← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/27845/2022allowed

Shinder Pal Singh And ANR. v. Serious Fraud Investigation Office

2023-03-29Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil11 pages

  

       

!

"#$%&'&'

#$#($) "#$%*&'&'   

         

     %  +,-& . -. -- , ****

   !

"       " 

 # "$  ./$"

0#("1234 & %   &

 

 ' (      )

 (  # *#+,+-./0   /1.,-./0"   ('    ,1",1"-//234"--3"5-1"-66#)

 "/0,5"37264"35"771"/73"773"771"/76"/77"/7/26424  #)

 " -./6   /-.8!   9  7.5" 7/3" 7/1"7-."753"751"73/"733"737 #"  (  

  " : 

) %         & 

  9   ))(     ) '   #8  '    ('  )  ;  #  #8  ' <= 2  " > # '?4   '

 )

  

   )     )

 )(   )   /..9 &  

9 @   #8 '    )

99 

- 2 -   

    ) 

  )    9   <      

   6: <    

    '61#$   ( 

 ) # # '<    '

 )"  

  )+(

  %  '



) '  /-3,   )+@  )! 

<      9 '

) + @  ) ! 

<  '  

')  )  '"     

    )

' 9      )  )  @  )!  < %         36   #)

 " -./6   ,18   #)

 " /0,5     )

' & +      ) '        8      & '   9  )     -2(4   #)

 2 @ 4 "/03,"     "9  > ? 9 

    9

  

9 )

   )  

'# '   "  "  

 # " $

   8()   "

(  

 ) &   !  <" 2#$4"   )##<('9 '   

- 3 -    ) )

   

 

 

     9 /3..  9 

 

 )##<9 

3. :   #)

       )

 (         

 "            (    )

' (' ' )      8 

 (  (  )

'+ +@     )

' ( "  )  

' (        )  #  ' ('  )

(   :   :  "(    

+ )()+ ('@   )

 9    <              9 "  ( -/-254#)

"-./6

   

  

  

 )# 

  

   "9  A# 

9 #



' 

 ( '    7, '<   " -..-9  ( &

9-/-254 #)

"-./6        ('         

      8B8    

)   9 

 9       (  '  A 

- 4 -  +9

('    "9

9

9     !!

"# $ % 

    &&"          

 C       

              &

 ' (      )

" '  

         ( '"

 ('   -/# C9 "     '9

(  ('   ('

9% )

      ( '        ( 99

 )  )   9#)

 9

  D +       99

 ) # C9 "            ' 

 ('  &  )  '"#  (   

9  761 # #! 9  (A 

'(' "&  9  )

  )  9       

8 8

 

)   "    

 "

 9 (  ' )   %# 

)9 ('           & ' 9  )     -2(4  #)

2  @ 4 " /03, % 9  > ?       

    )

- 5 -

 

' " ) (  A )

    

  E ' ('# "     "  " ) 

 

')



          (    )      

    

 

      

"      ' (      

   ( )  " ')  "



 F            (

  ' (   (  )

'+ +@     )

' )' -..,

-./3C9 "

"      

'   ))

')(  (   )

' 9 G  ('    (     8

')   (')

' '  "9   9 (  " (G)    

     "    9  

  

 

9  %

  '  ))   ('#  8(

%

& 

  

(   

         9

9C" 9  "        

        (  ("      

     

 '  E   '

 "

- 6 -   9   (

       (  &  ' " )  '  '(' 

 " 9 ( ')    )   9

9!9 (   ) &)    (  ' G  '"



' 9         ( 

(( )"9 A )     ('   

  2

4   &  #)

 " -./6"      )'8

     

< " 9    



"    ) ' 

  ;

)=" ;

'     )      

  =  ; 

    E    =  E  ') 

' 

   

 ' )# &  







    ) "9 ) ' 

'(  )  

 % #)

 "   )

          ) <  9 9  (      ( 

  

   )   %

'    )9

 (

  )   )      ) "9   

   "# 9

 

9 )"(   

) 

 %# 

      



)"

- 7 -  (  ( '  (          )

 ('  

      ( G   % ( "    

 9

((   

  

   (   ) '  (  

     

( (  )

!!    * %

"    +      * , " %-' .! 

/  +

0 1!

!

"2 "

1

!  (  )#  )       -,.1-.--"   ) #         9 G )

   2

4"   -,.1-.-- 

9 8   

        

                 

      

          

 

         

!  !

 "

 !     

         #  "9 



'-/-254 #)

"-./6

'  (  )# "9    )   -5/.-.-/

(' )#             3   !4!  ""1 ' 5     * 677- "% )    -5/.-.-/

('  )# "   9

 ) (G  9



- 8 -      

 

 ' ( "   

  

 ) '     

'   

 

 

   ) 

)  

9 )    ( 

 

 ' ( "



'  )  9   '  )     

 ) '"

  

')

      '   ( )   )       

'"  9 (G   (   9 (  )   ""

)

"  )

)

 9 (    

' E '  "(  9  (  (   E     9 "  "9 



9 (  ( '9

8   9 ('   ('   (       9

 % )#  !

!!

"!!   5   * &,, "%/5.1-.-/9 (    

 '    D 8(

  & ' )  

8  

'9      

"    8 $%   %         &         



    

  

%    %

- 9 -    

       %    !%                  '         (                      )

   

 

 *                 %          

      

       %        #  !

 . $ !   

!   #   "   !4! 188 1! * %-, "% 8 1 5 

!! *  (5 *  &% % " %"   ) #  (        

 #  #    $88  * -&797   -..6-.-69 E 9# 

9

9     9

(   

   (     (

 9"

 E

'

'  

  '

 (    E

' )         8  )



 )# # )



*57.-.--

 )#    /1.7-.--

(  

 (     ;          + ,-.    /  ' 0+           %   %     

    

- 10 -              %    %     

  &          

    =  8 " ) '" '



       /1/--.--  9  #  G 

 ' "(  )# < 2# 4*/-377-.--9

9       /6./-.-6      8  )   % 8   ( "  ('#  (' )# " 

9 8 24 

!

  ('#     /,/.-./0 24

 (   & C '

 ('   ) #      /3/--.-. 24

(  '

& (' )#     .3.--.--  9  (           

 )

H ) (   )   H   '    

'   9  

'H

 )  & ( #      ' 9 G

"

'H

& 9 "  

 

  "   & '    )    G    

 



"9   '9  H   ) '"  

' )

')

- 11 - (  

"#  9 

  (



"  

  

'"   

9 %   

 (   ( "   

" ('   

        ( (+   %  

(  

  ( A  9" "9

   



  9 

9)     

' -0.6-.-6 1  ./$"

0#("123

("1

1. Whether speaking/reasoned?

Yes/No

2. Whether reportable?

Yes/No