Ishwar And ANR v. National Insurance Company And ANR

  
     

  

 !! ""## $ # %!&'"(! )"   ! "#" $%&%'(

$"")'%()*+,-)(% $(.%)//%00)'(&  *++,-.- /0.!# .1&1&)')//%)0/$% %$$%+23(.%+$1,%$)'+4'%$ 25& 2%)$1'6  $%61&($)(1'    7 879 99  :.%$%1') (%$  +%&-$12%+  )&  (.%

%'+1'6,%.1-0% ;)6)1'&((.%)4)$++)(%+ <

8/)&&%+23(.% ($ --1+%'(0)1=&$125')0*>)$')0:

$&.$(* (.%$125')0 ;.%)//%)01& )--=/)'1%+23)')//01-)(1' 10%+5'+%$"%-(1'8 (.%!1=1()(1'-(*

?&%%@1'6-'+')(1' +%0)3  +)3&1' 101'6(.%/$%&%'()//%)0 .% )-(&1'2$1% )$%(.)()=($,%.1-50)$)--1+%'((@/0)-% ' ?8

.%)--1+%'(4)&$%&50( $)&.)'+'%6016%'(+$1,1'6 (.%

%'+1'6,%.1-0%.%

%'+1'6,%.1-0%&($5-@)6)1'&()25

)0*)&)$%&50( 1(+1%+)((.%&/(
 +)(%+ ?8

4)&$%61&(%$%+)(01-% "()(1''+$1.%

%'+1'6,%.1-0%4)&4'%+23&4)0/%$)(1,% $)'&/$("-1%(3 -0)1=/%(1(1'4)& 10%+&%%@1'6-=/%'&)(1' $+%)(.

(.%25

)0.%$125')0)4)$+%+)&5= 
8*

A7)0'641(.1'(%$%&(

 B98C/%$)''5=.%1'&5$%$4)&.%0+01)20%(/)3(.%-=/%'&)(1'25( 4)&6$)'(%+$%-,%$3$16.(& .%)//%)0.)&2%%' 10%+)0=&() (%$=$%(.)'7 3%)$&

(.%/)&&1'6  (.%)4)$+ .%'03 %D/0)')(1' 

%$%+ 1& (.)( 4.%'

&5=='&1'(.%%D%-5(1'/$-%%+1'6&4%$%$%-%1,%+1'

<*(.%$%0%,)'( /)/%$&4%$%-00%-(%+)'+(.%)//%)04)& 10%+(.)& 5$(.%$2%%'%D/0)1'%+ (.)((.%-5'&%0'%,%$(0+(.%)//%00)'(&)25((.%$%-,%$3$16.(& .%  %D/0)')(1'  /5(  $(.  1&  '(  &)(1& )-($3  (  450+  2% /%$(1'%'(('(%.%$%(.)(4'%$ (.%

%'+1'6,%.1-0%1&)-/%$)(1,% &-1%(3*%'6)6%+1'(.%25&1'%&& ($)'&/$()(1'.%-0)1=/%(1(1'4)& +503-'(%&(%+23(.%+$1,%$)'+(.%4'%$ (.%

%'+1'6,%.1-0%.% )//01-)'($%=)1'%+1'&05=2%$ $7 3%)$&(-)''(2%%D/%-(%+ $=) -/%$)(1,%&-1%(3(.)(1(450+'(.),%()@%'-/3 (.%)4)$+ $=1(& -5'&%0(.)&'(2%%'=%'(1'%+(.)(%,%') (%$/)&&1'6 (.%)4)$+1'

"%/(%=2%$*

84.%'(.%4'%$)'+(.%+$1,%$)//$)-.%+(.%-5'&%0 +%()10& (.%-5'&%0.),%2%%'=%'(1'%+ 012%$)0,1%41&(2%()@%'4.%$%(.%/%$1+ +%0)31&&.$( 25()&($1-(,1%41&(2%()@%'4.%$%(.%+%0)31&1'$+1')(%.%"5/$%=% 5$(1'
 

         

     

!" #

$!%*.%0+)&5'+%$7
      

       



 

   

     

 

         





   

                   

      

   



  

    





       

   

 

!

    " 

# 

$ %  &

'()*   

   

 

    

            

          

 





 + 

   

   

          



  

      

 "
5$(.%$(.%"5/$%=%5$(1'&' ( & " )* +  ,- ,. (.  / &    

0 1" #

$$0 .)&.%0+)&5'+%$
%     + 



       

    

   

 

    





  

     

   

  

  ,          

    ,- ,

 

    .

   " (.)&2%%'.%0+(.)(%D/0)')(1' E&5

1-1%'(-)5&%F4100 +%/%'+5/'(.% )-(& (.%-)&% '&)(1& )-($3%D/0)')(1'1&-=1'6

$(.*+%0)3&.50+'(2%-'+'%+ '  (.%  /$%&%'(  -)&%*  )  =)D1=    $=)'  0)4  &52&%G5%'(03 %=2$)-%+23%G51(3/  01

-   2#    4.1-.&)3&(.%0)4-=%&((.%)&&1&()'-% (.&%4.)$%,1610)'(41(.

(.%1$$16.(&*)'+'((.&%4.&0%%/'(.%1$$16.(&)//01%& .%)//01-)'(4)&'(,1610)'(1'/5$&51'6.1&$%=%+1%&

  6$5'+1&=)+% $-'+'1'6(.%+%0)3 .%)//01-)(1'1&+1&=1&&%+)'+)&)$%&50(*(.%)//%)01&)0& +1&=1&&%+2%1'6(1=%2)$$%+ *++,-.- / .1/+

8

=@ H.%(.%$&/%)@1'6A$%)&'%+

%&A H.%(.%$$%/$()20%

%&A