Gurnam Singh v. State Of Haryana And ORS





    
  


 
 
    !""  #$$

"" %&"$  $'"$ 
 


     ("'"$ ))''$ &*))+"$",

"-.$
(""* ""'"$"-.$   ("",

"$)*'"" $"-.$  ///// !$" 0 ,$1$)234"

"'""       !"" ')"   $ ) " $"" 4$ '"" $$)  " ,

" "

  '$$ *& ) 3") $$$ 5 2 3 *)  " ,

"   4" "
6
  $""
6 6
 '$$*&)5) 0 $""$")$$23 *)4+"$'"$$
" +7"" 8!+)$ '*" 

 "$

+"

" 68!  9 $   " '$"2  * 2 $ "" 

  " *" 6     " ""   !*" ! :

  '$$;2



')"4<:+$;) +"$*2

2 " '"" 2  * "     = $  " ')"  '""  2 $  2 + $ ')">$ *2""))&$"" " "$2 " '""  7$"   " "  $  %+42 "     2+" ')"'""+  " " !&" ')*""" $ 2"$,2+ +$4 $$2 "" 9 "2$, $""*$ " ')"")""$"&$"''$+ 

  2 $2  +) " "   )$$  3$     ")" ')"2+$$, 4$ *)+ 9"$2 )&2!4< 2 ,4 < $< :$'"$ " $'"4)&;2++  2  ) "  "  *   $""  % 

" ""2 $ !4 <   4   *)+  " ')">$) " 2$, 4$*)+"  "'"" +$$ ,4<  $ <   4  *)+$ " "  ')"  

 =$ &2 !&"4"" "" $4" ')""'"" ")"$ "$  = " *$$    $ )) "$2 ?8   "


  "$
2
+" " 8! +$  $"  $" " $$'"$ 
 "  " !)



""!,@2$""3 *) 3 " ')" 4$" "2'"  " !+$'$"""*&"')  A 0 $"" 4 ,

" "
6
  7"" "$'"$$
"  8! 4"" 

 "$

 +" "  6 8!  %+42 4   $" "
6 6
 2 ) 0 $""  )$ " $'"$$ 
 "   '*"B" "'$)*$ ' &" $    $
2C +"  $"&  " )@  "    " $ '2"$+"" " *4 8"+$ " ""$ &* &" "*2"&$))* ))'"4"$"+")+ 1$$"$2" +$  "" " $'"$ 
 " $ $)) '& $ 2C  "   + $ 2C  $)) * ' $  '$" " " ')" "   " $ C$)) *'&*)$$" ' $ 

4 $""$,

" )") "2 " '"" ')" '   '')2 *" " $  +$ $ $$ *& ) 3") $$$ 5 2 3 *) 4 ,

" "

 8"$" $ $"$2"'"" ')" $ )"'$"4$'""  A $)  " '"" ')" $ " "" *" " "$ *)+ 4 

""  ) )  *& )$  "



$ '$$  "  '$ "   '*"  9 '' $" 4$"*"@*&""$*)+ +) '" )$$'$ "7" $" 1"""$ *)+44"+ )$"""'$"$ )" '4"

 8!$ "&"" ("$ )4  "$' C,&) " "$

*&  ')" 4 <  " ,$ + ""*" " $'"$$ ,< !4< 2"$'"$+""")"* )$  '*"  3)) " $ '$$  "   "

""4)")& )" 4$,$+"*)" $' +'$ 9'"")$$$" $,$$' ) $" '"2 *" " "$ *)+ $ ')& 4" " $ 

$$   

 '$*)  "$ 
  
  +"

" 68!  A $)  " '"" $ " " "" + " ') $ $ " '    ,$ $$" *& " '""$+ 2""'"""'""+$"*&B $'DB !(CDB !(C D4"'"" 4 '')"  " 6  !  )  ") 4 *& "@  " B& +" "$ '" 

"  4 <   *& $

  " ) $"  0) %$'")2 3 *) ""  ) +",&'"2*""$'')"+$$ $$*&) 3") $$$ 5 2 3 *)  % $ '& "" " $'"$




" )*)"*4" "

 +"&4* 7""  4 " )$  '*" $ "& " " ,$ $

*&"'""" ')"  84)$) "'"" ')" '$"''*@  A ") " $ " " " 4  $ *$4""" $'$$"+"!( 

""$'"+""')"2+"$+$4 "'$ !( "2+"') " " $   "  ')" )   $ " "$" $ +  " ' E&$ ""   "&' $'$+ ")&  "$"$ *"   " '$"$   ""

) +"$$$  9 '$" +"$$$ +""""4$$") 

 ))&2$ $" )4'*& " '$" $ 2 " ") " $  ")& $$$  ''" " "$" $     #@$ :!(F;    A"  )  3, 1" :!(; 3$'"'"$DB !(6C3DB !(6C12"$'))$ """" ')"$$"')"+$)   ' 4 $)' ,$" *4    " +$  ' "$+4) "  !"" $$" "+""$' ))"+$$$)'2""++$ $''$") "$+ @+$'$"$) "@ 



9'$"$'4"$$ 

 '$*) "$

+" " 68!2*"$

)"'4"

'$*) 8! *& " '$"   "$" $ *& $+   *"$ 2 " 2 " $$'"$ 
 "  +  ")& 7"" "$ $  !$)  $""
6 6
 '$$*&) ")"4)$""""$ ")&B"* " '*"*& $ "'4$$"& "$ 94*& " '$"  4)) "$   $"$  " @ " & $' " *&"$" 9$4$

'"" ") *"F&$"&+ $"" 

$ 9 2"") " $ " 

"" & )) )"& +) B"  " * "  '*" " " $$'"$ 
 "  9 ") " +$ +)) +""$'+")$"$'"$
" '*"4+ ",

" "$" 

   !"#$ %&&'()*
(
++"*),,   8" +) * '"" " "  "" " $'  4$),$"$4$"+") "'+$ %>*)3'B"  - ". -



 / "0  ."." -

%&&,('*

 1%'+)) +""$' 4$),$"2$*$4$ 


         

         



  

              !  "#          $

 %   

   

  &            

  %      

%   '   %

  '  

    ( ) !$) "''*@ "4)$"""* " ")"* "''))""2"'$"$'4""" $$'"$ 
 "   *") 

$ 2 " 2 " "$*)+4 ")&'""7$" "$'"$$

 )$  "   '*"  042 " 7"    $" $ )+&$ B *& " "  $ $) ' "4   " " )$$ 

  $"$'$* 

 9 2"$"$ " &)) )"&2 )"&'4$"&" ' ,

" '$$*&)")"$+))$",

" ) ''))""2+ &+""  "$"*&4@ "$4$),$"  84+ "*42

 ",

""
6
   "
6 6
  '$$ *& ) ") " $ +)) $ " ,

" "

  '$$ *& ) ''))" "2 " '$" 4$'""2* 4 & "2$$ $$  
   

  . ""