High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/2798/2014allowed

Satender Dhama v. State Of Punjab

2015-02-05Mr. Justice Inderjit Singh9 pages

! "# $ %!&!& '()(

! ! %) * + (, " !

"!#$!%&$'

(" & )&*+ &$$!( , ! "

-.,/) '

1 !+ #

, ! !

"!'!

-.,/) '

!.$,+ !

,3'

3/ "

%( !

- .( )/"&0" 1 ! !#,!&!& .(&!)%) *0""20%) * + 4

" !" 4 56 (7&(!") " ( 5 0550400 040 00 -/05 %0 !#$( 1! (6 ( 8

848 % 1! !% &1 ! !& && 9& (0 % !& 7 & (! !6 ,( (0 $:0 % 6& " ; %& " "

! $< ) (, 7 !& (& !# 0 1 : 7$( # "7$( "=! -, , =:,# 6 ($ " $% 6& " & 7# " ! $< )6#&!#:6! & 7& 1 + & 7

%/4-%- 5 !6 ( ( 7"& !# !# ! 11)("-% 6& " & 7## "

!!$,!"!

! !!#& (!&7 !& 7! $ #& (!&7 !& & !#,( !1 (6 (1 $,!" "

& , ! ) " 5 % 6 ( ()+$&!!" 0 6#& 0 &! 6 ( $ !& " !# ! 1 - 11)("-% 6& " & 7# $ " "&(1 ()(! !$ !!# ! !6& " & 7## $ 6 ( ( & "& !# ! ( 1!& ( ")7(!!#!&$ $& 7 1# 70!#,!&!& $ " ,,&1 !& "&(1# 7(! !& 7!#& !# ! 1 (6 ($ "

)! 7 & (!#&$ ( &!#!#6 ( :1 1!& 7&" 1 #&( & $ !& !#1 ( #&( $6 ($ !& "& !# "

1 :6 ( ( !1!" $#&$ &" ,,&1 !& "&(1# 7 6 ("&($&((" "1# 7(6 $"&" "" !"4 #,( !&(& ,!&!& # (+ &"!

1# 7 "

"&($&(( ,,&1 !& "&(1# 7 (6 ( " $& 7 1# 7" !"4 " !#, 1"& 7( &(& 7!# $ 9 "1 ) ( !#,!&!& 1 ! "(!# !!#&(

1!& 7&" 16#&1#(# 6(!#& $ ! !#,!&!& ( &!##&( $6 ($ !& "& !# :1 :6 (1!"

$#&$ .

0()&1& !&" 16 ( ! "")1"!

!# & $ ! !#,!&!& ")& 7& (!&7 !& : !#+ (&( "&(1 () (! !$ ! 1 - 11)("0 $:0 % 6& " & 7#0 !# ,!&!& # (+ &$,&1 !"06# (0#&( $&( ! "# $ "

! !6& " & 7## $ 9 "1 ) ( ( ()+$&!(!# !!# ,!&!& 6 (1 & "& * && 1 6&!# !#

4" !"

57&(!") " (5 0 % " 8

% 1! "#&(, ")1!& 6 !(6 +! & "& !#,( !1 ( "#6 ( (!"

5 !&( ( !#1 ! !& "

) (!# !"&(1 ()(! !$ !&(& "$&((&+) " &" 1 1! " 1# 7 (# )" # + $" 7 & (! !# ,!&!& ) " % 1!9 "1 ) (# ( ( &"

), !#*)"7$ ! * (!# >&7# )!& !#1 ( 53"

&'3'/

5 6"

!# &-&"

&'049?&$& 40& (),, ! # ! !& ( 9 "1 ) ( !#(, " !- ! !()+$&!(!# ! : ,&$ 1&1 (&(!

+( !!#!&$ $& 7 !#1# 7 "!# 7 !& ( 7 & (!!#,!&!& $ !! &" 106#&1# !

+ = $& "")& 7!#!& > "!# 7)$ !( " 1"+: "1 ) ( !# ,!&!& (6 ( ! ! "# ( ,)("!#&$,)7 " " $& 7 1# 70 ", (("& !# ,,&1 !& "&(1# 7 (6 (

!#"

1)$ !( & + !#& # 7)$ ! !# "1 ) ( ,!&!& &(!# !!# ,!&!& # (+ &$,&1 !" : !#+ (&( "&(1 ()(! !$ !

$ "+:1 - 11)("0 $:0% 6& " & 7# !# )7#!#6 (

1!& 7&" 1& "&1 !& 7#&(& $ ! ( $ !& 6# !( # (1 $ )!")& 7& (!&7 !& !# ( ( + 7)"!# !!# 7"

"&(1 ()(! !$ !$ "+:1 - 11)("&(& "$&((&+) " 6 "$&!!":0 !# ,!&!& # ( + 1# 7-(#!" !# + (&( (! !$ !$ "+:1 - 11)("06# # ((! !"!# !!#,!&!& 6 ( ( & "& !# 1+)! !#& 7()+(! !& # (1 $

1 "!

!#( $ & !#& , !&") " %0 !#& 71 1!# (1 $ )!!

(# 6!#& $ ! ,( !,!&!& : & # (+ $ !& "& !# "!# !# 6 ( ( & "& !# 1,)( "&(1 ()(! !$ ! 1 - 11)("-% 6& " & 7#(# 6(!# !!# $ !#,!&!& "

( !

&7)& &! !##&( $# (+ $ !& "& !#1# : !# &$,)7 " " "&($&(( ,,&1 !& "&(1# 70 &! # ( + $ !& "!# ! !6& " & 7## $ &( ( & "& !#! " (& 7 1 !&1(06# (0 $ !#,!&!& &( ! "# $

&!# :"&(1)((& &(!#6&!#7 "!

& $ ! !#,!&!& & !# " :&" 1# (+ 1 1!"+:!#& (!&7 !& 7 7 1:!

!#( $ !# ( ( + ()+$&!!"+: "1 ) ( !#,!&!& !# ! !#" ! "&: 1 ! + "!

1 - 11)("0 !#,!&!& 6 (1 & "& * &

!# (+ #"& & )(*)"7$ !( > @+!#,= )! ( 6 !#&( )! !# ! & +( 1 : &" 1 =1,!

((& 1 - 11)("0 & ! 1 & $ ! $& !"

11)("1 +" 6 !# ( ( + #"!# !!#!& )!&( !!

1!$: ( , (! &1 !#& (!&7 !& 7 7 1:+)!!# )!&(!

,,:&!(& ", " !$& " !!#!&$ $& 7 1# 7 &3 &&'5.)36"

!#3 &7 89:;:<4> @+!#,= )!# (#" () " - A#)(0!# )7#1 ((& $ :+7 "" (&" 1& !# !

7 &1( (+1 )( !#, &(& ( 50!# 1!

$ & (!# !&!&( !&" 1 ("& "+: 5 1!#()!0!# 0&(!# !& " & 76&!# 1 ( 7 & (!

11)(",( 0!# )!1 !(! !6&!#!#1 ((&

1 - 11)(",( B&!$)(!+7& 6&!# !#&" 1 "")1"+:!#, " !&!# ( $"&!( ,& &

6&!#7 "!

!#C) &!: "1! !#( &"&" 10!# &!&(,$&((&+!

!) !

!#1 ((& & "!

1& (() 1!

!#1 1((& 7)&!6#&1#!#*)"&1& $& "&( + )!!

1# !#( &" !#&" 1 !# ! !# 1 ((& 1 - 11)(" ,( 1 ! + ! !" ( ()+(! !& &" 1 " 1 + ,((" & !

(&1 : 6# !# )! &( & 1& " !

11,! !# &" 1 "(!# 1((&!: (D& 7 (() 1

& (),, ! &!(1 1)(& "")1&+ $!#( &"&" 1

! &( 6 $ ( & !7 !# ! !# 1 ((& +: 11)("& ! ()+(! !&,&1 &" 1 7 & (!!#1 - 11)("

,( & !#( $!& !#&(0 , 1& 1 !# 6 &""

6 +:

> @+!#,= )!& !#1 ( 5&"

)3&3'/ 6"

!# 7 8=1=8< #1 ((& 11)("1 :+)("

7 & (!!#1 - 11)(" "& 7 (() 1!

:()+(! !&&" 10 &!#+: :0!

+)!&&E" 1!"),

!&(!&!!# !!#6 "(F !()&1& !7 ) " , 1"& 7 7 & (!!# 11)("F ,, & 7& !# , (!) !=1&( *)"&1& $& " !#, ! !#?)"7!

!# 1!( !#1 (& "!

"!$& 6#!# 1 ( !& # (+ $ " )!+:!#, > 60& ((((& 7!#&( 1!0!#?)"7# (!#, 6!

(&! "6&7#!#$ !& !#&$&!",), ( & "& 7 )!6#!# ! ,&$ 1&1 ( 7 & (!!# 11)("# (+ $ " )!#!(!!

"!$& ,&$ 1&1 (", "(), !# 1!( 1#1 ( "& !#&(7 "&!&( &!# (&+ "(& +!

6 ) ) &( ,,&1 !& /:

" 70# 60&!6 &6( C) :, ((&+ "!#?)"7&( ( !&(&"!# !!#&" 1, ")1"+ #&$7&(&(!

()(,&1& :

("&(!& 7)&(#" $7 ()(,&1& 0#6&+):6&!#& #&(&7#!!

"&(1# 7!# 11)("!!#&((! 70#&( !!

( (!

6#!#!#!& 6& "& 1 &1!& !#+ "!(!!

+ ,,&"&(6#!#!# $ !& ( 1 "0&) +)!!"0$ D( 1 &1!& ( +:, ((&+

6!# =!C)(!& &(6#!# ,&$ 1&1 (# (+ $ " )! 7 & (!!# ,, ! =1&(& 7, 6() "

!# " &$& % 1")0!#(!!", (&!& 6&(!# !!# ?)"76#&1 (&"& 7!#C)(!& $& 7!#1# 7() "!#( &"

(1!& # (!#) "

)+!", 6!

(&! "6&7#!#&" 1 !#

4 &$&!",), ( & "& 7 )!6#!# ! ,&$ 1&1 ( 7 & (!!# 11)("# (+ $ " )!B6#!#$ !& (, 1"+ !#1 )!

"&(1 (7 ()(,&1& 7 & (!!# 11)("6#&1## ( !+ , ,:

=, & "!#1 )!6&+):*)(!&&"& $& 7 1# 7 ", 1"& 7 6&!#!#!& B+: " 7&!6 &6( C) :, ((&+ "!#?)"7 &(( !&(&"!# !!#&" 1, ")1"+ #&$6#&7&& 7&(!

( $ ()(,&1& +)! !7 ()(,&1& 7 & (!!# 11)("0#6&+):

*)(!&&"!

"&(1# 7!# 11)("0 "& =1&(& 7*)&("&1!& ) "

!# " &$& % 1")0!#?)"71 ! 1!

$: ( , (! &1 $ )!#,&1 !#, 0+)!# (!

(&"!#+ ", + +&&!&( !#1 (0!#!

! 1! !#&" 1 "!#"

1)$ !(, ")1"+ !#1 )!+)!(# )" !$ D & 7 C)&:& !

!#, ( "1 ( !#$ !! "6&7#!#&" 1 (& #6 (1 ")1!& 7 !& >

'3!'!#',3&?

"." &#.$$&5.)& &)&$@'!

78A82=<B

!#3 &? &) "

3'/ 48A;7< 1=A > @+!#,= )! +("!# ! !!#& &!& (! 7 !# $& 7 1# 7&!#&( (! 7()(,&1& -&" 16#&1# "(!# )!!

!#& D!# !!#&(7 ) " ,()$& 7!# !!# 11)("# (1 $$&!!"

1!# &!&( ! , !

!# )!!

( :!# !!#&( ()&1& !

7 ) " , 1"& 7 7 & (!!# 11)(" !#&" 16#&1#!# , (1)!

, , ((!

"")1!

!#7)&! !# 11)("0 & ): 11,!"+ &!&(1# 7"+:1 ((-= $& !& +)!!"+:

!#" 1&" 10& :01 !(# 6!# !!# 11)("1 $$&!!"!#

10!# !#6&+ ()&1& !7 ) " , 1"& 76&!#!#!&

'3!'!#',3&? &#.$$&5.)&&)&$@'48A871< 1180 > @+ !# ,= )! ! 1 (&"& 7 !# (1 , (1!&

+("!# !!#6 "(G ()&1& !7 ) " , 1"& 7 7 & (!!#

11)("G1 :(# 6!# !!#?)"7&( !$: , (!- &1!

$ 1# 7 !!#+#(! !#, +)!## (!

=1&(#&(*)"&1& $& "!

!# 1!( !#1 (& "!

"!$& !# ! 1 ( !& # ( + $ " )!+:!#, ((((& 7!#&( 1!&!&( ! 1(( :

!#1 )!!

!& !

!#, ( "1 ( !#$ !! & !

6&7#& 7 " + 1& 7 &" 1 " , + +&&!&( +)! # $ : ) ! !# $ !& !

& " )!&!# 1!($7& 7!# $! D !!#& 1- ) (! +&(#!#& 7"& !(1 (!&!)!& 7!#( &" 1!1 (&"& 7!# 1 ( 6 !#()+*1!0!#&( )!"")1" () "

F# !!#?)"76#&1 (&"& 7!#C)(!& $& 7 !#1# 7() "(1!&

!# "# (!#) "

)+!"

, 6!

(&! "6&7#!#&" 1 !#&$&!",), ( & "& 7 )!6#!# ! ,&$ 1&1 ( 7 & (!!# 11)("# (+ $ " )! H#!#$ !& (, 1"+ !#1 )!"&(1 (7 ()(,&1& 7 & (!!# 11)("6#&1## ( !+ , ,:

=, & "!# )!6&+):*)(!&&"& $& 7 1# 7 ", 1"& 76&!#!#!& 5#!(!!

"!$& ,&$ 1&1 (6 )" !) :

", "), !# 1!( 1#1 ( "&!&("&&1)!!

6 ) ) &( ,,&1 !& /: " 7# 6& !6 &6( C) :, ((&+ "!#?)"7&(( !&(&"!# !

!#&" 1 "")1"+ #&$6#&7&& 7&(!

( $ ()(,&1& +)! !7 ()(,&1& 7 & (!!# 11)("#6& +):6&!#& #&(&7#!!

"&(1# 7!# 11)(" # !& =1&(& 7#&(*)&("&1!& ) "(1!&

" ?)"76#&1#(&1) "!#,( ! "&( ( & "=,& 1"?)"71 ! 1!$: ( % (! &1

$ )!#-,&1 !#, 0+)!# (!

1 (&"!#+ "

, + +&&!&( !#1 (0!#!

! 1! !#&" 1 "

!#"

1)$ !(, ")1"+ !# )!0 :+ (&1& &$&!&( ,, & 7& !#1 ( "( #&(# 6"

( !$ !# !!#?)"7(# )"$ D & 7 C)&:& !

!#, ( "

( !# $ !! " 6&7# !# &" 1 ( & # 6 ( ")1!& 7 !& F 7 & & . , @

) )+&'% !# /&$##&3"4 "

'/&$?'3$5.)& .'-&@ "08A87:<1A:> @+!#,= )! +("& , 7 ,# !#?)"7$ ! () "

F# (! " " !(!0 ,

" *)"7$ ! 6#&1# &( !

+ ,,&"& :+ & "& 70!# 11)("7)&!: !#6&(0 &( != 1!:!

+ ,,&" !!#(! 7

!# " &$& % 1")0 5!!#&((! 70 : (! 7 ()(,&1& ) "" ), $ !& ( + !# . 7&(! !6#&1# "(#&$!

$ ,()$,!& ,& & ( !

!# =&(! 1 !# 1!) & 7"& !( 1 (!&!)!& 7 !#

1 7"0$ :*)(!&:!# $& 7 1# 7 7 & (!!# 11)("& (,1! !#1 $$&((& !# ! 1F

! &$!?3', !/&$ 6"

""3"

!$$ % !!# '

&$C%3"

4& &&"

&78;=3 7& <:8=<7!)<4 &!# ( + #" !# ! 1 ((& (! !$ ! 1 - 11)(" 1 ! + !# ) " !& 7 & (! !# 11)(" !# ,), ( $& 7 1# 7

&$& :0> @+!#,= )!& !#1 (!&!" (!/ "

D&% 3'&/,3"

36"

!#& &&"

&41EE; 7<188 & , ( "# (#"!# !A()&1& !7 ) "(!

1" !!# 1# 7(#!&(()+$&!!"&(!

+1 (&""+:!#?)"70, (!) !(!#

,,&1 !& *)"&1& )($& " "6#!# 1 ( !& # (+ $ "

)!+:!#, #*)"7# (!#, 6!

(#&!!#6&7#! $ !& &$&!",), ( & "& 7 )!6#!# ! ,&$ 1&1 ( 7 & (!!# 11)("# (+ $ " )!I

&$& :> @+!#,= )!& !#1 ( 3&'-&'3'/

5&&)3'/ .'-&+36"3

',& 3)&-3--&&',!

"88E

7< &/ 891& , 4# (#"!# !A&!6 &6( C) :, ((&+ "!#*)"7&(( !&(&"!# !&" 1 "")1"+ #&$6#&7&& 7 &(!

( $()(,&1& +)! !7 ()(,&1& 7 & (!!# 11)("0#6& +):6&!#& #&(&7#!(!

"&(1# 7!# 11)("I

&6 !# 1!( " 6, (&!& =, & " + 0!# ,( !,!&!& &( 6" "&$,)7 " "4 0&"6#&1#0!# ,,&1 !& &"+:!#,!&!& "&(1# 7# (+ "&($&((" "

1# 7(# + $" 7 & (!#&$&(C) (#" %!&!& 0 $:0

! "# $ &( 1C)&!!" !#1# 7( $" 7 & (!#&$ +) :0 7 < ,