High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCWP/13413/2020dismissed

Anil Kumar Gupta v. National Bank For Agriculture And Rural Development And Others

2020-12-22Mr. Justice Rajbir Sehrawat11 pages

!"# $%&'&()*)+,

+)-./0$1/2%$ &%)%)+&1 *

$%)+$- $+4 151)(/-%/1& $+' /1$- &6&-20&+%7 "/08$) $+'

%9&1* 33 &*2+'&+%* 1$0, :"

; ;

!"# ! $% &% "'

($!"# ! %"

$<8)1;&91$=$%7 1$-# "

>?, )$ %%* %* ($+ ,"

# - "%%% -%" $%% '

# * . ("# ""/!$ !$ % %%* $ ."" 0#00 "

@>A , )$ %%*

*".-$ %%* 1%"

(% %* ##"$/ .$

%" *(/ $%$#% 203 "3 4$ " $ %%* !$ **/"

3%*- *(/ $203 "3 ! #" "

>BCA , )$ %%*

*".-$% (% %* ##"$ !( "

($ # !

20 " 4$ " $ %%* !$ **/" &#020 " #" "$)+$*&, )$ % $ .

*" 0" #*

6 $ 0 ,"

0 # / $ 0 #

"$ %0("""

" 78

209!/$.- $%"$ "#* "$#*

$% 2 / - #!. ("

.*"!.-

($ $ ( 5 - 5 - ! *(/ $ **#:0

" %* *

" "/ 0" $ 3 ($ / & #!

5 $;$#; 0$ "

# $%

($ 5 -

)$.

# $ # ! %* "" $/ % <$ $% (= ">/ $$%"> )$ % $

( %$- * "

- 0% $ 2 9 ? . ( % %*( # )$

" "

-$ "0*-. #

".-$#% "

-)$%".

00."- 0- #% < 0"".-$= ,"

)$#% "$.

%$- **-"

.*"% $ "

#0* ". ( $ % / $"

-$0 . ()$ ! %# ."

/ $ $ %" .

! 5 - @/! $ % . (

%$- **-$ %%"%!".$/%#

*# " $ ! $ %" .

" . "

#" $ % 0% 5 - $$

(0!$% % $ .

*" $ * (0 ($# !* "#0* $% $ 0. "$ #$% $# "" **

$ % $%$

(%$- **-$ %< " $*

$!$ !$#$ # "0-0%$##"=

- %* "#

< /** <$% <

$%#"0"$#@#!2" ($ ( $%/ $%$- *"

-!/0*". # # $ "%0% $#3 $!$ $ # 0%$

.-$% $# )$#0*$ * "0%$ #

" '# 6 $#.0$ (0 )$ #0* $ % $ * " 0% $ A0"( "".-$&

>#$ $ 0 ?

*" ;%$%& /+<$86 9/2)+'&1;)+597"# "" 79

"$ (0"

$ ..".-$&

>#$$ $%/ $%$- - $ % - $ # - " $ ! $ % - $= %#

*% $ # (- % ##"

(*-! / "

#" .- $ &

>#$ $ A0"($ $%* #- 2 78- 5 - !/$ #$/ % ""*- .* "%!.2""$% / $ **$"

! #%* "0"$#

)$#0*$ ** "0%$A0"( $'0% 0 $# :9$5=$+$**6 /+<$8;%$%&-&(%1)()%D$1'7@

#;B?>: #"$ $@;.*'0%0$ *."

0$.

*A0 # $%/ -<

$0$ * 2 *!$$0$0*"$

" ($ ##"

(*-!$'0%0$ """$ $%"

$ # /0*""

/ $$% $ # 0 $ #*-.# 0$$ "0".* "/$ * # )$#0*$ ** "0%$ 0".-$ = ,"

!/$ #$$ . #$".-$%" 20 3 "$ #""$ "$ !$= ,"

$ "2""$ $%*- 78- 5 - <

"$ " % "

#%#

.-"5 - .00% 5 !- .-# " ($# $ ( # # .

" / * "

%%* .*$ 00."

# ".-0"$=

@#! %$

" !$%" 0" .* ( # "$# % #.-"$

5 - < % /$% #0*

# $"

*#"

$% B2"

($ (0! 0. ".-$#0*$ #$ % # " # 2

0% # # .

!$ % /$ $ #!$%"$0*"."

#"# "$# $% /**! 2 $ 0% 5 - 5 - $$$ "!$#0* $%"$ 0. "

7 $ $%*-1

# $%".

2" 5 - )$ % 2

-# (- $%*- $%"' ** 0$! 0. "

$ (0 $#0* $% $ $ ".2"" $# (- %$- **-$ %%" /$ #! 0

.* * /)$ % $# /$ #$ 0% $ - ##"

$ (

0% %$- **-"

.*"%*-)$ "%0%

$# *-%"

/ $%/ -*-

##0 $ "

-< /** < * $ #"

$ 0# (/$ *$- #@#!$%"

0"*( *.* ( $ #$ $ $ % $# (- %$- **-$ %%"0"$%

$#'

$ ".-$#0* $%

##"! 0. ".-$#0* $%"$ $

-%#

# -$ %$ **.

" # .-"$ 5 - 2#% # "

#%#

)$ # (- "

* " #

# %#

# 0 *($

# (- " #* * / $ %#

0# (! ** " /*"( 4 $ *- $ =$ "% $2 $ /# ( < /- >0$%

** $ $

" # ( " $ >-" $ ! $

"% " -"

# / $$%".

2" - ( 0% - $ # (- @#! $

5 %" .

$ " - % 2 (

0% -# (- %*-)$% *.0"

#%* %$0*)$$ ."

/ $$% ##0 $ "

-)$ 0** .

$# "$$% * (%/ - $ * "-.2""$ "0 ($ #0 @#! 0. "$ $%% "."

" @ "$#0* $% > %#"

0$! %%%

$* $#'# 9!

! 6 $# %"0#" 0"

> ($%)+$-%1$)+)+5$+'*&-&02-D0&+%E )$ %%%

= $ ** 0* #$ " %( #*0"

( * ## *

" 0%% %*- %/ %#

**- $ #

"* %*- )$#$ "%( " 0.# $ ** " #*0 %/ - **

" * # * " **

( #$ %( < .0$ %/ -$ ":0 0%%

*%#

(< 2#*0 **

( %( % / / $ # * / $$ ! $/ "*% *! **#0 *!0* %*"

0 < * ## * #*0"

($ ##"

< ($%"0# ".-%/ <

# "

((( ""

$%( " $ **

"* %*-! #*0"

(%/

6 +A')*(1)0)+$%)+ )+ &02-D0&+% D = .* $$ **"

(

-%/ -

- * (%*- ""$ $ %%%

= -!$

(( "$ -% / # " - .* $!.-

"0.A# 0#$#"

-!2% - .* $ $% $ # B- = .* $ $ ** % " .*

##"

%%%

"#"0# %*-/ - % $ **." " %*-$(0"

- = .* $$ **"

%/ $"0# !

%*-/$ #:0 "

-"0 ($ $ # ""$ !

%*-

#:0 ("

- 0 .* $%$/ $*"

(!$ **.$

"$%/ $$ % -# * " #.

"" 0$$

% .* "A0$%*- (

-%!$ -. % 0%0 -%0 0 .*%

.*$

$ !/$ #$ * )$ %%%

= - %* % %*-/

F/$-221%/+)%D2-)(D DB- .* $$ **

- :0 *%%0 -%* #-"

( 0%%". .- %00 # $% $ $ % $ -. %# .".-$ *= B- .* $$ **( #%- $

"%* #-/ $$ $ $' ! $# -. E?

/0$+1&*/1(&'&6&-20&+%E $0%A0"

# -

0# "%/ 3$ 0# * ,"

# 0"0" $ 3$ 0# * ,"

#! 99 ! $ %%%

= $ ** " 0 "*% $0 0# $ %0% $ # "$ "$ **

- ($ **#0 $

( #$ - 3 A .!*( * ! " !

%* #

*!A0"( "* /-<

8 .

"0#"

- #% **"0# #0

#$*!#**( "+ - #$!"#!0!

% "

* %*! #

* /*

#! 0 "*%

#! $ / ! ( / / !

( ! #$ #! $ % * " #0 - / < #

# % -.0 *"

(%( #*0"

(

"%" *

( " #0 - * $ %

. #0 - " $ $*" " # "# (

"0%%< " 0 "%"#

%/ .0 *"#0 -* $ %00 *# .0 %#< #"0#

( %( % #$ /

#0%!( ! "0 #

- $ # % - "*% 0 - . :0 " **+ $ **% #$ " #$ "

- 0"

#*0"

( .* $ 0"-# 0#$0"

," 0*

**$.* ( " 0.# !$

%%%

=$ ** -

- 0" ".

*- 0* %* $#0 ! "0# ! !

( 0 .*%*0" $ 0 % 0"$ #F .

%0 * $ .

"% $#$/$ $## .* ( 0%$' "

*-$.

%$- *"

- %"0 ($ #0 > "$ <$% *% " 2"

2 .

< $%!% (%#

$/ %* #!/$ #$ :0 " "0%0% "0 .-$% / - " . ( $%*- % / $ $$ %*- $ ( @/! $ 0 "

" -

9 $ $ .

"'# -$% $ #!

/$ #$# 0%$%*-2"$

%*-/ -@#!$ 0"

-0. # $

(0 $#0* $% $ 0*

**$ $# $%" :0 "2"$ %*- / - *$0($ $ #0* $ % $ " $ A0"( $ 0 # 9/2)+'&1'

($0% ! /** ! $ @;.*'0%0 $# 9$5=$+$**0% !$/!$ 0"

-% ** *./$# "$%# , 9/2)+'&1;)+590% !$ 0/ " (*-/ $ *

($%/

" "

0" "

# 2"$.

# " !

/$ #$/ % "" # (- %/ -*-!$ $%/ $$"

< #%* "0"$#)$ !

A0"(!

**-!* " * "

/ $ (- %/ $%$- *"

-,$ # !$0$ "

0" - "

( $ % "

(

0% %*-1%/ )$

* "-.% "" 0"$ $#% -'

$A0"( $@;.*'0%0 ##"!$#

A0"( *-0$ * "

:0 $%*- /$ ($$ ("

-"0 ( #0B$ A0"( ":0 $#% -2"$"

$ %/ $%$- *"

3( "

($ 0".-$= ,"

!$ 0

"0. # $ (0 * "#0* $%" 0"$ * !$ % "".-$ = ,"

5 - *-$ !$ % %0*

$ $ %$ **.% "# 0 # .-"$ 5 - !2#%$%#

"# ( "

#%#

)$ ! " !$ "% $ %".

2"$"

$# (

%*-/ - *$0($$ #$ **($ -

$ !-$ 0 *"

/ $$ %/ - ##0 % "2"""

(.% """

#%#

, .

0 /** .* $"

#$ # # - "

*%#

*-/$ '

$ 0 / $$%/ $#

#%#

!/$

#:0 % #0* ** #

#2% / $*(/ (2% # , *-/ $ /

$2% # $%#

( $ $.

/2 - $ .( " $# ( )$ !$ % 0 (/- 2 #

$# (- "

#%#

$ ( ! $! $.

$ .* $ "$# - ($# (-# #*

% -/ $$# ( -$ (0"/$ "* -$ / $0# " % - / $$/# ( !$/0*"$ . - %$ = ,"

% " -2 - #$%/ -!$ " .# "" %%%

.-$ *=

@/!$ " -% 2""

0% -$# (-@#!$% # " - .

##0 $

" /** )$ $ %# *" $ )$# $ #*

$% $ $%".

2"" $%/ $%$- ." .!$ 0"

- 0-.

0"$% $# 0 # -0#$"

# >0 0#$

0- !$ /0*"!

**-!* - $"

# $ %* #-

(= -)$ 0/0*"

0 (

# $ -% #0* %* #- % #0* , / $ .!

( $%% !$ "

; #

(13 "

G1 3% .* G1