Union Of India Through Its Secretary v. No 707309l L Ex Wo Hanspal Malik And ANR




    
    

 !"#$# %&''(




        

  !"   # $

 %&  )&  *+) ' ,
 ,
) ,
,
 *+) ' ,
-
.,,

'( #)*+,++++- +..- /*% #* .-&,0+- /%&1 22222  ,
) ,
,
 /'0 +1   1 *%%-*0*+..3*4%3&& &+&15 65 5789(1:%+&;<%&5(4&0 ;+.-  3+.  )0*-  *+&3+*  8*+/  /&    +  =* ;+.>:-;<?*0*-%&1*+;+..?&*;// &+;.<%+.3?**;//&3///*&+;.< .4/45 @A @-B%3,?*/+0+&004+0/ *%0+-*3&*+*+4%, 5 +&0./*%+3*+*&+;.</


 

    //&;<%&1

85:

?+ +&;<*#&0+.)+&+.*+5 @ +&*/-* ;//&+;.<.4/*&+;.<%0.&*+,; 3+&%&1-?*0*/+0*+;3&;<* ;+.

%  0  /  4-  #  *  .-  &,0+-  *+ +%%+&;*+.//%&1+&;4*++%* & 4&0+.//08#.+<:-5 55-&3/&+;.40+/ *+3.0+;+&.*+5 @+&*/-,/* &3/&+;.<//&;<%&14&*4&0+. 0/0+;<*#&0+.)+&.*+5 @-*+4*+;+& +5 @/*%%/3+/;//&+;.<% +& 0./%&1/*;4*+*.+& ;+.- 6 5/5 51-.&+=   



  !

" "

# $ &0&&51

5 55-3+&*4.+;/. +C,$+0B- *4.+3&-?*0*C&34*++.+&<;%*.&%*

>;. %4/&+,.%%+.8+<7577D/5 55:- ?*0**+;&4&1 55 7 +&0./*%0,*+4+& ;4*++%* &#&0+.//08#.+<:-5 55- *+&;//+3&+;.</+E5 @-*&+;.<*.& ;  //&  ;<  ;* +-  ?*+  *  &+;.< //&  ;<  %. 00&-*%0+.<*+ A "*+,*+&.+&0./*%++&*+,3 *3**0+/.?**+;.++0

:

D 0-*&+;.</*+3F+*%&?++& .*+5 @-;+40+;.*+5 @,+%*4++.

3,3,0-+<%./&;//3?***+3 &+;.<+0.+4*;//&+;.<.4/*&+;.< %-*+&&+;.<*+;0B&E5 @ *+&%0%. *++.+&<;.&%* >;. %4/&+*0+ /   

$0+8%+:-?*0*/+0*+3;&+* *+&/.+&0./*% 0-*3+/;/;< +3444&+;.<E5 @0+/*+3&+;.<+%*

&4&0+.//08#.+<:-5 55-%/0.<,+.&+& .3+.+&;+&%*.&%0%./.+?   

$ 0+8%+:

*-+%*.&%0%./.+?.&;< >;.

%4/&+
  

 

- , %2#%,3(-?**+;*.&*++4&0 %..&;3+&*;//&3//?*3+& &+;.<%-%0,/*/+0*+*?+,+.&+&/ ,0-&++3*+3/%++04%./ */*3+34-//&;//3/44&+;.< ?*0*+;+;.+33+,+&;<*#.+<,0 .,+%++ /*C&34 

0+8%+:++&'( G7 )<*%/+%%+.*+%%..+8: +*F-?**-+&,&+.-?* *+&++3*+3/%++

87:

04%./*/3+34-//&   ;  //3  /4  4  &+;.<  ?*0*   +;+;.+33+,+&;<*4.+<,0- .&;3+&*;//&3(/// &+;.<  %  *  +%%..+8:  *  ?.& 0&  *+-    *  ;+  /  0.+   185:H H8(:&;<*#<//0-

,4/&+-&+& 1 15

1-*+/+& ;/4+&+,+.+;..<+4&0 .?*,+.&+&/,0-+& +<  *  0+3<  /  4&  0  . 4&*+;, A "*+,*+&.+&0./*%+ *. D "  &      +<      *  4%3& C&348:+&&8:+&*/+..*+%%+. ?*0*%+*00%/&3(///* &+;.<%+&4&-?*&+ 0

 *&4+./*4+?..;+B /;<* 3*+?..+;<* ;+. 3+3+%%%+./*%;/ *4-/+<-?*+33+.&* &+;.<%I 6

0-B%3,?*+;,-*3+/;// &+;.<%E5 @-B%3,?*%,/  & #&0+.//08#.+<:-5 55+&/*-3+/&3 ///*&+;.<%EA @-+%*.&%0%./.+?- %.+&*+;,00 $%3,?*+;,-*4%3&&%+&;<* ;+.%/0.<,+.&+&.3+.+&*+4*+;/&;

8A:

%,*/+0*.&%0%./.+?-
 

   

       00&3.<-*?%&4& 0 ,
) ,
,
1   0-
.,,

1  %4 56/(  



"**%+B3H+&  "**%+;.