High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14028/2011disposed of

Mukesh & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-08-24Mr. Justice M.M. Aggarwal,Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan3 pages

!" "#$%$&'(

)*"%+ &!+", -- "!$!$&",% .",%)% /! !" ,0 & !+",% -- "%1&2"&!%

,"%"&!'-

, 3 & ,4526# !" ,!+"1"!$!$&",%

,""1 * 70 &52275 ,0 &

,8 3 7 !+$526# !" ,

, ,$&2",/$&4+526# !" , ,"%1&2"&!&9

,/ &: 0.$:526# !" , ,"%1&2"&!&

,%+; &$ 7; ,526# !" , )%$&4 ,25 ,0 & <<<

+"1"!$!$&",%+ 6"%)4+! ;,$! &2 3)%2$,"#!$&4!+"

,"%1&2"&!%! 77!!!+"317!%)&2",!+"#&3$# 770" *",/"#!$& /#+"3" //#+"3"7 )&#+"2$&!+"0" ,=-+"1"!$!$&",%+ 6" 7%%)4+! ;,$! #",!$, ,$!>) %+ 17$#02 !"29 +"1"!$!$&",%?# %"$%!+ !!+","; % 17$#0$&!+"0" ,=- ;+$#+;)72+ 6""&!$!7"2!+"3!!+" 77!3"&! 17!)&2",!+"/ # !"4,0!$%$31,! &!!&!"!+ !!+"1"!$!$&",%+ 2&!@""& 77!!"2 &017!%)&2",!+ !# !"4,0 +"17$#0 =-+ %)&2",4&" #+ &4" ,3!$3"! !$3"+","%1&2"&!%#&!"&2!+ !!+"0,"#&%$2","2!+"17$#$"% 7%$& 6$"; #",! $&@%",6 !$&%3 2"@0!+"1,"6$)%$6$%$&"&#+"% !+$%

-- ),!+" !!"31!; %!3 *"!+"%0%!"33,", !$& 7 &2!, &%1 ,"&! +"17$#0 9 &&"A"2 %&&"A)," -,"

",%!!+"1,"6$)% 17$#0;+$#+ ,"%",6"2B !+"!! 7&)3@", 17!% ,!+"/ # !"4,0 !!+", !"3"&!$&"2!+","$& +"1"!$!$&",%?4,$"6 &#"$%!+ ! &; #",! $&&)3@", 7 !% ,","%",6"2 ,!+"1",%&%$&!+"# !"4,0

"7; 6",!0C$&" C "!$!$&",%%)@3$!!+ !)&!$7 &2)&7"%% 77 1",%&%$&!+"/# !"4,0 ," 77!!"217!%5!+"1",%&%$& C# !"4,0 )4+!&!!@"#&%$2","27 )%" !+"17$#02 !"295;+$#+ ; %)&2",#+ 77"&4"5," 2% %)&2",'-

" ,"$& ,3"2!+ !!+"1"!$!$&",%+ 6"$& #!@""&,"

)&2"2 !+" 3)&!%!+ !!+"0+ 21 $2 !!+"!$3" 117$# !$&%!$%&! %$ !+"

1",%&% $& !+" / # !"4,0 + 6" @""& "A#7)2"2 ,3 #&%$2", !$& 7!4"!+", +"

$#$ 7% ,"%1&2"&!% + 6" &; 2"6$%"2 &"; 17$#0 ;+",")&2",17!% ,"&!!@" 77!!"2# !"4,0;$%"!$&2$6$2) 7%+" 17!% ," &; + &2"2 6", ! !+" )%$&4 ,25 ,0 & 5 ;+ ;$77 #&%!,)#!3)7!$%!,"0@)$72$&4% &2 77!!+"% 3"!!+"1",%&%@"7&4$&4 !/ &2 C# !"4,$"% %1",!+"17$#0 +"1,"%"&!17$#02 !"2 =9 $A"%!+">)! ,!+"/ &2 C 7 !%

$,%!70 !+"

$#$ 7 ,"%1&2"&!% ;"," &! 1,"6"&!"2 ,3 #+ &4$&4!+"17$#0 !7" %!$&%)#+# %"%;+","6"%!"2,$4+!%+ 2&! 7," 20 ##,)"2."%!"2,$4+!%+ 2&! ##,)"2$&!+"1,"%"&!# %"+" 77!3"&!%+ 2&!@""&3 2" &70 117$# !$&%+ 2@""&$&6$!"2+"%"

-9- 117$# !$&%+ 6"&;@""&,"!),&"2+"1"!$!$&",% ,"&;"&!$!7"2! 1170 ,!+" 7 !%$& ##,2 &#"!!+"&";17$#0

,%+; &$ 7; ,526# !" 11" ,$&4&@"+ 7 )%$&4 ,25 ,0 & %! !"%!+ ! 117$# !$&%;$77@"$&6$!"2 ,"%+$&,"%1"#!

7 !%;+$#++ 6"&! 7," 20@""& 77!!"2 &2!+"1"!$!$&",% ," !7$@",!0! 1170 ,!+"% 3"5$ 5!+"0 ,""7$4$@7" ,$!1"!$!$&$%2$%1%"2 ##,2$&470 !"#

$%!&'(!)"*+%!$) ),!&#) !&'((!&#+

*#') -./0-/12 7)#*0