High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/23596/2025allowed

Harwinder Sharma v. State Of Haryana

2025-08-07Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel8 pages

#&#&4@<2 4@<2 4@<2 4@<2&3@:

A#;

3@:

A#;

3@:

A#;

3@:

A#;

!-% $ !-% $ !-% $ !-% $/./%3= /./%3= /./%3= /./%3=53@ 53@ 53@ 53@ ; @

B) 0%/% "

B) %,

#$ %$ %$ %$ %$& 6'# )

# 6'# )

# # '

# '

# ' #)7+ 07%50 -! , ) #),18/ *5 ") 99999 99999 99999 99999

'5):

5):

() %%- , %+ !*/ - 4< !

* -/5(<=4:! % > )) )6;! . !./* +* , -% +. )4( 3@)()345 .% !

!!-% ,/% +* / - (@ ! - - - /.% %"- ,- /+%-% -5 (< <?@ :! % > -6;5 *- .*

/ "5%-# # . ) ) .0 ! **. % .% , % % . -0 *0.34 4 --/% !

!+.0 *0 , 1.233. % !, ,,"%:- , %;) 4) '- /%*! , %./ , %-/% "

"%-3@)()34)'- / /%* %!/ %/+

, %-/ 0% 50*+* %%.

.5%/!!%! !-%

% ", 0% % ! - 0 %-/,/* /%*"+ - ,*

)'- /%*! , % *% *"

*+*" ! - + !% /, , ) ) ' - / /%* % !/ , % %/!! -- ! 3(") /%5.

./*+*%,"! ) ) ' - /%* % , ,, % ,% , +"

./.

**. %%.% , % /%/ 5 /%5 % %0 - -%% ! ./*+*)'

- /% *%1% ,*- - -/% "-!-32)3?)3@ @ /5 - %1 - ) @) 0 - /%*! 0 *,% 0. /.

0*+* - % ! -%) 2) , % % 3@)()345 ! 0%. %- /- **% %,% 3()34)3) * <, %-/ %%% 0+-5+/ / *"3( %+C ** ) 0 *- %%.0 % ++*%%/%% **+ - /, /. - /% ! * *) / % ,, , *0, %0*- - %5 %%.5*%

" ,D/ - *) . .+*

% + + /.

! - *1* ! , + +%- . ! , -%% !

D/%- !. , %-/ 0 -) 2)() /++*"5 ,% , % %- , +" , %-/./*+*) *%+* *,*,!+" ,

% % %% % (?)34)3 @) 05 1,. 0 !/ - - ! , ! , ! 3 , .

%% *5 / % -* !0 /+*" - % %,*!

! +*), !+*!-5 %.5-+ D/.

! !

/ ,%%

& & 44 44 44 44&34 34 34 34 * % !H 8

!H 8

!H 8 0%/% 0%/% 0%/% 0%/% !" !" !" !" E*0 !%%/$ F(3) % ,* ./

,-,*% .$

- G%/--%%0

+**A - % **" . / ! )

/- %- G%/--%%

+* * G% %%% , *, %% %% %- G%/-- %/--5 , G,,* H/ % %/+%*- ! %/,!-* %

, - C,%% ! % /.

++%- * %/+%*5!!-0- % 7 C /%0./* /*- %/%/+% -% % % /H/ ! ,% .+// +%*! D/-*%

%/- %- G%/--%%0 7 -% /- +*, :%;5- .*/- + - ! .. %/ %- G%/--%%0, :%;)

0. %/--%%!/**" %- G%/--%%0 , :%;

-, +*! %

+ 0 %-/%% 5 ! ** .

, ./* +* , :%; !* %/- , /.

+D- +*" !) %0 ./* +* , :%; * , % % %% % ,%%G% %%! &, %-/ % %) --%%0 ./* +* , :%; - % ** + %%**"G,*"

- .--/ %-%% .

%+*- . /* %/!!-) 1. %- G%/--%%0 +* ,*:%;

; ** % !, :%; / %H/*- .--/ %-%) *%-, %%+*"+* % *- .--/ %-%%0"

!-%G--/ %-) #1. %/- ,0 /). 5 %%%/%

%- ! /*.

./*+*, :%;) %% .%- G%/--%%0./* /-% %,*"H/ /- ,* %, %/- ,* +.

%5 -/%! /

- /-G %/-

; /.

+ *" -**"

,%%)I

2)) ,/%* ! L %, %%+" * /5+ /.

! +" , 5-% *%, -%. ! **" !

! - + %* /,

, ) % , -/% "

-!- 32)3?)3@!*+" * - /%*5 ,

% *" %/!! -- ! , ! 3( "5 3?

%3 3(") 2)4) / D/.

* % 8/* 0%/% !

8/* 0%/% !

!!!! /D+ /D+ /D+ /D+,%%

#&#&23= 23= 23= 23=&3 3 3 3:3 @$ $332<@;E!*".

/, - ! D/.

% !

6+* /, / /%%8 0%) -")5 ! :(<?3;(

?(E+/*

/*" 0% ) ) "1 :(<<; (

@E 0 /* +

1 0%)

!# % 53:4;

*;<E E # #/%*

J/%%0%) : !

!* ;, %34

4((E * ,,* )@G33 3=)3)33 * % F

%%*% /+ %0%) !K% .*IEF% 1"J J , 0%) ! K% .*I5

,-* '0 ,,* :

*);

; )@@43&3 )3?)3*%F# #

* !

0%) ! /DIE * , ,,* )((2< ! 3 3@)3?)3 *% ,*8% J ,*/% 0%) !5 1/

/ " 0%) ! # " % 5 3:;

*;(= =E % *5 /%$ F=)?) .

%,"

0*%!./ ,0// C"- --- ,".

, +*" !--/% 0- .% -*%,0. " C, /% * % *" ,,%%0-- E .

--/% %**% -/*"

% ! %*!5+/ % "! %,"*) %.

+,*"-/ - + 0&! /, /6%D/ -% % ,./,0%% ! %,"*% *. !/ *.

*!*+"5

%/ ) .

%," , % ! % -- - - /% 0%. 5 H/"5 *5 ,,* ,D/- "%/*/ ,

! -

%% ! - %/

!*"5 - /* +

.H/-1%, %*%H/ 0- /& -1%5 0 ,%%/ , %-/ - *D/%,/* - % / - +C-/%! 1,. --/%! !, !

- * D/%- %"% 5

./ ! %," * % *" +" , %. / , - * % +

! *,/, %)%*"5, -% * ,% E %- *"5 * ,/+*-%/%,- / /% *0- .% %1 0- ** + ,%%. ! 5 /%5 ,.

%*!). % /%".

.0) --/%5 ,%/ %/+D- ,%"- * .-* , "% / /%- %)H/**"

%/- --/%!H/*"!**% ! *") % " - % % %.) **.

--/% +. 0 *0 - +/ -5(<?

-%0 *0.-

-*H/ . /%/ / - 4=

/% - . +* - , %-/ ! 0.%%! % +* . /% ! +*0.

!!-- .G**. 5 * +*) %.. /%

/% + -/* /%*" %-/L !/ *.

%,"*) - +/. "+"/ ,-/**" %/- *":%;% D/%! ! , %-/ - + 1, + +% ! !/.. /%* - *.%*/%% 5

-%%/ -5 %, 0 ,% - ! D/.

% 0* %% !

! !/ *.

%) - -, !

-*(%%%*, ! 5./,%0/ / * +.% -/* % % ! --/% - %H/ ** %.%5 *"5 %. !

* 0% % " , %%+* , %%+*0 +**"%- , !!- ** - * , -.% + 0) %," *5 *"

H/ !- *D/%,/-) 0"0 */ ! 1 %/* , *-5/++*"1,% /%%%%) 05 % ! -*% ..

) % %0"-

1% ! % % ! !!%) 0 ,,%% ,0 , %-/ +*. , +*%,- ) ./%0% --/%.% ,,%%0,& 0% --/% ! C" - *- .%*%*"5, -% & , + * % %

+*" ! --/% ! ,

- %H/-% !,&* -5 ** , 0 %5 %-* ,0 % ! D*&*!5 /%/**"

, 5 +/ ! !

0*" - +% ! %,- ! - %0% . % ,% -% *

*. -

-* H/" !

<?@)K *- %.+*, "5 / % 1, = ! -5(<?@ - % - @ --/% *" ! . ,/+*- , %*! !- % -

--/% % ./*" ! % *1*" -

" !!- - 4= ! -5(<?@ .% +-1 , ! --/%6% .

*!,% **+"

*"% D/-*, -%%5 +/+* --/% , +" - .% %)0/* , ! +" 1.

4= ! -5(<?@) %/%," *"%, %* !

! - %/ !%,-* /%

/ - 42& ! -) " , -*"%%"% *.%*0,/, %) / !* +- - ,*-0 * %."

.- , -%. 0+" .

(<?@5 / /% %1 D/- -/+ - !/.% !C, /%*) * -/%5 %1% %! . ,&* /- -* ,-, . 5 /H/0 -* !* - -*/ % -- 5 *% .% *+" . / * 0. %/ " +. - -5(<?@ /.

+- %% %5. !+*-%, . / !//*"*5- -5(<?@)I 05 /- /*% 6% -!!--" !/% %/"&+ / %/ % !0/*6%!/ *.

%5 * %/)K **. +* . /% ! - 4= ! -5 - /% +*- + *.%*0 , %- %-.

! --/% .-- 5 /D/%!+* ,/0 ,% 5 ,* !D/%-H/") *!-% * % +* 5 %/*. , * .

,- /% !/ * .

% ! *!

5 % %/- 5 - * *+"

/ - 4= !

%,!-% !.0-%) . -

-*H/"5 +% +!+" - 4= = =) / 5%, %-/% "- -!-5 , %% +0 *0 34 -%%,. -A ) 05 !-/ - + . / %/!!- +" % *!5 -* - -%% !

./*+* , H/% % -%% /! . ! .

./* +* H/ H/% % +" -. /, !-%G--/ -% ! % ) *- %.-+,*-/,

D/.

! 6+* /, / #/*# ) % #/*# ) % #/*# ) % #/*# ) % 0) !

0) !

)) 53(:(;

*;@?2 :

*;@?2E0% -

D/.

6+* *-/.

/ -% ! %0) 5

%0) 5

%0) 5 5555 (<<?:;

(<<?:;

*;==

*;==AD/.

% !

#&# )4??& & 3*% %1 *% .

0) !"

1 *% .

0) !"

1 *% .

0) !"

1 *% .

0) !"

" " " "5- <)(()3(5 *D0) *D0) *D0) *D0)

!"5(<<?:4;

*;(<() *;(<() *;(<() *;(<()

/!!- %"5 !/ ! , % /*% !-%- -/ %-% ! -%)

?) 0 !+ 05 ,%, , %** ) % + *% ./*+* %!/% .+*G%/"+ %

%%!- ! ')- -*

/G/"#.%) 05 - % " +

, % +" - - *

/G/"# #.%5 , % ** + /+" ! ** .

- %$& :; , % **

:; , % ** -/ "5/. :; , % ** +

%&/% *+".) , "0-5 * *) +% %*! "+!

*) :0; , % ** -

" !!- * +*) :0; , % **, * /) :0; , % ** .0 0%.. !!-G

% ** - . %- , %% ! *

:0; , % ** % %,%%, 5!"5 % -**, / +

! - - *- -**&, / + /, /G**H#.%) " " *" *) :0; , % **%/+

5 !% 1." !

0" 5 !!0

/5 !!- -

%% !" !! -% , % !!- ! % +. 5 +%% ! %!

05! - ,*5 +/ ! - /

% !) 05 +! - - * % + 0 *0 -!+.*% +*) ) % ! / + 0 *0 "

*. +* ,% !!0 %5 % 5! --** ! %+* %5 % ** + - /, <) -% !+- !" ! ! %- % % - "+ + , %+"- -*

/G/"#.%%-

+ 0 /, . "

%/!!- -/%5

G- ,* % ** + *+"

0 --** ! +* ! , ) (3)

-- .*") (() .% + 0% **+ +- %/%C,%% !

% ! -%) ()

- -% %+ -5,. %-** /% ,,*- 5 !"5% ***% %%%, % !!) /./%3= /./%3= /./%3= /./%3=5 5 5 5

0 K %,1 K , 3@ 3@ 3@ 3@ :

# '

# '; .G% $ %G +*$ %G