High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/982/2023allowed

Charan Singh (Since Deceased) Through Lrs Rajinder Kaur And ORS. v. Ut, Chandigarh And ORS.

2026-03-05Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja5 pages

!"#$

! " # $ # %

' ($ ) * $ $ +

, $-+!

.....

$ # " %&'

() "

+ + (

$ /+ + /'

0 -+ +

$ #(1+ +(

+(

#+

+

& 34 5 %#

++#+2 #+

$ /++

#+(+

5 -+ - +

#$(#-1 (8- #/+ (- '-(66 6 /#-

6

! " :- $/

# + #$

1/(#-$++ (/+$1 $1-# #(++ #+

-++- 5/ - +0;/- ( -+ "##

##$%&

' (#)$) *) $

+,+,%-.&( /.. < +11 ( %&

' (

0 ) ! +,+12"( -,-.$1/#$#+6# #1

#/1(# 1/11

+# " +<-

!"

# %$"

%!"

# &$

% '

' ( ) "$"#

$$ %%

$"

$$

"* %$+ )$ $ '

"

$ # # $ ',!

-"

!$ "

'""$$ +

'$ #

'""

$$ $

+ #

'&%"$+ &$$"( "( &+ $ . #$

"

$"

,!$"

.$) %$"

' . )

. '

.+

+ "$$!$+ .#$"( "!' "

$"$ #

+

% / $!"

# '"

% $$

+ # #"$

" '!

. '

"!.0'$ ' $ $$ %%

$"

)!

$ . $$

! ! .#$ #

+

% / $ "!' !

' %%

$1"

#! # " $$ .$' # #"$ $ "$' # $

)"

)"

"$

% '" $ .# !$

$$ !$ !$ &%$'

+

$'&"

)"

.#$ # $"$ '

!

$!&(

'$ # '$ # %

#&

$ # %"" # )

.+ #' !$ $

# # #"$ "3 5 1+-(/ $

1#+2 2#+

/#

1 #+ + #+ 2

64=$-/''-<

* %#

+( +

$162

2 $ /+ + /'

0 -+ - +

$ #(1 ( +

/( +

( +,-&,.

-$-+

-/(

8-# /#'-(66 6 /# -

6>?&

!

1/#$(= -+8-1 +

$2

@ " +'-( - -

- #'$ $$ # %!%" # """"&$ # # ',!

( ' )"

% '

!% )

# #' !$ %$ ',!"$ #

# "&

4( # )' $#'$

'$ # '$ )"

""!

( "

$

"%!$ - %'% "

$

"%!$ "

"

. #

.+ 5 -$+( #"

',!"$( $"

!$

6) 0$

!0 1"

'"

"!%(

""""

"8((9 ' - "

$& % # $)$+ &$"

.$) $) ',!"$"

& + ',!"$

$

',!"$ ,!"$ ) $#'$

'$ # '$ )"

""!

:8: ; # #"

$& % '" )$ '!&!

$ ##'$ < !& "

$ ( &!$ # )!

'& !$ " (82(829 '( )' "

!

## " (8:(9 '

: '' +(

)"

$

" (8:(9 ' -+ "

. $$

"$$!$+ .#$"

.

$& '$ -

) 3 >$- / +-

+-'-(

3 ) % # &1 $ -1+-+

8-#$

+((

3 ) % # & 5+-

1/ + +#+2 2#$+

%

$+#$ +

$ #

=

A =@ B@) A / B@)