Ranbir Singh v. Kirna Devi And ORS
!"# $#%&'&()
!(+&,&(-.
//#00!(" 1#,'2'
3&,(! #1&!($".#,'
#'/($#("'
) 4 5 5
,#'#(") '1&(!'.!($0!6$1%!"#6
,".#!//#00!(" , $0!7.!6$1%!"#6
,,#'/($#("( , #.-!06$1%!"#6
,,#'/($#("( '3!80&6$1%!"#6
,,#'/($#("(* 56 ,!0 (".&''#%($!//#!06".# 009&(-,$#,.!$+##(/!''#$(
):
;.&'!//#!0.!'+##("!7#(2/2" "2,((".#,#<2#'"
".# 0#!,(#$ %2('#0 !//#!,&(- , ,#'/($#(" (6 ( ".# -,2($".!"&"'"2,(&'("0&7#0="%8#2/&(".#(,8!0 %2,'#6&"+#&(-0&'"#$!",( >? ".#,$&(!,=8"&(0&'" 5#!,(#$%2('#0'2+8&"'".!"!'!8!""#, !%"".#$&'/2"# .!'+##('#""0#$+#"9##(".#/!,"&#'&(8#$&!"&(/,%##$&(-'6 9&".".!",$#,.!1&(-+##(%.!00#(-#$+=,#'/($#("(1&$# &1&0&'%
::
*69.&%..9#1#,9!'$&'8&''#$ 1&$# !( ,$#, ".&' %2," %,$&(!"# #(%. $!"#$
>69&".".!",$#,&('2%.!//0&%!"&(.!1&(-+##( !
&,8#$+=".#2/,#8#2,"(
?
> $@2,(#$"
(".#!
,#'!&$%&,%28'"!(%#'6"+#'.9(&(".#2,-#(" 8"&(0&'"A $!=6 0#!,(#$ %2('#0 , ".# !//#00!("6 !' !0' , ,#'/($#("'(6!($*6$("$#(=".# !%"".!"!
"#,,#'/($#("( 3&,(! #1&.!$%.!00#(-#$".#'#""0#8#("!'9!'!,,&1#$!"+# ,#".# 0#!,(#$#$&!",&(".##$&!"&(!($(%&0&!"&(#(",# ".&'%2,"6".!"
!//0&%!"&(+#!,&(-
:
*9!'$&'8&''#$+=".&'%2,"
(
>6!
"#,9.&%.".!",$#,9!'%.!00#(-#$+# ,#".#2/,#8# 2,"+=9!= 5 (>
>6".!"/#"&"&(!0'.!1&(-+##( $&'8&''#$( ?
>+=".#2/,#8#2," .2-. 0#!,(#$ %2('#0 , ".# !//0&%!(" &( ".!" %!'#6 &# ,#'/($#("(6'2+8&"'".!"'.#.!'("+##(-&1#(! !&,$#!06(!"2,!00=6 9&". ".!" 8!""#, .!1&(- !0,#!$= +##( !$@2$&%!"#$ 2/( #!,0&#, &( ".# !
,#'!&$!//0&%!"&(6&"%!(("+#(9,#/#(#$ .!"+#&(-'6".#%8/,8&'#!,,&1#$!"+#"9##(".#/!,"&#' (?
*6"9.&%.,#'/($#("(&'!0''##("+#!'&-(!",=6920$ +#9.!"920$/,#1!&0!',#-!,$'".&'!//#!0!($".#'2&"&"'#0 &('"&"2"#$+= ".#!//#00!(" .#!//#00!(":/0!&("&
.!1&(-'2-."!B*".'.!,#2" !B*".
'.!,# ".#""!00!($8#!'2,&(- >7!(!0'!($C8!,0!' 200=$#'%,&+#$ &(".# &,'"/!,!-,!/. ".#&8/2-(#$@2$-8#(" ".#0#!,(#$$$&"&(!0 &1&0 2$-##(&, &1&'&(6 !-!$.!,&6!'/#,".#!
,#'!&$'#""0#8#("6
".#!//#00!("!-,##$"-&1#2/.&'%0!&8""9 !%,#'2" ".#'2&"0!($ &( !12, ,#'/($#("(' !($6&#!,@ !0!!($ &80! #1&69&".
.&8!0'-&1&(-2/.&'%0!&8"C7!(!0'!($8!,0!!'.!$!0,#!$=+##( '0$+=.&8",#'/($#("(*6&#!(+&,&(-. ('#<2#("0=6 ".&' !//#!0 &' !009#$ " ".# #D"#(" ".# !
,#'!&$'#""0#8#(",#!%.#$69&".".#/!,"&#'.#0$+2($+=".#"#,8' ".#,# .# $#%,## '.##" +# /,#/!,#$ !%%,$&(-0=6 9&". ".# '#""0#8#("B%8/,8&'# $!"#$ ?
*6 !,,&1#$ !" +# ,# ".# 0#!,(#$ #$&!",&(".##$&!"&(!($(%&0&!"&(#(",# ".&'%2,"6"+#8!$# !/!," ".#$#%,##'.##" .#/!,"&#'!,#0# ""+#!,".#&,9(%'"'
/7 E.#".#,'/#!7&(-B,#!'(#$ #'B E.#".#,#/,"!+0# #'B