Buta Singh v. Amar Nath
!"#$!$%&'()*+ ',-.#%/0
!,#,#%!1 2!13'3 4-1-,0
!35%$!%, & 67
. 72
80!,0!11!51,!13("-(%!935-5!134-):!-((9!$,3!!;'$/4!%,< :!1!!11!$,1!51,!131%,< = 80!,0!1,0!;'$/4!%,30'($:!1!51,!$#%,0!#/!3,<
1!3!%,&
1 -14#%$!1.#%/0+$>"-,!
1,0!5!,#,#%!1
0!5!,#,#%!10-3#(!$,0!51!3!%,5!,#,#%-/-#%3,;'$/4!%, $-,!$* ? 5-33!$:)(!-1%!$$$#,#%-(.!33#%3'$/!+-,0#%$->#$! 90#"0,0!;'$/4!%,"%>#",#%-%$1$!13!%,!%"!$-,!$@ = 5-33!$:)'$#"#-( -/#3,1-,!3,(-33+-(9-%$#.-:#%-"45(-#%,"-3! =$-,!$ =9-3'50!($-%$,0!-55!-(,0!5!,#,#%!19-3 $#34#33!$ 0!(!-1%!$'$#"#-( -/#3,1-,!>#$!;'$/4!%,-%$1$!1$-,!$ @ = 0-$ "%>#",!$ ,0! 5!,#,#%!1 1 "44#33#% ,0! !%"! 5'%#30-:(!'%$!1.!",#%=!/,#-:(!%3,1'4!%,3",+-%$0-$ 3!%,!%"!$0#4,'%$!1/1#/1'3#451#3%4!%,1-5!1#$%!)!-1
-%$,5-)#%! 3 +A /-#%3,,0!3-#$>!1$#",,0!,1#-('1,+,0! 5!,#,#%!10-$#(!$-%-55!-(+:',,0!3-4!9-3-(3$#34#33!$:)(!-1%!$ $$#,#%-( .!33#%3 '$/!+ -,0#%$- >#$! #45'/%!$ ;'$/4!%, $-,!$ * ? '%3!(1,0!5!,#,#%!1"%,!%$3,0-,,0!5!,#,#%!1#3#% "'3,$)3#%"!* ? -%$-,!1$#34#33-(,0!-55!-(:),0!(!-1%!$ $$#,#%-( .!33#%3 '$/!+ -,0#%$-+ ,0! 5-1,#!3 0->! !%,!1!$ #%, - "4514#3!% ? 90#"00-3:!!%5(-"!$%1!"1$-3%%!B'1!
,#"!4,#% ,,0#33,-/!+ 1 .'%#(0-%$-+$>"-,!-55!-13%:!0-( ,0!1!35%$!%,-%$3,-,!3,0-,,0!1!35%$!%,0-3-""!5,!$,0! -%"0-)-,# "4514#3!$-,!$ ? %%!B'1! -%$0-3%:;!",#%#%"-3!
,0! 3!%,!%"! -9-1$!$ , ,0! 5!,#,#%!1 #3 1!$'"!$ 1- 5!1#$ -(1!-$) '%$!1/%!:)0#4 !'1,0!13,-,!3,0-,,0!"0!C'!-4'%,0-3-(1!-$):!!% 1!"!#>!$:),0!1!35%$!%, '%3!( 1 ,0! 5!,#,#%!1 3,-,!3 ,0-, ,0! 5!,#,#%!1 9#(( :! 3-,#3#!$#,0!;'$/4!%,"%>#",#%#3'50!($+:',51-)3,0-,,0!3!%,!%"! -9-1$!$,,0!5!,#,#%!1#31!$'"!$1-5!1#$-(1!-$)'%$!1/%!:)0#4 %>#!9,0!-:>!53#,#%-39!((-3"%3#$!1#%/,0!-",,0-, ,0!5-1,#!30->!"4514#3!$,0!4-,,!1-%$,0!5!,#,#%!1#3#%"'3,$) 3#%"!* ? +,0!;'$/4!%,"%>#",#%$-,!$@ = 5-33!$:),0! (!-1%!$,1#-('1,-%$-#14!$:),0!(!-1%!$-55!((-,!'1,#3'50!($
9!>!1+,0!1$!13!%,!%"!$-,!$@ = #34$##!$,,0!!B,!%, ,0-,,0!3!%,!%"!-9-1$!$,,0!5!,#,#%!1#31!$'"!$,,0!5!1#$-(1!-$) '%$!1/%!:)0#4 9!>!1+#%"-3!,0!-4'%,#%! 3 +A0-3 -(1!-$):!!%$!53#,!$:),0!5!,#,#%!1+,0!3-4!#31$!1!$,:!1!'%$!$ ,0#4-35!11'(!3 ""1$#%/()+,0!5!,#,#%!1#31$!1!$,:!1!(!-3!$14 "'3,$)1,09#,0+#%,1!C'#1!$#%-%),0!1"-3! 8#,0,0!-1!3-#$4$##"-,#%#%,0!1$!13!%,!%"!+,0! #%3,-%,5!,#,#%#3$#353!$
6-/',,6