Mukhtiar Singh v. State Of Pb.




  
   



!"!

#$"!!% & #$ '(#)*'+ ,-"!"!.

*/0+&1+(*/0+ .....

& (/( && #$ /34 .....

#5



   

&)*. (+6/-52#'& -$# *.6..57-52#'& -$#&+

&. *(.0(+0(+-- /34.

.



  . 8 9 + &

+(4

 $  51(&&+ 3/51 &#$ '#2'&#5#5 #$( 5& 5 ".!:."!! ((   /51 - 

'  #/&-  #(+ /-  25  7+'+  &+  

&  +(  4

'#2'& 5$#+21'#&& 5&+ #$$ /(+4 /5  '&# %#$ '#&'(/1(5 (;'+#&# '/4(&'

('&- <=%>$#(+#&-?&+

'&?@5( 5&#/5 1#1##/( (# &$#

#5#$ A ;

5&# ;$ #$ (. -!!!B -5 $/&7+ #$&#$/&+ /5 1# 1##/( (# &$#

#5#$&+

#&+(.
&7((#5 &+&&+

#5/5 1# 4;&+

&5/12 (&1&#-C/;5 &-  (+  4  ( & #$$  $#  &+  (/4(&&2  (  #$   (#  #( 5/ #+.

8"9  $;-  &+
 #. "  5& 5  "".!."!!"-   &&# /#7/5  '&# %#$&+ '&7( 1(& 5#&+  1&#(&+& #  "".!."!!"  .
.  4  1+-  $$'  
'+1  #$   &&#

 /#7 2 5( ' &$#&#&#&+ '&&+&&+

&( ';1 #

;+/(0&+ &/'04 1 1(&&#/4  ="!!, 5('#1$#/56(+&#( &+ ( &+ 21 (5 &/'07('#1&#21 &+.

;1/ #&+ $#&# /CC 7(   '#5 5 5  5( &'+ 5 &# &+ (&&#- # &+  4(( 7+ #$ 
 7(   1(&

5.  .
 4  1+  #17&+  $ #7 

#$$'(  ( 5  045      '+#  451 -  6+5  +  5 $#&#7(( &&#+3&6/ > @7&+&+ C/ (&&#2

&&+ #&.&4#/&<.!!..-&+ &/'0' $#5(5 .
&7( (1 5&#(&# .
&7(4 152 4;&+

&5+(5 &&;7( $ 5. +3&6/12 +(&#5/'&#&#&+

&5 &#5+&+&( '+#$&+ &/'0(&#4 '#5/'& 5(&7((/(

5&+& + 7(';1'#&'((/4(&'

.+

&7($/&+ (0 5$+

& 5(&#1 &&+ '+'#5/'& 5&+ #$;#&+ 1D && #$$'

#*1(&& 4/&&+

&

#( 5'#$5 / #+.+

'#( &(&& &7( 5/'

5&#7&1.+ '+#$&+ &/'07( ' 5#/&4/&#'&1&' 7( 5.#7 -&+

#$ +3&6/-&+

&5 5('#(/ (&&

E+4& &#&+ '&&+&+ +('#'

 5&+ #

;+/(0&+ &;

'+4 #$&+ '#5 &#$&+ 5 &0#$&+ &/'07+'+7(+(

E'/(2 0#7 5'1 &&+ ( 5.#( C/ &;

/(/'

5('#(/ (&& &-&+

&#

5&+ '/ 7&+ +  #$  7+'+ 5&#&+ ;#$ ! '0 &(#$ #

;(&7.7# (  (7 1+1"%!1 '+7

& 55&+ 1 #

;

(&77 1+ 5<01%!!1.

& '

(#$4#&+&+ (  (5&+

4/07

 55(  57&+&+ 4 1 ((#65.

 +

' ( 7(

 55&+ '&1&' (7 &0 &# #(( ((#25

& ; #.+ &/'0#17&+&+

1(&&#'

&$'& 5(/'

'

&$'& 7 &0 &# #(( ((#.

+

(#( '+#$&+

&7((#'#5/'& 5.   &#$&+

#&  #$  &+  + '  E   5  '#'/(#  #$  2 (&1&#-  &+

'+7( 51(&&+

&.  &&##$'+&+

'#  (#$5#'/ &(7 (/

 5&#&+

&. $' '(

/5 ( '&# %#$&+ '&7(5 #/&&#7+'+&+

&  5 5#& 1/&;5' 5&. 89
(/

#&#$&( 1&#(-&+ #( '/&#+( E 5$2

7& (( ( ;1+ F -#(&4 /0+75 1+

F"-.
.41+ F-35 1+ F:5 +3& 6/ F%4 (5 ( #5/'15#'/ &; . 8:9 + (&& &#$&+

&/5 ( '&# .

..7( '#5 54/&+ +(#& 5;5 $ . 8%9 G5  3/51 &  #$  '#2'&#  5  #5   #$  (  5& ".!:."!!%&+

&7('#2'& 55( 5($# (5. 89 11 $# (53/51 &-&+ &

+(

 $ 

&. 8,9
+2 + 5  5'#/( $#&+ & (5

/( 5&+

'#5. 8=9 F+ ((1&+ 3/51 &#$&+ &#/&-&+(4

'#& 5 54;  5'#/( $#&+

&&+&#5

5 &7& (( +(4

3# 5&&+ & #$ ;.+

&7(#&'/(&#5;#$ 5(/'+''/(&'

(&+ ; 5 /(/'

#$  5('#(/  (&& &  4 '# (  '#( C/ &.  /&+ # -  &+

 

&(#&; '# 57&+&+ &/'0$#7+'+&+

'#&457( 5; 5.

8<9 &+ '#&;-7+ (/

#&1&+ 3/51 &#$&+   &#/&-&+(4

1/   5&& '#/( &+&&+ '#& ;4&#4( &+ '#2'&##&+ (&& &(#$&+ #$$'7& (( #;. /&+ -&+

&7(&+ 5

5'/(&#5;#$&+ &&+

& 7+  ;7( 5 /(/'

&#+(5('#(/ (&& 5$/&+ # &+

&7(7#01(52 #&+ &/'0$# 7+'+&+ '#&457( 5. 8 !9
&(#5#/4&&/ &+&&+ '( #( '/&#+1 (/ # 5

#(&##$#$$'7& (( (#;4/&&'#&4 '#(&/ 5( ''/(&'

&#5(4  &+ 2 (##$&+ #( '/&# & &;.+

(# #2(##$77+'+ C/ (&+ #$5

5 &7& ((& & #$( '+#$&+ (/(

'&.+ 5

#(&##$&+ #$$'7& (( '#&4 2 57&+5(&/(& ;4 '/( #$#$$'(&&/(#$&+

7& (( (-/ ((5/&&+  '#1 &1#/5(&+ $#.*# #2 &(

11&+ '#((

E&##$
41+ F&+&+ 5

$$#&(&#3# /4'7& ((4/&## 7(71&#3#&+ &;.

&(&& #$'###4( 2&#&+&&+ (1  /'&'

#&+

&#$&+

#  #&&#3#2 (&1&##$&+ '( &#2#5 &;#$# ;(/'+#&+  (#.;#(& &'+#$1&#-&'4 (5&+&&+

'( #( '/&#(4 &#4 5(4  5(# ;#&+ ('# &+&& +1 (/ #&+ 5

#(&##$#$$'7& (( (#;.
  

 

 !"

 # #$"$%& '"( )*)*+,-
+
!".-/01 &+(4

+ 54;&+ #?4 / #/&#$
5($##7()

H :.

/&+ - & (  '#& 5 5  4;   5  ( # '#/(  

1$#&+

&&+&#5

5 &7& ((7(

 

E 5-  5 &  &+  $'&  &+ ;  7  24 . 
  &+( 15-&(&#4 #&'

5$#&+ 5

#(&##$ 2I-  5  #(&4  > @-  5/1  &+  '#/(  #$  '#((

E&#-  +(  (&& 5  &+&  $$#&(  7  5  &#  3# 5

5 &7& (( (-4/&# 7 24 .+ 

$'&&+&&+ '( #( '/&#(4( 5#&+

#$#$$'7& (( (-5# (#& &+&( (+#/5#&4

 5. %.

+ 3/51 &&+ '( #$
 

   

  

  !   5  #  4;  &+  '#/(   $#  &+   #5 &&  (# (/

#&(  &+  '(  #$  &+ #( '/&#. 
  &+  $# (5 3/51 &-  &+(  #/&  +(  + 5  &+&   ;  4 '/(

#( '/&#  55  #&  E  ;  5

5 &  7& ((- 7#/5#& ((; 5&#'#'/(#&+&''/( 57( $( ; '& 5.+ #$#$$'7& (( ('#& 5(&/(& 555(4  5- ;#''#/&#$&+  #$$'(&&/(.
&+ '( #$  "

# $% 

&' 

(  

 

(&7(+ 5(/5 )

H
&  (    '+' #&# &+&  '&#(  #$ &+

$$'

-(+#/54

#'+ 57&+&5(&/(&.
& (& #7&#(&& '1& (&&&/(&#&+

'&#(5&+ 5#'/ &(5 4;&+ .&;

& -&+ #/&('#&(&&7&+&+ (/ &#&+&   '#5(    /&/(&7#&+;.  (  

(/ &##$7-&+ (/ &#7#/54 &+

#&+ 7;#/5.+ #$$''&(#$&+ +2

   1/; 

$# 5  (    7( '   #$

(/ &#5 '#1D 5 4;&+ I 1(&/ J.

8 9
&;4 ' &/& 5+ &+&&+ &/'07(4 152 4;

&7+ &7((1 5&#(&# . ' &$#&#7( 2 &+&&+ 7 '#&'(/4(&'

4 1' 5&+ &/'0.#7 -& $(&(&'

#'&1&' 7( 55/1&+ '#/( #$

 #( '+./4( C/ &;-&+

&7(& #1& 55+ 5

5('#(/ (&& &- /(/'

7+ #$&+ ;+(4

 $# &;'+4 7&+&+ 5 &0#$&+ 2 +' . 8 "9 */'+  +(( +2 4

5 4;&+ 5. #/( $#&+



&  #  &+  (

'&  &+&  &+   (&  #$  &+  

&  7(  (/4( C/ &  &#  &+   '#51  #$  5('#(/  (&& &  5  (  (/'+  ;

;  5    /(/'

 #$  (5  5('#(/  (&& &  4 '# '#( C/ &5& .
&((1$'&&##& &+&&+

& 7(

+ 5 5 /(/'

' &$#&# 2 51(& +. 7(0

&/5  (&&(&+ '+#$&+ 2 +' 7(4 1 '#5/'& 5.*# #2 -&+ '/(&#5;5# (#& &+ '/(&#5;.
&+

&&+

&7((# 05#$(/2 '

5 (&&#&+

#2 &-&+(&#4 (/ 5&+&+ 7('/(&#5;5 ;4 '/(

$# (&+(4

 5&(/4( C/ &(&1 7#& 5 &+

5('#(/ (&& &5&+ ; 5 /(/'

&+ #$&#4

'#( C/ &5& .
&+( 15 $ '4 5 &#&+

2(# '+5 '(##$&+('#/& (2"#2
2" 3   # # $"$%&"

4""

)**5+,-
+
!".-60 7+ + +(4

5 5#7($##71)

H<.  +  C/ (&#  7+'+  ( (  (  7+   &+  5('#(/

(&& &5 4;&+ ''/( 55/1+(& #1&#7+ + 7( 3/5''/(&#5;(5((4  ( (&& &  5  4;   

(#  ''/( 5  #$  ;  #$$   '/(&#5;#$ #$$'

./(&#5;(#&5 $ 5 &+  #5 #$ #'

5/ #&+ 25 '&.+

& '/(&#5;5 (& #&(;#;#/(& (.
&(&/

&+&$&  ; (&&+ ('/(&#5;4/&#&2'

2 (.+

C/ (&#(7+ &+ ''/( 5'4 '#(5 5&#4  '/(&#5;&;&  7+ + +(#&4

$#;

  (& 54/&(& #1& $#&+ / #( #$ 2 (&1&#.  5;  $#&#  '#1  $#   ''/( 5

(#-7+#(4 &#4 $/

74 #

&#(/( '#./&$&+ $#&# 5(&#&+

5('#2 ;#$  2&$'&(&+&5('#2 ;('#(5 5&#4

1/&

&/&+#$$#&#5(5  2& 4; '&#",#$&+ '&.
$$#&#( 4 7+ & '# ($#

(#&+ '/(&#5;#$&+ -&+

( #1##5 (#7+;&(+#/5#&4 (#7+ &'# ($# ''/( 5

(#7+#(#&&+ '/(&#5;#$ 5- $# -  #&  /5   &+  $/  #$  .  +    & &##$&+ '&#2 ; #44;(&#0 $#&# $#''/( 5

(#7+'+ 5(&#5('#2 ;  2&

7+ &+

(#( '/(&#5;.(&& #$$'& / '+#$I+# 1+#/&
  

    +(& & 57#5 K'/(&#5;K  &#     &+&  K&+  '/(&#5;K  5# (  #& ((;     '/(&#5;  $&   $#   (&  5  &  (# '/5 (K(# $##$ (/2 '

5 (&'&## #2 &(#$&+

(#'#'

 .K
&7( $/&+ + 5&+& K+ 1/1 /( 5&+ '&#&+/( 5(&#&+

'/#/( (/& #44; & 5 5 &+&7+ (/'+ $#&#(12 4;''/( 5

(#-7+#(#& &+ K'/(&#5;K#$&+ -&7#&4 '#2 54;

'&#.#7 - &$#&+ 4#2 #;-  & &#  #$  &+ '&#  (

(- 
 &+0-  ' 

#/1+5&+&(&#0 $#&# 51&# 5('#2 ;    2&-    7+   &  '# (  $#   ''/( 5

(#7+#(&+ '/(&#5;#$&+ 5 &+/((/43 '&&# $/ . 5;$#&# '#1  $#    ''/( 5 

(#-  (  4  &#  4

$/ 74 #

(/( '#./&$ $#&# 5(&#&+ 5('#2 ;#$  2& $'&-&+&5('#2 ;('#(5 5&#4 1/&

#$

 &/&+#$&+ $#&#(+(4

 #& 5#/&  5;5+ (/'+$#&#(5  2& 4; '&#",.#7&+ '4 && 5#/4&-&+& $# +($# (&-(''/( 5

(#-7+#( & #71&#(/( '#1(&+- (4 &#4 $/ .+('#/&+( $# /&    75  & &&#  #  &+  7#5( K'/(&#5;K(/( 5 '&#",.

 <I+#

!<-&7(+ 54;2(# '+#$&+(#/& '#((&1#$+5I5#5(& -.&+&

'/(&#5;5# (#& ((; '/(&#5;$& $# (&5&+&&(#'/5 ((# $##$

(/2 '

5 (&'&##&+ #2 &(#$

(#'#'

 .

 %I+ !&7(+ 54;#&+  '+>45/ L55 1I-.-$##71
 1!<@&+&( (##(''/( 5#(/(

5

(#'# (&#&+

+5(#$ #$$'

-+ (-&+ 4( #$'  5/(&04 &#&+ '#&;-##1 & 4 &;5(&+ $# '/(&#5;7&+&+  1 #$  '&#( " 5 ",-  25  '&.  +

& &&#  '

5    &+  /1(  #  &+  7#5( K'/(&#5;K(

(&#4 0

17&+&+ &5 & &#  #$  '&# ",  5    &+  4(  #$  ;

$&#  #$  &+  7#5(  K'/(&#5;K-  &1  &  &# & &#$&  (&-
(

# (#$#5

&1 $#&+(& &&#.K !.2(# '+#$*5+; 5 (+1+#/&

 

  ! "#  $%&  +( (#575(&'&#4 &7

&+ 7#5'/(&#5;5 (& 5&+(4

+ 5&+&7+ 

(#(' 5&#&+

(&&#5(& #1& 5(''/( 5'# '&# 7&+&+ 2 (&1&##$' -+ /(&4 5

5&#4  '/(&#5;#$&+ 7+ + ((#& #1& 55# $#   (&  (   ((;-  &  7(  + 5  $/&+   + 5  (

 $##7()

K+ (5(&'&#4 &7

'/(&#5;5 (&.

/(&#5;5# (#& $#'/(&#5;4/&'/5 ;(#&#$(/2 '

# (&'&## (&&4;&+

. 
 &'' 

     ) #     * ''+ ,-%.*& /  *&7(+ 5&+& 7#5K'/(&#5;K '&#",-25 '&5# #& $#'/(&#5;5&+ ''/( 5'4 (5 &#4 '/(&#5;7+ + (/5 (/2 '

.(2 77( (( 5''0/

  1% ,.1%21-3&  -5!  /

  -''+ %.%2-3&  1 
&+ +45'( &7( + 5&+&&+ 7#5K'/(&#5;K '&#",-25

'&5# (#& $#'/(&#5;4/&'/5 ((/'+ (&& #$$$(7+'+&+ ''/( 5'4 (5&# +2 '# &#&+ +5(#$ #$$'

#'4

(5&#+2 4

/5 (# (#&#$(/2 '

# (&'&#)25 1 + ,.
  / &  

    !

#   ,-  &/      ,-  2 &3 &+  I#5(+ (  '#(&/'& 5  &+ ((#  K'/(&#5;K  

'&#",-25 '&('##&1(# (&& #&+ $

5##$#2 &#$&+

(#7+ 4;

7#5#'&#.
&7(+ 5&+&&55#& '/(&#5;

$& $# (&.+ $##71#4( 2&#(#$&+  I#5(+ (& .", 

& &)

K((##(

(#((/(

5$#&+ '#((# #$#$$ -5&+ #$$'

'+1

2 (&1&#  '( (  (#  '#&#  #2   +( #2 &(-$#&+ / #( 2 (&1&#-&+

4( #$'  &#&+ '#&;-+ (# #1 &4 &;5;4 &0 &#4 '/(&#5;

7&+&+  1#$ '&#",.K "=.F+ 

(#(' 5&#&+ (&&#5( & #1& 5  (    ''/( 5    '# '&#  7&+  &+

 2 (&1&##$' -+ /(&4 5

&#4 &+

'/(&#5;#$&+ 7+ + ((#& #1& 55 #$# (&( ((;.K .+/(-&(

 &&+&5('#(/ (&& &E.

5

4;''/( 57+ + 7(3/5''/(&#5;&+ #/&

( (  &#  &+  #$$'(  & #1&1  +   5((4    .  F  5#  #&  $5  ;  1&;  & #1&1  &+  ''/( 5    '#/&  ( (  7&+  &+

((##$&+ *1(&&  /(/'

#$7+'+''/( +(  5  5('#(/  (&& &  7+'+   5  &#   ;  #$ '#&45#&+  E&5;$& &+ ''/( 57( ((;

&& *1(&& &#4  (& 5&+ &'(

(7 &.%! ..J 8 9
&+ &#$''/(&'

( ;4 '/( &+ $# (& #$&+

&+(4

 5(/4( C/ &&#&+ ;-'#&4

&  5&#4 ''/(&'

&# 5 &+ 5('#(/ (&& &5 4;&+



&5'#( C/ & ; 5$& + 7(

+ 5 54;

 /(/'

' &$#&#&#4 '#( C/ &.

8 :9 + (&'#& &#( 5#4 +$#$&+

&(&#&+

'&&+&&+

&(#&; '# 57&+&+ &/'0 7+'+&+ '#&457( 5.
&(#5#/4&&/ &+&&+

& 7(#&#7 #$&+ (52 +' 4/&&;4  &# 5+ &+&&+



&7(7#01(52 #&+ &/'0C/ (&#.* ;4 '/(

#7 #$&+ &/'0+(#&4

((#'& 55/12 (&1&#'#& &  5&#4 ''/(&'

&#5(4  &+ 2 (##$&+ #( '/&#

&'/;4 '/( &+

&7(521&+ &/'05&+ 2 (# 1(&+( 11&+ (&& &#$&+ 7& (( (&#&+ ;.

 8 %9
&+ '( +5&+ ;+(4

 54;
4 1+ F&+ #$35 1+ :5 +3& 1+ %.&+ 7& (( (+2 12 5 & 55(&($'&#;'#/& 7&+ 15&# ;5( C/ #$ &( 51&#&+ ;#$ '&1&' ($#&+ #(( ((##$&+

&.# 7-4( ##(&;(5 #/&1(&&+

&4;&+ #$$'(5# (#(5 #/&$#+($(  '&#.7& (( (&#&+ ;

+2 5

#( 5$;(&($'&#; 57&+ 15&#&+

& (

'&(#$&+ '( .+ 5

#(&#(  ('#$5 5$#( 251#/5$#$#/51&+ '#2'&##$&+

&.+ #( '/&# +((/''

(($/; #2 55 (&4(+ 5&+ 1/&#$&+

&4 ;#5 (+5#7#$; (#4 5#/4&. + &#/&+( '#5 5&+

$51(#$'#2'&##&+ 4((#$ 4 5(&($'&#;

(&4(+1&+ 1/&#$&+

&4 ;#5&+ (+5#7#$; (#4

5#/4&.+ 3/51 &#$'#2'&#-( '#5   5&#/&( #&+ 4((#$(&($'&#;5 4 5&+ ( 5# (#& (/$$ $#; 1&;# 1/&;7+'+;'$#;& $

4;&+(#/&.((/'+-&+ $51(#$'#2'&#-( '#5 & #/&- $$ 5. 8 9 F&+ 15&#C/&/#$( -&;4  &# 5+

&+&5 C/& '# (/& &#&+ 1/&#$&+

&+(4

 #( 55&+ ( 5# (#&'$#;& $ 4;&+(#/&. 8 ,9

#  &+  $# (5   (#(-  $51  #   &    &+ 

-&+ ( (5((( 5.

 8 =9 +

&(#45 ((;(&

(4 && 5$#

'&1+(

 (&(#&+&+ ;/5 1#&+  #( 5/ # +. "

72,0 )*)*   + -

































89