High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/14449/2011allowed

Chiranji Lal & ORS v. Hvpnl & ORS

2015-05-26Mr. Justice Mahavir Singh Chauhan6 pages

!"# $ % & '$'% ()"* +,

$- *./ , 0% /%*./ ,

"# $% 2, ' , , # , '3 / 3', 4 , /%),#' 5 %5 655

, ) 7 9, 4 ,, 4 - (355*4/ *),#'44 - , 4 ( 3 # /3% / 3', 55 3(% %# ) , '3 2 4#&:;54 -##

<4 - 4 # 55 /( ) 55 ,, /# 4

( - , 4 - (3.

/4* &:;5

,,) 3##' ' 4% '4%#33 3 ,= , )9 % , , ) %554 - (3*## /4 # ,, 3' , 4 % ,,) # 2 , 4 ( > ## ' 4 (%# ?'

#, 4 4 -( 3*4# #') ,,)4 )3 2 )# #'%, )#'*5 :( 2%#+)*43#4 -(55#( 4 , 4 - 3#) ,25 :(4( ##3 #%( %# )4## #/*4/ *, 3( )2# %# % %3) , %4 -(4%'3 -%,

4 ,*## /4 (%# ? 2# %# &'

$()

( '*

/3 (%# ?*, /% /3 % 4 , ' 3 2 , / 3 (%# ? , /% /#%( 554##4 ,=, )#3#3

%4 , '3 2# %# , # () ,

( $ -.((

( '* :"

*$/ 0 $ ,

(/ $( -( ( "

( '*

@:2 *

,1 0 $ () ,

( '*

.' , *$2

( '$ 3 0 .>% = * # %# , .>% = *#% *4 3 , ##' #,,) , 4 ,% #' 3 , ' / 4 ) >, ' # 4%'

4%((' 2# %#

% .>% =7* , )/3' , :%, ( ;( * 4 3' ' / , ' ( ,,) ) !( & ':;# '5 3 /'6&:;56%# ))'#3 3,) & 2&63#:%, )% () , $ -.((

( '*3 /% =

! " # # !

$ ""%%! "

!%& # % '() 9 ,-: #'!- % 4 #'( %,/ %!%#, #),#'4 , )*# 3 % , /% / # , ) 344'*,##'>, 4%#3 4, )4#, / # , )%#3 ,', '

3 *4 , *, /- #) %( , /% / 5- % 5 * ) 3 /4 !%#, 3/A%#'* #3#3%%, /% / 55 , '3 / 4#&:;54 - (3#3#3%/4 %%3'5 <()&$"/4 !%#, 3/ .)#'* / ) .>% 4 %#3': '*&:;5 ),#') -##4 -

) 55 . # 4 %#* / .>% = * 4 3',#') -##4 - )554%(9 3, 4##'!55 A% -##)-)#(3# A% )%(3'

,9#3, %4 , /% ),#' * / , 4%#/3# # #)3', , 4 ,2 ,= , 4!3' , % , ( ( ,#?

( / 4 ,= , 2 , #%#)%3% )4 % ) ) , ,'

# % (& 4 (+ )

( -( '5(