High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2727/2014disposed of

Charanjit Singh Meelu v. State Of Punjab

2017-08-22Mr. Justice Jasgurpreet Singh Puri12 pages

#$%& $'()(%*+,+)#-. / 1(# (,/ $$2+ / 1(# (,/ $$2+ 3(0$ $04+5 0 %#/$0) ... 6.

#$%&+1 7 ... *

0$)$#*

/0(#+28 9/ :

2- $(%0 6%'

#$;(#/

/0(01+8 9/ :

2- 6%'

#$&%0#/$:$#(#(%$0)

(

/0(4 ;

21(# (,/- $(%0 6%'

#$;(#/

/0(7/()/$9 1- 6%'

#$&%0#/$:$#(#(%$0(

!".

5( /(0-$:+#< 6%'

#$$$0 2-+1 7.

!. /$)$#/0$$0$6()(%:$#(#(%) 0$7$(, ():%)$ %&7<#/() '%55%%0 $0.

-#/$:$#(#(%$0/ 1(# (,/ $$2+/ ) :+##%'/ 22$,$#/$%0 $0 #$ .=.:

))$ 7< :$'( 2+ ,$- , 0- %/ 2(&0 5(,'/ 0,$ , ()##/$:0$)$#:$#(#(%$0/ 1(# (,/

$$2+.

;

)&(2$ 7</ 1(# (,/ $$2+ , ()##/$ %0 $0 #$ .." :

))$ 7< :$'( 2 + ,$- , 0- %/ 2( )+55%(,/(5 ) (#(% 2 ''+)$ ($>$0'()$%&:%;$0+ $0 $'#(% "!0...( ..%. ?@.=."?@.=.!.

!";

)&(2$ 7< 3(0$ $04+5 0- %/( $0 (,/4 0(0-$1

5%< 2 5 01(# (,/

, ()##/$%0 $0 #$ ..".

/$& #$%&

;%+2 $:$ +:%#/$& #$%& %#/$0#;%0$6()(%:$#(#(%).

%. #$ .@.-+ $0 $'#(%)-@-@A-- $'#(%) " 0$ ;(#/ $'#(% " %& #/$ 0$6$#(%%&%00+:#(%'#-!AA-%2('$ #(%3(,(2 '$+0$ +-

%/ 2( ;

)0$,()#$0$ #/$#/$ +'

#(% (()#$0-%# (,/$#'.

;$0$)$#+:&%0#0( 2./$:0%)$'+#(% 22$, #(%) 0$#/ ##/$ +'

#(%

(()#$0%# (,// ,%# %$7+,2(,(0$'0+(#5$#%&2$09)(#/$ ( '%(6 '$ ;(#/ #/$ %&&('(

2) %& #/$ . $ ,%# #/%)$ '

( #$))$2$'#$ ;/%/ & (2$ (#/$#<:(,#$)# #/$(0$ 02($00$'%0 ;

) $)#0%<$ #/$(0#<:$#$)#;

)# 9$ , (./$%#/$0 22$, #(%) $ , ()#/(5;$0$0$, 0 (,5() $$ )(#/$ +'

#(%$:

0#5$#

))(,%&;$ 2#/ ():0%:%0#(% #$#%/()9%;)%+0'$)%&('%5$.

#/$7 )()%&#/$)$ 22$, #(%)#/$&%05 2 ;

),%#0$,()#$0$

(6$)#(, #(%;

)'% +'#$ . ''%0 (,#%#/$:0%)$'+#(%-(#; )&%+ #/ #(

<-!!A 6$0#()$5$#;

)())+$ &%00$'0+(#5$#%&"2$09) (#/$ &%0;/('/$> 5( #(%;

))# 0#$ (#/$<$ 0 " 2$09);$0$0$'0+(#$ (#/$<$ 0.&#$0)'0$$(,;0(##$#$)# -#<:$ #$)#;

)#%7$'% +'#$ .0.4$/ 0 (,/-/ (05 %& '%)#(#+#$

'%55(##$$6( $%0 $0 #$ ..'%5:0()(,%&'%6$$05 0 (,/

$'0$# 0<- %/( $0 (,/4 0(0))()# # $'0$# 0< 3 0( $04+5 0- ))()# # $'0$# 0<#%/ (05 .&#$0/%2 (,%&#/$#<:$#$)#-#/$ );$0 )/$$#);$0$:+#()$ 2$ :

'9$#))(,$ 7< 22#/$#/0$$5$57$0) ;$0$ )$##%#/$$> 5($0)&%05 09(,. 5 )/#%(0$'#%0'

$5(')

2 (,/#%%(# $'0$# 0<5 $)# #$5$#)#/ #)$ 2)%&#/$

'9$#)'%# ((, );$0)/$$#);$0$70%'9$B:

'9$#);$0$%:$$

)%5$ );$0)/$$#);$0$)+):('(%+)B)%5$%&;/('/ ::$ 0$ #%7$#<:$ 7< +)(,#/$) 5$#<:$;0(#$0 #/$0$;$0$)%5$%#/$0 ()'0$:

'($)

2)%./$0$;$0$5 <%#/$0 22$, #(%)(#/$:0%)$'+#(%'

)$ &( 22<- #/$#0( 2)# 0#$ . +0(,#0( 2- 5 )/C@;

)$> 5($ 7$&%0$#/$#0( '%+0#;/% $:%)$ 7$&%0$#/$#0( 2'%+0#( $# (2. 5 )/-#/$;(#$)) C@ #/$&(2$ ::2('

#(%:+0:%0#$ #%7$+ $0 $'#(%"!0...

7$&%0$#/$#0( 2'%+0#&%0)+55%(,#/$ (#(% 2 ''+)$ :$0)%)- 5$2<-

22#/$:0$)$#:$#(#(%$0)(#/$)$:$#(#(%). /$#0( 2'%+0#:

))$ #/$ (5:+,$ %0 $0 $>$0'()$ #/$:%;$0+ $0 $'#(%"!0...&%0 )+55%(,#/$:$#(#(%$0) ) (#(% 2 ''+)$ (#/$#0( 2.$'$-#/$)$ :$#(#(%):+##(,'/ 22$,$#%#/$) ( %0 $0.

* )+::%0#%&#/$:$#(#(%)-8$ 0$ %+)$2&%0#/$:$#(#(%$0) 6$/$5$#2< 0,+$ #/ ##/$#0( 2 , ()##/$ +'

#(% (()#$0%# (,/

%#/$0)/ ) 25%)#'%5$#% $ &#$00$'%0 (,%&$6( $'$ )+'/ 2 #$)# ,$-(#;

)%#:$05())(72$&%0#/$#0( 2'%+0##%$>$0'()$:%;$0 + $0 $'#(%"!0...&%0)+55%(,#/$ (#(% 2 ''+)$ -(.$.-#/$ :$#(#(%$0).8$ 0$ %+)$2&%0#/$:$#(#(%$0)(6(#$ 5< ##$#(%#%#/$ $6( $'$%& 5 )/C@;/('/0+) (#%+57$0%&:

,$)

'%#$ $ #/ #$6$(&/()$6( $'$()# 9$(#%'%)( $0 #(%-#/$#0( '%+0#-7<%)#0$#'/%&(5 ,( #(%'%+2 / 6$:

))$ #/$(5:+,$ %0 $0.

/$$6( $'$%& 5 )/C@%;/$0$ ()'2%)$) <5 #$0( 2 , ()# #/$:$#(#(%$0))%#/ ##/$<'%+2 7$)+55%$ ($>$0'()$%&:%;$0+ $0

$'#(%"!0.../$0$() 7)%2+#$2<%5 #$0( 2 <;/$0$ , ()#

#/$)$:$#(#(%$0). ''%0 (,#%8$ 0$ %+)$2&%0#/$:$#(#(%$0)-(#() ;$22)$##2$ #/ #7<5$0$:+##(,#/$ 5$(#/$$6( $'$-#/$:%;$0+ $0

$'#(%"!0...'

%#7$$>$0'()$ (#/$ 7)$'$%&):$'(&('$6( $'$

#/$0$&%0$-#/$<)+75(##$ #/ #%0 $0(5:+,$ ()0$D+(0$ #%7$D+ )/$

)$# )( $.

$0'%#0 -8$ 0$ %+)$2&%0#/$ #$%::%)$ #/$:$#(#(%)

)+75(##$ #/ #)('$#/$#0( 2/ ))# 0#$ -#/()%+0#$$ %#(#$0&$0$ ;(#/#/$(5:+,$ %0 $0)+55%(,#/$ ''+)$ ./$:$#(#(%$0)'

;$22 7$ 'D+(##$ (&#/$0$()%$6( $'$ , ()##/$5- )'%#$ $ 7<#/$5-7+# (#()%#2$, 2 :0%:$0#%(#$0&$0$;(#/#/$%0 $0)+55%(,#/$ ''+)$ .

8$ 0$ %+)$2 &%0 #/$ #$- #/$0$&%0$- :0 <$ &%0 ()5()) 2 %& #/$ :$#(#(%).

* / 6$ '%)( $0$ #/$ 0(6 2 )+75())(%) 5 $ 7< 2$ 0$ '%+)$2&%0#/$0(6 2:

0#($) #2$,#/./()%+0#/ %A.A.@- &#$0 /$ 0(, #/$ :

0#($)- :0%%+'$ #/$ %0 $0 7< 22%;(, #/$ :$#(#(%).

%;$6$0- ##/$#(5$%&,(6(,0$ )%)-#/()%+0#&$2#(#$'$)) 0<#%0$/$ #/$5 ##$0 ''%0 (,2<#/$)$;$0$&(>$ &%00$/$ 0(,%.A..

''%0 (,2<- 0,+5$#)%&#/$:$#(#(%$0);$0$0$/$ 0 , (%0 $0;

) :0%%+'$ (%:$%+0# 22%;(, 22#/$)$:$#(#(%)./$&%22%;(, 0$ #/$0$ )%)&%0 22%;(,#/$:$#(#(%).

/$%)#(#+#(%$'/1+ ,5$#%&#/$ +:0$5$%+0#(#/$ '

)$%& 0 $$: (,/6?) #$%&+1 7

-(#/$ ##$0%& $'#(%"!0...2 <(, %;#/$:0('(:2$)&%0)+55%(,

(#(% 2 ''+)$ ;%+2 7$5%)#0$2$6 #./$#$)#)2 ( %;7<#/$:$> %+0#(#/$) ( 1+ ,5$#&( 5$#(%(:

,0 :/)!A-!! -

;/('/ 0$D+%#$ /$0$+ $0* E

! "

$ $

$ $ ' & (

$ %

$ &

) $

* +

,% )

$ *% & &

-.$/

01 2341 23 5 66 "

78 $

978 &83:

& "

;

= & 9 % $

$ >

./ $ $

$ $

$ $ &

, 8%%9$ # #/$ :0$)$# (5:+,$ %0 $0 ( #/$ 2(,/# %& #/$

&%0$) ( %)#(#+#(%$'/1+ ,5$#-&( #/ ##/$$6( $'$%& 5 )/C@D+ #/$:0$)$#:$#(#(%$0) %$)%#)/%; <'%5:2('(#<%& #/$:0$)$#:$#(#(%$0))% )#%)+55%#/$5 ) (#(% 2 ''+)$ 7< $>$0'()(,:%;$0+ $0 $'#(%"!0...()2$,#/<$6( $'$/ )7$$ )$$7<5$7+# %%#&( <5 #$0( 2 , ()##/$:0$)$#:$#(#(%$0)( /()$6( $'$&%0)+55%(,#/$:0$)$#:$#(#(%$0) ) ''+)$ :$0)%).

#())(,(&('

##%%#$#/ # 22#/$ 7%6$:$#(#(%$0);$0$'(#$

):0%)$'+#(%;(#$))$) , ()#%# (,/ %#/$0) #/$<;$0$&%+ (%'$# +0(,(6$)#(, #(%.

/$#0( 2'%+0#/ )-/%;$6$0-,(6$#/$0$ )%);/('/D+%#$ /$0$+ $0&%0)+55%(,#/$:$#(#(%$0) ) ''+)$ :$0)%)*

!#$ !# %

! ! %% &

!!%

% !(

!)' &%!

! !% # ' !

$# ! &* +$ #

& !

, (

#+$ .'

# &$

! ! /

!%0 .!

4*!

&* +$ !#

!%/&

/ !

! $ !% # ' !

+$ /

!% .!

! /

!% .!

1 5 %!' !

!%%%

$ $ %!

(

6 +$ +$ &$!

!% ! !%

$ '

!!%(

! !!

! 8 0'

(

6 +$ # %

# ' $

+$ *!

$ &

+$ /

(

6 +$'! #

! ! !%

1 5

!9'

!% .! 1

$ $ '

!% :!

+$ 6 !

!% .!

! &

!% .!

1 5

!9'

!!%'

$ 9'

!% .! 1

!% .!

5 !

4: !3"

47 /

! ! &

;# $ $%%

# :

!3"

14-

5 %'

$# !%

!%% !% + /

!%!

! !%

! &)'!

! !

! '

& !% +

&!% + 3"<!%%!

!% )'!

)$= +$+' +

!% !

! '

# !

*48

!% !

( '

+$/ +$ /

! ! '

& 5!

(

6 +$ ! '

! $ !% -'

# +$ ,

* +$ #

& ! ,

4 !#

6' * +

& !% :!

+$ ( '

& +

? !%

!% 9' %

! !

& )'!

! !

& !

!% " !@ &

&/& / !

! &

&)'!

! !

..../ !% + $!

!'$ %#

& * = +$ :'

+$* +

6' *

& = +$:

'; $ *

! %%

A!: '

( '

& ! !'

$ /

! * = +$:'

B !%

5 !$ + 6'

' !!%

' !% !# ' #

! '

! !

)'!

! !

!!%

! $!%)$= +$+'+

( '

/ +$

+$ ! '

+ # !

!% (

6 +$

' !% #

!!%

! $!% * +$ #

&!%, !#

+$6 ,

! '

< &

! !'

+$ !% + '

!%1

< &

' %'

;

& !# )'!

! !

6 +$

! &

!'$!

! $!%* = +$:'

+$,

6' = +$:

* / = -!

+ +

& !(

+$ ! '$

# '

%!'

!'$ ! !

!%(

6 +$

! !!

% !

! !

$ @!

! %!

< &$

0 ' !'

!)$= +$+'#

/ +$

!% )'!

* +$ !% /&$/

+$ 3' !:

!% +

!#!!%

'= +!!

3' !0! * 88

! ! !!

!! !% !%%

$ ! !%% 9'

! !

$' ! & /!

+$ 3' ! :

! (

6 +$

!% + !! '

# !'!

+$6 ,

/& / !

&' * +$@/ = -!

+ +

& ! @ =

+$:

6' * = +$:'

!% !

+$ !

! !%

%!'

+ %

$ ! #

!% !# / ! '

! :!

6' 1 (

6 +$

& ' !%% $!%%

# $ !$

$ '

!!%

# $ !$ 5!

& ! '

!$ (

6 +$

!& :!

+$6 1,

!'$

!" '

! '

/$)+75())(%5 $7<8$ 0$ %+)$2&%0#/$:$#(#(%$0) #/ # ##/$7$/$)#%& 5 )/C@#/$ ::2('

-#/$ ::2('

#(% '%+2 %#/ 6$7$$$#$0# ($ #/ ##%% ##/$$ %&#/$#0( 2-;(22/ 6$ #%7$0$1$'#$ )(#) ) <5$0(#.

$0+) 2%&#/$ 7%6$0$ )%) #/$:2$ 0 ()$ 7<C@ 5 )/'2$ 02<)/%;)#/ #$>'$:##/ ##/$:$#(#(%$0);$0$5$57$0)%&#/$ %55(##$$&%0'% +'#(,#/$#<:(,#$)#-#/$0$()% 22$, #(%0$, 0 (,

<%6$0# '#('%55(##(, <%&&$'$.# ::$ 0)#/ ##/$<;$0$5 $#/$ ;(#$))$)7<#/$:0%)$'+#(%&%0#/ #0$ )%)('$#/$(6$)#(, #(% ( %# &( #/$5/ 6(, %$ <5 2:0 '#('$%0'%55(##(, <%&&$'$./() '%+0#/ )# <$ , ()##/$:$#(#(%$0).

$0+) 2%&#/$$#(0$5 #$0( 2D+%#$ 7%6$-#%5<5( - %$) %#)/%; <;/$0$ <('0(5( #(,$6( $'$5+'/2$)))+'/$6( $'$ ;/('/'%+2 2$ #%'%6('#(% )'%#$5:2 #$ 7<#/$:$>%+0#.

#/$0$)+2#-/%2 #/ ##/$(5:+,$ %0 $0()%#7 )$ %#/$ #$0( 2%0 %$)(#'%5:2<;(#/#/$0$D+(0$5$#)2 ( %;7<#/$:$> %+0#(#/$ &%0$) ( %)#(#+#(%$'/1+ ,5$#./$)$:$#(#(%)5+)#- #/$0$&%0$-)+''$$ .

))# #$ $ 02($0-(

-/ 1(# (,/ $$2+ / )'/ 22$,$ #/$'/ 0,$)&0 5$ , ()#/(57<#/$#0( 2'%+0#.6($;%& #/$& '##/ ##/$)+55%(,%0 $0(#)$2&/ )7$$&%+ #%7$(22$, 27<5$

) 7%6$-#/$:$#(#(%

5+)#7$/$2 #%/ 6$7$$0$ $0$ (&0+'#+%+) #/$) 5$() ():%)$ %& ))+'/.#/$0$)+2#-5 9$#/$ &%22%;(,%0 $0*

(

%). !"%& 0$ 22%;$ B (( 5:+,$ )+55%(,%0 $0+ $0 $'#(% "!0...-

#$ .."-()D+ )/$ )$# )( $B (((

() ():%)$ %& )(&0+'#+%+)(6($;%& #/$%0 $0:

))$ (

%). !"%&.

+,+)#-.

# & $ C/$#/$0):$ 9(,?0$ )%$ $)?% C/$#/$00$:%0# 72$ $)?%