← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/25412/2020allowed

Paras Bolia v. Serious Fraud Investigation Office

2023-03-29Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

  

       

!"#$%&'&'

"#"(#) !"#$*&'&'    



   

  $  +,-& . -. -- , **** 

 

  !



# #

  ! 



 # 



!  $ !%  ./#!

0"(!1234 & &

 

'     ( )       )  $ * $# +,+-./0 

 /1 ., -./0! 

 )(

  ,1 !,1

!-//234!--3!5-1!-66$

!/0,5! 37264!35 !771!/73!773!771!/76!/77!/7/2642 4

 $

! -./6    /-.8   "

   7.5! 7/3! 7/1!7-.!753!751!73/!733 !737$! )

  9 : &           #'

  #    "



)     (    $8  

( 

 )(

   ;

  $

 $8  

( < = 2    ! >

$ 

(?4



(

    

 

    

   

 )  

/.. "

  #'

 #   "



$8 

(  



"

 "

- 2 -     

   

    "    <   



"

 ( &   < // ., -./6 "      :$

-- .7 -..1 

  

       "     8'

 "

  "

     " "

  ( 

 88



    )

( 

 @        (   !   

+) 







 &

      )

 

 )  773

$

!-./6 

& 

 

    773

$

-./6"

 

"

/- .0 -./6  &  

 

      

   36 

 $

! -./6    ,18

$

! /0,5   ( '

+   

 

(



8    '

( 

  -2)4

$

2  



4 !/03,!

!

"> 

?

 "   

 

 " 

  "

   

 

(

$ 

( 



 !# 



   $ %    8)

! ) 

 '

  

<

- 3 - 2$%4!     $$<)("(  

 



  

 

    "

  /3.. "



   $$<

"  3.  : $

    

 

 ) 

 

   !  

       )     ( )(  

( # 



 8

 )

  

 )

   (

+ +

 

()

 !

 



 ( )         

 $  

( )(



)   :A    :!

)     +  )

+  )(





 

    <     

    

"



!  )   -/-254

$

!-./6  



 

    

   



  

  !"

B$ 

$

  

(

 )

( 

 )    7,

 # (< -..-"

 

'



  "  -/-254 

$

!-./6   

   )(      

  

  8C8

     



- 4 - "   "



)

(  

 +"  )(

 



"

 "  "        !!

" #   $  % 

  &&!





@      

 

    



    

'  ( )        ! (

           ) (!  

 )(

-/

$

  @"

!

  ("

) 

)(

  ) )( "

&     

) (  

  ) 

"

 " 





 

 "$

"



   + 

    "

 "  $

@"

!

         (   )( '

 (!

  )

    "

  761 $$ 

"

     ()(

 !'

"

      "

   

  88

 

  

! 

 



!



"  )  (  & $ 



 )(   

  '

( 

    -2)4 

 $

2  



4  ! /03,  &  " > 

?   

      

- 5 - 

 

( !

 )







  E ( )(

$   

    ! 



  (

  

 

 )     

 

 

  





 

!

   ( )  



   ! ( ! 



 

F

 

 

 )

 

  ( )    )

   (

+ +

 

(

( -.., -./3 @"

! !

 

   (  

( )

)  

 ( " G  )(

   )        8(

 

)(

( (  !"

" ) )  )G 







" 

 

" & 

    (

     )(

 $   8) )    &



'



     )

   



 

 "

@ !

"  !

          

      )   )          

    E (  !

- 6 - "  ) 



'

 ( 

!

(

()(

  " )  (  

   

 

     "

 "

 

"  )  ) '

   ) G 

(!   ("



 

)

   ) !"

B



  )(

 

  24  '

 $

! -./6!       (8   

#< ! "

         !

   (     ; 

=! ; (

    



       =  ;

 

    E    

=      E  (

   (    

 '

'

    





    !

"

 (

 ()  





  &  $

  

  

    )   #<  "

  " )      )

     

       &  

( 

  "

  



            !"



   )

    "

!)

 

    

 & $    

 

     

  )   ) 

(

 )

- 7 -

 

 

   )(

     

 ) G    &  )

!

 

   "

 )

) 

    

)  

(  )  

 

    (  )

!!    * %

"    +      * , " %-' .! 

/  +

0 1!

!

"2 "

1

 )





   

 -, .1 -.--!

 

 $   



"

G 

   24!

 

-, .1 -.--  " 8   

        

                 

      

          

 

         

!  !

 "

 !     

         # 



  

( -/-254

$

!-./6   ( )

!"

 



 

-5 /.

-.-/ )(

          3   !4!  ""1 ' 5     * 677- "% 



 

-5 /.

-.-/ )(



"



)G

 "

 

     ( ) ! 

  

 ( 

  (



- 8 -   

     



 "

 

   )

        ( ) !    (

    "  

( 



 (!



   (

 

   (  )    

  

(!

"  ) G



 )   " )  

 

!  

   " )

 

 (  E

 ( !) 

"   )



)   E  



"! !" 



 "    ) ("

 





" ) 

( )(



) 



 

"

&

 !

!!

"!!    5   * &,, "% /5 .1 -.-/"

) 

  (    D) A8) ) 

'

  (





  8

  ("

   

 

!

8 $%   %         &         



    

  

%    %    

       %    !%              

- 9 -    '         (                      )

   

 

 *                 %          

      

       %        #  !

  . $ !   

!   #   "   !4! 188 1! * %-, "% 8 1 5 

!! *  (5 *  &% % " %!

 

 $  )    

   

 #  #    $88  * -&797    -.

.6 -.-6"

 E "

  "

 "

  

"

)  

    

 )

 

  )

  "

!   E (  (

 

(  



)

 E (    

 8  9   

$

    * 57.-.-- 

  

/1 .7 -.--

)

  )   ;          + ,-.    /  ' 0+           %   %     

                  %

- 10 -    %     

  &          

    =



8 ! (!

(  "    

   

 /1 /- -.--   "

 

 $  

  ( )

!)

<2$ 4* /-377-.--"

  "  "

     

 /6 ./ -.-6 

  8 

 

 & 



8 

 )

)(

$ )(

!  " 8

  # )(

$   

/, /.

-./0

   )   ' @ (  )(

 

 $    

/3 /- -.-.

4   )  ('# )(

  

.3 .- -.--  

"  )      

 





H

   

H  

 (

  ( 

 "

 (H 

 '

 )

$



 ("

G

!  (H '



"

 !

 





!

'

( 



 G

 

      

 

  "    ("



H  

 (!

   (

( )

  !

 $  

   

"

- 11 -

  

  !





  (!

 

   "

 &

    )

  !

  !)(

    ) )+

  &

   )

  )

 

"

 !  !"



   



 "     ( -0 .6 -.-6 1  ./#!

0"(!123

(!1

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No