High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCR/2190/2020disposed of

Gill Rice Mills v. Punjab State Grain Procurement Corporation Ltd. And Others

2020-12-04Mr. Justice Girish Agnihotri9 pages

!"!

#$%&&

!"!

#$%&&

!"

$ '()& * )*

# $"% & ' " &"(%& ' )"

* "%& ' ) +, &-, , )

, . * + &,- *"

"

( "!" '

) !

) ( () -/012

")

$! ) 3"! ) "

!

45 4545 7 48 "

$ "

) "

) ' ) $ !

'

19 4545 7 118 "

$

&

/ : !

% ;"

3"!!")"

19 4545 7 118 '

" "

&/:% " $

)"

15 45457 28

<=

!

)"

" ".1 4545%

)

!

*"

'

$ ''

"

"!" " "

3

"$%"%)"

( ) '$ ''

"

%

)"

) " " ' ;"

)

"

%")"

' " "

' ' )

$ "

'

$

!)"

" '

!

42 5> 4512% "

' : !

7: /'8% "

" ) "

))

"

- 14 ) "

! '

) $

%" )"

( ) '$%

""

' '

!

42 5> 4512

""

)) "

!! ! ) 19%?2%55%@12 42

-

""

))

)) A16B )"

))"

C)"

*"

"

15

"

" "

"

$

%"

) =

5?

-.)"

%"

"

" ! "

!

42 5> 4512%

0 !

)

& , @@. ) 4512

&/:%

52 4512%

@1 9 ) $! "

=

) "

!

5> 4512 )

*"

&

/ : !

%

$"

)"

!

)"!

$ $

0 !

"

)"

" $ "

( "

) ) "

"15 (! $)"

)!)"

52 & )"

1> 4512%

0:/!'

&/:

(! ) )"

*"

)

$"

$

12 4512%

&/:% )

52 - "

%

"

0:/ )"

$ !' $(!

"

) 45 =

56 &"!

%

" "" ""

52 4512 12 4512

$

*"

!

56 4545 "

56 4545%"

0:/ '

<=

!

7;/ 8

*"

" )

$ "

$ !

'

) )

7 ' ) "

) "

0:/ " $ )

$ ""

8

"))"

%"

)"

"'

15 4545%"

<=

!

"

"

0:/ " )$

$

""

)

&/:

52 4512 12 4512% "

!

"

0"

*"

) " " "

"

)"

"

$ &"!

% '

"6)"

% ")"

""

=

! '

4@ 4512 "

) "

) 49B ) "

-)"

"

0:/)

0?2..04512 "

% %""

' '

54 -""

""

' " "

4@ 4512

$ <=

! %

&/: =

)"

"

3

D %" %" 1.

4545 7 158%

0:/ '

&/:

(!$

)"

"

( )

"

19 45457 118

$

&/: "

" !"

$"

&/:

""

)"

&/:)"

!

=

!" $

&"!

%

( )

2)"

! $"

15 4545 1.

4545%

)

&/:

)

" % 4

"

)"

7 & ) )

$ "

%

" )

' ' "

" !!"

56 4545

&/:% - " ' ' !"

!

45 4545

$

&/:%

%"

=

!

!

*"

)' )$ "

*"

! '

)"

) "

" '

!

45 4545%

&/:)"

"

) 4 " " )

"

15 4545 1.

4545)"

)"

:/"

)

0"

& "

'

% " !

% " !! "

) !

19 45457 118 45 45457 458

$

&/:%"

"

)

*" " .1 4545

) !

#0

! "# $% & '(

) "

0 +, &-, ( )

"

19 4545""

"

$ )"

(!) 45 !

)')"

'

*"

) 45 ( "

) =

!

$%

"

" )

0>.1104512 " " !! "

5@ 4512

$

=

! -

"'

44 4512%" "

" "

%

! "

=

!

" $

" "

(

"

E$ (!

"

! ) "

)"

( ;$%

""

)

$ "

44 4512 $

"

&

&/:%

)

"

&

%

&/:

4512 ) 12 4512 "

""

"$"

0:/ D

$""

) " " "

'

$ "

0:/ "'

)

$ "

&/:

45 4545 "

52 4512 12 15)

#0

)

**+ % ,# '# - ,# % %' % ,# %-#%

%' %

,#.

%% % ' %' .

' - ,#.

#

'.

# %-# ' '

/'% % %-#% ,#

% ' % / % ' %- # # %' 0 # % ,# %' ,# # 1 # % %1 # # ( & " !

%

" "

) 02@410--0454546 -" 9

) $

#0 .

##

%' 2' ' # ' 3 - 34%56- 6 '

#'-%' 6-# ' # ' ' (

" "

) "

)"

""

) 0124204545 ! "

F " !

) F( ) - " $ ) !

!!"

)"%"

!

F( "

"

) )" (

,

) "

$"

"

)

- $%"

%

"

"E

%"

"

)"

$! "

" ) ;/ "

) "

"

'

& " !

%

" )$ "

0F("

" $

"

1?

4545 7 1@8 $

0:/ ' ' D "' )"

.1 4545$" %"

F(

"

1?

4545)

0:/

$% "

""

" ) "

!'

(!""

4 " C

$ )$ )

!"

""

F(%F " ""

!"

$ !) )

)"

" $ D "

$

" )' $ "

'%"

$!

'

!

)

'

'

" " -

)

'

%"

) !

#0 78

""

)=

)44 4545

&/:%

=

$ ) $ "! ) $ &"!

%

" " "

"'

" )!

"

)=

44 D %

)"

!$ % = ) $ " !

" "

" "

'

78 * "

$ "

&/:% 15 $ ) % $

$ "

%

4545 " =

" "

)

$"'

.1 78 " 0$"

(!

C ) 4 " " )

"

'

15 4545 1.

4545

"

!

45 4545

"

F( ! "

$ " ) "

- ) ) " ) "

$ ) "

) " " "

4 % "

! ! / $ "

3 )"

0:/% " " "

)"

G""

'

%"

' ! "

78 "

)

%&& - !,!"./#!.

,!

01/