M/S Vang Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

  
    
   !"

#$% &%'()(*+, -
 





                
!+ .

/!0
0  / 1%)%*$+ !10#*2#34#5)6#780%*(1&9'#$%:($6 !1125*065;7#8&9'#$% 1$6%<%$($(*%1 !1#9%%*4#5)6(;8&&($(*#7&9'#$%%*%1#78 #13#*# !1)6:(*(%45=#1 #*)#78&9'#$% 11%)<*&%*$>  #2%)6 (*&#7 6%<%$($(*%1(*$6%<1%)%*$'#)%6#) (7%&$6%<1%)%*$<%$($(* (=<5?*(*?$6%'==5*('#$(*&#$%& **%@51%A-"1%'%(9%&B3($

1=$6%B#*;(* 1=(*?$6%<%$($(*%1$6#$$6%B#*;?5#1#*$%%) 51*()6%&B3 ($$$6%0$#$%6#&B%%*(*9;%&9(&%'==5*('#$(*&#$%& ,  /%#1*%&'5*)%7 1$6%<%$($(*%1)5B=($$%&$6#$$6%<%$($(*%1 6#&)5B=($$%&#$%*&%18:6('6:#)#''%<$%&B3$6%1%)<*&%*$A0$#$%9(&% =%=   ,, &#$%&  , , #*&  $6%<%$($(*%1  :#)  &(1%'$%& $

51*()6<%1 1=#*'%)%'51($3$$6%$5*% 
 8 -CA($61% %1%*'%$ $6%)#=%'*$1#'$8$6%<%$($(*%1 51*()6%&B#*;?5#1#$*%%B%#1(*? D>C,  &#$%&   ,  $  $6%  05<%1(*$%*&(*?  *?(*%%18 
6#*&(?#16
(1'7%8#13#*# "8
6#*&(?#16 1#)5= 
 8 -CA6% # 1%)#(&  '*$1#'$  :#)  &573 '=<7%$%&  *  ,    9%*  '=<7%$(* '%1$( ('#$%  :#)  #7)  ())5%&  $  $6%  <%$($(*%1 *  $6%  )#=%  '*$1#'$8  $6%

  <%$($(*%16#&&%<)($%&
> 8>-8 -CA#))%'51($385$ :6('6 E:#) 1% 5*&%&*'=<7%$(* $6%'*$1#'$#*&#)5= 
-8 8D>CA:#) 1%$#(*%&B3$6%&%<#1$=%*$6%)5B=())(*()$6#$*'%$6%'*$1#'$ 1 :6('6$6%<%$($(*%16#&)5B=($$%&$6%B#*;?5#1#$*%%:#))#$() #'$1(73 '=<7%$%&8$6%)#=%&%)%19%&$B%1%7%#)%&$'57&*$B%(*9;%&$ 1%'9%1#*3#77%?%&&5%)<%1$#(*(*?$$6%1'*$1#'$%*$%1%&(*$B%$:%%* $6%<#1$(%)6%<%$($(*%16#&B%%*'#113(*?*=#*3<12%'$):($6$6% 0$#$%8 1:6('6(*&%<%*&%*$)%'51($(%)C?5#1#*$%%)6#&B%%* 51*()6%&#'6 $1#*)#'$(*6#&$B%&%#7$:($6(*&%<%*&%*$73% 51$6%1)5B=($$%&$6#$ $6%B#*;?5#1#*$%%:#) 51*()6%&$$6%05<%1(*$%*&(*?*?(*%%186:%9%18 $6%)#=%6#)B%%*(*9;%&B3$6%@%'5$(9%*?(*%%18:6('6:#)$$#773 :($65$251()&('$(*8#)6%6#&*#5$61($3$(*9;%$6%)#=%% 51$6%1 )5B=($$%&$6#$$6%#

(&#9($:#)$#;%*B3$6%1%)<*&%*$) 1=$6%<%$($(*%1 5*&%1&51%)) 17(*;(*?$6%B#*;?5#1#*$%%:($6$6%1$%*&%1)86%*'%8$6% )#=%'#**$B%=#&%$6%B#)()$<%1=($$6%1%)<*&%*$)$(*9;%$6%B#*; ?5#1#*$%% 51*()6%&(*&(

%1%*$'*$1#'$) *  $6%  $6%1  6#*&8  7%#1*%&  '5*)%7  1  $6%  1%)<*&%*$) )5B=($$%&$6#$*&5B$$6%'*$1#'$(*F5%)$(*:#)'=<7%$%&B3$6% <%$($(*%1* ,  86:%9%18$6%1#&:#)$B%=#(*$#(*%&$6%1%# $%1 B3$6%<%$($(*%1 1#<%1(& (9%3%#1)8:6('6%@<(1%&* , D6% <%$($(*%16#9(*?*$'#11(%&5$$6%:1; =#(*$%*#*'% 1#&8$6% &%<#1$=%*$6#&$?%$$6%)#=%%@%'5$%& 1=$6%1'*$1#'$1)*$6#$ #''5*$8#)5= 
> 8CA6#)$B%1%'9%1%& 1=$6%<%$($(*%1%

51$6%1)5B=($$%& $6#$ $6% )%'51($3&%<)($%& B3$6% <%$($(*%1(* $6%1 '*$1#'$)8:6%1%#7)'%1$#(*#=5*$):%1% 5*&$B%&5%8:%1%1%7%#)%& # $%1$6%<%$($(*%1 51*()6%&$6%#

(&#9($)$#$(*?$6#$$6%B#*;?5#1#*$%% #71%#&3 51*()6%&B%$1%#$%&#)?& 1$6%1'*$1#'$)#):%77$$6() )$#?%8$6%<%$($(*%1'#**$B%<%1=($$%&$B7:6$#*&'7&#*&'7#(=$6#$ $6%#

(&#9($:#)$#;%*5*&%1&51%))8*'%($6#&$#;%*$6%B%*% ($$6%1% 6%B#*;?5#1#$*%%:#)5*'*&($(*#76%B#*;:#)1%F5(1%&$1%=($$6% #=5*$$$6%0$#$%(==%&(#$%73# $%11%'%(<$ 7%$$%18:6('6:#)*$&*% 6%  (*$%1 %1%*'%  (*  $6%  '#)%    (*9'#$(*    B#*;  ?5#1#$*%%  B3  $6% #5$61($38$:6=($() 51*()6%&8'#**73B%*$6%?15*& 1#5&#*&

> *$$6%1:()% %#1&7%#1*%&'5*)%7 1$6%<#1$(%)#*&<%15)%&$6%<#<%1 B; ) #1#)$6% #'$) $6%'#)%#1%'*'%1*%&8$6%)#=%#1%*$(* &()<5$%$$6%%@$%*$$6#$$6%<%$($(*%16#& 51*()6%&$6%B#*;?5#1#*$%% <%1$#(*(*?$#<#1$('57#1'*$1#'$8:6('6:#)(*9;%&B3$6%0$#$%81% %11(*?

$'%1$#(*#=5*$&5% 1=$6%<%$($(*%16%<%$($(*%1'7#(=%&$6#$$6% #=5*$:#)&5%:($61% %1%*'%$)=%$6%1'*$1#'$8:6%1%*'=<7%$(* %9%*$6%)%'51($3:#)1%7%#)%&:%9%18$6% #'$)1%=#(*$6#$$6%<%$($(*%1 6#& 51*()6%&#*#

(&#9($?(9(*?7(B%1$3$$6%&%<#1$=%*$$(*9;%$6% B#*;?5#1#*$%% 1$6%1'*$1#'$)#*&(* #'$8#))5B=($$%&B37%#1*%& '5*)%7 1$6%0$#$%8$6%<#3=%*$)(*#77$6%1'*$1#'$):%1%1%7%#)%&#*& %9%*$6%)%'51($(%)$:#) 51$6%1)5B=($$%&B3'5*)%7 1$6%0$#$%$6#$* #''5*$ **A (7=%*$ $6%'7#5)%<%1$#(*(*?$=#(*$%*#*'% $6% 1#&7#(&B3$6%<%$($(*%1 1#<%1(& (9%3%#1)8$6%&%<#1$=%*$6#&$ )<%*&
> 8CA8:6('6#1%1%'9%1#B7% 1=$6%<%$($(*%1 6%(=<1$#*$#)<%'$8:6('6'#**$B%7)$)(?6$ ()$6#$$6% B#*;?5#1#*$%% 51*()6%&B3$6%<%$($(*%1:#)5*'*&($(*#7<%15)#7

$6%'==5*('#$(*&#$%&  1=$6%B#*;%1 $6%<%$($(*%1$$6% <%$($(*%1(*$(=#$(*?$6#$$6%B#*;?5#1#*$%%) 51*()6%&B3($6#9%B%%* (*9;%&  B3  $6%  @%'5$(9%  *?(*%%18  19(*'(#7  (9()(*8   8  

1#*'689(&%6()=%=&#$%& , #*&$6%<%$($(*%1:#)#&9()%&$ &%<)($$6%#=5*$(*'#)6'1%&($#''5*$(==%&(#$%73$%)$#B7()6%)$6%

#'$$6#$$6%B#*;6#& #(7%&$#'$5<*$6%'==5*('#$(* 1=$6%0$#$% (*9;(*?$6%B#*;?5#1#*$%%8:6('6:#)5*'*&($(*#76% #'$$6#$$6% <%$($(*%1:#)&(1%'$%&$&%<)($$6%#=5*$ B#*;?5#1#*$%%(*($)'#)6 '1%&($#''5*$)6:)$6#$$6%B#*;&(&*$6#9%$6%1%F5()($%=*%31 )%'51($38 1:6('6$6%B#*;?5#1#*$%%)6#&B%%*())5%&6#$():638$6% <%$($(*%1:#)1%F5(1%&$&%<)($$6%#=5*$05'6#1%*$$6%'*&($(*)(* $6%B#*;?5#1#*$%%)6%B#*;?5#1#*$%%()#*(*)$15=%*$8:6('6%*$($7%)# <%1)*(*:6)% #951($()())5%&$1%'%(9%$6%#=5*$(==%&(#$%73$6% )#=%()(*9;%&$()*$$6#$($()'*&($(*#7*&%<)($ $6%#=5*$B3 $6%<%1)*:6 51*()6%)$6%B#*;?5#1#*$%%

D *9(%: =3# 1%)#(&&()'5))(*8&*$ (*&#*3=%1($(* $6%<1%)%*$<%$($(*''1&(*?738$6%)#=%()&()=())%& #2%)6 (*&#7"

5&?% , - =;