Baljinder Singh And ANR v. State Of Punjab And Another

    
      


   

 !"  " #$ %&   $& '  " #( 

    !
  !  "#$#%&

 % ) *"+ ,-   .- "/+ ,-  " (  ( 0&/+ ,1+ $& '   ." "/+ ,1+ $& '  "' !" 0"+ ,-  ( .  ! '   2" ( ( " ' ( &  3  "
 
/ $&+ 453 " 6
$
7 8! 9&"!  :; . 3  34 ! &  43,+ < ;$
 $  
) +  &(!  

&'9& (! ! "/ 
 
(   2" :; = !  "   ( .+ " =  ( . 2" /! '= ( .  $'"

 0&+ &!"  ( . =  /  -

! /(&+  :"!" "'+  <  = "  = ' &  " = 8   /!+ ( .+ /"  ( .+  &! $'"

 0&  

+ / ,& +  &  =)

 ;! ') " /+ ( .  "! "  / ++>    ? $'"

 0& /-  ,& +  - /"  /!  " @(  " / = ' ') " " 2" ( & "! " "  / ++> A/ !"+ " / &   ( .+ =" =   " /  " /"+   ( . " "  ) =)    " &!" =&  '  ) " /  " ( ,!

)+ ( . !- "/  &/ "9&  4++>  ++>  " B   8 " (=  ) / $'"

 0&    = :  ++>  ++> (- ) ; (  "+  45+ $'"

 0& = "& &  " // "/  ,&   !

 * &  " (

  " '" " (  ,&  C  "- ' !  .= &" D   "  4 /" 2" /! '= ( .  $'"  0& = & ) !  ;+    ') " /! 

,@& $  2"+ ( . /- '8  ,&   "  - ;  3  " ( - " ,&  C"(+ $'"

 0& =   

  ,&  " ((   C"(+ ="" = !  < ,@& $3  ; = $'"

 0& =" =

!

)  " // "/  45+ -!

'" " &!" '" 2" (  & & " $'"

 0& "  )   " /!  ! ,&  C"( $'"

 0&    -  " / = 

= -   4

,@& $ 

  * & &" &'/ " " !"  '   '" (    ') =)  /&&  / ,@& $?

 2" &(  "   " " / 

+ (!+  /+ /+   @(  ;  ,&  :&"/+ $'"

 0& " )  /   /! ="   1= +   ') ("!(" - '

  ,@& $ $'"

 0& " ( / ( .  45  " =  B=-+ ( . "    /(  ' " (  &"  ;  3+  " '  ="" :;

 = !+ 

!! =) "/  - )  /! ,

" 

!  / " )  , &"+ " :;

 " ' !  (  "  " " !C  " /  ' ') / &  <3
$
  " /@/&/    &  43,  < ;$
 ? ) :

)+ $'"

 0&   (&& ) /(   ; - "&!" " = ! "  - /"  /!   "  ,& 

!) !   !!

< B-! " "  &  " (   (&!

"   "  =" " '

 +  ( " '" ( .  " =$'"

 0&+ &!"  ( .+  ,&  C ; (( " $'"

 0&    - ' " 
&   '& ="" = 

= -   4 ') "

 :
&
& ,@& $  ; =    " " - '= " ( =&  8  / <4 5 $ )+ " 
& " (   &  54  " :/ ) *= ,+ 45
"

  " 9&  " '8=  " /! 2" /   /+ - '

  ,@& $

* ?+ =   ') '" ( .  $'"  0&+ =" "-  ! " / ,

/ (!  (()+  /)+ (&

&((  )    -+  (  & 4  " /   /+ '" ( .  $'"

 0& "-   " " / 

+ (!+  /  " '   ,&   =

  ; 2" /  (& ' =  


   


  


 




       !  !

  

! 
   


   

  
 

  
 
" /("  3 ; (  "  /+ ( . "  /

(& ! " (  ; ') /  :; + (

)  $'"

 0& "  ) / , = A&! '"  " B7'  &(/
&  
      
        

 

  

(8! "&!" A& E/"
  + (  

= #$
  
  




!   
 % 
&'
 (
 ) 



  
    
 
 



  
 % 
*+,

-  ,    .  

   
  




  
 ,   /  
    
   
           

 


     



$


 .

 


!



 


 12   


 

  !   



   

!3 
 

    


3

 

  

  
 
!   


 %
  


 

 




 



 .

  



  


3

 
! 3


!  
  

 
 
3 
   
4!

 
   

 

  

  





% 
*+$
    

 

  5
,  % 
*+,

-  ,  3


  
   
  
  
   
   !  
  3 

    
 
     5
,   


 


!  


  



!
 3


!
  
        
    

 



  

$ 

  




3 
  

  
 




  







 "

4 :&"+ 
 '"  "
&  
 
 

   !"# $     

 %&+ (8! "&!" A& A" 2"8&+ / " 

=! '- 1    0       
  
    '  

 /  
(    
 ) 
*+ ,  -    

   .

&   /  *   #  0  
/ *   #   +-, &-  

      
 

 

  

  

  


0  (    
  ) 
*'   

 /  

, 
1)
      !2 3      +4&

 

 -,%1 1  
       !"# $     .  

 %1 1)        !2 3      -  56-1
,6(3(31&#13 *78
7#**78 1 5    0   !

2 3      +4  

 4%1"

/("   :&" 

+ $'"

 0& /-  ,&   - /"  " /!  " ' ! C"(  ;  ' ! " :; ((( &(  ;+  "   ( .+ ="  " - (! = &=)  ,& + (

)  -=  "  " $'"

 0& " - (&& ) / /(  ! " (  ;   ,&   !" )  /! 2" &  ;  /  " &  = / ) A/ !" -!  & "9&   4++>  " /&  ++> / ( .  ="=! /) / : &! " ! (=  )

+ '= &( "/ ') $'"

 0& ; (( " A/ !"+ ="    " /  " /"+ "  ) ' (  " ( :;  "  "  )  / " (7 // / ) ="   ; ,

" 

! 9& "/  &  =) ! " (  /'&  &  ((  '  & ') / &  , = A&! '"  " B7'

 &(/
&  "
7'    !6 / 

-& ..& 9&" " /(  ! "  =  " /(  ! " "   (&(   ! " /(  =  "&/  "  

=! / (&  & =&  /&   '&  (  = (8! "&!" A&  - "+ " 

=! = '- F&9' 
 

      
. !




.
 !


  3 
$
  .  

 !
 

 
   3


  !
 


  
!       &+ 


 
 




 3

4! 
 /


    

 


 

:       
 !  

  !

 
   
    3 



 
$


  

.
 

  


  .

   


  $

 
!   .
 







   


 
 

. 



  
! !

  "

   " !    ' (   " &!/  " B7'

 &(/
&  7
    / 8     !(    , -&&+ $
/   !( 3 " %   

 %  (  /
      !   / 



-  

 &

,  -+  <3 
$
 (- / (  8! !C   2" /  (& ' =


.4*   /
 
9  ! ' !'
 !


 
:

4   
 !
  

, ,   .  
;    






3  
 *


 



 *  



 <  



 





=   
 





 
  
 =




 





 
  
   
   & 5

   
  
  



 

      
      
         
 
           
 



 
      !


                    ! 




/("   2"  &  43,+ < ;$
 (&"'  =" ? )  /(/ "+ "+  (  <3  '


$
+ " (  /  8! !C  " / =&  ' " ) ,
& "  " B7'

 &(/
&   (  
 ! 
0  ;
   --  

 -+ " !

) "  "  " (&(   & ! " (  / &  <3 
$
+ "  -  =&  ' "    !  " /(   "   &  (&   "   ="" " ! 8 !C  "   &  ( ') "
& ; "   "+ " /(  =    3 2" :;  " "   "/ ="  $'"

 0& =  ;    /!+ ="" 8 (   < , &"+  (( " "

- /(   " '  ="" :; = !+ =   '& <5 )  " 

! & &  )+ " 
& =&  ' ' / 8! !C  " ( /  " (& = & ') " (  / 
!  ?

 + "
& " '-  &'!  =" /

(&    // (&  ; ') !  + =" "- - & ) -  C"(  " &)    &&  " ; ! + ") "- &'/ "/ -  "

&  !
&  " /( & ,  " ( + /  " + " &(  - - "-  ) '  -    & (!  (& &((+ &)  "   &" ') " (("! "
&  " &)  "  B=-+ / )  " (&(  "/+ / /(      ; D" " // (&    ') "  &/ '+ (@)

!  ;  ' 

=  ' //  ;  ) ( ( 2"
& !

) / &" &&(& &  &"

(    "  ( " " /  & /&  '

=  '  !! ') 

+ -@& (! ="" &" '& "  ) -=8
& 2" &   ! /

(&  " "(   - !  ;    )  & '&  " (  =+ =""  ! &"8 2" )  "

& (  ' 

=  ' / ') ! 

+ &

!  &    &/  ((

.  ; -=  " & '-+ " ( (  

=  :; . 3  34 ! &  43,+ < ;$
 $  
) +  &(!  

&'9& (! ! "/  9&" 9& " (  $! /

& ((   +  )+ "

  ( 

 !     * > D"" (8!>  G>. D"" ('

  G>.