High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2594/2014allowed

Balbir Singh v. Raj Krishan

2015-03-03Mr. Justice S.C. Datta33 pages

!"

#$%$!&'()()

'

*+

) ,

,

! "

, #$ "

, %

& ",

'

( )( *+, *

( - *+, *

!

"

"#$ $!

$ %"

%

& % &$$ $!

% '

& $

,

.

/0 #/1 + 2 *345* , #/ /% #/# 2 ( 67*+ *, !

,

%8 ) 6 + *88 *9) + 9 ! #*0//:;*

6 *

!

+ (: $ $ *

5 5 $ ,

*!

, ( + $ ;

5 ! :

! + * #< /0 #//1* ,

! *

,

= ) ##/<1%/ #//1 .*10*///:;

,

) 118% ! ) 5 ,

= ! 5 > %/ #//1*!

=*! 5 9 5

?6

3 @

,

= /% # #//1* !

!

/8 # #//1 $

/8 # #//1 =

= $ ;

!,! 0 # #//1 ,!

.*10*///:;! $

, $ * ! > , *

%8 )6 + !, ;

!

? @

$, * ! ;A

%A 5 *75* ) 5

*+ 5*75*7 5

#

($)$($

# $ "

* "('"

+ ' (

,-

,-.

$ /0

.1$1 $.1 ." (

$ !

" !

( 0

2$13$.1 4$5 " $ $ 6 %

$

% '$ 6

%

'

"

$

%

%

.7$13$.114

&

1$

$.114 % $6

8$).

% %

%

'" '

$ %

%

$ 9

" $

"

"

% $

"

$

$

$

%

% $.

'% "

% :"

$

%

'

$ B,

5 : C

"

+ ! " " &

)0 ;

+ %6#!

"

$

< + %6#!

#$ C 5

=! ,

$ D / #//0 6

%

$

% $

$ $!

$6

%

'

$ 6 * #/07 7 /1 ) " % % $6

(

% + %6#!

$ 6 *

#//% 7 1</ %

$

#% %

=

5 * 75* ) 5*! E

, ,

) 118% 5 E

BA

;* BA

;#*

=5 BA

;% , BA

;1 , !

,

=5 E

= BA

;0 !

!

$

=! ,BA

;< E,

= BA

;D

BA

;8

# + 5 * 75*7 5 (: $ ,

5 $

=BA

;0! 5 !

5! !

BA

;.

$

=! , BA

;< E,

BA

;

/ ,

= BA

;

/:+ E ,BA

;* 5 <.1:;

= 7 ! ;

A

%

E

=BA

;0*

= BA

;<* BA

;

%* BA

;1* F 7 BA

;0* 5 ! BA

;<

5BA

;D 6 #% = $

A ), *75* (5 7 & * !

#//%;

/1 E (57*+ !

,

*

$ *

!

* E ,

BA & BA & 0% )

!A & #*!

5 !

!

E !

* 5 !

*

!

E

4

, , E !

,

! * 5

5 ! *! , ,

8 %. ) + '

!"

#$

%

& & ' #

"

$ , ) + ! *

, A

,

= ! !

!

! !

! !

+ *

(: $ ,

*!

!

, ( + $ ! ,

! ,

5: ) ,

, !

!,

5 B, BA

;#% $ ,

BA

;#%!

=*

*

5 ! !

! = !

,

* ! 6 : 5 :

= 5

5 , * 6 * , , ! !

* !

!

!,

5: , , , :

5 A 9 9*

+) 8.# .8<*

# 12$1 $.1 4" =

!" # $%%& ' "

# $$ '

"

( (

)* +

# $, - # ./

"

0

!

)*

#

+

"

2

"

. # "

!

)* # " "

"

"

"

"

"

#

"

"

" "

!

)*

3

" "

%%$-)/

!22* 4

#'3 % *&**

#'3 %5)!2*) 6

!

)* #

"

"

"

"

0

" ' " 7"

0 !

"

2 - /

8 "

!

" "

"

"

8 "

!

"

"

"

"

"

"

'

'

"

"

"

"

.

" !

"#$ %

%#$ % 444- /323-2/ 9$!2 ! &

% #'3 %9, !2 45$ '()

(" *

%9,- /':3-;7/*)5 +)',&

- . (* #'3 %:))$

+

%/ 4 )- /323-2/%9

0 !

"

2

"

"

<

"

"

"

"

!

)* # $,

"

2"

"

"

"

"

"

=

"

"

'

"

!" # $%%

"

;

"

"

"

'

8> :

0 2 -

-0#'3 %* :54

( ( ( " "

"

"

"

!" #

#

8>

- #'3 %)5 :59,

"

"

"

' "

%

%,4;:3$ 0 "

"

" "

"

#

!

!" #

"7"

# ;

0 2

#'3 %5$#;$$

"

7 "

"

'1

* 444-/;:3 ,%

0 2

2

"

1 >

" "

-/?

-5/!

#

" "

'

"

& "

"

!

-5/-/ #

" "

"

"

"

"

@

" "

"

"

"

"

!

!

)* # =

"

"

!" # $%% >

"

& ' "

# $$

&

"

" "

# " "

"

'

'

"

!

)* #

"

"

"

"

"

!" # @ "

"

!

"

"

"

A > 370 2 .&

#'3

%5) 37

+

7"

0 0 2

"

"

"

'

"

"

"

"

"

"

BBB ' "

"

"

#

"

"

C "

"

# "

" 3 54D? " DD? &

"

"

"

=

"

"

"

#

2

"

"

"

"

"

"

.

'

%#'3 %94 374

"

<

* & ' "

# $$

&

1 >

"

!

)

"

"

'

?

"

"

>

>

!

* & ' "

#

"

"

!

* & ' "

#

! "

"

"

& ' "

# .

"

&

&

' "

+ 7

7

5 ,! '

?

6

>

"

"

>

&'#

D )* ' +

# $, "

# "

"

>

" "

"

"

"

6

"

E"

"

"

>

D)*

' +

#

#" 0 2 2 3" A C"

FA 2345+#+

$ %=

2 0 @

> ;

# 2346+#&

$*

&

> F "

"

"

"

-

/

"

!

0( # 2

2 G"

G >: +2378 2946370 2

;

3"!

H "A 2335+#.$2:3

) @

"

"" ""

D " 8 "

7

>

"

"

>

" &'#

" "

"

" D )$ &'#

3! !! ;

< # $

;

< # $"

5: , 5 * * A

!

* ) + $

5 , %1 6 B, + *

,

! +

,

*!

!

, ( + 6 ! * !,* , 9 6 ! % 1 ( ;

C 9+ *.%8'

< ) ( )=

( <

) &

"

"

" ?

" ?

""

"

"

" ?

?

-/ "

<

-/ "

?

- /

< -

/

" "

"

<

-

/

" 2""

<

- /

" ?

2

2

<

" ?

2

(

*+

" ?

"

"

2

A

< "

"

"

35.

$ , , ; + *!

, , * , A

! , =

+ , , * , , : , ( C 9C + *.%8 6 *

,

, * , ;

* * $

7

, + %6#!

"

"

% %

$

%

*!

!

, ( +

6 '

?

*!

"

"

" "

" "

"

*

" &

"

"

(

"

"

"

"

(

' ;73 @ ?

( # %)$ -

@ ?

(# ./

! 0 0 ."

# :=

%9$!

*-/ "

"

- / # "

5 :

!

) #

"

"

"

"

""

"

#

"

"

"

"

""

"

9 # 7 "

" "

0 "

(

8 "

"

"

"

"

D* @

(# !

"

2

@7 F H 5929#>$# $48:

A 0 2 ;

7F" C 3 @ 5929#>$ :29

"

"

D

"

)$ &'#

,

"

>

"

"

@

(#

"

?

?

""

- " /

"

"

" D )$ &'

# .

+ *

= E!,*

, *

>

* ;

5 , 5

=! , !

! 6

! #< /0 #//1

* ,

=

##/<1%/ #//1!

!

%/ #//1 6

= !

5

! * !5 ! , & ! !" #/% 7,.8/* E 97 '

()

*

' &

+ &

*

, '

-. /0

& %

1 & +

,

*

2 3

)

1

% 3

*

* *

*

& & 333333 $ 4

3

& &

&

' # 5

&

5

6

)

728 9

55:;

&

&

5 +

&

&

6 <

&

* 8

& 4 ) ,

&

6 <5 333333 =#

728 9

55

3

&

&

>1

1

& 2$?= @=((A 6 ?

(((< B* 2* '* 8* C ,,

& *@=((A

2#E B* 2* '* 8* C DF

,, & * >

1 @=((A % & @=((A

<

1 & @=((A

@=((A8

& * @=((A @=((A

%

&

& G%

&

&

* ,

@=((A#=((A *

<

1 %

&

+

&

6 <5 +

1 & =@ +

&

*

& %

1

"

6 * 7 !

!

* ! , 5:

= 6 ! 5 , E $ ,

+( 5 ,

), $

! ( ,

= ), 5

, $

=!

! A

! , 6 * ! 5

! * !

, ! #//1 $

6 ,! ,* ! , 8 %. ) + %1 6 B, + $ : ! , * ; , , !

$ * *, !

+

* 7 ! '

7 , !G $ %8 + G $ , ! G , $ =

, , 3 * * ;

G

, $ ;

! * = G , $ ;

! ,

! !

()()

'