Punjab State Civil Supplies Corporation Ltd. v. State Of Punjab And ANR.





    
 



 !
"#!

$$#
%$%&  % '%  !

 (% $      


%

%! (%)*" %($%

!+(%)*,)

 

% &!--%)!%*" .( *%+!--%)*" %%$/  * '12 +%.% 13 # -%4
#)5%).(" -+6"(+%

%!74
-(+ %-%-% +$%+ %(%1%$16)8 #(%)  %(% %-%-% +$%+%+( 9%#1)(($%$% %1

 %(% -%) :/!:

)%;%<$ %( + +$#%!!

);%<$ %%%-%;4- '12 +%=#+) 
) :/!:

);%<$ % %  $ 4($$#)((('12 +% .$ >( :/!:


%"%%?@@ % -%) :/!:

);%<$ %((%@@A ( >(%!-()4$%,%.#%1$(% 4(%-A( >(%!-('12 +%#1$ %(.( %$1%@@@6@@6@?(%-%+>- #"%1+.(;
4A( >(%!-()4$%)(."%)     6 @@?A  (%%  '1  2 +%  
 #  %+    1.(>A("%%8 @@? 1%

-%) :/!:

);%<$ %!(9#.!-()4$%,%. $4(%- >( 
%$# >(%!-('1 +%) 
.%("%((%- >( 
% 9#.!-()4$%,%A(.#%('1 +%. #>(%-.(9#.!-()4$%,%A (  %  (  $ %$   ++  .     +$%-  !#+ 3 %) ;

;%<$ %)*+%!-();# %*+%&#) !%* %);%<$ %A('12 +%(("%(%- (#++#> -%)$ %-% .(>(+##"%.(;
4$%"$%$ %+"% ++A('12 +%) 
("% (%-?@ -.-(-?6@6 B #.( %$ !-()4$%,% %&#)4$%,%44 %-(

 $%7@@7@@7.(> +/4& >( )

:/!:


%A(%($ %$ -  :/!:

)

>( 
%)    (%  ++ %  ++  +$%-   *+%  &#

()!*)4%$#3(%)* %2%((-%)!%* * . ).((% -(  + %$%@@7)(. %(%C+ 1* 9%(  +%$% @@78@@7A((* 9%( # + $$#+%1%$%@@7A($%( %$%* 9%()'12 +%) 
#-.( >(%!-( ($ %(%?@?? -.-(-77B # .(%$1%@@@6 ((+(#"%;
4 -.-(-7B # %-$%8@?8@A(( $- #7@@. 6?? -.-(-  #A(%+78@8@?(1( >$- @ - C6?B #(( >(%!

-(( #- #.776 -.-(-B #'1 +%) 
#. 1(.(A('12 +%%+ @8@?    8@  #"%  ? 7  -  .-(-  ?@767  B #   .()( (#- #8@ .('12 +%.66 - .-(-766B #.(%$ %-(1%@@@6D( #$ %(+#"%1 -.((" -" ($$#)+-# ((%.(%-@@ -.-(-7B #"# @)@)?;
4% .(('12 +%) 
(+ <<# .

:/!:

  D(  #  (%-)  .((  (    .%>     +  

 @B #.("#  )?)78("  + <<# 1 '12 +%) 
)(.%(> - @)@)?  $#   )) 8  $#    )?)7  ##- ))7 )68*%>-$%+$ 1* &-# )%+# ;4%( %!@.%-%D(+%. "- .%%(@ *%  +$#    "-    (%  %+#) (##-( .$%$%#(
 %

$%(##(
 %)$ + %# $((##.% $$#( % $%" %! 
% 
 &%  3 #  -%  4 
#)  5%  -  (  %!7.#-( )(%- (( %().(()($#- #1   #+  %#  D(    .  (  C  %  "    ( $%  D  %-  (+  - #    (   )  (  $%  C++1.#".)+#1 = + %>()!% * ) :/!:

);%<$ %) = .%-#1+)

=  2
  !()  $ 1  -%)  :/!:

) 
(-%()  = E%+(2 +%)$ 1% -%;#) :/!:

!-% %) = E>+!-()$ 1 );%<$ %) =%!-()4$% ,%)D#.9() =?2%(2 +%(-%) = /%( +%)  %  2$%  )  :/!:

)  ;%<$ %)  =7  +( +%)!%* )4"-- %) =*+%&#

6

()!%* %) :/!:

;%<$ %) = %!-()% %)
"#
 %)5%) =2.#!-()%4$% =((($% "# !+       .  %%  %  !  
% 
).((##(%+-% +$$%-- (+.%$ (+ ((##--(( ( ##1"#"( 4") C+=+(

%) !%*)% ) :/!:

);%<$ %=3-% !-()!%*) :/!:

);%<$ %) %-  + *%  (%-  %- +)  #% 3 #  -%  4
#)5%"( + $% ;#---%")( $%%%$$#- ( -+"%%$ 1(3 #

-%4
#)5%).((.-(
 %#% *#!3 -);%<$ %).(" -+7@ $($$#)( -+"%% $ 1(%#
 %B ( ((%- %+-(+ D( % -" 1 #% #.% *$$##
 %% %%"- (% %  D($% (   #$%"('1 +%. (>#-.( >(% !-(+%'12 +%.(#$

?

>(%!-((.%>.(# >(%!-( (1%@@?)(+ <<#+.$%%1% @@).(%$(1#"%.( 1%@@  

=  %  !-(  -  (  .(  (  .  $)(%-..(9(!-(%(  $  9(  !-(  .  (  "%  ( $  .(  > %  -    %  -(- %D(.-( %C+  (  % (    >(%  !-( (%-.("%(+( $ (%-.("%9(!-((> ((%-.(-"-(- %> (% 

=?  2%(  2 +%  (-%)  * %   %-  ( %C+  -  (    $$% 1  . -"'12 +% $% %(+ ($% %+(1%@@@. 1

>(%!-( %(%(%.1 (.(%$D(. %(%-(.( %(1%@@6@?.$ %( 1 >(%!-(  1(;# %(>(> $(1##1"%1.((%(>$%$%#1 % -$%$%#1% =?+- (  (%      %$%  1   $%"%1  %  (

   (+$$%$%(>(% %%%(%$1%@@@)@@@@6@? %-%-  .(  .  +  1  >(%  !-( '12 +%(+1 %% %-(#+ >(%!-(%-%- (.(%$ "

4"%%$%FC =8*) -%% (%-%-(%$1%%+@@@@7)( .(  .  %     $%"  $%    '1 +%  .  #1      (  4$%    ( %$ #1 C%#1 "

4FC =78
)#%#1%%( >(

%) >(%!-(. # 4(%-'1 +%. #(+'FC =78)'12 +% .  -"    #  (%-    
   >(

%  *  $%  FC ?8
 (%  .  (%-   7"# -@)@)?%(%$1% @@@6@@6@? >(%!-(("- 6@@?)(%+$#"(.( % (%.%>. 1 >(%!-((. 4(%-(
% D(#.%*$$##
 %$%/@( -+(  %" %
          

                         

7  


 !!"

#$ %&%''( %) *+ ),-& .$$- 

(  %( $  ()*+ ),-&  -    ) !   &%''(  & .$$- 

( /$     (( %)  )   -%   -$

   ( -(  (( 0 $$-

-() -  %(   -$ ( - $&& ( $/$  $ 

    -$     &    ( %(    %  /  

(( # $$-  / $1- ( ;#---%")(+$#(#(%" $(
 %4( #.(+D(%#1 1#-%"$)#( -($$# % !6(&+*( #>- #1%(%(+$# +(#.% "# #(+.%#9 4(%--" # %1 !(&+*)@?#.(9% &+  $%"-  (  "%1      )  $$#  $%%%)   $$#+%($%% $%(## +#( -( #+(  $ !6("%1$%"(1$$#%1 $$#+1 +%($%% $%($$# (
 %(((  %$%%%-(

@ $$#%+>-($$#.( ($% E%( -((+$#G$%(+" ( $$# %1%$#  #C$#( -" D(%%)41%$($$# (#11#-(%" 41  #%%#1 #-(%"$D(%"$%("-  # %( %%%#+   +(% E."%)+%#)($%("1 41##-#1%%- #%1( -+ $ 1(#%#.%*$$##
 %(%  $ $%$%$$%#$$%"%%%$% #.

4%#1 %+$%"%%("- $ -#$%$#D(%%%%$$%(D( #..###((%"# %(
 % B  #+D(
 %%%#1(%##-#1%%+1 $$%(( -+8%%$ 1
 % #.%( +$%"% %#1  (%".(+%$ #) %.

 9%  

 !"#$ %&"'

!()$*  "&#

 '# !+,

 "&#