← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1181/2007allowed

(O&M)Hardip Singh v. Tara Chand And Others

2024-10-04Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma16 pages



     

    

!"

#$%$!&'

#!( ) * )+$, -$&./ 000000,, 11 & 2%0  )

/ &+

&+ !/ )% 000000 %,!&+ &%  34

-0 - -  -  



   

   



   

  

  !!!!!

-  -

0

4 " # 

 $ %

&  ""'     (    "''   )  "*++$   

 #$(  % ,     -   #$( -.    &           $  

/

%

   &    -  

-  #$    

     

  *"*** 

/

  $  01 2

%&  % 3((  $ (  10")0"'4# & $ % $

    &  

%$   5  % 3  ( $( *  

(2$ %%   10""0 ""$ % $ 

"

   %%

 $$ %     

      ( 

0

 (  

(  6(     7              

      

/     8    %            #$(      & % ( 



     

  

    



  !  "

" # " $  %%&&'($'($ 

'($&

")*  + $ #

   (

      

   ) *  & # "#

  #



  # # "

  



   )* ,& -  



' " # 

       

()* ,& .,

 4   2 %

    %    

       #$(          0    1   

/

  

%

  

- ---   -4-   - ' # (  

0



       

&     %(  

%%  %     #

    

   $  &         $  %

    

/

9    :(   

%(    

& 

   

& (   ( ;(

  $ $ $ :#$(  (   &  & %  1( 

   & % $

  $ :#$( #    + < (     (  &     * =

        &   $    : #$(    ( (  +//01$* 23

"   "    

   

'       '                      "  

 &4

 $  ''   '

  

  



" ( # "  $  # "  '#          # #      

 3  "



     "

" # " '# '($     

    

  

       "

   # " 

   

          

5  6



*

-3  "#   '(      '# #

  "

  # 

(  (#   '(



 ' 



 

     "

" # " '# '($



 '       

   #  16 ! 

 '( $4 7 '( # " '#     $ "

"     ' " #'($

 "  ' " #"  + $&       ' " # "

"

 $  # "

 8 "8 "

4       4   

   '  #' ' 

'( ('  ##  

 .  *           $  4  7    # "

     , "

(

     "

" # "  '(



    # "

"  

#( "   

5   # " ' " #'(

 

"

          #( "    

 (#(  + 

   "

  



     

(    #       

5+

     # "  #( "    "

"

              "     

 9$ "  '6  '

" %6

 $  '(

 ""   "

 

"

 "





  #   



 ""    # "   "

"



  ""   ' " #'(

      +    

( $ 

%

   %   4  

          

   

(

     # "          ' " #"  4   

"

  (      " +         '

 #

  

    ( "

# 

  "#



  # "  

"  #' "

  

   

"  +  (

    (        "    

 :  '

#      ;+,  16,<!       "

    "

    

 



 (     

            $ 4

     

(

" 

     '#'( 

'#  4   ;+,  #   

 '        



($ =4 #  

'(

 #  

 3   (" "     '(     '#

      "

" # " '(



  



   

 '(

  

 

 167 1679!4   

"



 " (  & &   

   50"    

"" 1 2 %& >  50&  

  "***   

01 % & ( %

  &  

01 %& & %  3((    ( $ %%   10"0)0"'4 1(    

01 %&  %  

    

"&  %  (2$ %%  

 10""0 ""    %%

 ?%?%

#    $  $ 

01 %   (2 (2  (2%



%   1( 

     

2    (          %%

  %    

"& % (2 10""0 "" " :  #$(          1 2  %  ,50.  & 

($6   >  $  

  



$  %

 

#   %% $ :#$(    $   (     

   > 1 2 %,50. "  :#$( ( $    

 

 $$     " :#$(    $   ($ 

  &

     ,@>".  

& ( (    %%

 %  % (2      :#$(       &

     &  

"&  %%

         %(  && %  $   (     

1 2  %  &  &  >     50   %  >

%%    

"   % (2 "4 # / % 

  >  ( (

           ( &(      % "'  (  $ (   %  6( 

 & ""' $:#$(  %

   $  $    6(  "9 < & $  

 & 



 

    -4

47   - "+ 1 B$ ( (   

 &% %%

    &     $ #>(     9:;

) 2%0 8 < 9:;

)

&+ &!/ )

  -:,) ;

!:)  % % 5*5   (           .4# >?

3 == @3 @!

     '      6 

(  5  

  

4 '   "

" 

" 

     "         (          

   5

4  '



 #  

"'  # ( 6    

( 

  ("       

(   5  # 3   ('   (

('

      (4

  '   

(  



((

    #('   

(   

    #  /7/'

+(#4  $

3+,:A/ 7&:9,

 "

 # 7 +

!B. !/77.. 

#

"'(:A37-9:! 9 4                  

(  

 "C      

!  16  

"       

  

     " 

 

6 

!B  "

"

!    #

 '   "C

!B  " "  D

'!  B        "        

 

(

!; 

6$% 

(

" E

"!

#!

"

 " 

 5    

#!B

 

<  



"!

# !B6  

  "

"# (! + 

(    

'  ( 

!

!

! 

#!+  (   

(   

#   ' " #  

    

'" 

( 

!

'!

! #!  # !

"   "        

  

(    

6 

 

<  



"!

 6  

    

   



 !

!3

  



 "  !     "

(

=

!4  "



(    '(  '  '  "

  "

(4   (  "    "

( 

  "

 

( 6   4 '

'

 #       "   "

( 

  "



(!

!4   %

6



'5 ( 6 



(

  "

#  #     (    "

    6    

 

(4   "

(   " 

 # ' '(4 '

  #    (

#!  4  

  

  

( 

(           "          " 

(         "    ' "     "#$ 

 %

%%  

& 

%  

% '

 ()(C4  

 "&A(    ",&AAA<%  



3

 @  #      

  

(     

'   

5       (     9AF      5





( 5    &AF4    "

( # '(4 '

.F '

#  ' 

    ( ' " 7

  

' 

C !3

  '

C,&9AAA<% '!B  " 

.F  

  !C ,.-AA<% !>

 

   "C: !B  "C .-AA6:!C ,=AA<%



'

 (*(C4   # "&A(   "

,&AAA<%   

   

 

(  9AF 

  '        "   #          " "  (   (  '

 # " ('

(

 ('    44 '

     "

( :.F7

   

' 

C

!3

   

C,&9AAA<% '!B  " 

:.F  

  ! C,:AAA<% !>

 

   "C: !B  "C :AAA6:!C,-.AAA<% '

 (+( C4  .(   

( 1"

 "3  

  

   " 

  # 

 4

   :AF3



      5      # "

    "

(

  :AF4

   

' 

C

!>



    #"  ' ( 1"

 C,9AAAA<% '!B  " 

:AF6  

  ! C,-AAA<% !>

 

.( !  C= !B  "C -AAA6=! C,:.9AAA<% G$  C  4   "     

   3!   

!   (

4 " +

  7!# '





    3# 

>   !H "* 1 B$  (   (          ,   '  +- .



/0 >   6 - 6? 



&(    "''"' 0 "'+  )  "*++ & % 

,.

C(      %>    

(  D ,E.

   (   % % D ,.

%  $   % ( D ,C.

=  $%(   

        (  ( >  &    ,@.

8( (          %           

% & 

6$D 0 >  #

   6(%

 ( (  4   ( 6   +      " #

 

(                

6   ' ,.AAA ,-AAAA  ,.AAA   # (4 # "

 

   #  ' %    5  %                 '  " 

  #5    '     "'

#((       '  AF   (    '  

' "   (   I  1 B$ ( (   1  .

 1&

$+- "#"#)+2"34  (  2:4     5 '6

'( C 

 %  %(5( 

%(6(D 4 

   

 "'



"   

 & (  "  "

 $

+  7 (B

#  (/ * A:  37J  :AA  /7!  +    -9      

  "

   7      # (  

 '      /

?

/ !



*# 4 7  3AA37J = /7!+ "".%.( 

  '@=@

"   " 6

( 4 

  

( '(   / 7        

' 

  



 '@=@ @:@ -

%  

%





  %78 +         

    

    

      '  

J " #> K*A=37JA /7! /    #3

K3A:37J: /7!6 '   J "   !  =C L=  +   "               ''

3#





      (  

(     '( 

                   4

          # 

"     

 "  C

!

   "    

  "    

D

!

B    "   D

!

4 

(      #

      

 "  

 D

#!

>

6  " #

'5   D 

#!

B6  

L G  

H 4 

 

'  8

"

 /     ! "

 

  "

(  "

(

5



5  (       



(

 + 

   6

 

(  

  

 <

=  #  ' (#M(  3" AJ  (A&4    ' C L, % C

!

     

!

 '' 

!

  '' "

#!

 &-K. 



 " 

#!

'     " 

# !

   

#

!

 ''  "

  #

"  6       "      (

      



"   '(    / 7  

    

    

(   #          6;  '   & /        !     

   "  

   #   



  

'       5 #

(#  

     

  

    "

      

 '



   

  "

 

( &F45  



 "

 $

+  7B 

 !  

( 9

!   " "  

 '.AF 



(   

*

 $ 





 

  

    "8 +  

 

      "  "F #       

      "     J " N   !*    "

   

'(     

   F

     

'( 7 +0,+-9'0, =4  

   "  

   '( 



  .(   #'

 

C :

)  B      "   ,=:=<%

,-9-=66&<AA ;     .A   ,-A=<%   !

>

6  "

,=-9=9-<%   "     B   



,.AAAAA<%   B          ,.AAAA<%

   

"(

 "

,AAAAA<% 4

,-9=&<% 4 

 '    ,-9=&<%



" 

  



F     



   4 " < & && $ 1 B$ ( (  $ 6(%

  

 &#&  ""'         #  

0

   

    %

       (  0(  -)0 !0 +% !;, &% $!& @ )+ + "

> = 4/0 



% = 4/0



= "/0    ( %  = /0 #   % = 4/0 !

!;, &% $!& %0A AB 

        

              $  1 B$

( (   

; *.

  

. =  5 6   <. 0

 .$ , $ 

+ 



-:,) ;

!:)  % %  A



0

 %

 

 G*H

  (

   %       ?    # < (            (

     %& 

 &  #$( &   &

  ##$(  (    $(   (

     %& 

  (

 

/

#

6



/

        (      $ 2  (

      #$(   C   % 4   %       

-  - 

  #!( ) *A *  5  2 %/  

2 % 5  $ I /