High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/277/2015dismissed

Raghuwinder Singh v. Amrik Singh & ORS

2017-03-03Mr. Justice Dr. Shekher Dhawan5 pages

!" #$%$& $ '$$$

!" #$%$& $ '$$$

!" #$%$& $ '$$$

!" #$%$& $ '$$$

$&$

$&$

$&$

$&$

&( & ) *)+,- &( & ) *)+,- &( & ) *)+,- &( & ) *)+,- .+/01 2.+

/12.+ "

$42.+1

$*6 7%8 # 2

#& 2 & &2$ $*6 7%8 # 2

#& 2 & &2$ $*6 7%8 # 2

#& 2 & &2$ $*6 7%8 # 2

#& 2 & &2$ "

"

"

"

(* 2/$.+ (-$1

)( 9:9:9:

9:9:9:

9:9:9:

9:9:9:

#& 2 & &2$-#

#& 2 & &2$-#

#& 2 & &2$-#

#& 2 & &2$-#

((

5 1 )( 1 . ((+

;/1. (1( 1<=>5

12

#/1.

-

+5/ 1 0+ ?@ (+ ;/1. ( )A/(( (+

1( 1<5

#/1). ((

(

-& /@+

% @ () 1- ) 5(6 .+/01 2.+ 5

( 5 1 ) 5( . ( ))/

1 $4 2.+-& 2.+ ) 1

1-%?2.+-%;(2.+- $ (2.+-B/01 2.+1/)+B//1

,,->->-C 1"

((.(+((+

5(

( 1 ( )+ 1

1. ( .

.( 5(

( 1 (+( (+ 1 + 1. (+

5(

15(( 1?@0@ @5(( 1 /)+- (+ + 0

5(

+

10 ..( 1?@(/?

0+)++1?

;

(@ ( 1(+ 1(0 .

165(@+

1 . /5 1 . ( (+ ) 5( (+

5(- ( 0

( 1 (+( ==C- ))/

1 %;( 2.+1%?2.++1

./@?.

0+ (1 .1.0+)+) 5(+1.

55)( ( ")+@(-?/( )( 0 (4 C==<-))/

1%? 2.+-%;(2.+1$ (2.++10(+1

(( ( )/(0@(0 444(

1 ( 1(+ (+ 1

;.2.+

0(+ .1( . 444 (

-) 5( 1(

.

55)( (

!

( & 5( (

(+ 5

( ) 5(

1-(0 .

1(+( ===(+

10(+ ) ( ( +1 ( /( 0( (+ 1 (+

5(1(+ ?@0+ () 5

0 4+1?

( @ 1 ) 5( + . A/

( 1 (+

.1. /)+

(- (+

1 +1

/( 1 + 1 ( ))/

1 +1

1 (+ ) /(@1 (+

5(1+1.

?

(.

0(+ (? 5(/(+

( 1(+(((+(5 ( #.1 8-?

11#.(2.+

#.2.+) ((+

(10+ - ( @0(

1(+ ))/ -?/(

5( 5( .1.(+ ))/

("

) 2(( & /@-?/( )( 0 (4 1+

5( , (+ 5 @

-(+

1( / 1( ) (/1 >-

, ,,->-C 10(+2 ,> 1"

$))/

1& 2.+1 11/.(+ 5

1.

)

1 /)+-(+ 5(. (+?( 1(+ 5 )+.

5(11.5)

)

-)+.

/1 >-C 1"

0 1

165(@11 (5 1./(@1) ( .+/01 2.+-) 5(55 1(+ 0(

D "E&/.+( 5( ;(B/55 1 0(

D "E2(( (

10 /1 ,, " 1/ 0+ (+

)(.

5/(( $))/

15 1 1

5)( > + . )

(+ 1 + .

55 )( 1

11/) 1 1-(+ /()A/((

165(@ $55 + . ?

5 1 ?@ (+

5(

(1 1

1

/((@- (+ ((

$.+ (- 1 )

55 . (+

5(65 + ./ "E .+/01 2.+1"E ;(B/0 /.+(

(? (+((+

+1)@(

5

1(+ /(@1 +

5(1 + .1 1(+

4.+1(+ /(+ (( 1 + .

.( 1?

( 1 /?((

165(@F

C

+

+ 1( .(+1(+ 5 1.

1+

5 /

/(+ 11.?

1/5 (+

>

( "E .+/01 2.+- ) 5( (+( +

(+

(+ D)/

1(+

.

15) ))/ ;

0 +5 5(

(+

() 1 ?@ (+ /((+("E-+ )

D( -+1) @ 1(+(+ (+ +1 ( )/( @0 .1.(+ 5 (@F+

/ @ 1

1(( +

;

0 +50(++ /) 5( /(+ 1 (+( (+ 5 (@ +1 ( ?

5(( 11 ;

0 +58

55 .

(+ 5 + ( 1 ) 1 @ /?

( (+

(@1+ (

) 1 /)+

( ?@ /((

1 /)+))/ ()

-(+ ( /(+ .+(/@(4 0(+((+

1) (?

+ 1 ./(@ + .) (( 1+

(

5

)) /( .

( +

5(/5 4.5 5( ( 5/( + +/( /1 > 1 "

(?

1 /( <

/( 0+

(4 ) )/ ( /5 D( 1

( "E) 5(

;( B/- "E .1 (+ .( ) (1( 1(+ .0(+;/@ +

0(+( )/

+/(?

./(( @ ./ (+

( /( (+( (+ ( "E .+/01 2.+- 5(-+ 0+ 1+ D( 66+ (

0+( 1( 1 ( (+

1 .

1@ ) (( 1 (+

"E ;(B/+ D( 66+ (+( 1

( ?

(+ 1( ))/

!/(+ -1 (0(

-"E,1"E>- +

) ( 1(+

(

5(

.1 )(1( 1

( "E1"E-(

(-4 /()

5(@(+ .?

1 ) 2/)+(+ 0 /1 (4 /()

/1 C

1"

=

55 . +

? ( /(@(@ 5

(@(+ ;/1.

)A/(( /(1

$55 ( /(

( 0(( (+ ;/1.

)A/((0+ ) .(+

;/ 1)( (+ /( /( "

1

#& 2 & &2$

#& 2 & &2$

#& 2 & &2$

#& 2 & &2$ )+,- )+,- )+,- )+,- # &

# &

# &

# &

2 2 2 2 * * * * E+ 4.F

1G '

F E+ (? G '

F