( / !

*% +%! 6% (7/ %&+ (/

+#(%((!

+= (* +

*% ( (!D

=%( ( 6 7= ;%'(6!+ (%

( %!6 7+(. 6 (% ** )#(% * !!( - @ ! + (% ( / ! #(%) ( !* !&%*%/( % * &%*%'&%!* ! 6% ( (% / %&&/ + %!6 7=%(=( /(- @(! D

) +=(%*((+(. 6( * / !!( = & . %!%(%& %'% ( + ( * /%( / + H5( %! +#(%= = ;%'

=%((% +( (% (6 $%! %! = & . %! % %& %'% *%! =%

*% ( + ( %! * *(- @ (6 + * & 7 +6'* %%'6 ! %! (% )

* %%'( '

(!!( ! +!* !)=(%*(= '!7

* & ! ( 6 + !% *

/ +( - @ '! * &

7) % = 6/%! = + 7 ! ( - @ %!!=%

= . %!67( %* 7 (%/ + !%' +!% *

/ (%/ +++*%' %!

* & 7 @ ! * + ( +

! ( + %* $ '%*E/%% E05)** !%' =(%*((/6 !'

?8= !*!+ /(E(%6% %(* ( +(!* !&%*%/) 'G %*) 6 ! / + / ( ) 6 ! / + / /

) = ! (! ! = ( % ( + %* $ '%*E/%% E40 %%' (6 ! / + (!(+ & ! (% (% )(/6 !

= !*! E(%6%3%(+ & ! (% 6( +6 !

= !*! (% E(%6%(6 ! / !%( 6 7= +6 !'

?8( + ) (% '!7 * & !

(!% *

/ +- @* ! 6* *!=%( (/ +#(%= '!(( % !% * * &%*%'

&%!* ! * *(- @=%(/ +#(% = ( 7!(.!'/ +* &%*% ! + *

!67( ! %

%6%(7 +=!

- @! & *D%67**%'( 1 @ !* + ( '!(+* +( * = !7 &! ! + / ( %/ 7 + E/%! H5(! (% +( ((6 '=%(

2 - @(%'( + **

*%011B31B!=((

! ( / ( E !7 % 11231B) (% +( 7 / !=%( (% 6 !77%' * ) =( )- @ (!

/'! =7+ /( H5 6% (!( / %&6(%!( **

*(- @(!D

=%((%

* = ; ) +=(%*()( %!= ; >7 '6 7A+(!(6 #(% * !!(- @ (% * !+ (% ( / ! #(% ( % &%' %'( + 011B31B-11231B / / +#(%= &! !+ /( %/ 7 + !

(C E/%! H2! .7C/ )

E/%! HF ( / / E2)( = %E%*% != !

(+*)*;! %'( ( ! +(&%*%/ ! ( %% + ! + *

)%= (/

('%* ( *;! %*% != !)%.

7 9)=(%*(= ++%*% * !(%

!% 7*

+ ( '

( +(* + **

* &! 67 6 =%! $%'( HB =(%*( = *%*;! 11231B( %!( '

( E2 E30 %%%& %'% ( = *

%! 67$ .

E/%! HF!!!6 !7= + / /E/%% % !C/ H +# 6% %*/= . %!%( %& %'% =( %+!6 !! ( %* + /( =(%*(= (!! & (& %'%' ++%* &=%

(&6 E/%!67(

*% @ %& %'% */%((!

+$ $;(=%! $%'(E/%! HB=( '=%(( %* 7(!

' %6 ' ()

/!(= (!!+ / .. >

/A!6 '(6*; ( 351531B (6 +

5 8 !% *

/ !! 3F1531BE39)6 * !6'= * & ! (' +$ $!$* 90)

( + / =(%*( ! * (% )

* %%'

( '

( !!( * ! +(!* !&%*%/= * & !!

( /= ;% %*

% &%! * & 7//

E34!E3B + $@ &! ! E05!

E0F@ )6 ! / +(- @= 6%!=%( ( /%

% +(

!%= !%(6 7 '

=%(( (% * & ! (6 +(% !% *

/( %!

+ $@% E40( + ) %/ 7 + H5 * ! =%( * & 7 ++ %! %* (6 + !% *

/ + - @ !7 * * (%/ =%( ( / + #(%( = + ( =7+ /( %* (= % *@ ! %

67&%'(&%!*!

%(% * %'(7*/ (* * % (#(%= / !67 (% = ; % - @ ( % &%' %'( + 011B31B-11231B=( ( + )+!+ /( ( + )*( ' + /!'% (- @= !7 &!67&%!* !

!(= %'(7(!'%7! $*% 013 + %! %'( '

&%7 + ++*)(D/ + *%/ !67( ! %

! D% 7% + * = 6/%!( +

!67(- @% =%( / % !( /! &

!% /%

(* %(!) ( 6 '% ! ( / + * /% !! 11231B1"1/=( !

( ( = = ;%' 6= ) 6= $* 93 )

(+ ( 25/ ( !((% +( #(%!

7 ' 6 ( %! '!6 347

= %'(6 '=%((!. %%'= + = +$* 93 ) ( =( ( @)6 '(67(% +( + /

/6 =7>31A !7 %*%!! ( 7 ' 6 7= = ;%'=%((%

+( + 1-31!7 +(% . %%'(!(6)'&6%'

(7 ' 6 7=( +(!(6= %/!!67 !* !+ (% **

* ;* (% &%'%'( + 011B31B-11231B @* /!%D '=%((% +( =( !&% !(%/ D

@' '

7 (% * ( + )(7 * !((6!= H(( ! ( /%(

%! = 6 1B"4/)( %*!((% +( #(% = / !!(% 6 !7= 7%' (* %+ /!( %* !%& %'% = ! - @ =7+ /( '=%((% 6 '%'

*!(%/+ (/ + #(% - @ = *( ' (! ! $*% 013 + &(*( ' ) %*% *!67

%/ 7 + H5)(* /%! * & 7 + * % %* +!* !(% * +

!% *

/!/%!7) H5% 7=%

( %! **

*% ( %! * *(- @ =%(( %!/ (6 +:@ $<( 7!*% */ % &%!* & */ ) :9 * + ! %* %:

<) ) /( %G! ( +* ! &%!* =(%*( 6 * %! ! =(%

1 !%'=%((* 6 ! *% */ %&%!* 9 +( .!'/)%= (! ! "

! ! " #

& & "

" ' "

(

)

* (* %(!) / + H5)(%

!7(

= + /13"11/ 1B"11/ 011B31B)(% +(

'!7* /!%D =%((- @6 1"111"01 / /%+((6+ ;%'(% /6 1"01/ !((6= * !6 "11/ (&

% + * /%)( ! ( /%(/ %' +11231B6 1B"4/=(( =(!!6 !7 +(% +( #(%( % &%!* ! =((!%6=(% % !( % '' +/ ( &(

=((* /% H5 =(% +( %&%(* /7 + @

*) ---

9 !& # %=

&!%:

! <) ; )

! "

(

$ $

* % %'(7 %! 67 ! * + ( - @(

*% !%! 7 . % %! )6 ( + (* /% %%& %'% )=( = !/%!7= ;%'

( %!(6 '=%((% +( %! % &%!7/ %

3 =%

) =( = ! (& ( = %'( ( +* ( % E% + E/%% + (% / % =%

H5!

%'(% *

E/%% * *!!((( /% !

(/ +(7 ' 6 7=( = = ;%'(6 '=%((%

+( ++ = /!67(& %'%' ++%* . %( %!6 7 %%& %'% +%! ( =(7(+(. 6%( % ( 7 &%!* ! %!%* /*(

& ( (7 %*76 !7 ( 6 7= ;%'(!(6=( (!+( * * D ( + H5 !

%' (% *

E/%% !/%!( D

;*%(% * (&

!(/ ( %*( %/ !&%%; * *=%(* %/%D % % * %* 67% 6 * + /(% )

*% ( +%! * *7&%!* ! 6% ((* /% = ! %' %&. 6 +6=

$* 93 ) (( + )(

*% ( +%!

!7&%!* ! &( *!/ %&6(%!(%

* 3

*% ( %! * *(- @=%(( / +#(% (6 +* % * & % !7/! (% * +$$;(=%! $%'(HB! * & 7=%

$ / (! H2 ! ( %* 7 (! ' %6 ' ()

/ 67 % 341531B ! ( 6 + %+ /% ( - @ = %!%+%! ! =

! + / ..)% %*%6 ' (>

/A (%

)(% % /!=

; ! = 6 '( 6*; ( 351531B %'

'% ) @ ++ ! !% *

/ ( ( (! ;

0 * *! ! * (% %! =%( 6 !)

* %%'

( '

(!!( ! +!* !%6* * (6'% .' ! 6(%! 6*; ' + $!) $* 90)

(

!% *

/!!3F1531BE39) 6'* %%' !* 6 ! %! (% )

* %%'

( '

(!!( ! +!* != * & !+ /( 6(%!( ;%' +6 !$* 90) ($/=

!% * !;%

% &%! * & 7//

E34 ! E3B *%&7 ( %/ + !%' !% *

/ ++*%'+ %! * & % ) %!! %&=%

= !/%!7. %!%( %* 7* 6%' !( %!

* & 7= ++*!+ % ! +6 = / ( + / 6(%!( ;%' +6 !=(%*(% **

%6 (

+ %! * & 7 + %* 6 '%' !* !% ! 6+! / * 6 +7 %! 0 ( / ' !%'(

+- @)&%!* + H5% / %H5*%/!%(% E/%% % *(%+( %* (!!(- @+ /$ $!) $* 90) (*

7%'6* !6'+ /=(%*( !*

(% )

!+ /( %!

!( !!

%G ( '

( + (% +( = * & ! H( ) ( @ =

(!!67 %* 7(!!67$$;(=%! $%'(HB+ / ..)% %*%6 ' ()

/ /%+ ( '!(+

( *% +!!6 !7 +(% +( )( ! (% &%'%($ +

/!( + ) !+ !(+/ (( %!

6 ! %! (% = 6 ! / +(- @;

9 =%(( /%

% +

= $@+ ( + %'

!( %(% ' !% E40(% )%% /% !( ( = (/6 ! ( %! ! (% 6( +6 !'

* ! 6!*! (% *=(* %! !%('%&+* / %E

/ %/ * 9 $ .HF% (& %'%' ++%* =( (! *(!

( !* !*!(%& %'% % !C/ H + # 6% %*/= . %!%(%& %'% (6 !!

( %* = %+!+ /( (= + ++*=

7%'( =(%*(= ;% %*

% $ . HF !/%!( +%' % = %+!+ /( (= + ++*&( '(+%' %E = +(/=(%*(

%&! (% *%' ( + ) ( / % %; % /%

%' * *(=%(( %!* %/* %: !

9 !& <;)%= (! ! "

( + )/ +*(- @ =7+ /(

(!7 + %! **

*=% ! (* * % (% = (=( (!/ !#(% (

*% 6 %'

!* &%*%'&%!* * /(*(% +& =(%*(= !

! (% *6* * % (#(%= / !67( - @( 6!% *( '! 4 @ ! %

( +%! * %! (+ %! *

+( * !% * %! ! %% = '7* *!!( *( '+ /!'% (- @! $*% 013 + =

&! (6 +&%!* != !7 +

*% %'( /('% +- @67 !( (! = + 6 ! 6 =(%*( (

*% ( +%! ( + ) % %% ) .!'/ +* &%*% !!01123131! + *!!

14153131

! 67 ! !!%% $

% !') ( >E *% %' =

+ (%!

A %

%6 $/ %

** !%'7) %! 7) +

!67(- @ **!!(% *D%! +(*( '+ /!'% (%/67'%&%'

(%/(6+% +! 6% !% *! 6 !+ /* !7 + (=%()%+ D% !%7 ( * !%' %*% > A %+ 7) !

!% ! + ** !%'7

5 .

..6

36) 7633 5,74

5,74

H(( ;%'- !"

- H(( 6"