High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13208/2020allowed

Dharambir Singh v. Uttar Haryana Bijli Vitran Nigam And ORS

2024-07-11Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri18 pages

!$%&%"

(( )*

+ , (((! % %"

!- .,,

/ . +

(((!&0"

& )*

/ 1+ (((! % %"

!- .,, ,

(((!&0"

& +'

2 / +( , , ,

#$%

& ' () *+

!" "

#$%

....

, , 3 ( )- 4* ' / 0 1 2 134 "

5 0 3 0 "

! "#

6 13( (7 879 :*';, 1

% " 2 " 1

+ <+ = 2 / " 3/ *< 1 >

&; <?5 7 1 " "3 1 + @1 3 "

6 ("3 2 2+

" <+ 2

" "

#$%

+ /

+ " 2 / 1 3 1 <+ 1 "3

5 / <+ "3 1 0 / 1 1"3

< " + 1 , 2"

3 + + 3 <+ /

<+ = / 11 3

/ 3 1 3

3 1 / $

AC1 %B 3

<+ 3 " 3

" 1 + 3 / /2?+ 1

+ 1 / 1+

1 0 2 /0

1 1 $%& '# "( ) * (#"(#"#'

* " +## +#( # ## +

+#" ( #"

"%,%-./ 01#'

(# " # 2(* +## " ( * (#

((

( # "( ( 2# " )

++# + * *% 3 * ) +#( #) (#

""# + * ''+'

# "

#' ++")( 2# " ( " +#( # %#

) '# ) "# "

** 4

'# ( #"

# #' +) (

# '# + ( +

'' "* #" %5

( "# *

( #"#'6*2'

# "

# " +# ") '

* + )

"# ' +#( #

( #'07(% %# "#+ + "*%%'% #' + (

% %8( 2# " '# ")( "*

( #"#' *2'

# "

# " +# "% +# /(+ "*#" (( + )' +#(

2(" #( ###'5 9 #' # * .+) : "

( +

+#" + #'(# #' (# " 2 (( #( ( # ( #"

(# )+ #'#"'#*# 2

# %;

6 1 <+ 0 30

, 2"

6 1 1 ("3 2

3 ( , 2"

11 3

1 / + + / 1 , 2"

1 41 1 + 21 " 1 C 13 + 2 2

= 1 ("3 2 A

13"

3 (

1 C1 -

% 134

1 /+ 1 3 1 21 / + 1 1 / 1

* 1 13"

C1 -

1 "

5 / + C1 > C1 # "

3 2 2 " /

* 1 13"

1 C1 # /1 / /'

+ 2" 31 "

3 2 2

* 1 13"

1 1 "+ 3 "

1 / 1 1 21 " 31 2 2

+ 3 3 + 21 " 1 "+ 134 C"

* 1 13"

" 1 "+ 1 /1 31 2" 1 + 21 " + +

/ 31 1 1 11 "+" 4 D

3 0 "+" +/

* 412" *93 1" 1

! "

#$ 412" ( ' 1

% & '

! " &+++

2 1 "+ /

1 1 21 " + 3 "

6 #

= 1 1 13"

1 "

("3 2

"12 > -

AC1 #B + 30 /2 + "+ 3 31 "+ 3

"12 > -

AC1 #B

/ 1 41

= 1 &1" A

#$%

13"

12 11 "+ 31 0 , 2"

+ 711 2+ " "+ <+ / 11 "+ / ' 1 / 0 30

6 2 "

C1 /3+ 3 + 3 1 , 2"

30 "

4 1 12

, 2"

/+ "

1 1 + "

* 1 13"

, 2"

/ , 2"

0 + 11 "+ + /1 3 " 3 2

, 2"

* C1

2 /3+ 1 +

A 3 B

3 + 1 "

31 ("3 2

* 1 13"

C C1

/ "

* 1 13"

1 C1

/1 /

2" @1 &1" / 4 D 31

* 13"

"32 + , 2"

1 + 21 " 1 C 13 + 2 2

3 " 2 1 0 /+ , 2"

* 1 13"

1 C1

/1 / 3 3 11 3

* 412" *93 1" 1 ( ' 1 3 1 ("3 2

= 1 1 13"

1 "

&1"

"12 C1

#$%

+ 30 /2 + "+ 3 31 "+ 3

7 1 , 2"

13"

3 / 3

* 1 13"

("3 2

1 3 ( &1"

11 3 1+ !1 + 21 " / 3 "

* 1 13"

3 1 3 , 2"

1 3 2 + 1 21 "

41 "

1 ("3 2

* 1 13"

2 2 /2

" <+ / @1 " "3 1

* 1 13"

/ <+ / 11 3

2 ' 1 C1 % 31 3" 3 1

41 1

* 13"

' 1 $

0 30

1 "

/ / / /0 3 1 1 21 " + " 3 1

+ /

+ 3 /

21 "+ , 2"

1 ("3 2 /0 3 ( &1" 12 3 1 3 31 /0 11 3

< 3 "

1 + 21 " 2"

"12 > -

AC1 #B / @1 ("3 2

1 1 %&&,-,./)0100&,//02 <4<=/+= ) <(

# #) !)!

% #!#%,6 6, )> /,6 66 = /#(

? %+# 3/3,2.3403/3,2.,54% 5# %

.83- 9 14# % ##

<4<@<@4 #) !

% 3##%00

"A:404 (6*78&

* 4 ,

* #9 :

* *

* '

)'# #'##* ' ( + # #' * + ) # '

++" #' % 5# #++

") # %%B% ( "

"%%B" #

# '#" '

"+##'' " #) <<4 #

) #

* " * +#( % )#((# '# ( #

* # # ##0%0%A.3)* <<(*

#* # "'##*

# "

# ( 4+#4

A & '

; '

;&<

* * (

;

25* &= *

$ /

(''

6 ('

> 3

; ' ) * #' #) # ( # '

).++# " # +

.83 "+#"* " ''+% C=!@<@ #) !)!

% < 2 " &1" C1

1 1 <%%B #A0.3)& +" +

# %3 D

83-.

%5#

.83-#+#

+ 14# %9 * !>.

#D . '( '

#D 3 ( #* #% 5 & " " # ) #

+ * '#"

5'#'##' (

#' : D .54> < # % F

" '( * #*#''% <' G

)* '#"

%5# ).83 -# +#

+ 1 4# % 9 # *

.83-

1* " +#( #' %F

" '( * + * *

#' > ( #( % %

.83-#

1+# +"( #+

# %..

-#+#

+ 14# %

9 '# *+ #'' D '( '

# D 3 ( (#*

## " +#( #'#*#'')5'#': D .54><# %F

") '( % "#'*+ #''D . '( ) %.).4# %

9 *+ "#'' "*

+2"# # #' D . > ( ) # '

# 3 ( #* #A %5# .83-#+#

+ 1 +"# # + #'54> " #" ##' 5 #'54>*

")'# ((# '# + (' )# #*#'')5'% "# #) ' #+2#'+ ++

H'"#*% &*#' #) ++"+#"

#""

- !

* *(" ( *

? @

- & '!

* *("

' * * $ - 4 & ' ;

&< > - ?25* (

* , ('78 !

* *("

4 !4 "A & ' (

'* & *

*("A & '!

* * (" ( *(

4 0!4 "% 3# # % 3 83 -.

# ( #

('# #" '''# "#( ' ( + #* "+#( " #* # "+#( * # 25#+#+ "

'" ## " +4"'+F<*+ ) '# * +

"% <"

"%%B #A.3& +"

+ '

# %

.83- 9 1

# '

++"#' & '?!3

* " 4< %9

#++

" ' #D . ' '" '

# D #) !) 3

% 5 & " # )* '#"

5'#' D .54><# %F

" % ' * #* #''% <' #)* '#"

%5#

.83 4< % 9 #*

.83 " +#( #' % F

" A ' * + * * +#( #' > +#( + % %

.83+# +"( #+

# %. .-#+#

+ 14<%

9 '# *+ #''

D ' .'" '

#D 4) 3

# " +#( #'#*#'')5'#'

D .54><# %F

" % ' % "#'*+ #''D . ' '" ) %. .4< %

9 *+ "#'' "*

+2"# # #' D . > '" * + #

#D 4)3

% %5# .83 +"# # + #'54

" #" ##'

5 #'54>*

")'# ((# '# +(' # #*#''5'% "##) ' #+2#'+ ++

"'"#*% .' #+") %

.83 * ##" * %5# D

.83 #

#( )

2( " %5# D

.83 #* (#'

' ' "'

##(

%5#

.83* '

"#F& ( +#"#% 3 834.& <4< <I<I4 !)

1 /1 / /

("3 2

+ 2" "

+ 21 " 1

1 C1

&1"

12 + /3+ "

&1"

3 + 1

3 2 2" "

1 1

< /

< *E3 1" 1

B *!"

3 1 $%5 (##'

# " #'

##' (#

(# # ( # # #

(# )(+# * #+

# ' "* +# % +# # "

" '

# ##2 # "

+ + +) ) + + +( # # +#'# " #'

# # '" # * " ''++

* #'# # " #' ## '# "

'#"

#'# # " %&' +# +##

+#+#

# " * ) '

+) #) ## # " *#"# ' "* )' +# +## +#+#

#+ "''++

* '#"

#'# ( #'# " #' #) ## + # " *#" "#( " ' "* + (( #( ( #+"

#'##*"%5 "+##' #

"(# 3 %D%9 D

##'

" # " #'

#)*#('# (# #"+ #*

* ##'( # " #' #)

+# ''"

%&+ "+ "

#' ( #* # '# * + (# +" ++# +* #'

(# " * "#( (# % #/ # "(

( "6 #' +# ''"

) ( + *#" "''+'# # #"

") (#

((

" + ++# +*

#' (# "# *

#'(# ( G#%;

( ' 1

% & '

*!"

3 1

$%.( #' '# "(

*#" #*

+ #'+#

+#' +' #'#""#

+#"+

"" ( + ' # " '% 5 '# "

" #" '"#"

* + "'

# ( #' "#'#@ ( # + #' #'%%%D

D # 2 BB-1 :B "% %*

@+ -(

1%#* ) '# " "

# "

# # #" (#

"* +#( # '"

" +#"+ #' (#

# # '

+# # +# (+ # ++##' )+#"+# ''++

+ ++# + * "+#"##' +# #

"+"( +# # %5 # # "(

,#' " + #'D

D # 2 @+ -(

1 " A $,%.(#

F#%

# # #" (#) +

# "

## @#+* # # " #' +#

+( #"'# + ## " #

" +#"# #' (#

F#% %+) (#

F#%

#"# ( #+##'.

+-1 ( F#% )

#') G#

* # " #'

# ++# + * +#

+ #'

5 + " (#

(# # @ *

#'( %&#* *"

'# #' # " #+#+

"#(# # #" #' # " %&

# 8

%##'

&" .&9B0 : ## + #' # "

#' /( # 2 @ @# @"+

@#+#+ "( #' #' + /( #) #

" #' # " # + * +# 2 F#% ( % 5 # ' "

" #' # " # #" (( *# A -1 * (#

F#%

" # (##

2# -1 *

"* +#G+J "' #' '") "

# " #' # #'

F#% *

#'( %& # "

F#%

# # #" (# " ##'+

F#% "# # * +#G+% 5 +#G+ "

# 8

@+ -(

1"##+" # #' + #' (#

F#% ++# +* "+#"##'

+%5 * 2 ## +

" " '' " ## + "+##' # 5 #'< ". %%9 !

.&9B: ,,J9%%8 + %5 #'

"< %%.%!#% 0B4: "+"" # %%B:J

(

%5 ##'&" .&9B:6 06JK " 3 %5 ##'&" .&9B:6 66BJ.%F%

%##'&" %.%!#% 64::"+""#%%B:: "

". %% #'

-B,61 )5 "+#

"+" "'##*"

K" + #'

". %%

" .&9B: B%;

' 1

-' +! " &+:

3 1 %5 # *#"

# # +# "

"+##' (#"# (#

###

/# # (#

" +#

'#""#+

+#"+%+

" G " # " (# "

%B%6 -./ 91

" ' " > + # # #'3+( # (#

#)>

" (# ) +#"++ # #*#"

#+# " '#"

##' "+###+#* + #' (# %5 "+##' (#"# (#

# * +

(% % +# #'

)

# +# # "

( # # "+# +# " ./ 9#"(* +#' (# ) ##((# #'

"# "

#*+ #+

"# "% 6%& #**"

+ #'

((#4+#

+ (# ) ' # " #'

"(#' +'#""#+#"+

(

(# (# #+#"+ G

" * + + (#

# #+ "%& '

+#' ( + ) "+##' (#"# (#

## "(* +#' (# + # +

##' ( +(#'

+% "

3 2 /"

0 , 2" "+ <+ / / / 3 1 ' 1 / C1 % / 1

1 43

, 2"

<+ / / 11 3 /

(7 1 3

1 1

/ / ("3 2 1 1 / &1" "

4 1 1 31 2 3 "

2" 1 + 21 "

' 1 +

1 2 + 30 /2 + "+ 3 / + / 1

6 / 1" 3 / /

"12 > -

AC1 #B

("3 2 A

&1" A

#$%

B / 1 +

2 2"

' 3 0 30 1+ 31 + 3 + 30 /2 + "+ 3 " + /0

= 3+

2 , 2"

+ " 13 + 2 2

/ 31 " " /0 " "

) , , * ((

7 89- 0 2? F?, 3 F?,