High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1911/2016disposed of

Shiv Dhiman v. Ut Of Chandigarh And ANR

2019-07-23Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal9 pages

!"

#"

%

'&( )*" +&" "& ,

!"

#"

%

'&( )*" +&" "& ,

!"

#"

%

'&( )*" +&" "& ,

- -

!"

#"

%

'&( )*" +&" "& ,

. .

!"

#"

%

'&( )*" +&" "& ,

!"

#"

%

'&( )*" +&" "& ,

/&!

+"

%

'&( !

)*" +&" "& ,

/&!

+"

%

'&( !

)*" +&" "& ,

/&!

+"

%

'&( !

)*" +&" "& ,

/&!

+"

%

'&( !

)*" +&" "& ,

/&!

+"

%

'&( !

)*" +&" "& ,

- %&

&0 , 1"

!&2# 3

" &%&*/3& 2# & ",

& 4 &5!6//

2# & ",

& 4 &!(7

1(, 2/%%)*" +&" &!(&8%&7"

2# &&,

08 &&

"// , 6& ( /& ",&

"#&&+($

/8 ( 3" "&

3&:8 :/3 &;( & : && &(

/8 &

// " 53#& :&

"& (

3(/:,,&,&

2 ,& " (, :8 "

3 $,

$/8<*& #4 & &(

(&%& # 6 $

< %0( /&%& # 6 $

(

.

( /

3&

":(

&/ #/,$

2,& &,

"&3 +&$

: 3

: " "& $,

"

(3(/+ ,(& " &/ "& .

. <,& &

$, 84 "&3&

( $, 83 + "( 8 $7 && +$

&,(& " &/ &

$, 8

$,

:/ 73

"&$

"

"#

8

. " +&"4 3+&

"#

/(& "

( (/ //

,&$ "

( "// : / :/ ,8 (:/ " &

$ 8<#

$(

& =, &8 "& $

" %(&(

& +&$

//+ - . < 3 , :8

$, 8 "

( $, 8:(

(

$, 8(/

",&&$

"+&$

5

( +& ,8(:/ "$(

#

<!$ $(

3, :(

"&+&$

+$(

";(3& #&

& /$(

<*" & ";( ,&

&

"$

3& " (& &(/

/

+ #

( &!

&3

"!

- "+

:/4 &($

2

4 $8: "&

( <%0( /&%& # 6 $

$" 3

& !"

"

/&!

+"";(3& ". &&3& (:8

( $, 3"& ";(&$(

<3

(

(/:8!"

#"

"

(" 7 ,/

"

$(

&,

$, 8 (/ //

,& ,&$ 4 3(& "&,/ :/ 7 ";(+ # (&

8"# : //

,&

": 7 "& &/ "#:

/ 6& & /(& ,,&

#

:8,& >(+$

-

//

( ,

&+( / 8 "#

$$

( &!

&3

"!

- +

:/4 &($

2

6& & /(&

&&

,& 38&

" = , &,& 8&

&

+&$ ";(& $(

<6& & /(& / && ";($(

// "//: "$(

$,

3"

""//:,8:/

,,/3&,&&&

&

(//8/ /

,,/2// ",,/"#: $ :8 "/& ?

&

2,,// (& # ,& >(+$

# . *" "3 "&# "# $(,&"&

+4

$ "&# ,

,,/

( &!

- &%&

3& &(

/8"/: /4 (& "& +

(&

",

8 "&# ,

+ $,&$

3&

+3&& # : 3 ",&

,(&(

3"& . < 3 , " &,

$, 853#& (& "&+&$

3

"&+& & &

,&,& 8

!

5 "/%&":8 "

(

#(&

$, 8

"&+

/ :

/

8 $ / @"

/$

// "&(+"2/ "(+": " ",&

&//+

( "(/ " "& 8"3 (& &;( & +

( 2,&!

- &% "

&&

3&

&

& / &(

/80

//8

"

3"

" :=&

&

3

"3// :/ ">(

/,&

,/ 6 (=$

+3" ,&

/83 ?

& >(+$

5 A:/ "!(,&$(& 3"

"": :&(+"

(&

4 " & &&

3,

/&+ ($:& ( &!

+

:/4 &($

2

5 A:/ "!(,&$(& &=$

+ ,&# !

- &%

. :&/8//

"& &

+&8 &/

+ &

&,&

< &

"&& && //

+3

" +&8

3(/&(

/8

//

,& +&8 :8 &

3(/:+

&( & =, &

"& " $ (

#/8!(:;(

/8 & >(+$

3//3:85 A:/

"!(,&$(&

!

"#$$

%&4 >(+$

5 A:/ !(,&$(& "/

:&& &(

/8 #& ( & $

/

&&(/

+/& &

2

+

$8: /&+&0

"5 A:/ "!(,&$(&

'( )*+,

- -"/=$

"& (

$& , " (/

/8"/

, (, "

3(/=&

"

&

3

"3//

/ ,&

,//3 " "&" /& ( /,,&

+ :"/

" &/ (, "& >(+$

, :8 5 A:/ !(,&$(&

./0 * 1

/## $$

&"

"(/ "3( (

/

8 3&

*"

(& " &(//8+ "&(+" & >(+$

+,/*&&!(,&4 "&

3&+&

,,& (

8:85 A:/ "!(,&$(& ,8

";($(

& / ,8$$(

:( &, 3 ,

#= , 8

&

,

,8*"

# & &$

,&

(& 5 A:/ "!(,&$(& / ( ",,83

" ,,& "

"&

&&

";(

;(

&/

+/ &

"

"// &( (

#/84 # 3 "& (

,,&

>(+$

&/ (, :8 "/& ( /& "&,

+,/*&&!(,&

"

"& >(+$

/ 5 A:/ "!(,&$(& "/ // &&

+(

+/ &

& & &

:&& &(

/8 6 ( 3& ,

(/ "

",&

4

,( // ";(&&(/ //++&$

: 3 ,&

3&, -. &&:( ( (/

/(

"+&$

"83&&;( & ,8 <4 /

,( $$(

3, : 7B" :"/

$, 8

&,,&

#

"$

$(

" : , "3 / ";( 3&

<3&+ # :8 "

(5

($

$(

< /&8, 3(&

",

8 &# ,

"&$(

. <": ,

( /,8$

- . <

($

< , *"&3 "& &

. < 3"

" " / : &, :8 "

<,

& 4 "

& ($

(& ",

"#$ :

$, ,8

/ " ,( $$(

": , "

(& " : &3 8& 3"

/ ",

& "

# /:/3

"

"

(& ",

>(

3(/:$

// 3"

"&

($:&"//&(

/8,&# ,

&(&& &:& "/& & /(& 3

$

" & ,

,8 >(+$

%

&"#/&8 :

&$= $($,& ,& & : 8&$,

&&:8 ";($(

$

" "& $

// "&# ,

& , 2// ",

+$ // (,,/

& ,

# 3 ":# >(+$

!

"

#$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0