← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/563/2020dismissed

M/S Kotak Mahindra Bank Limited v. Dalbir Kaur And Others

2020-09-18Mr Justice Rajiv Sharma,Mr. Justice Harinder Singh Sidhu11 pages

 

   ! " ! 

  

   

  !

 " 

# $%& !'$!(!)!'* + ! , - ! &!-!      # $   % &% '  $   % ! %%!

  $+'(!.)(!  + "!

! . $+ !)!!+ "!

  ( !  $! !/0(1!$!&(!!+ "!



 $ 2!+  ! " 1 ! 3!4 ( $1-

&!-1   !  -  5 3!  ! %%! ' 7(*

 !

 + !(!

 !0!  ( /-0

!

8#

    9 ! &!-5

3!! 94(

. ( 4   . ! &!-:

( 4!! 4 ("

 ! (  0 ! ;"

+  !4!   4 (!.    

  !   &!-  (!     (  4  

  !.0 <-!(0 (  =-

!

 >+ ?- @A  4("(( !  

!0

 #B- 84! ! <-!(0 ( %"

-"!  !

B >+ ?- @A4(

.(    !  !

 >+ ?-

@ A  !     (   0 !    ;"

  @>  

  8 A!0!  (  =- % -0 ( !  4!  .

( .  . 0  (! ( !  (!

  -  > A>(A  +" 8B>   .C ( +" DA!(

(! 

     !  

     .  (   -    2-"! $!0 !

3 !*-(!!

 3  "!

4! (! (  !!0 4!

= 4 (+-

0(   ( (   (

! 

!(

! +  !

4 (74 "( 4



 E -   - "

4 (( (- !( (

!"' ( !  !(

! 

4 ($!"( !"

(

(!

0 (    <-  .( 4!-!4! -  !"    ( (- !( 4!( 4 !   ( -   - .( (- !4( !( (! -!. !. (

!!    !  -    (  4!  ( "'

      !  

  !

 B# . ( ! @& !'$!(!)!'! ( 

4 ( !  0(  (! (

 !

  .

 -  2-"!$!0 !

 !*-(!!7(

.( 0

' 4  (  "!

!  B( !

-  2-"!$!0 !

 !*-(!!!4! !

 

B#( 4 !' #

(  4(

4! 0 (  ( -0(("(

5+( "!

!"' 3! ;(  -

!' ( 3!3

0!    

!

 !  ( 313+  

4 ( ( !  4 ( - !.  !  !.( 4@"!-  "

 (  !   !  %! !

!

@ ! E (    !

,

-"!  !

B( 4!

.

8 (! ( !  (!

   (   

>A

!0

#8 

E D (E0( - 4("((!

    .

0 (! ! !/ !  "!- !"  (!!  (  !

 -/!

4  -0(  (!



 ( -  E !

 4!-  !- (    -(!"

.

 !

   -0 (  4 (! 

 4

'+ ( 4  -(     (

  !  ! 0! "

!

 #B>+ ?- @A

87( ! 

8   (! ( !  (!

 !(

 !

    7( "

-"!    -"

4 F ! B G

+B###8% ;+%  

 

(   

 

!!! " #$ %&' 

( ' !)* 

!+ ,($ -

.#  !/!*    ,

 ' 0(( # 1&  & 

   .



(&   2 ' !)*3  !+

 (& ,0 1& 



&'



(( #  !!!*  #  !454 (  %  ' 1# *+3 ''

#

 #  #  & 0((

67 8 # 

 % 9  :



-

.# &   (#  ' ( ";

1  ' 0(( # 1& < 8 )  (  *  0  2-0  (  "

     

(! 

4! (!  ( ! & !'$!(!)!'(!  4

!  -   #

!

3 -

 +" ##

2-"!$!0 !

*-(!!4(  ( ! 0 4!  ! 

!(

=8#@+$!<

 !+  !4( !( 4! 0

4 (!  (!  

 ( 0 ' 4 (!  (

!

  B .4( ! @)!'



(  

 B#!

-  (  "!

!   7( !  4!  ! (  (! "! 0 (!  ( !

 4!-.!4!  (! ( 4! 0! +  !

 ! !

 - -0 (  "!

!  !4!0! ! B# 7( !  (  "!0( !!

 

!  7(- ( 4! ""!  

8@  0 !  ;"

  - (     0 - (! (

 !

    !"

4!!"

! "  ( - %)*!++,-./012&- %*/*+ /13/4/'

  12)24/564(  4!( ! @ =

%

  #      && '#  & ((

 

''   ' #   & > 

 9  

(  9    2

 

  '# &   # &2

   ( #   ( '#  & ((   # 

' .< 3 4!- ( !0-  (!  (  "

- (!

 4 ( - 00   - . ( !0 -0!( 4"!-  "

! <- -  >A  +"  !"

4!!"

"  E 9 -

 -  ( "!  /4+,//47.2&-

424 472//471-689% (9'%01+-./47/&- 

9

% 8( B 7( "!      (!  /-    (   !"    -0 (  "

0 (!  4 "

! !

 !(!

  

! @)!' 

  (! 

4!!0-!!  ! !!

- ! (!  (



0-   #

!

3 -

 +" ##(

(! 

     !  

     3  4!  !0-   (!  ( -0(

(!! !

"

  -  B# !-(  ( !

.

!" 

! (! " !

0      0  !0!  (  7(   (   !   (! 

% '

-  > A> A>(A +"   (! ( 0(  ! "

- .3 4!- ( !0-  (! 

(!

-(  ( ! . ( "

  -  "  !0 !    ( 8! . (  ! 2-"! $!0 !

   !  *-(!!  4!    -    (  ! !- (    # ;

(! ! !  4!"

 (!  (! " !"

! !0! $%!=0(H  4("(

!( (- !+-

0(4  !  $

(!" 4!- !0! $%!=0(H   74

"( <- !

- 0 

#B%@ !"(-    "   (

!.

 !   !  0 ( 3 4!- ( !0- (! ! ( 4! .'

(

 (! 

!( (- !

0(  ! "

- . ! !.0 ( -  !0-  4! (

!' ( ! (!  @# @

'0 -0

!  

 )- !-0 ( ". 4  4!  4! !-"

-  7( *0 2-0 !  ( 4 

0

8 !!!-  ="#  !4/5 (  1#  '    (



(  (

&' 

''

&2  '

  (#   

9 .

   !!/!*

 #  ''      (

#'2 ( & (  (

&' 

 '' (  '    

 .

 #&& #

  & (   ''

   '     #  )!3!*  .

   !+!)!*

(&   #



 #  '#  & '

 ''





&'  (  ?  (

#'2 (   '

 ## 9 (   

 ''

,' / ,

 ' 0(( #

    !!+!* '

  8 # 

  . @# (    !!+!*    $ =6 .



& #    ##  



  #  '#  & ' .

   !3

 





.

   3!)   '# &  '# 

.



 &   #





   



 ## ' #   1##  2 '# &  '#    ##  ''





<

%   

 ( ' #  & 

    (   !!+!*

'

 #&'    "#  ) (   %& 1# )) '(

' +;

?

,

 ' 0(( # ' /

9

 &  ((  > 

   ( '# &  '#    '  

A. .

  #  )!3!*    ,

 ' 0(( #  '  

(&  







 8 # 

  3!)  '       && '#  & ' 

(  9 ## 



   ( #   ( '#  & ' #  ' A.    #&'      '     "#  ) (   %& 1#

#

((# 

&'   ( 2 #   .

 9    ''    

(  ' # '  ( 

 & '&  .

 

 '  

   #  '' 2 (

 

&' 

 ''  !!*

   (& & 

 #



  2 2 

  B .    9# # 

 #  .2  (

&' 

(

 ''

#  (  '

. 



.

  . (  ' # '  (   #

  # ( '   #   '

' / 

.

  .  '  #(   ''   2 

&' ''

>

 # 

   2

(



 #  

 ( 

    # .

#># A.  ''  '  

 '   .

;&   "#   (  1#  # 

' ;9

( ' 0(( #

    '.

   ;#   ( "#  !;1 (  1#

#

'# # 2 &   .2

  (  ''

 '# (

&   ( '  ( ''

 '  #  45  #  ( 

6  ;# 

.  '' 2 (







 '  (    

 ? #? (&   ( ' 

( #

  B' #

    9 C.&

&' 

#2

 

  

 & (2  .?    

# 

  # ( ' /

&' 

 '' (  '  

# 

&'# 

 D& ,



1 &  . '  '  E

.



''

(  8 # 

  :





    '# &   # 

' .

 (#



  ?  ( ' /;,

 ' 0(( # 1&  .



((#  #   #

&'

 9   

 (  ''<  *0 2-0 - ( "

"-  (!  ( "

-" 



0!  (   

8@ 0 !  ;"

+  ! !0 !0  -0 



 0!

!"

! (  ! - .  ! (  !4 -

0    *  2-0  "

"-   (!    4!  !  " !  ?!

   (

!  !   !"(  !"(0  (  G-!

 !  0(     (

 7( 4!! 4 ("

  !'(>-

; *!'(A

! .

8(   7(

-0 % =- 

 !

  >+ ?- A!

B>+ ?- A4 <-!( ! (  0 !

  ;"

  +  !  4!        (  !  

4 (!.

!

  "

 

  .   (+'(!.)(!*   -   ( ! (!

!"!. !

 ( -

 !!"

(! !

*0 2-0  E !0-  (!  (  "

 ! .

!

-  ( !! ( (- ! ! ( ! .

 (  ! 

!(

 

 - 

E

- ( !0-  (!  (  

4!0( . !" !

0-   #

!

3 -

  +" 4 0!0! ( ! ( !0! ' ( 

0 (

- .  !    (!      4 - 

 "-      (  (-0

-  !0  -    0!0  4("(  (    !  0-!!   ! 0  4 (  ( (- !E   > A> A (  +" ! 4("(  !- (  . !. - "!-

  '

!

!    !  "-

 F

0 "  !  "

!

(!

"

. ( (      !  "-

 !

0

!" !"

- 3!I  E!0( !* -   ( ! 4 ! 

"   4 ( (  *0 !4   0! .

 ( !

   3 ( 4  

(! -0  (  =-

 !

  >+ ?- A!

B >+ ?- A"

 .0 (   ( !"  *0 2-0 (! 0( ."

"-  (!  .4! (  -0 !"   ! 0!

0 !  "  ! -!/- "

-(

  -0 (! (

 !

  4! @

?    7(  (!

 -  > A>

0 - 

0 "  !" !  "

0 !0! 

4("( ( 0 -  . ( ! 

/- .  -0  3 4   (!  ( ! . !!  !  (!

/-   . . ( 

   ( ; (!  -"(

 -0 "! - ! 8 +""

0. ( 

  (! !! ( !

      E   (  "

   !   -"

   %@  

%@ B 3 ! "!  (!  ( !- (   !   "- 

!0!.- <-   -0 (  

 /- !

0 - " .!  (  +" ! (  !4  &%   ! %%!  

!  ! %+:*+);+19'

0! (  !'0%  J (   !

J %