← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/1528/2007dismissed

National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Sanjeev Kumar @ Sanjay And ORS.

2025-07-09Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma15 pages

 

          

 

 ! "#

$% &'( )*' (("" +% $

, -./$'%0, -) 1%

 2 ( 

        3%

% ,$.%4 5.%1((""   % /% +%, 615.%% (  !  ! %% (  !       81  " 9%1 &$%%%%%"1:,("

 %. ;%1! <* = *% $

"%1(%   11'%

 9%%%  & " & %1 &$%5 51 (% ((" "6

4%  

>41%9)1"'

(  "  9)  1  % (  "'   4  ""4     

$%  '( )4 1""9"()'(





!!"

81(% (("1 9 "9)1(("" #

$%  &'( )1  6.1"6

14%  

> (

 1"'( $ %, >>1% &"'

8%9$ "5? 1%($%  % 1%5@18%9$ "@541% 51* 8%9$ "

""41"'( "9)1"'  1"1#

$%  &'( )"9"()'(



     81  .%'  '    1  "'  (  %  1  

  

5"' 4 %. 6+ 9% 6%6 % ! 3A 4 (% 6%'3164%&1994"5,$%-, 615B 4 , 61 ,"/$%" CB/$%4%%."" 6 1 + 9$ 541 1)4% 1%  %'+""6$D1-%5 19$ 9" 6 6&8E9% 6%6 % ! &? F  G9 %.  % 1  6"6 '

%541$9"4 6 )1% '%'

? 1%($%   ( 41 1%.%1 9$ 4 .% D 621% &%  1(%

59%$611 9$ 5 14% 6  1%  %$D6

1+ 1"'   % $" '(5 1  (

6%  %."" 6    1  + $     -$% 5   "$ 6  1 "'  81 )1%.%19$ 4 %." , D1,

,%4 , 615%  /1$%($%541"4)%'1 (5 %". 619$ 1 (511 D("$ % % 1  6"6 %. 6, D1, 61%.%19$ &"' , -./$'%" , -) 1% -$%4% "") 1.% !$% 6?'9$1)4%%%%&."? ("51"($%5%'

41%1)19 %%%&? ("5*$1   1 ' ,$%-, 615#2!   

$ %,

 5 5 5 G #3&%6% 61 4 %6 %3", 51"($% E(     1  "'  ( 5  ((""   ((%      1"'( 9)" 64% %(") ) 61$' '(

 H %'1("  1(% 5 1 8%9$ " %'1

 ""4 6

$

    

       

        

   

   



  

              

!  "#$%$&'()!

 * 

  

   '()!

+ 

, *  

  



 

 -'()! .      

         $

  

 -

 '()!

/

      

 *    

 * '()! 0



   * 

*'()! &!  %D 6 

% 1("  1.  %%51"% 8%9$ "4%'(

 1"'

$%1%51* 8%9$ "1 1"1#

$% &'( )"9"()1 '(

 ? 51(% (("

    

   > *%   $

"  %  1  (("" I#

$%   &'( ) .1' ")   11*% 8%9$ "%%   6"9") $( 1#

$% &'( )()'(

 1"'  #

$9'11#

$% &'( )51%$616 . 5 9" 1 11%. 6" ($%(%")

$ 1 '1% (   %.%5, D1, 6154 D   1. )%% (  %%411"  6$1%) 81%%51(%) 1(% (("

9""4 "9")

$% '( )()1'(

 9

G

  3% %5"% $

"%% (  ! 4 %1   69$ 5 $9' 11#

$% &'( )1 9 %61")1" "9"()'(

 ? $9' 14  $'9 $( 1 #

$% &'( ) 9" 111

$% D% 9"%  $   4 6"6 41" '(") 6 1 %.%  ? $%1%    11(("" H

$% '( )" 1%61  9$% 5

J$ ")51(%) % '

"1(% (("

#1.1%"% $

"%1(%  (%$ 1 41"%% 81%". (% 1((%9D %(%$ $ %  .1    -

  

 

23!$&  -4

5

 -  6

            

      -

 

  

,

   1

"

-3 

!$*

 5

  -6

 

!$6 *

  "    4

7  85

9 -% 

 /:    1



- *  1



-      !$*

 

*   23!$            

    

  

   

 

    *      

  

    

  

   

  



&;.08*   -  :  *   





    *  - 1

"

- 

 ,  *  

 *   







 







  

-   

- 

-            



*  -

  

 *   

 

 - 0( 

         



%     *   



 



     

 



-*

-

 



 



 



-* , * 

  

 

 

 

*

  *  -

 * * , 





       

 *     <

 1

"

-5 =9

"

>0$+?)5!$.& 5 "

  =  (   1

  "  5  >0$+?  )

 5 * ! $&.



=:( 1

"

-  

>0$+?)5!$/

 

) 

= ) 

 

0>.?!"!>"

?00 &  1    

-                

"

-

       -    :   

    *



     <

  1  1

  "

-  5  =  9

"

  > ?  5   "

  > ? 

 

  > ? 



) 

> ?

  * 

     



 *  

 

     - *  



"

-   

- *    * 





  1



-  *                    *   



-  

-



1     1



-   * *



 5

  - 

 











 

#*    *    -

>   5

  -

 



 -  *    1



-*

-    



%  7

":<

 -



 

   ** 



 *     *(  

  1

"

-    *       

  

      

  

   

 

   

-

* 

  - 

   



  

$%  7

":<1



-     

* 

 



 

 -



- 



:   

- 

E(    %$"  (%$ "    1  %%5      .   1 2 (  ! 5&1 6%18%

(%E %D 6 &8E51 66 2 (  ! 5, D1, 615 %.%%$ %D 6%J$ $ "6  81.  %%5(%$"%")1 ' ), D1 , 61 2K5 9" 1 1(%%1 (( ' 51&8E $ %. 6  .%1.")1 %. 6"  81%". (% 1 (  %  ""4

@1        -        *     "

 :

  < 

  

  ;;  1     

 

3       1       

   

  

*     * -  

 -9 -

 -





    -   -     * -  3 

 -    ":<A  81 &$% 

$ 1"6"(  141"1

 

$%%  "%  $%) $ %, G    1%+1" 5 5 16%$ 11%.% (

 ."%. 6" 51 $  9" 111

$%4 6$") 4"$"9%1(") 

%"L% % 9"%

.%) 61" % J$%")$( 1

$%%  A1 ')51 &$% 1

%.41

'(")% L( % 411%(% (.%.%(

 %. 6" 1((% 5 159." 

$9) '( $1%) 11%.% $")J$"(%1"

.1"%4111 9 6'(")  81"4 '(  9"6 $( 1'(")% $ %D     (    .%    1  "   41  1  

$ 26 "8%

(% 285$ "

1%% (%$'

  %  69"%

1 $9 1$1 )%.")1"  3" 6161%9$%  1

$% $"9%.%

%

 -$% 

 4$"  '$     '( 6    $ % 9"    '(%"9"6 5 ("") 19  )((% $ %

$ ( 81  %9(("  % 9"

5 1 9 "$.6"  G # 1(%  51%%"%")%" 1&8E1 .%%. 6" , D1, 611'1 (( '   $ 9"")6 $  $%1%'%51% '%" %%  $66 11%.%L19 '(  1 $ %11 &8E1 )% $91$1 )1 "   ,6  ")5  1  (("" H

$%   '( ) 1  " 

   1%619$% (%. 6 ) 6"6  1(%1&8E

1(%

'(") 61 %.% 81% .   11&8E1D 4"65$"%

%$.511" 4

D% ." >  ? <9",$(%'&$%  



            !""#$%!1 1"1 14 %1.1" L(.%)1%. 6 D""

  %$  1"

6$1%).%)16 $

1%. 6" 9% ((  6%.% 81%%5 14 %  11%.%

'( %.1.1"5 L(%'14 %1%% .%)16 $

1%. 6" 

$1%.%

$%1%'%51 &$%5  -$6'  



> " &'& 

        41"%") 6 -$6' (L&$% 2 13", 61<  

$(% 1 "%)-$$(  '"%

$ 1"114 %1 .1" L(.%)%. 6 D""

  %$ "

$1%) .%)16 $

1%. 6" 9%'(") 6%.%1 %". L% 1 ' %(%$ $ %

;9  * 



$) *

 

 !$

    -

$     -  -

 

 B  

  4:(C



 

23$!

23! :

   *  &

    D$ @. *, *  

 *  

        7)

9     



 

  -) *

 >!?* 

   -

    

      

    

          

  4:(C 

 -



23!

23!

  





) *

      

       *  

-  

-       

  /  9 

     7       9                +           23!0    5

  9 -84:( !

    

        

      .+.8!8087)*  

 7

   

     

          

  

   

 

- 

    * 

-

-

- 

01  *              (       # E   "

D *1 9

"= 

>+?! "

! >"

?&0

*  F

 

 - 

-

   *

 * * 

 

*

    /7= 9 ; - *

-  - * 

                9   

 -  * * 

 :



-     

   

, *  - 

*  

  ,  * 1  *

  

-

        -

 

  - 

    

      

  

-    5   

   : 

-

     -

 9:

  

   - 

-

#*    : 

*  





-



  

  -      *     *   *       #* *    

   *  -  

-  -



   ,  

  

  - ,  -  1*



*

-       - 

 -   

- &1

      *  



-*  

    

      *  

-  

-        1    -          $3 

          *        8

  

 

 

- -            ,  

     *      

 

  

 *  * 

* 

*  

#

  

    

-       23!0     

   .+.8!8087)  *       -    

 -84:(!



  7

  ) *

      !     -            -  7

 

            )C$+98+&0;   

  

   3 

  



     

 

 >7

?4:(!

 >7 - ) ?#   

 -   !

  5

  9 -              

 



     7



*



 



 *  

 

 - 

  

   - -     : *  3    



, * * , 

 

 

-

- #

 - 

23!

23!*   4:(C 

*

     23!89

23!89  

 *

1  *    

D *  9

  "  =     > ?     *



 



  

23!.   -

 7

7     

 *    

 -5

9 -!

>7)?9   23!0 

 *   -

5

9 -

      

  

    

     :   

    ) *

    





   

-

  

-

      -23!/* 



    

1  *    - # E 9 3"

 , 



-

   



  

   -



9       

     -  ) *

   7

  *     

 *     >) *

 ?  -  >7

 E?

    * 7

 *

 >) *

  E? - 9 23

 !/

 -

 *

*      

  

-  : 

 

      

-

 -      

-8           

*  !  +8$  1         

- 

     

8   -



-

   -) *

   



 



-    >   ) *

  ?      

8   -  *     ) *

  ?    

   

       7

 

       -

  

  

 , 

  5

9 -!

>7)?



-  

     333333 +1    

    *     " , -  1   - 

 

*     ! +8$

  

 

 

 







 7

) *

 



1

"

-5C 

* *    

- 

   -     

-8     

 * 

*  -

* 

   



  ! ;G 

      

      HHA

G   $%1%51? <9",$(%'&$%  () ( ( 

   &( *$%" !

 ++1" $ %  @1 

 

- 

    .;>?> ?>

?

      



  * - ( 

 

   

C 

   - * 

 * 

- 

 , 9

*     *            *              

    :   -      1  

    

 

 *   

 

 

 -

  * , 

    :* 

 3   -  3  -

 

 

 * 

  - 

   #*  *      

  



- , *    -  

  -   *    * 

       - -  

 

-* 





      

 

 

  -: * 3



 *

I > ?1





 * *    -  

   

 -



 

 

*    



 





-   A # .41%6 6 $

   

411.4 D 9)1 &$%51  %%9)1"% % &"'

8%9$ "%4""% 5"6"") $ 5  ""% ) %% 

% 6")51(% (("  '

59 6. ) '%

 $%1%  #

$%   &'( )    %     9$%   1  $%%

1$"% ,$.%4 5.5($% $ %%

G (

 ! > 

9)1 &$%541 (%4 ))

%'1%(()1 -$6'  3  6(("

5 )5   (  !#!"!

    J   $%&'%&()*&+,-./0(&+)1.&2

&)01 $%&'%&((&*1('+34&

&)01