Sanjiv Jain v. Ut Of Chandigarh

  
 

 ! " #   
 "  "

$% %&'' () *
   +

%-'' '$ .%/0 +$ $% 
1

'2 /1 %3

 +

%-'' '$ .%/0 +$ $% 
1

'2 /1 %3

 ( 5!6 +
7 6" +

/%% $( / 8%1+1 /8 $%9/$1%/%-'' '$ 
     $'

%/'$7 0/9 $%9/$1%/%-'' '$ 
  /+
1 :9

'$'

: 0;:'& /%&0$/9 //%3

$

' %//'$/49
1

'2 /1

<1%$1%/$1%%3/$%/:& : %=3 3%/8 4;%

::=% $%%$1%,0 $>  ;%/%%//% $$1%%3/$%// $  <1%$1%/$1%,0 $10:

;%/%3/$% '

$1% '2%$>  

 6" +9 !4$1''

2:%,0 $9=':: '3%
   


 9':% ;4/%-'' '$+

  =%::    +

  $%9  $  $1%  ,0 $ 

 ? 9  3 %  ;4  $1%  :% /

'$'

:  +%'   0 2%9
1

'2 /19 '/8'

2$1%,0 $& -'&$'

@A 

 / %/    % &% 

  A 9  3 %  ;4 $1%  :% /

'&'

: 2'$/ $% $
:

9
1

'2 /19-'

%=1'&1$1%3/%% /%-'' '$=%/%& -'&$%

% &% $0

%/2'83/' 8%

0

%/(


 

 

   )*
4% /% &1   

  )**
4% /

'

% % &1 )*?
4% /

'

% % &1 )*@
4% /

'

% % &1 )?


4% /

'

% % &1

 !

4% /% &1 1%;/'% &$$1'& % /%$1 $  @ 9

9
:%/B$ 1B+'

2:

+0/%1+'

2:

$%9$B

&34/



 930/3/$% :43 % ;4 "'-''

!% &1$1'
0/$9& '$'

2 5;:%/0$'&%!

B1'1 0/

 5;:%/0$'&% 7%:9'


< A? AA 9 $$1%
34!/

&1$1'
0/$9/ 'C'

2% :$1%'21
0/$

   $1% 8% 1%& &%/ 
34!/

&1
:%/B

=

708 / .

 2$  03'&'0  $1 $  $1%   &08% $  '  /2%   % 

;/021$$1%8 $$%/$$1% $'&%$1% '$

$%2'$/ /
349 =1%/%+1/'0 '1+'

2:

$%9$:

$1% '$

$%2'$/ / 
34$1 $$1%&34/ %/'

D0%$' % $;%: 2$$1%8   @ 9+1/' 1B+'

2:

+1/'+

$%9

: 2='$1.', 4708 /

+0 1'/03$ & 8%$$1%'&%'

%2'$/ /0 '&'

:9=1%/%$1%$ $%8% $+

$%9 .', 4708 /

+0 1'/03$ =%/%/%&/ ;4$1%'

$%2'$/ / 0 '&'

: +

$%9'

1'$ $%8% $/%-% :% $1

$1%//2% &%/$''% &34/

*) 9/%:

$'

2$
< A? AA = :3/%3 /%  "0/'

2$1%'

-%$'2 $' 9'$& 8%0$$1 $+

$%9/2% $1%&34$1%/



 9/%:

$'

2$
< A? AA 

:/2% $1%&34/

*) 
%/$''% &34
< A? AA = ;$ 1=%-%/9$1%/'2'

:/2% &08% $&0:

$;%$/ &% 0$ $ = 0

$1 $+

$%9= '

$/08% :'

/2'

$1% &08% $'

&

'-

&%='$1+

 ,'-<

1=
:%/B

%$/%//%3%&$'-%:4$1%'21
0/$.', 4708 /

+0 1'/03$ =%/%$1%;% %'&'

/'%$1% /2%/4 "0/'

2$1%'

-%$'2 $' 9.', 4708 /

+0 1'/03$

) =%/% //%$%  @ +

$%9= //%$%

  A  

$  $1%  '

$

&%    +

4  9  $%9 

&830$%/= /%&-%/% 9/8=1'&1$1%/2% / %/= $43% +3%&'8% '2

$0/%

1

=/'$'

2$1% &&0% +

 ,'-<

1= 9
:%/B

%$/%//%3%&$'-%:4$1'
0/$9 =%/% :$ B%  $%//%&/ 2$1%%-'

&%9'C3%/ 9

8%:49 +0 1'/03$ 9.', 4708 /9+

 $%9+

 ,'-<

1= 9
:%/B

%$/%//%3%&$'-%:4$1'
0/$

9
:%/B$+1/' 1B+'

2:

$%9=%/%30$ $/'

: 1%:% / 0 '&'

: 2'$/ $% $
:

9
1

'2 /19

$%/$1%$/'

:9& -'&$% +

 $%9+

 ,'-<

1= 9
:%/B

%$/%//%3%&$'-%:4$1'
0/$0

%/ +%&$' )*)**)*?)*@)?


/%

='$1+%&$'  !


&D0'$$% $1%/%8 2 &&0% 9-'

%,0 $& -'&$'

@A  

 / %/    % &% 

  A    +%3 /

33% :  ':%  ;4  $1%    $1/%%  &&0%  =   '8'%  ;4  $1% :% /

'$'

:  +%'   0 2%9 
1

'2 /19  -'

%  ,0

 ?  !%/%$1'
0/$9 :4+

$%9

+

,'-

9C
:%/B$1'
0/$91 -%&8%;4= 4':'

2$1%%3 / /%-''  1 -%1% / $1%:% / &0 %:/$1%3 /$'%

1 -%



:& /%0::42 %$1/021$1%':%  ;%1 :+

$%9$1% :43/ 4%/'/ /% 0&$' '

$1%% &%// %/'

2$1%% &%$$1%3%/'

:/%

40

%/2 % $1%2/0

$1 $ 3%/$1%8% '& :/%&/

3/ 0&%  ;%/%  $1' 
0/$9  $1%    +

4  9  $%9  ' 0%/'

2  /8 2

2/% %   '  :%$  :%2  1   ;%% 830$ 1%/%/%9'$'3/ 4% $1 $1%;%% &% $$1%3%/' :/%

%/2 %;41'89=1'&1' 4% /9?8 $1

4 

A 9 1%1 :/%

40%/% /1'8' %% $'

$1 $$1%% &%+

$%9= 03%

;4$1'
0/$9-'

%/

)A  =%-%/9 ;%1 :+

9C
:%/B$1'
0/$9 '$1 ;%% -%1%8% $:4&

$1 $+

= $'

-:-%

$1%&/'8%1%/%' $1'

2 ':%$1=$1 $1%1

&1 /2% ':%='$11'8 1%8 $$%/1 ;%% $1/021:4%C 8'

;4;$1$1%
0/$;%:="0/'

2$1%'

D0'/4;%/%$1%'

$%2'$/ /9+

$%91 8

% $ $%8% $$1 $1%1

3 * $ +


:%/B/033:4'

2$1%&34/ %/ $1%/08  9 = 3 $ ,'-<

1= 9%$/%/$1'
0/$ $ 0/$1%/&8%0$$1 $+


:%/B1

;/021$$1%':%'

$1%

$%% $1%'21
0/$9 $ $'4$1%& &%/ 3 /$4

*

;0$$1%2% 0'

%$1%/ %/ -% &34/ %/=  %/$% '

$1%
0/$':% /8$1%$ $%8% $$1%='$ %%9'$' &:% /$1 $+

9%$/%/$1'
0/$9= '

-:-% '

$1% /2%/4

033:'%  /2% &349/=1'&18 %4= %C$/ &$%

/8$1%& &%/ ;% %'&'

/'%.', 4708 /

+0 1'/03$ 1%  ,0 $    ;$1  $1% 
0/$  ;%:=  /%  ;

%    0

/%  2=%-%/9 $ :4/





= /2% 9'$ = 0

$1 $

$1%//

*) = :/2% 1%  &$$1 $$1%/'2'

:/2% / %/&0:

$;%/%&-%/% /8$1%

&&0% ' 2/0

$1:

$1 $ /2%/4= &88'$$% $=   $1%3/ 0&$' /



 $1 $$1%
:%/B
34 !/

&1$1'
0/$;%& 8%03'&'0

$B$1%8 $$%/$$1% '$

$  %2'$/ /  
34 

 $1'  '  1=  $1%  '

D0'/4  $ /$% % &%9$1%/%' 2/0

$'

$%/%/%'

$1%& &0//% $'

2  &$9/%&/ ;4;$1$1%
0/$;%:= + / $1%& %+

'& &%/ 91%=  3%//8'

2  1'  0$'%    '&'

:    $1' 
0/$ 

 8

4  ':% /%8 '

1'&0$ 4 % '$&1% $1% 8% %3 /$8% $9=1'&1 = 1';/%

;0$$%/1%/%/%9 :% '% &4'$;%1= '

1'& %+ / $1%& %+

$%9'& &%/ 1%1

&88'$$% $1%/2%/4  &830$%/= /%&-%/% $1' $

&%9=1%/%$1%/2% / %/= 3/%3 /% $ :4 %/ %/

? = /2% 9;0$'$& 8%0$$1 $

$1%// %/= :/2% 1%/%/%9 %3'$%1' ':8% $

830$ $' :%$:%29  $ '

42/0

$/% 0&%$1%% &%
 %D0% $:49  $'

4  /&%  '

 ;$1  $1%  /%-''  

 $1%   8%  /%  &&/ 2:4

'8'%  6%$+

$%9;% //%$%

% $$$1% ':$0

%/2$1%/%8 23 /$$1%% &% 7 6" +  " ) * ,B