High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1029/2007allowed

Sulekh Chand And ORS. v. Ram Kumar And ORS.

2016-01-28Mr. Justice Rajesh Bhardwaj11 pages

!! " #""

$%$

" "!

!"#$% #"% &"'$

" & ' ((()* + , - !! " ' . /(* + , - "!

0 ' !

* + , - "!

12", $!3 #()*)&(+,!

" ,/$ "2!! " -/ ! , 044 '

#/," , ,/$/( - +/ / $

+/, ,,/ )/ , 5/( (/"

20627148 9 -

/(+/,;<*)/,)" /"$/"" 53'

,,/ /$"/5*$(9 -

/5;<)/ 5"+ +/""

-,,/ )/ /(+/,/"

5/" /(

" /"-/ *,/$ "+-/ /"!!(/"

) !"" 53 /5

% $#- = ) ,/$ ! " 5/( ' " 84 86 =>>? ) -/ * ,/$/( , - - /+ %$ +/ / $

,,/ , "

,,/ "/, !

/!=8 ,/$! /'

86 -=>>?

+// " "- )"&2

!"# ! " # $" "" %& '

" (# ) "

#" # %& '

! $" "* $ +"* ,# -"

" &"! * $" ! ,#" !/ " #!"

" /%' $" "*$) * )" " #

# # $ / " " " # "#) # # ! !-$" . $

" /$ # " ) )

$ " "*" /$)%) $* " )

" ! *

) ""

!*$*3 1 " -,/$ "*/5/-*/" )"=0 3"

( )" "-2$! 3 /( ,/(@ / , * 53 /( A>>>@2 ! $ /$ " ! " " ," ( $ !/ ( 3

,/$ " 3 ,/$ -0>,"- / ( 8 )/

$ -/ 53"!

" 0 =/ /+ ) /(+/,*/ )" /

)" ,"

" (/( /+/(

/(+/,53"!

02 $%$

0 ?

12", $!3 / / " "! )/

$ "

! * /- 3* )" ," * / )"

(/(, /+ $

,3,* )/, )" 5/( /+ 53 /+ %$ / " (/( $ )/ , $!3/( )/ --/, " )" - ( +/ )"

/( )" "

+/( /, $ 4 /$ ! " 5/( ' 84 86 - =>>? ) !

( 53 /5- !!

" -,

+/ , -/ /("

)/( , "

/ /""" ) -$ /5

,""&2 9/< B )","

" (/( /+/( , 2062714853 $ /(2"!

0*"( C

9//< B ,/$ "2 / ,

, + 3 $ - , ,,

- /+ %$ / * /- "

) $ - $) $C

9///< B ,/$ "2 ,

, + 3 $ - , ,, +/ / * /- "

) $ - $) $C

9/+< B /" +/ 3 $" " -/",!

/,3*"( C

9+<

/- 6 !!/" -+/ ,* /5,

/"" 0 !,

" (/( /+/( /( +/, 53 "!

2 " /(/ -/+%$ /+ $

,3, )"* )+* 5"+ +/"" -,,/ /"

5/" /5* )+*"""" , $ - +/"=," )+*/+/) -/ /"" 0*,/$ ")

, + 3, - +/ A D , "- !! ""( /5 " /( $ /

,$ 3 +/ , -/ )/ ,

/( -/ +/ ( ,/$ "2!! " / /"

+ /( +"/ / )/, )" ,

/$$ / 3 - ,,/ "

$ -" "

- $ !3

)" ,

5- /5

/, !" ,(/"

$%$2 /+ /(+/,)/ "!,/-/,,()"-$ / == >0 =>>?* "!

02 $%$ ," -/+%$" )" +// , !3 -,(2" )" !

, ,

"E 28 /"( )""

/ -/ !

"5$/

53 !

/, , 061 * , !3 )/, )" !, ,

" E 2? ,,/ !, == >0 =>>? ,#" 4!/* $ (

3 +/ )" 5 (

/+/ "!/ * $ ( 9( /< == >0 =>>? / )"$ / !

$ !

9E 24< 5

3)"5 ( - $,#" !/ $ ( 9( /< )" "

/./" !"

9 +/<, 55,"

"/ ,,/ 5

3 -/+%$)""

5 (

"!/ - !

$ E$/ - $ ,#" 4!/

/")5 ( 53 /"!/( 871

/" ) / /-/ 53 %$+ (5/ /( )/ """ /" " )" +/ )" )/

/+ %$ /" $

,3, /$ - ,,/ /5 /( /" +/ , (

")3 $ B20 / )/- 2/+ %$ ) "

")" $

,3, -"5 /$

- ,,/ /" ) ," - "!

!,/ /5" "

""""$ 3/, $ +/) )"!

2( )"

/ ) $!"$ -=,""""" 53 /5/" )"/ 7 D , " - "!

" + (

/5 5"/" - +/ , " /( 3 5"+

+//$

,,/ )/ /(+/,/"

+ +/ ,)"!

, 53 ,/$ "

/ ," (/+/( 3 "

- / -, )/ -/ /(" /5 0> (/+/(,- (

"5$/""/ " - "- ! /" !" -,

-,/$! "* -/ /5 " , $$/

)/ ,

-/ +/ / $

,,/ )/

/( +/, == >0 =>>? /"

5/" /5 /( +/ +/ , ,

!!"

+5(

")3 53 "

$ B20 /)/- 2/+ %$) " !

( ),"53 ! /("

1 ")" $

,3,)/ "5 /$ -,,/ ,/+ /./"5

+/9 < )""

,3, 00

!!,/ "

/$ 3 B20 / /!

!!"!, /+*/ ) 5+

-/"

! /("

,,/ ", / /!=8 -,/$ ! 5/( ' 84 - =>>? -/ /

" ,/$/( , - - /+ %$ )/,

!, == >0 =>>?)/ /(+/, =8 ! ",/5 / - )/($&2

! " " # $" "" %& '

" (# ) "

#" "" ! "*" # %& '

*# ) $*" " &"! * $" ! ,#" 4!/ " #!"

" / $" "" %' $" "* $ ) * ) " " # # #$ /" " " # "#) #

! $" $

" / $ # " ) )

$ " "*" / $ ) %)$* " )

"!*

!*$*3

" 5 + ! /(" " ) ,/$ "* /, B20 /* + ! ()/ /" "/"

;" ( )" ( $

,3,

/ / - 5/( ," +/, ,,/ !, ,#" 4!/* $( !

9E 27< -/+%$/ )" $ / + , $ 5

3 5 ( - $,#"4!/*$( 5

3 -/+ %$ )" / /-/ 53 %$+ "

- $

(5//("

- $ " -!

9E 24< +/"

" )" 5

3)"5 ( - $ ,#" 4!/ )" / /-/ 53 "$ %$+

(5/ /( ( )" (

" ) "

+/ @ )" !// / $

,3, - /+ %$ /$ ,,/ /(+/,," /+%$ +/ " /( / / "!

/, /+"

/( !" -/ !

9E 2?< )/ /

",/5" +/ ()/ /+ %$/ !3 -,(2" 9E 28<" )"

$%$ /+ /(+/,)",(2" 53

-/- /,/'(/"

*( /*- --, , 1>82 /

9 <- ,"/( /+ %$ +/

" (/( /+/(

/(+/, 5 +

,$ 3+/ ,

+ 3/

5 / )" +/) )"!// /

,3, - /+ %$ + "!

" +

/ /"-, / !3

,/$! !3-/ / ," ' 86 - >? >8 =>>? -/ 53 ! " +/* "!

"+ ) ! +/ )"

," / 3! 53"!

" 0 =)"

" (/( /+/( /(+/,53"!

12", $!3 / / " !3 ! F ( )"

/( )" /, $)"/ G 01 ,/,$"

," /","" 5 +*/ /"H/ "

(

/ )/- 2/+ %$ )/ !!/( "

B20""

")")/ "5 "!// /

/"$

,3, ""

/ /./"5

+/ ( - *) / "!

/ ,,/ " ! +"/ - ,,/ (/+ / ! -/

/*"9 +/<)"!// / $

,3,)/ /+%$ 08 D , " - "!

" " ( - +/)!! " B28

3 /(5 $/)/,/" ( / / ,,/ /"

32)/ "" ,,

,,,

"!!

,/$ -! " +/ " (

/ / )/ /(+/, 0? - +/ !! "

B28 "

/" ( " / / "/ ,,/

== >0 =>>? )"

32)/ ""

,,,*" ",* ,

5 E!,

(/+ /"

",/5

$ -,,/ )"

+"(("

/" (

/ / )/ /(+/,

!,/ 04 25

,$ 3 +/ , ,

/","" 5 + /" "--/,/

, , ,"/ +/ / / /5", $$/

(+ )/ /(

,$ 3 +/ , ,

/ /" ( 5"/" "

/$ 3 B20 / " ,

-/ +/ " " ,,/ /H"

5/" -/ /5

/"" 0

/"--, /"+" /"!

+ ,

+/ ()/ /+%$ / /,,/ )/ +/,* )/, /$ - ,,/ )" 5/( /+ / " (/( $53"!

0 06 /5 """" !35

,/$ "

+/ " = ," /" )" ,, 53 /( ! ,3 -,/$ " /, $

-0>>>@2!$ $/

3* )"!

( B28 " "

" )"

/ ) 53/(A>>>@2!$ 5", 3

,$ 3 +/ ,* + /-* /" ! - ,/$ " /"

,,!

/5/( , !"

*/, $,5 " - "/ 5 )/, / 3 =>>? )" ?>>>@2 ! $ ," -

" # $$ %&'

!, >A 00 =>>8 !E /, $ "4>>>@2!$ , "/ /(

5 - /+""/ .

5 "/$/,"5- //( / ," -

(

)

# *+$, % %* !, =8 >7 =>>7 //( """" /, $

" 6?>>@2 ! $ %!/( / +/)

5"+ "/5 +,/ ,""*$ 3/, $ / /" ," /" " ?>>>@2 ! $ /$ " "

, -0,- "" - + --, =?>>>@2- -E!"" )"=03" (* " ",* / +/) - $" -/E / ," - -

% $$

* $ /!/ - 0A /" !!/ / /" ,"

"""" $ ! ,3 0A /( 5 + -,

,, * ,

)/,,/$ " /" 5 "- )"&2

(

)

9/< , $ +/ ?>>>!$ 9//< 0@= -9/< , "!"

E!"" ?>>>2=?>>I =?>>!$ 9///< - $ /!/ -0A /"!!/ 9=?>>J0=J0A<I ?8>>>> 9/+< "" -"

* + --, 0>>>>> 9+<

E!"" =?>>> /

. 07 +/) -$35 + /",""/ * /"

!!" $/ "$/",,!

) !"" 53 /5/" " "/ ,/$ " ) , 4*4?*>>>@2 - +/ $ )/,3/ "

K6 ?L!$- $

--//( ,/$! /, /M /(/"

/( +/,* $ - , " 5 !/ "!

12", $!3)/ /"/E)" !()/ , 0#"% &"'$1 . !"& 6$ &)7(8