Sudesh v. Kaptan Singh & ORS
!"!#! $!!!
!"!#! $!!!
!"!#! $!!!
!"!#! $!!! !#! !#! !#! !#!
#% # & ' ()*+, #% # & ' ()*+, #% # & ' ()*+, #% # & ' ()*+, -%-(.
/0 -/ 1
(
23%-4/.
!5'6 7"85 - # -##-!
!5'6 7"85 - # -##-!
!5'6 7"85 - # -##-!
!5'6 7"85 - # -##-!
%'
5%!.+!.
&% 9:9:9:
9:9:9:
9:9:9:
9:9:9:
# -##-!+ # -##-!+ # -##-!+ # -##-!+ %%
3 . &% . 4 % %/
;(.4 % .% . *< 3
. =) %/ . !..% -
(.4 + 0.% 0/&/%/ ;(.4 % &>(%%.% .*< (.&54 %%
+ 0&>(%%4 %/
.?
/
&/4
(.
- <?<@?6"?< .
" &% %/% % %/ 3 .4 %/% 1
+/( =. & 3%+ 0 & . # %&% +5 /.
4/ &
(.
,@
. (.
6% "/ -4/ A
B/ +0
& .%/ ;&
(.
- . %0
3%%/%"/-4//.33 &/ . 1
+ /
/( =.+ % 4
)
%/% / & (. = 4
.%%/
%3
= 1
C3
4/
=%)% 4 )+/ 0 .
.=)"/-4/%
/ ..% 0/&/ 1
4
.!% (&/3 % % + "/-4/& ./ = =A
% / B.
23% -4/+ / = 660 A
% / B % %% . % D .
3(&/
&
4&(%( . 1
! .
. % /
=
%% . ( E+,+?6= %0
3%
3( (& %/ + 1
(4/% 3
%/
3 % (%/ %) % = 3 .(& . = %/ -(= % .
% &%% %/
)3
.%
4% .. 1
0 .(& !(%/ %
-(= %.
. 0 &(% . <
( 23% -4/ = 0 %%
%4 0%
% %/ % 0
. =) %/ & 3% %/% (% % % (% E+,+?6+ ) E<++?6 0
% 1
%%/ %
..0/&/ .
% . / %/ (;= % "F+ - & %%"&/+ 0.%/ (%0 F 3%=) =.23%-4/!% .
.+ 1
0 = (4/% =&F (.
3 &
% % /.
4/ &
%
. %/% ( E*++?6+ (&/+/
3%
& & 0%/ &/ & (.
<?<@?6"?<
.
.
(%+ .% 0 .% & -%% 5 0+ 0 .%/
%4% 0
%% % / 4 % %/ &&(
. 0 . (% . %/ 3 %
/ 0 % . &&(
. % & % 3
&/..
&( .(3 =)%/
(33
.(.
, .( % .% .*+&&(
&/4 /
. (.
- <?<@?6"?<
. 0/&/%/ )3 .
. %4(%).& %
(33 % &/4
C . )
0%
&(.4-(.
/& 3% G+8
( + %/ 660 & 3% G+ 5 / %/
%(. .(%) .% 3 .(&%
. G@ 0 $. +%/ -(=
% & . G / &&(
. 0/ C (.
.( .%/
4% 3
. 3 .
.
3&%
+
0 .%/ .
< 4..(& .%/
.. / 4 / . . &
%/ 3%
+ %/ (.4 A ( # B? (.& 54 %% %
+ 0 3
. ;(.4 .% . *< &>(%%4 %/ 3 %
/ !33 /
3 .+ 3(4 .;(.4 %.% *< 3
. =) %/ . !..% -
(.4 +
0+%/ ;(.4 % &>(%%3
(% %.
.
(%%)+%/ %%
3
< . &
33 4 %/ 3 ?
3%/ 4( .%/%%/ (% 0/
& &%3
%/%&&(
.=0 )%%
%4 0%
% %/
. . % = &) . %/ =) 4 4%/ &%%/%=0 =
.0
% 23%-4/+& 6&&(
..0/
(%/
.0 &(% .. (&/&
% /3 %
&% .%/%%/ &&(
./.&% .& & .
( 0%/ &/ %/
& .%/%%/ (%
= 0/
%33 &% .%/ &% = (4/% .%/%%/
.0 &(% ./
3
. <0/ 1
+
/.=
= (4/%(.
3 &
%.
? = / )/.&& 3 ./ .%
.+/ /.=
%F =&F ;(.&&( .).0 % (.% &)4) (% 0%//. &( ?"F3
6=
F/.=
3 .(& &%%/
% 6& (% E*++?6% & .%/%%/
..(& &% )E<++?6%/ "F&& (%
.(.
&&( %&
&
+ % 0 (. = 33 % %/% %/
=& 6& (%/.=
3% .=)
.63%)8 .&
33 4 (.3& / ) &
% 5 /+ 0/ /.=
C (% G@ G@0
%(.0/ /.= (4/% 1
% 33 = %/ -(= %
. <8 .&
%/% G@/
% /.
& ) . %/% =
.+ 23% -4//.
E<++?6% 1
+0/&/%(+/.=
% .=) 1
(;=% "F+- & %%"&/+
0 G@/.
.%/% = ) 1
0
%%/ / %%/ %
. . C& 3% E<++?6+ (%/ (% 0
%( 1
/
%0 4( .%/% (&/ &&/4 %
% ) G@ / % =
33 &% . %/
&%3
.0/&/0 (& %% %/
4.
6& (%/
3% @ .&
/
/ .% 4%/
. &
+%/%/.=
>( % .+ /
3 (
, .
% $. + -(= %+ 0 G0 (.= &(&%/
%&
0 +(.
(=% .)+ % 0%
4.
3
4 %
6&
(
/
% +/
&% &) .%/%%%/ %
.+ 1
/. . %/% / /
. %/ % 23%-4/+
/
..% < 3% . (
%/% &&.&% & .4
1
0%/ 4.% % 6& /
. /
% ) G$. +& .-(= %& %=
. &.
. )
%/%5 /-4/+ (. G@ /. .
. %/% / 3
23% -4/
@
%( 1
( E<++?6 ) G@/
.
)0 4.
(%/ 4 %=
.=) 1
23%-4/= -(=
%%%/ %
./%3%+ (.3) %/. %=
.
=)23%-4/+% 0 0) 1
%
. =;
=
-(= % (&/ =;
?3
%0 .
(&/ &&( %&
+%/ 4 . (.
<?<@ . & ) %.
(%
4.
4%
/
. /
%).(&
?.
/
= %)+%/
%=
(= %%% 3%
.(& % & 3% %/% 1
/.=
3
. )
3
0/% 0 (&/ .(& %% .
.3 ./ & 3 )4 ) / 4 . (.
< .
%.
(% * %0 &% 0 0/&/0 (.& %
.
(=%%/
%)+%/
.0
&(% <!
(4%/%;
&/(F (%/. %=
3.=)%/
23% -4/% 1
+%/ 0 .% .
)
% %/
= + / 3% &%%/%%/
3%0/ 33 4= (% G / &
C% %/% / (
%/ /( =.
) %/- .)+%0 % 1
%
.
&/ 4
&(% .
( 23%-4/
,
4 (.
0+=(%%/
.%% .=)
%/% (&/& (%0 %%(% .=)/ %/ & 0 %/ (%+ )
%/% ./
%/& 4 4.
% E*++?6=) 1
+.
%F (%&
4.
%( % %. 3% %%/ /.
%0 0
= %/ &
+%/ %/% (33
. ;(.4 % &>(%% (% . .33 =
& %. .
4 .=
.( 33 &%
..(& . .&
/ %=
= % (%)3
%) 4%)%/ %/%0 (.;( %)%
% =)%/ (% &
%
;( .&% (.
<
.( <
.=
+ % (. %%
3 .%/ .
A # -##-!B A # -##-!B A # -##-!B A # -##-!B ()*+, ()*+, ()*+, ()*+, # # # # - 5 - 5 - 5 - 5 '
'
'
'
G/ F4?
.H $
? G/ %= H $
?