← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaXOBJC/42/2022allowed

K. Ishwar Babu Lal And ANR. v. Kaushliya Devi And ANR.

2026-01-31Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma11 pages

         

!"" ##$%%&'() *)

 "

+     $)#,'-$'() $)$.*$-,'/0  1 .,',2'3$-,'/0

 1 #%,&-$-,'/   1   

     

 /  4"          

 

        

     

 



  

   !!!!

      CM17585CII2025 "

#

  

  $ %  

 "&'(  )  * +( * )   ,



  ( -

)  

 



 

  

        

 

/

%   

 

 / 

     *  $ 1 



      * /  *

 

 

/

 '

#  * +( * )   

XOBJC822025 #      *     



) 

  "3 "3 ,3"+  

 

  "''

 4

 "&++ *  

 .

# 



      )      5 "(3"('3 

) /  &7 

   5



 

   ,, 3& ,3"2 +

       



 

 *  # 

      8        * 

 "  "     & #       

 

 *  #

/ 

    #   *    

/





  

    





"3 %   

      /



 )

 1 -,++',3,3 #*



 *

    

/ / ""

#   

  

* /    9:-;<.

0,,3,$=  



",

>        

  /    / 



 

0 ""!    "( ?@   Sarla Verma Vs. Delhi Transport Corporation and Another 5 6 1 2#.$7$,2.(&)$) 8

 /

   

 

 A30                       

  !

      

    "  #  $          

    %    &   #$       

 $     !

    $       '   ()*+,          

 -+$'()*.,   

 ./$ ' ()*0,  

! !

    

 

$     

1 

 $  

$  023            !

$            $  

     $     

(, 

 "  

4$   $  "     

       

     1    $       $

         $ $   

    

 

$

      $ 023        !

   023   

% $ 

        $

      

'    $    !



 '    

 "  ' 

* * * * * * 42.    

    # (.,   ( 





   5$ "#  # ,$    

   

)6(  )0-2 -) -0 ,$   $ 7')8 -/+2 $7')/+)+0 $7')0+/.2 $ 7')..).0 $ 7')+./02 $

   $ $7'))0)00 $7'9 0//2 $7'8/)/0  7'0//82 

"0 ?@  

National Insurance Company Ltd. Vs. Pranay Sethi & Ors. 5 1 1: 8 

  "'' "'(

"'+  4

 "&++ /)



= B  

) C  

 D 9;= 

 )

)  D 9.=

)     

*)

D 9B= 5   )  

 

*     



C / 

D 9E=  

) 

 

) / 



D  *  C

* #  

)   

 A52. : conventional heads $ 

       !

 ;

< 1    ; -0$222       !

$  ;  )$22$222     ;)$22$222                !

 ;

 

 = $          $ 

$          

     > "  $

 &   : &  

          !$ " $

       

       

   $       !           

$

1   

 "

 "

 

&  $

  

  "   $  "   !    1      $  $  $         !

       ; )0$222$ ; .2$222    ; )0$222    

    

    

     

?    ' & '  "

                           &       

      )23



              

@ @ @ @ @ 59.3    $  023

 

   

 $          .2 $       +23$     .202

 1     02/2

$   )03  : 

     

  !

59.4 1    '  (, !

$  .23

          .2 

9 :  -03      .202  )23    

02/2    

     

  

  ! 

59.5 4  

$ 

  !

$  

 

+2+-

A B       

59.6.    

   

 

A C  

.- 

59.7     

  



59.8 ;       $  $   $    !

 ; )0$222$;.2$222 ;)0$222  

 

    )23  

 "$

?@  

&;7&$'$.&% ')2.&'3$ ,7#&'<"=7=($-+) &'2&7&%=&)>2>.2&7(>$.)5 : :

 0 8  )

&.%&+$.7& )2#.&

.&'&< $(>= 2#.&  

) ) 

5 

 

 E21 :#  ? # F

 <         



                       1  

:

$G G     

 G    G$  G

   G$    G

 G       

$ $ $$ $     $    

    $   

 !     

-) ) Spousal consortium 

    

  

  '

          G

$  $  $

 $ 

    G

-) - Parental consortium        

$ G



$  $  $   $ 

$  

G

-) + Filial consortium  

          :          "   



     

         #     $

 $



   



#   

            

7    '      H  !    

     7   



         





6             $   $     



  7A  : 

  



    

$   

  1      

              $     $

   

   

  F 

 

   

      : : % #

     % $     

     

  

 

   

  

  



    G  G

  F

 < 1  $ 





       $      ; .2$222         

 

"'



   

   0$ *  





 *

     

 

*



)   .8 *

 "0 / 

 

 

"2

 

   

)*

 

* 

5 ""+03 

   

"+

 

   #

)*   " (  /  

) C



  

     



C ?/ #

 ) )  

   

*     

     



 

 

#

 8   )   " "& > /

 / * ?@ 

 

)    

/

#

  "3 "3 ,3"+



)* #   

    





   Sr.

No.

Heads Compensation Awarded "

* > 5 ""+03  ,  ,$7 5 ,&'3  9,$7 ""+03= ( B  /  

C " ( 5 0&((  9"0+33 :

" (= #

>

5 &+'2  9"0+330&((= $  "0 '

B* 5 "'$2'$'  9&+'2:",:"0= % E  5 "$333  + 

EC 5 "$333  & % .

 5 +3333    03333 "

1  03333 "

"3 ,(&%,7#$')&(=,'

) 9?19?1 1@ ""

$-23(=,'

 * #

) 0?

?01 @

", '>&'3$-&7,2'( )?11?61@ 9?19?1 1 0?

?01

,3 

  

 * ?@  Dara Singh @ Dhara Banjara Vs. Shyam Singh Varma  60

R.Valli and Others VS . Tamil Nadu State Transport Corporation (2022) 5 Supreme Court Cases 107?   



)   $A3%2-=';(>$#$.=,-,B-$%&<,B:0-&<)='B=%=';(>$3.,)),CD$3(=,')

&7 

 



 )

    F  ,"

#

 

   

 

) /  / #

/

 /

 

 * 

)  # #

    

 

) / 

 

  

   *  #   

  "3 "3 ,3"+ #

  

    

  #

,, # *

5 ,$333   *

 





     

,( )

 9= 

*

 

 1        

:

*

   G  )  )   )