Shibani Parti And Another v. State Of Haryana And Another
!
"#$ % & & '
( )**
!"#$%$
& '
# + ) #,-./0
*1234 032 5+ 4 +62
#"$"() #*+,*- .*$),/0 1-2*)"3#),"4")/)/("#$ #,*,*#0 # 50*#6*(* 5+ 4 +62
71* "# +/% ,"4")/)/("#$0863/9/(+),"4#"$"()4")/)/(02*$)%(1"# "2)/(
: 3 #0 $""; +#*() 3 *()/2/4*)#6 8*/9 /( 2*$" & 3
0#"+/$)"#"1*)9/2" )*)/(*#.*(*/)60/$)#/2)</(1 *#6*(*0 .,"#"/($33"(2"$2($)/)%)"10%(1"# "2)/($
0 *(1 3)," (1/*( "(*91"0: 0*#""=81/"1
(),"/($)*()8*/94")/)/(0),/$%#),*1(1*)"1 +#*()"1*1/()"#/=8*/9)),"4#"$"()4")/)/("#$."-"#0),"$*/1+#*()"1*1 /()"#/=8*/9)),"4#"$"()4")/)/("#$0.*$=*1"$%8>"2)0)),","#"/(*3)"# "?)#*2)"12(1/)/($ @ ( )," ="*()/="0 *(10 )/99 3%#),"# #1"#$0 )," 8*/9 *449/2*()$4")/)/("#$=*6()8"*##"$)"1086),"*##"$)/(+33/2"# ."-"#0 $%8>"2) ) )," 8*/9 *449/2*()$4")/)/("#$ 3%#(/$,/(+ 4"#$(*9*(1$%#")68(1$/(),"$%=3$0
A"*2,0)),"
$*)/$3*2)/(3),"*##"$)/(+33/2"# ,"8*/9*449/2*()$$,*99*9$ +/-"*(%(1"#)*;/(+8"3#"),"*##"$)/(+33/2"#0),*)*$*(1.,"( ),"6*#"$%==("1),#%+,*.#/))"(%;*=(*=*0),"6$,*99"($%#" ),"/#$#"(1"#/(+24"#*)/()),"/(-"$)/+*)/(+33/2"#0"$4"2/*996 B%*),"/#$=*;/(+*(%(1"#)*;/(+0B%*),"/#./99/(+("$$0)1"4$/)* #"*$(*89"$%=3),"4%#4#)"1"=8"CC9"1$%=$08"3#"),"9"*#("1 )#/*92%#)2(2"#("1D
,"*8-"=*1"2(1/)/(*9#1"#3*1/()"#/=8*/9B%*)," 4#"$"()4")/)/("#$02*%$"1+#/"-*(2")),"4")/)/("#$*(19"1),"=)/($)/)%)" *E
8"3#"),"(E89" 4"?%#) (),"
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
#"*1/(+3),"*8-""?)#*2)"1#1"#0*$=*1"86),"(E89"
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
(8",*934")/)/("#$086),"/#2%($"9$0),"*8-"=*1"#1"#0/$),%$0=*1" *8$9%)" ,%+,09"*#("1 )*)"2%($"9044$"$),"=*;/(+3*8$9%)"
),"*8-"=*1"*1/()"#/=#1"#0),%$0(),"+#%(1),*)),"4")/)/("#$,*-" ()#"(1"#"1 *(6 *89"24"#*)/() ),"/(-"$)/+*)/(+ 33/2"# 2(2"#("1 ."-"#0$/(2"),"9"*#("1 )*)"2%($"9,*$()8""(*89")49*2"(#"2#1 *(6E
/$$%"1%4(),"4#"$"()4")/)/("#$0),%$*$;/(+ ),"=)4*#)/2/4*)"/(),"#"9"-*()/(-"$)/+*)/( ,"#"3#"0),"9"*#("1 )*)"
2%($"92*(()$%8=/)0),*)),"#".*$(24"#*)/(=")"186),"4#"$"() 4")/)/("#$ ) )," /(-"$)/+*)/($0 *$ %(1"#.*6 /( #"$4"2) 3 )," 4")/)/( 33"(2"$ : "),*)*$/)=*60$/(2"),"),"9"*#("12%($"93#),"4")/)/("#$ *9$$%8=/)$),*),"#"*3)"#(E
/$$%"1%4(),"=0),"6 .%91 ),"#"86 *8/1" 86 )," $*/1
*(10 $,*99 *9$ #"(1"# 24"#*)/())," (-"$)/+*)/(+ 33/2"#2(2"#("1 ,"#"3#"0$%8>"2))),"
4")/)/("#$#"(1"#/(+24"#*)/())," (-"$)/+*)/( 33/2"#2(2"#("10( $2#/8"1
8"/(+$"#-"1%4(),"=086)," (-"$)/+*)/(+ 33/2"# 2(2"#("10),"#"3#"0),/$%#)4#2""1$)=*;"*8$9%)"),"*8-"#1"# H ($"B%"()9604#"$"()4")/)/(/$*99."1*(1),"#1"#=*1"86 ),/$%#)(<%960 0/$=*1"*8$9%)"08%)$%8>"2))),"2(1/)/($
$%4#*0#"9*)/(+)),"/#$#"(1"#/(+24"#*)/()),"/(-"$)/+*)/(+33/2"# 2(2"#("108"$/1"$0),"/#$())*=4"#/(+./),),"4#$"2%)/("-/1"(2"(# ),"/#$/(39%"(2/(+#/()/=/1*)/(+),"4#$"2%)/(./)("$$"$#"-"#0$%8>"2) )),"2=49/*(2"3),"2(1/)/($0*$"(-/$*+"1%(1"# "2)/( :
# #"-"#0),"4")/)/("#$$,*991"4$/)*$%=3$9*2$"*2, 8"3#")," (-"$)/+*)/(+ 33/2"#2(2"#("10.,$,*99$%8$"B%"()961"4$/))," $*/1*=%()/(),""$)*89/$,="()3),"9"*#("1)#/*9<%1+"2(2"#("1 ,"
! 1/$8%#$"="()3),"$*/1=("608%)*$-/2)/=2=4"($*)/(0)),"-/2)/= *++#/"-"10$,*998"2="#"+%9*)"186),"%)2="3),")#/*90*$8"2=" "()"#"1/()86),"9"*#("1)#/*9*+/$)#*)"2(2"#("1 ,"*3#"8$"#-*)/($*#"="*()(963#),"1/$4$*93)," 4#"$"()4")/)/(0*(10$,*99()*33"2)),"="#/)$3),")#/*9*#/$/(+3#=),"&
$%4#*
994"(1/(+*449/2*)/( $0/3*(60/$1/$4$"13*22#1/(+96 "32 5+ 4 +62 % 12&80 & ' 9 7 G,"),"#$4"*;/(+A#"*$("1 '"$A G,"),"##"4#)*89"
'"$A