High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/3330/2014dismissed

Sachin Nayyar And ORS v. State Of Punjab

2018-03-14Mr. Justice Arun Palli7 pages

'() *!"

'), '--''

.(, (( /0

('(0 1'2 4 . (

(*5 %,'-'6.)'(6(,4(( %% 7''('660 1'2 % ,0%','1'

6.)'(6(,)84' (

-(, 4(( 6(,4(( 7(,(( :'. (,840:

...'(.

; !"62-<,),(,' .(')0( ,.(,'('48''))'<'8'.0(':' ((,4(( #'))0.& (,)88 '

)40

='.<(,

",0(,'.(,4(.(,)''8 :(, ),': (, >(.'(,' : ,4(( ,' :2 . (,-' !"6'( () <'0.(,(')0(<'.)(.('.10 (,8'((('.'(2- .

(,'(>.2-(,0('((,'((':6<(,(,'..) ( 0 :( 4'((.'( ,':'( ':' ((,4(( '8'.0(

? .'(. " !

6:(.'() ('( (-'7.'6()( ''

.,'6(, ,' :2 :(.'((, ('

) /,' '--'6<,('(.2(,4)(,'(4(( !'

6 '),

'--''

08('--'6,'.2<. ')8,'(,,7

5 5 '--'620(<, ,'(,<' .(,8 -6(,-8'.>)0 ( ((0 (6.0(<,),,'(,8' ..(02.'

. ')((, <'' ( ( '04'

),'-'((:((,8'(('8)'2- ((.620(<(,0('

-0( @0 (-6(,)84' (A'(,,'.:(:(.'

':' ('(,4 (4(( ''#(, '(0(,>')( )8'.0( (,'( (: .(' (, 4 (-

@0( B20(' .)0 (,4(( 4 (((,')((,'((, '. <' :(. ': : (, (, )88 ) "

6"C 6

6C =& ,A4 ( A: (('((,'( ! " !

6(, )84' (A'(,0 :,804'

.(.,8(,'(,<'0 ..4

.<'2 :,''.2-(,4(( '

.(,'(,,'.) 08.4

.<'- : ,'

)(',8,)84' ('

.,8(, (,'),.(,6( .,'(, ') .( 6)()',' :

2 ('7 ((,)',4('6,<'.((,4('6 ''

.,'6<,,<''.8((.'

.8,4)7(6<,'(('(.(2'

0). (6<').6('( :'<*5 D,7E08'F%:, '1'--'F0 ?6 .', -6'7.' >8 (,2')76,'. (. ('

':8 ( (8-,4 ,G') -<(,% 02', ,'

.). ,(-,G')'(7 8 -%-'( .2(, ,'8'-'

.2(,, 08('--''

'),

'--' F ,'8G''--' F0 "?!+6 06'7.'6 8,<6)'8(7 <'20((,('

')( '

.(,-'7.8(,'((,- 0.. -@0.8 -((,(0 ( G')6(,-,''

8: )-:'(,8 -((,82 :(,). ('6 86(,-'8-'(,-:'8'),@0<(,':. :

'(0'((,'((,-'44'),.8':' '

..8'

.. 04, G')8'

. (0 40'..8(,'((,-,'(0 8 < (- G')'((,'(42H, '7.((0 8- 04< (-') (,-)'8(8-,0)0-'

.2'( 8'

.(,'( .(78 ,8 -<'4..((,88(,'('

')( 8-,4 '8,)7.(>4 ) :0((.8'-'

..2'

.2,'0 )'4.6')'8'-2:(.':' ('(,(,'2 '8.

4 .F5,7E08''--' F.', -6''

.,' '.6 '7.'I ,'((,)84' (A'(,...0 :('(8 ('

.' 4 (, ':'( (, )84' (6 , ,'. .. .0 ( , ) 08 :4 002('

) '))0 (,''8 ('

5(0 8 -'((,,'

.4(( 6 ,'8G''--''

.,(< 6 4(( !'

,4),' : (0'-028((.'4(0

# &6(,)')'8(2)88((.((,0( '

(0'-.((,4' :(,840:

.. 40'(,,<(,'((,' .('0(,'4 .

(,'(8(,0). ((<')'(,'((,'))0.4 ,'.('7 '

,0:'80 ( ')8(,.)'.'

.<, ,.8'

..(, 8 -2')76,<': 2'( :'

.<'(,'( .6.0(<,),D, <',)7.I'

.)88((.0). ,62 :(,'((,.)'.6 (,0). (6,'.

)'-.((,2')7:0 . <,),,,'.('7 (,>(8(46

5"5 (,'(0(8.(,4 (,'((,<'0) (' '8 :'

),':(,)88 '

)40

='.

<(, "(, H,. :6(,10.:8 ()(.2-(,' .)0 (,'))0.<.0-.(2-(,(')0(620(,. :(,'( (, ')('

.))08('

)(,)'6(,-< ('44)'2 (, 0(6 % /7'8 ,'0.,'-6 ' . 0 6,'.':0. (,'(.'(,' :(,'( )40 ,'2

=)0.28'.0(84-2)'0(,.)'.,'. )88((.0).',<'':.-<.'(8 -62)'0- 4 ')(. (-(. ((0'( '

.(,68(, 44 (,'8(0'( <0.42'2- (,'('7 (,'8(4 .) @0 (-6(<0.2(,'((,10.:8 ((, 048 0( "#$"%

&'()6

# & #&=+?6 <,),<0.'44- ( (,'( (,'()'(,<''@0'2(< (, '))0.'

.(,,02'

.,(6<(,(,'))0.( :(,.)'.

(,'(,,0.AA:'

..AA<(,(,.)'.(,'(,' :)88((.

0). (,(,..'-'((,@0' @0 (-6(<',.(,'((, 0).<' ((,.)(0((,@0'

(, (, ,'

.6 % %','1'

6 ' . )0 (, )84' (6,''.04 '010.:8 ((, 0480( '<*5

5C5 !& *+ &', -' - 6 ! #"&

#& ??B & ) &'' ) - & ' ( .

- 6

! #"& #&? "B

& ' , -'- ' ,&'()- 6

!"# &G'<'.# & ! C'

"& /- 0, + - ' &'()6#

+& "

8(E'4A)'#04'&6(,'))0.4 <('(.

( ,' '0.0 (-2(' . (,:

'(0 (,.)'.6 <(,(, .)'.,' :.)0.(,42(- :'4(< .2-(, '8-'

.(,'))0.,' :(.(,.)'.(,'()(' .)08 (,'.

(2>)0(.2(,4(<'.604 <,),(,-<4'.'08

+'),'))0.'))04.(<8 (,:0 .(, ,0 (, .)'.6 ('- <(, , ) ( 02@0 (-6 (, '))0.0.(')'((,,06 (0'-'. :((,.)'.

44 : (.4 '

.)88(( :0).2-,'

: :, ,': (, )88 ) 40 ,'2 0 .

""+'

=(,<'8.':' ((,'))0.B<,), <),' :.2-<'-' 4(( 2(,,:,0( ,'(0(@0',.(,),':'8.0

=6 <,04,. :(,),':0 ""+ (,''.))08('

)6(,10.:8 ('

..(,

5=5 ,:,0(,. :(,'( )(,)88 '

)

=<'8'.0(6<'('.2-(,

0480(6<(,(,(')0(.)(.(4).<(,(,('

(8(,),':'8.0 .(,''.4 (,4 ()'6(,))08('

)'. :((,.'(, (,.)'.''.-,' :2 .)0.6 8-4 '6'48'

'))''8 :'),': 4)((,)88 '

)

=8'.0(':' ((,4(( 6(, 0). ((,.)'.6''(,)84' ((,)84' (2 :

4))((,)((,'((,.)'.)88((.0). '))0 (

') (2 :(0 .2-(,4(( ((,.)'.6<,), ('(.(,'2 : ((,8<, (,- ..(20(<(,(,(0

( ('7 : 4') <, (, .)'. <' . (, 8 -6 <(, ,''8 (()',' :2 ':.'((,,'

.(,4(( ( (,.)'. (0(, (,'((,.)'. :( "!.'(.

:(.'((,'84)('( '20(!J8 (,4( ,0).6': :(, (, )''.-.(, '26 (,':'( (,'( 2 : ('-((,'8)(','2

''(., '26<(,(,.)'.'('( :(, (,'(,'

., <,'.2 (,'( .<(,.'(,2- (,4(( '

.,,'.

02@0 (-2 2'( 042-(,4(( '

. ,':'( '8# )4- "!,'2 ''

>.'

>05?6<(,(,

5?5 4(( & @0 (-6 (,''.))08('

)6 .'20(-

(,840:

..(,' .(')0('8 :(,),': ':' ((,4(( 68'7 :0('

)40

= '.<(, "(,'

.) @0 (-6(,4(( .8.

<(,(, (8.')'(.,('0(<0.4).<(,(,(' 8(,(':(<'( <6(8'.)'(,'( (, :('(., '2,' 2('7 (2'

2'( (,0( (,8((,)' ':' ((,4(( 6<,),,'2.)..<,- (,2'(, . ).2(,'(0(6'2'( 8'., '2'

-.4'.40-62 :)84(- (,) (>('8 : (,),':':' ((,4(( K(((2 ().(,'((,0:,':08 (<'...

(,4(( (,.'-2-(.'-2-(,' . 0 6

!+6,<6(,8'((,'.2 '.10 .(-(.'- , @0(6(('7 (0)( '(<,(,(,4(( <0.7( <(,.'<(,4(( ) ((( 8(6'((,0(,'.>4.

(4 (,'((<' ( ) .('<((,''.' L !"

!+ !

):':