← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1257/2007allowed

Raghubir Singh v. Ram Niwas And ORS.

2025-03-06Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma15 pages



        



  !

"# $% &%   '

  

 (

)' '%   (#  *+('%'

'

'(      

      

      

  ! "

 #### '

'(% $ %   & '  (  )*$)+)),

       $,,

 



  $-..& 

 " %&/(



 1 %&12

 

    '     3    

4)5,))3  '(      

-6   

7  &  3  

    $-)5+))8 + 





        

 9 

      ( &   %&   

   

  

      :

  :

&  '( ''

'+  '+ 

' 8 %  

  3      2 %      (& %&

  (   & 2 %    ( (            

'    '     (  ;               & ( &  %&   

 

  

   %

   & (      (   3 

&    ( 4       

    !  "

  (   '    (   '  & 

   

     

& %&  ' &' %

 

 



  * !      

         (  

    ,  

 (  

(     3   

5)6  &   & "   <= $, ;  

       3 ( ('  

54843       :    

   

          

  &  

 &  %%& 

 ('   

 

 

 '   ( ' 

   3 

     ( (    

'    '           (  

 & 5 ;  

  

(     3 



  '  7  & :'   &          

         :        

   (          % "

   (  

    

        

 

    

 !  "   #  $%    

       5 ===  ===  ===

                 $ !

 !   %

 &

  

 '

 ()  

* 





     !

"

    #       $%&'()  * +  ,   - + .       /       (       ,  , 0 (       1,   $%&'( )  *   11,    (

 1  ,   (        23 (4  5              

            1      1      

    +  %           '    *          

   ,      .



  *  + ,(  (       6  (      ,    

       ) 7 ,     8 %     1    (   7           )

-7 ,           . '  (  &     7'    3    

     

   ' %

 (9 '

  "

  '

++) ( '

- > ?&"

    (''' 

    (      & %="

   



 ,-./01!%,2-./0"3"

4 05 6'.70 /  .0!

! &8&    + 

 "

"  ), -"

 -

  &9 6( 5..:;6;  < *     1(      ( 31( ,  = ,       

1      *        ,    (    (   1  = 1  

   1            1 ,  3    ,     ,(         1,  =(  1 6,1    , ,(1        ,

   1   1,   (  1,,    

   , 1    (    1,              

    :'

>  '1   %,

> *  ? ( 6%) 5+ '  4+"( ) @ A       :% < B ( 55- :

< '

--   * / 1,( 5+6 "+< "



            ,   ! .

", -

/ "&

0

 :< 23     (  C ( (   (   (   3 :<B :   <        1(! : <B   D :1< B           1, :< E   3  ?

1 2  - 3 ,

    "

  ",

 4 5

 :< 6  :    1   <(   , :<

   1,    1, ( 1 1           ,    ,(     ,               1, :3  (  1  1   (             ,             1,< :<

       3   1=,     3     1,   ,  3     1,

       ,   1 1,

1    , : <

   1, ,          ,   (        (  1( (       6  

  7 

 7 7,,

   

8 4 33 

"

 73 9, ::!

( * (  4 ,     )  47           6  @;  (      1, 1  = ,  "F    =     1,      =   4F

    

   ,   1, 1   -F 1  (1      ,( 1          1 ! < 6   1    ! ) 4"(7 1<B   :

-F   <!) - 7 <&  1  ! + < B     ! :-  3 +< ! ) (.7 9, :(:!

    4, (  ) 47

A    

    1,    "F  A     1    A  , , 1 *       , 1(     ,   *,  1   

1             ,  +-F     1 ! < 6        ! ) 4"(7 1<B   :+-F   <!) +7 <&  1  ! + < B     ! :+ 3 +< ! )

(-5(7 9, :;: !

    - ,     , 2 6   (

          (             

    1     +F  6                   =        (    ,     +F

   1  <&   

 1,   2  !) "(7 1<B   :+F 3  <!) 7 <&  1:-, < ! . <B !:

3 .<!) +(-"(7 G? !

      :6<  :< 

,  

% :

<   1      *      6  >  &   : <H $) > ?&  "

     

  9 , "

;-<'

.

-  =

95  6$'$:

;   (  $,,$,8 $,.

 

   $-..

 

 ('    02

  



'=    @ 0/2   

 ' '

 @ 0"2 '

  & 

' @

  2



& '         

    

 

    =  (    @ 0<2 ;  



   '



 

 

 

  '  (    7 &@     =

 %    

 7'     

( *,3  1 %        1     

 (  ,(    (       3   1 )

-(( )

(  )

-(  ,  

             1         1 =  / *    1          =    1      1    , ,     1    F   ,  / 

1  1,     8 $$ > ?&  "

     

  > , - .

- '

  >8

6 ; <  ;? $1   

+

         =  1 3 1,! /0 "7,

7:

#: 7:

@:D

            1      4, ,   ?   %   , B   ,'  0 ( +6 #+:'

< %  

"      (     ,   1    1  '  9 :'< 0  @      6 ( 56 # 5.:'

< %   --, (

  1;

.;    3 1,

   ,1,   '    ( (             1       1;

.;  ;

+;

 /40 <

 7   ""- 7     3  

  4-7

 A %      (          1      #   &  I 0 (  . # 

 :'

< '  >   6 @  I 6 (  + 6 # 5+5 :'

<  / 3  1   #  : <  .! J.

 %       , 1      1 1    6          ,  1, 1,        

           (   ! :<  (    D :< BD :<

 1,         D : < &  3         , 1 =   *  D  : < B3  J G H

    1 C     (      '  >     : <     ,   , 1 = ,              1,    %            (   3     1,  (    7  C   .     1   ,   K ,   6 

 

 #  ,

  1  ! J,

7), -!

=     1  ?  %   B   : <(   ,    "

:<(      (1-F     ,     /"0 6            "     

  "  A %      (                  

   5F           #  L   : <  0   (   (          1,                5F    1,   ;;<B9

 .

    ,  (         1,   (        -    ,( 

1  !   3   B     :)

("

.3 34

 ) 5(.

(5+.7 E  :-   < )

(5(5.57 &  3    (  ( )

.( "(."

7 B   ) -((7 B  (      , )

(-(7    ) ((7

  )

("5(.4 7

  ( ( 1    )

("5(.4 7            5F             , +  $+ !(

 ( (& > ?&"

  &   7'      (%(  )*$)+)),    '% 3    

          

      ;  3   $   !   +

 

 0*)62  8 !   



  

 4 B

 '    &  05)62 

 

 *  

 ,

 '       5 

'  .     - %    '  $) ;   "'  $$

 

     $+ ; 

 

< /7 "! "     

 /7 "! "=03 3>24

0 >."<  "4"

3 /7 "! "          $8                  & > ?& "

 &  C&  () '

 - '   ?& $'

'6, 6    ;  5 6'.70 /  .0!

! @  3  '    C-6        

'

      

 D  

 $4 %! "

   

8   

    

     '(   (  %& (    

 (       

  

  

  7' %%&     &    

     '(      

  3  % 3      &:      %& $* !  "

   &     &    

     (  

+)

   

 

  

  7'        $.)5+)+4

;E $,.+ +))5 $, '   





    5'

'(6    

$% &%      F  :'3 :' :' F   & G