High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3192/2014dismissed

Shamsher Singh v. State Of Punjab & ANR

2015-01-22Mr. Justice Satpal7 pages

!" "#$%$&'

(

( )* +%*",)$&-* .",%/% )! !" /&0 1 &2 &!*", ) % '34 5))5) 55 '34 5))5) 55 '34 5))5) 55 '34 5))5) 55 ,"%"&!'

,.$+ 67/+ ,/8! 9 2:# !"

,!*"8"!$!$&", ,))* /2* ,;9

9/&0 1 , * :; 2""8< 6$ 9 2:# !"

,,"%8&2"&! 5) 559 5) 559 5) 559 5) 559, 6 "!$!$&", * % #* 66"&-"2 0/2-+"&! 2 !"2 =

8 %%"21;/2$#$ 6 -$%!, !"%! 6 %%9 !$ 6 9 >*","1;*"* %1""&#&:$#!"2 &2%"&!"&#"2!/&2",- ,$-,/%$+8,$%&+"&! , 8",$2 !>;" ,%91"%$2"%8 ;

$&" ?(9

@3 &2$&2"

/6!!*"," 9!/&2",-%$+86"

$+8,$%&+"&! , &" +&!* , !*"

"&#" 8/&$%* 16"

/&2",)"#!$& 9 "!$!$&",4% #&:$#!$& * % 1""& /8*"62 1;

22$!$& 6)"%%$&%/2-"9 %!, #B/,!9 !$ 6 9:$2"!*"

$+8/-&"20/2-+"&!2 !"2C

%8",8,%"#/!$&# %"9 #+86 $&!> %+:"2 1;/62 )$&-*>*$%!*" !*", 07 /, 07 /,$%!*"

8"!$!$&",4%>$ ")*"> %+ ,,$"2!!*"8"!$!$&", 1/!A ;" ,% -!> %!*"%"#&2+ ,,$ -" !*"8"!$!$&", &2 *" 2"+ &2"2 2>,;

!", !> ;" ,% + ,,$ -" *"

2"+ &2"2 &">%#!", &2+&"; ,+ 07 /, &2*", 8 ,"&!%*"8"!$!$&",-!!, &% ",,"2!*,""%*8% &2&"

86!$&!*"& +" 07 /, &2%/1%"D/"&!6;*" ,#$16;

-!%$-& !/,"% 07 /,& >", !!,&";$&*$%

:/, &2 !*"& !, &% ",,"2 !*" 8,8",!; ! %+" !*$,2 8",%& ,#&%$2", !$&"!*","

!",9%! ,!"26$:$&->$!* -$,6 !:$66 -" 6$8/, &2+ $&! $&"2$66$#$!,"6 !$&%>$!**", & /6;9

9 )* +%*", )$&-* * 2 1" !"& 0 7 /, +",#$6"%%6; &2%*"> %$& 6$#!"2%",$/%$&0/,$"%)*"> % ,"

",,"2 ! * &2$- ,* 1; 8,$: !" 2#!, &2 & $&D/$,;> %#&2/#!"2$&!!*"+ !!", &2&!*"1 %$%

,"8,! &C 2 !"2 =

(/@%

96$#")! !$&) 2 ,9 !$ 6 > %,"-$%!","2 - $&%!!*" 8"!$!$&",

8,$+" #$"# %" ,!*"

"&#"8/&$%* 16"/@%

> % /&2!1"+ 2"/! - $&%!!*"8"!$!$&", ! >*$#* *" 86" 2"2 &! -/$6!; &2 #6 $+"2 !,$ 6 & 88,"#$ !$& !*" ":$2"&#" &2 !*" #!% &2

#$,#/+%! &#"%9 !*" 6" ,&"2 !,$ 6 #/,! #&:$#!"2 !*" 8"!$!$&", ,!*"

"&#"8/&$%* 16"/@% >*$6"!*"

#3 ##/%"2-$&2",)$&-*%& 6$8)&> % #D/$!!"2 )* +%*", )$&-* > % %"&!"&#"2 ! /&2",- ,$-,/% $+8,$%&+"&! ,!*"8",$2 !>;" ,%91"%$2"%8 ; $&"

? (9

@3 &2 $& 2"

/6! !*"," 9 ! /&2",- %$+86"

$+8,$%&+"&! ,&"+&!*"!$!$&",8,"

",,"2 & 88" 6 - $&%!!*"0/2-+"&! #&:$#!$& &2%"&!"&#"9>*$#** % 6%1""&2$%+$%%"21; 22$!$& 6)"%%$&%/2-"9 %!, #B /,!9 !$ 6 9 :$2" !*" $+8/-&"2 0/2-+"&! 2 !"2 C

*"8,"%"&!,":$%$&8"!$!$&* %1""& $6"21;

!*"8"!$!$&", %% $6$&-!*"0/2-+"&! #&:$#!$& &2,2", %"&!"&#" %>"66 %!*"0/2-+"&! !*" 88"66 !"/,!

/8*62$&-*$%#&:$#!$& &2%"&!"&#" 5" ,&"2 #/&%"6 , !*" 8"!$!$&", :"*"+"&!6;

,-/"2!* !+ ,,$ -"1"!>""&!*"8"!$!$&", &2 07 /, * %&!1""&8,:"2&,"#,2!$% :",,"2!* ! 07 /, > %+ ,,$"2!&" 00 &)$&-*%& $%* &)$&-* &2 * 2 6% $6"2 & 886$# !$&/@% (, &&"E/,"3 , -, &! + $&!"& &#" 8"&2"&!"36$!" )*" * 2 6":"66"2 %$+$6 , 66"- !$&% 2"+ &2 #6/,.9%#!", &2 ?(

@3D/ 00 &)$&-*% 6% 00 &)$&-* 6% $6"2 & 886$# !$&/@% !*"$&2/ ,,$ -" #! - $&%! 07 /, & =

= *","

,"9 !*"," $% & D/"%!$& &;

+ ,,$ -" 1"!>""& !*" 8"!$!$&", &2 0 7 /, 1"$&- %6"+&$F"2& C!$% /,!*",%/1+$!!"2!* !!*","

$%&+"2$# 6":$2"&#"&,"#,2 !8,:"!*" 66"- !$&% , $%"2 - $&%!!*"8"!$!$&",*","$%&"#*$621,&/!

!*$%>"26#B 52 /&%"6 /,-"% !* ! !*"," $% & 8,

2$:,#" 1"!>""& 00 & )$&-* &2 0 7 /,9 !*"," ,"9 #&:$#!$& !*"8"!$!$&",$%$66"- 6 &26$ 16"!1"%"! %$2" 5" ,&"2#/&%"6 ,!*"%! !" &2,"%8&2"&!

0 7/+ , * :" 8$&!"2 /! !* ! E $% #,$+$& 6 #+86 $&!9>*$#*> % $6"21;!*"8"!$!$&",/&2",%"#!$&%

9 ( &2

- $&%!,"%8&2"&! 07 /,& !*"% $2#+86 $&!9$!$%#6" ,6;+"&!$&"21;!*"8"!$!$&", !* ! %$+86"+ ,,$ -"> %8", ,+"21;*$+>$!* 07 /, & C "

","&#"> % 6%+ 2"!E <@ $",2",% !*$%#/,!,"

6"#!$&- 07 /,!1"!*">$ " )* +%*", )$&-* "!$!$&", > % -, &!"2 1 $6 %/10"#! ! 8 ;+"&!

$&!",$++ $&!"& &#"!*$%>$ ","%8&2"&! 07 /,!

$% 8$&!"2 /! !* ! 886$# !$& , $&!",$+ + $&!"& &#"

/&2", )"#!$& (9 , $6"2 1; 0 7 /, * 2 1""& >$!*2, >&1;*",,%"#/!$&* %8,:"2$!%# %"1";&2 ," %& 16"2/1! - $&%!!*"8"!$!$&", &2*$%#&:$#!$&

( &2%"&!"&#" ,"6$ 16"!1"/8*"62 * :"*" ,26" ,&"2#/&%"6 ,!*"8 ,!$"% &2 -&"!*,/-*!*","#,2 !*"# %" ! $% 88 ,"&! !* ! !*" 8"!$!$&", *$+%"6 * % 2+$!!"2 ! %6"+&$F$&- + ,,$ -" >$!* 0 7 /, & C!2"%&!6$"$&*$%+/!*!% ; !!*$%%! -" !* !&+ ,,$ -"> %#&!, #!"2>$!**",,!* !!*"% +"$% &! : 6$2+ ,,$ -" &29!*","

,"9*"$%&!6$ 16"!1"

#&:$#!"2/&2",%"#!$& *"8"!$!$&",* %-&"!!*""E!"&! , $%$&- >$62 66"- !$&% - $&%! !*" 8,"%$2$&-

$#", !*" !,$ 6 #/,!9," 2", !*"#/,! &2!*",0/2$#$ 6

$#", %>"66 % 86$#"

$#",% $66$#$!,"6 !$&%>$!*,"%8&2"&! 92/"! >*$#* !*"; * :" %/88,!"2 *", " * % $&2/6-"2 $& /& 1 %*"2#* , #!", %% %%$& !$& *","$%&":$2"&#" >,!*!*" & +"!%/1%! &!$ !"%/#*%",$/% 66"- !$&%9 >*$#* 88" ,!* :"1""&6":"6"2$& & 1%6/!"6;,/!$&" # %/ 6+ &&",>$!*/! &;#&%$2", !$& !*"-, :$!;

%/#* 66"- !$&% )/#* #&2/#! 88" ,% ! 1" #!

2"%8", !$& )8"#$ $# 66"- !$&% >*$#* * :" 1""& , $%"2 - $&%!!*"8"!$!$&",>"," /66;%/88,!"21;!*">$!&"%%"% <5 #**+ &)$&-*9>*!*/-*2"#6 ,"2*%!$6"9* % 6% #,,1, !"2 !*" 8,%"#/!$& :",%$& " 2+$!% !* ! *"

>"&! ! !*" $&36 >% 0 7 /, 6&- >$!* &#* ; ! */-*!*";!,$"2!8",%/ 2"!*" ##/%"29*","+ $&"2 2 + &! $&,"- ,2!!*"2"+ &2 2>,;*/%9*"* % 2/6;8,:"2!*"+ ,,$ -" %>"66 %2"+ &2 2>,;":"& !*/-*2"#6 ,"2*%!$6"<3 07 /, &2*", !*",<3A /62 )$&-** :"6":"66"2%8"#$ $# 66"- !$&% - $&%!!*"

8"!$!$&", &2* :"2"8%"2!* !*"%! ,!"2* , %%$&- 0 7 /, !",!>;" ,% + ,,$ -" ,2>,; &2%/10"#!"2 *",!#,/"6!; *$%#/,!$&"E",#$%" ,":$%$& 60/,$%2$#!$&$% &!!,"3 88,"#$ !"!*"":$2"&#"8",:",%$!;"+",-"%$& !*" $&2$&-%,"!/,&"21;!*"#/,!1"6> &2&"$!*",* % &; + !",$ 6":$2"&#"1""&$-&,"2>*$#*> ,, &!%$&!", ","&#"

1;!*$%#/,! &!*$%%$!/ !$&6" ,&"2#/&%"6 ,!*"8"!$!$&", 8, ;% !* ! 1"&"

$! 8,1 !$& 1" "E!"&2"2 ! !*"

8"!$!$&", , !*" %"&!"&#" $+8%"2 /8& *$+ + ; 1" ,"2/#"2 *"," $% & !*", # %" 8"&2$&- - $&%! !*" 8"!$!$&","* %"&2/,"2 -&; !,$ 6%$&#"

( 7""8$&-$&:$">!*" #!% &2#$,#/+%! &#"% !*"

# %" &2!*"& !/," !*"

"&#"$!$%&!#&%$2","20/%!

&2"E8"2$"&!!!*""&!$,","2/#"!*"%"&!"&#"$+8%"2 /8&!*"8"!$!$&",,"E!"&2!*"1"&"

$! 8,1 !$&! *$+

= &%"D/"&!6;9!*$%,":$%$&8"!$!$&$%2$%+$%%"2

( 5) 55