High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/27804/2022allowed

Manish Chaudhary v. Serious Fraud Investigation Office

2023-03-29Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

!"#$%&%&

"#"'#( !"#$)%&%&

$ *+,% - ,- ,, + **** !"

! !# -.#!

/"'!0123 % $ %

& '

& ( ")*)+,-. -/,*+,-.! &

*/"!*/"""!+--012!++1!3+/!+44 ' "!-.*3!15042!13"!55/!-51!551!55/!-54!-55!-5-04202 '

"! +,-4 -+,67 8 5,3! 5-1! 5-/!5+,!531!53/!51-!511"!515 ! & 9

! :

' $

% 8 ''& ' 6 & ' ;"

6 < = 0 ! > ?2 ' ' '

'& ' -,,8 % 8 @ 6 '

- 2 - ' ' 8 < 8

< ' ,1--+,-- +.,.+,-+ ( & '

'! ')&

$ ' & '

& 551 '

"! +,-4 ' $

551 '

"!+,-48'&8 -+,.+,-4 $

14 '

"! +,-4 */6" '

"! -.*3 '

%) ' 6 % 8'

+0&2 '

0" @ 2

!-.1*!

> ? 8

8 8' ' ! ! ! #

6 &' ! & ' % "

7 < !

- 3 - 0 #2! '" <& 8

' '

8 -1,, 8 '" <8 1,"

& '

& ' 6

& '

) )@ '

& ! ' & ' & '

!& ) ' &' ) @ '

8 <

8 !

& +-+032 '

"!+,-4

!8 "

& &

5* < "! +,,+8 &% 8+-+032 '

"!+,-4

6C6

- 4 - 8

8 & B

!88

8 !!

" # $ %

&&!

& D

" %

& '

& ! & "

+- D8 !

8 &

& 8$ '

& &

8 8

' 8 '

"8 E )

8 8

D8 !

& % '

8 54/

7 8 &B

!% 8 ' ' 8 66 '

'8 % 8 '

+0&2 '

0" @ 2

! -.1* $ 8

> ? '

- 5 - !'& B '

! !

! '

& '

! &

&' ! ' !

& G &

& & '

) )@ '

' +,,*+,-1D8 !!

& & '

& &

6 ' '

!8 8

&& ! & '

! 8

8 $

' '

6&& $

88D! 8 !

" & &! F

- 6 - 8

! '

8 8 7 8

& &'%' &

8 & && ' !8B'

% '

"! +,-4! ' 6 <" "! 8 ! ' ;

'=! ; ' = ;

F = F '

'!8

& '

$ '

"! '

& ' <" " 8 8 &

' $ '8& ' ' '!8

8 8'!&

' $

- 7 - ' &

$&!

8&& & ' &

& ( )

!! * %

" + * , " %-' .!

/ +

0 1!

"2 "

! &

+*,/+,++!

+*,/+,++8 6

! !

# ! 8

+-+032 '

"!+,-4

+3-,+,+-

3 !4! ""1 ' 5 * 677- "% '

+3-,+,+-

! 8 '

& 8

&! '

- 8 - ' ' 8 ' &

' 8

& ' ' ! 8

& "' ! !'

! ''

& F

!& 8

& & F 8

! !8

&& 8 6 8

& &

8 $

"!! 5 * &,, "% -3,/+,+-8&

E&A6&& %

' 6 8 ! 6 $% % &

% %

% !%

- 9 - ' ( )

* %

% # !

. $ !

! # " !4! 188 1! * %-, "% 8 1 5

!! * (5 * &% % " %!

# # $88 * -&797 +,,4+,+48 F 8

& 8 8&

& & 8! F

& & F '

6 9'

(35,+,++

-/,5+,++ & & ; + ,-. / ' 0+ % %

- 10 - %

= " 6 !' ! " 8

-/-++,++ 8

& !&

<0 2(-+155+,++8 8 8

-4,-+,+4 6 ' $ 6 &!

! 8 6 02 "

-*-,+,-. 02

& % D &

-1-++,+, 02 & % &

,1,++,++ 8 & '

H' & ' H

8 H ' %&

8 ! H % 8

! % '

&!8

8H '

& !

- 11 -

&! "

! 8 $ &

&! ! &

& & )

& B 8!!8

88'

+.,4+,+4 1 -.#!

/"'!012

'!0

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No