High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/23466/2025allowed

Balram Alias Kesav Rana v. State Of Punjab And Another

2025-09-24Mr. Justice Sanjay Vashisth7 pages

! " #$$$%&'&'()%* "%*+,+ #$$$%+-().%)&+ #$$$%&'&'()%* "%*+,+ #$$$%+-().%)&

#$$$%&'&'()%* "%*+,+ #$$$%+-().%)&

! ! #$$$%&'&'()%* "%*+,+ #$$$%+-().%)& %/'.%.()0 0 2$ " *%+%)&0 *$345').%* 3)673)8.5(/3&%8 9(*&:%-%&'&'()%*+ ;') 8

3).

<$ *$3*%).%*!,=3*3)38.5(/3&%8

9(*&:%-%&'&'()%*;')

<$ *$3)>').%* ')6::,443*88,)>3?$ @@@@ " 8$

*3A%*') &:%+% -%&'&'()+89'4%.,).%* %/&'()

(9&:% 8 *$$$<8'+9(*6*3)&(93)&'/'-3&(*A?3'4 &(&:%-%&'&'()%*+87:(:35%?%%)?((B%.')3/*'=')34/3+%3*'+')6(,&(9 '*+& )9(*=3&'()%-(*&83+.%&3'4%.:%*%,).%*0 ($ 3&% %/&'();+< (4'/% &3&'() '+&*'/&

) $ $ 8 9(44(7')6(*.%*73+-3++%. ')

! ! "#$ % $&$#

'%(

) % * "% + ((

( % (( ( *,** ' ( %( ' -%- (

+ *("(*( .% % * *

( "

( ( (*(+ ( %( / ( +

( / ',',, &

0 1, -%(*% 2 - - ( 3% ( % ( ( % +

* ( % + (( ( %% % 4(*4 "( - % ( . 5- %( (

( % * (

* ( ' + (( ( .( %

(

(( "*+ ("% ( + * " %( / 6% + " " * *

( "

(*(+(% + (( ( % +

* #(* "(

) * (* ' # . ' $ 7&81 .+ ( ++ * %""% + 9 $ ' $%% $% & * ' 7% $( %& * + ++ * %""

+ # : &. ! % -%( % + (( ( ( * .( % (

(( -% 2( %

(( & *;

"%( % + ((

% ,( (( . *%( " ( %( ( % ( "*( "% & ( )""(* 6% + (( % ( % * (( (- $ *( "#$$ ( $ *(

/1/ ( (( ( * %+ (( -% %( +

+ % ;

(( & * / * * (" % +

)% -( - ( ""( ( ( * ( % "* % % +

&'+34+(.'*%/&%.&:3&?%9(*%4%35')6/(,)&*A3)A&'=%.,*')6 &*'348-%&'&'()%*7(,4.+%%B-*'(*-%*='++'()(9&:%(,*&$D )$ $ 89(44(7')6(*.%*73+-3++%.?A&:'+(,*&')

"#$ %#& %%#'&#&" %%"& %%(& %%)&

%*%+ %*# ,

&#&+ - .

%3*)%. /(,)+%4 9(* &:%-%&'&'()%*8 ')&%* 34'38 3*6,%+ &:3& )( +-%/'9'/ ')>,*A :3+ ?%%) 3&&*'?,&%. &( &:% -%&'&'()%*3)./(3//,+%.34*3=E!%+353)38:3+34*%3.A ?%%)6*3)&%./()/%++'()(93.')&%*'=?3'45'.%(*.%*.3&%. $ $ 8-3++%.')

8&'&4%.3+8C34*3= 34'3+!%+353)3 5$ &3&%(9,)>3?3).3)(&:%*D83).+3'. -%&'&'()'+)(7-(+&%.9(*'&+:%3*')6()

)+,--(*&(9:'+/()&%)&'()84%3*)%./(,)+%4:3+ -43/%.()*%/(*./(-A(9)%&6%)%*3&%.(*.%*.3&%.$ $ 8 ')(,*&&(.3A87:'/:'+&3B%)()*%/(*.8+,?>%/&&(344>,+& %F/%-&'()+$99'/%&(&36&:%+3=%3&3--*(-*'3&%-43/%$ ,*&:%*+,?='&+&:3&-%&'&'()%*'+*%3.A&(>(') ')5%+&'63&'()8'9-*(&%/&%.9*(=3**%+&$:,+8:%-*3A+9(*6*3)&

(9 /()/%++'() (9 3)&'/'-3&(*A ?3'4 &( &:% -%&'&'()%* ') &:% -*%+%)&/3+%$ (&'/%(9=(&'()$ $ )3.53)/%)(&'/%84%3*)%. &3&%/(,)+%4-,&+') 3--%3*3)/%()?%:349(9&:%*%+-().%)&G &3&%83).+%%B++(=% &'=% &( *%+-(). &( &:% +,?='++'()+ 3..*%++%. ?A 4%3*)%. /(,)+%4(--(+'&%839&%*+%%B')6')+&*,/&'()+$).8')/3+%(9 )%/%++'&A8&(9'4%+&3&,+*%-(*&?A5%*'9A')6&:%+,?='++'()+ 3..*%++%.?A&:%-%&'&'()%*H+/(,)+%4$ .>(,*)%.&(

)&:%=%3)7:'4%8&:%-%&'&'()%*'+.'*%/&%.&( >(')&:%')5%+&'63&'()3+3).7:%)*%I,'*%.&(.(+(?A&:%

)5%+&'63&')66%)/A$ )&:%%5%)&(9:'+3**%+&8&:%-%&'&'()%* +:344?%*%4%3+%.()3.')&%*'=?3'48+,?>%/&&(:'+9,*)'+:')6 ?3'4?().+&(&:%+3&'+93/&'()(9&:%**%+&')699'/%*$:% -%&'&'()%*+:34434+(?%3?'.%?A344&:%/().'&'()+43'..(7) ,).%* %/&'()

< *$$$<$ %+'.%+8'&'+.'*%/&%.&:3&-%&'&'()%*7(,4.:3). (5%* :'+ -3++-(*& &( &:% )5%+&'63&')66%)/A (* &( (,*& /()/%*)%.8 '9 :% -(++%++%+$ &:%*7'+%8 7(,4. +,?='& 3) 399'.35'&8 .'+/4(+')6 &:% 93/& &:3& :% .(%+ )(& -(++%++ 3)A -3++-(*&$

&'+34+(.'*%/&%.&:3&?%9(*%4%35')6/(,)&*A3)A &'=%.,*')6&*'348-%&'&'()%*7(,4.+%%B-*'(*-%*='++'()(9&:% (,*&$

(?%:%3*.34()67'&:

$D $ )

89(44(7')6(*.%*73+-3++%.?A&:'+(,*&')

3=%J36% (9%&'&'()%* ;+< ($ 3&% %/&'();+< (4'/% &3&'() '+&*'/& 3*=').%* ')6:E ()%A 3)3836%.

3?(,&

A%3*+

;

<8 ;<8 1 (9 !:3*3* 363*

%3*)%. /(,)+%4 9(* &:%-%&'&'()%*8 ')&%* 34'38 /()&%).+&:3&/(3//,+%.8)3=%4A3)'+:!,=3*E3)63 3)387:(73+3&&*'?,&%.3B'/B?4(7&(&:%')>,*%.,+:-').%* ')6:8:3+34*%3.A?%%)6*3)&%.&:%/()/%++'()(93)&'/'-3&(*A ?3'4?A&:'+(,*&85'.%(*.%*.3&%. $$ 8-3++%.')

;))%F,*%<$ )/()&*3+&8-%&'&'()%*'+ 344%6%.&(:35%6'5%)()4A3+43-?4(7()&:%93/%(9')>,*%.8

7:'/:/(**%+-().+&(')>,*A($ 3+=%)&'()%.3&+%*'34($

')&:%%.'/(%634%-(*&;<$(**%9%*%)/%8&:%+3'. ')>,*A'+*%-*(.,/%.3+,).%*0 CK 8 L L8L " L8"

D$ ,*&:%*+,?='&+&:3&(&:%*/(3//,+%.)3=%4A 34*3=34'3+!%+353)3;-%&'&'()%*')

< 3).3:'34E3:'-34;-%&'&'()%*') < :35% 34*%3.A ?%%) 6*3)&%. &:% /()/%++'() (9 ')&%*'= 3)&'/'-3&(*A?3'4?A&:'+(,*&85'.%(*.%*+.3&%.$ $ 3).$ $ 8*%+-%/&'5%4A83).+3'.-%&'&'()+3*%)(74'+&%. 9(*'&+:%3*')6() $ (,)+%49(*&:%-%&'&'()%*+,?='&+&:3&-%&'&'()%* '+ 34+( *%3.A &( >(') ')5%+&'63&'() 3). 9,44A /((-%*3&%8 '9 -*(&%/&%.9*(=3**%+&?A&:'+(,*&$ :,+8-*3A+9(*6*3)&(9 /()/%++'()(93)&'/'-3&(*A?3'4&(&:%-%&'&'()%*')&:%-*%+%)& /3+%$ (&'/%(9=(&'()$

) 3.53)/% )(&'/%8 *$ %%*3> 3.33)8 *$ 8,)>3?8-,&+')3--%3*3)/%()?%:349(9&:%*%+-().%)& G &3&%83).+%%B++(=%&'=%&(9'4%+&3&,+*%-(*&')&:%=3&&%*$ .>(,*)%.&( (?%:%3*.34()67'&:

)&:%=%3)7:'4%8&:%-%&'&'()%*'+.'*%/&%.&( >(')&:%')5%+&'63&'()3+3).7:%)*%I,'*%.&(.(+(?A&:%

< *$$$<$ 1$ %+'.%+8'&'+.'*%/&%.&:3&-%&'&'()%*7(,4.:3). (5%* :'+ -3++-(*& &( &:% )5%+&'63&')66%)/A (* &( (,*& /()/%*)%.8 '9 :% -(++%++%+$ &:%*7'+%8 7(,4. +,?='& 3) 399'.35'&8 .'+/4(+')6 &:% 93/& &:3& :% .(%+ )(& -(++%++ 3)A -3++-(*&$

&'+34+(.'*%/&%.&:3&?%9(*%4%35')6/(,)&*A3)A &'=%.,*')6&*'348-%&'&'()%*7(,4.+%%B-*'(*-%*='++'()(9&:% (,*&$D ) 89(44(7')6(*.%*73+-3++%.?A&:'+(,*&')

3=%J36% (9%&'&'()%* ;+< ($ 3&% %/&'();+< (4'/% &3&'() '+&*'/& )B,+:

3)3E )B,+:8 36%.3?(,&

A%3*+

;

<8 ;<8 1 (9 !:3*3* 363*

$ )&:%5%*A(,&+%&8/(,)+%49(*&:%-%&'&'()%* +,?='&+ &:3& 34=(+& +'='43*4A +'&,3&%. /(3//,+%. )3=%4A 3)'+:!,=3*34'3+3)633)387:(73+)(&3&&*'?,&%.3)A +-%/'9'/')>,*A8:3+34*%3.A?%%)6*3)&%.&:%/()/%++'()(9 ')&%*'= 3)&'/'-3&(*A ?3'4 ?A &:'+ (,*&8 5'.% (*.%* .3&%.

$$ 8 -3++%. ')

8 7:'/:

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

$ .>(,*)%.&( $

)&:%=%3)7:'4%8&:%-%&'&'()%*'+.'*%/&%.&( >(')&:%')5%+&'63&'()3+3).7:%)*%I,'*%.&(.(+(?A&:%

< *$$$<$

$ %+'.%+8'&'+.'*%/&%.&:3&-%&'&'()%*7(,4.:3). (5%* :'+ -3++-(*& &( &:% )5%+&'63&')66%)/A (* &( (,*& /()/%*)%.8 '9 :% -(++%++%+$ &:%*7'+%8 7(,4. +,?='& 3) 399'.35'&8 .'+/4(+')6 &:% 93/& &:3& :% .(%+ )(& -(++%++ 3)A -3++-(*&$ 1$

&'+34+(.'*%/&%.&:3&?%9(*%4%35')6/(,)&*A3)A &'=%.,*')6&*'348-%&'&'()%*7(,4.+%%B-*'(*-%*='++'()(9&:% (,*&$D

()&'),')6 &:%'* +,?='++'()+8 4%3*)%. /(,)+%4 9(* &:% -%&'&'()%*++,?='&&:3&')/(=-4'3)/%(9&:%(*.%*+.3&%.$ $ ;')

<8$ $ ;') <8

;')

< 3). ;')

-3++%.?A&:'+(,*&8-%&'&'()%*+:35%>(')%.&:%')5%+&'63&'()83).:35% 9,44A /((-%*3&%.$ :%*%9(*%8 &:%A -*3A 9(* /()9'*=3&'() (9 &:% +3'. ')&%*'=3)&'/'-3&(*A?3'4(*.%*+$ %3*)%. &3&% /(,)+%4 :3+ 9'4%. +&3&,+ *%-(*& .3&%.

$1$ ;')

<')&:%(,*&&(.3A3).&:%+3=%'+ &3B%)()*%/(*.$

%3*)%. &3&% /(,)+%4()')+&*,/&'()+8 /()9'*=+ &:% +3'. 35%*=%)&=3.%?A/(,)+%49(*&:%-%&'&'()%*+(9>(')')6&:%')5%+&'63&'() ()$ ?A&:%-%&'&'()%*+;')344&:%/3+%+<83).+,?='&+&:3&3+(9 )(78 /,+&(.'34')&%**(63&'()(9&:%-%&'&'()%*+ '+ )(&*%I,'*%.9(*&:% -,*-(+%(9')5%+&'63&'()$ 1$ %3*.4%3*)%./(,)+%49(*&:%-3*&'%+$

$ ')/%8-%&'&'()%*+:35%34*%3.A>(')%.&:%')5%+&'63&'()3). /,+&(.'34')&%**(63&'()'+)(=(*%*%I,'*%.M3.')&%*'=?3'4(*.%*+.3&%. $ $ ;')

<8$ $ ;')

;')

<3). ;')

<8 -3++%. ?A &:'+ (,*& 3*% :%*%?A =3.% 3?+(4,&%$ //(*.')64A8-*%+%)&-%&'&'()+3*%344(7%.$ (7%5%*8-%&'&'()%*++:344/()&'),%&(>(')&:%')5%+&'63&'() 3+3).7:%)*%I,'*%.&(.(+(3).3?'.%?A344&:%&%*=+3)./().'&'()+ 43'..(7),).%* %/&'()

//(*.')64A8-*%+%)&-%&'&'()++&3)..'+-(+%.(9$

-:(&(/(-A(9&:'+(*.%*?%-43/%.()&:%9'4%+(9(&:%* /())%/&%./3+%+$ ; " <

35'+:3 L:%&:%* -%3B')6K%3+()%.0

K L:%&:%*%-(*&3?4%0