← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1406/2007dismissed

Makhan Singh v. New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

2024-10-03Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma8 pages



     

     

!"

#$%$!&'

#!( ) * +, -$&., //////00 11 2%/  3 &4$

%%5) &# !60 &7 84/ ////// %0!&4 & '

98 -/ - -  -  

    

  

      

" #

$$$$$ -  -

/

8 %    

     &    '

  (    %)  "

  %)*   +   %,--.  /  01&   

#  &"

 " ".  2 &"

21(& &



3

'

 (    -  

-  &    

 

%4%%,,)5 &  (  "67 %-8( ' ' 9&   6  :  "6(    *;  +

'  ( "

 & (   



5 &   &6 <   "

 "6(

"



 

 "6 "6'

 '   

5 &

 "

 '"  ="     "6( &  '   (  6  (6  !

 '   "( 

&  5'   %4  (   &  " * >    

  

 "

3   ?   '     &"

 

( '

 "



      "#$   



&  '

   



 



(

" 

( 

) *)  4   6 '

    '    

  &"

   :  

 

  

 ----   -8-   - )   "

 



  @&"

  

  "     

   (      

*

 

 &

( ( %) &@ &"

 " "&    8    "

   

" #

'"    ( 

  &  

 '

&    - !  "

    "  (     ,  

  ( %) " 

+, 

  *--.

$    !  &

&

/ "



  

'0

    1

&  ) (

       2  2

3 

   

" 4)  !  "  !

 (      !

 



&$ !  (   ( & !

5 

  ( "

#

& )3*636667 8  (

!   ,

  "

&         !            &    (  

& "#

,

 ,

(

" 97.'%1   

(

  

&  "#$ 





& 

$     (   !    ( & !

5 



 - % 

 2

&  

              *--.$    ! 

&

& / "







 !

&) (

3

 



" 

  !  "        !

 



&$  !    ( & !

5  

        (       "

#

&   1             :  (

    &      

#  ;

!  

!#    ((

       

&  $

&

   )3*636667,

  & 





#"(  



<

% 

2

&

   (  

# --.),

( "), (  = (   &  ( 

 

 (),  &), 



), (  2 

&      % 

2

& 



&   *--.3  

! ! 

% 

2

& & #

:

   >  

 (  ), "),   (  (),% 

2

&  = $$)   & "#

?<   ((#$$)  & "#0 

2

& 2;?< ( #

(( #)

0

7 /

5  &   

8 ?< '      (#           .666  "#   ,

  , 4 (        

&  (( ( ?<  

&  ?<  (#),,

(   " (& (

"

?<. (#     % 

2

&  (  & 

# 6  ,

#     (   ?<  )    (#     !   (  8  

&       *.-.6  

&     ?< "

&.

' $

&     6*--?<) ( @ 

& #?<)' "(#

&  

?<)

)   (  

#"  

&   " .

 6*-

$  ( 8

&   *..6;(   

&       !

 8 

     

&

 ;

;)--0

( &'4  %

&3 0

2 ) 

(,( 

 10

    

  "  

! ! 



"  

& ((#976%1  2

 " ( " , ,;

1 ,AAA;;;B66'  "@ )(( &')& %

&12  /



   97.' %  1        

 (          7

  

  

&!   7     ( #

" ;

66  ,C  ( &  6*  $  2C #

 2#  1  



,@ 3    D  >%  1    3  -3  2   BE  % 

     ,   ;

5   

  "#   

   @

#   



  

# 

5  

 "# 

     "# !3  

   ,   <( F

#( F

&

2  BE    &   

    

 

&   

 

  

        #      #<   "

&     ( #  

  #





" G  

,  

  --B'E),)B, E( &

'2" ,

B$  E& @)19

 ;



,

#

   D >%1  3-2 ..@

# ?< 

#

 





G    !  

  

<

  

"   G!3

    &       #  "     ! & 

 " (! > /     #     "#          

"  (   " 

(   

&    

  "

&  "#$ %   &      

   ,     



  

 #   !  

 

),!  

 



   & 

   (  #(3),!  

& "

! ! 

 )

  0

  7  /

5     5

 ) 3  H &  ,

;





2

&     &   !  

! ! 



;!   (  

# --. #), &

 





!   & "

! ! 



3 ;

(

 

 #,

(

" ) 

 #     

 !

 

  



 % "    (

 & ' ( (

@&"

    (   & '

&  & @&"

"

  %)*    



 &  %% "   "  (  

(   ' (   

  "6(  & 5 &  ((    '   

  & (  "6(  "

 (   (  "6  

("

 & 

 &  "

'  "67 %-8 

% ( &  ' !   (  & @&"

 " "   

  4$%6$%% 4& '



 &  %*   '       

-  - 

 

#!( ) *<     <  6 '3 6 6 '

  <  &   A