Swaran Singh v. State Of Punjab

 



 

 

 
 !
" #
  
"  



 " $"% &

'()* +, +

-. /

 0&& + $ 12 / &3

4  ' 
5!6'

+ " 7  &  



 !""#
$%"

 
& 

'

""#
( )#
 *"+ 

(!""#
$%"

 
%,&"" ----- " 7  *  

'

8) $9 .

/
/
"
"&&%"

%"

"0


"0/


 
"&&" 1" 2
 
"//
,

 
"&&%"#
 
/",
/ "!

("0


"0/

 
"&&"
/
%



) $9 ( 
"

"
%"/
"/
 

23


4
" 5


 /
"
%
"
""
'

""#
(/%
 
"

 "#

%/
 #
4 #
45#
45 #

6#
4 #
47#
4 8
3# &
"
!
 /
"$
+
/ ,,

%
 8



"%
"
"
!
""0
% ""
"%% /
$
,& 

"

&"//
+0
"
"
///
9  #
 
"

"#  "#
"#
 "


&
"
!
 /
"$
+
%  $

"
  5

 : 
4

"/
+ /
/#
 /

$/

%
4
"
!
%
47

 
,"

% 
"/
+
& 

23

; /
 : 
 
!"/
%

 /",

,
1"!
'" #
"/
&
!

#

/+"
 "" 

!"/
!


+/!"
&
/ "



& "
"#
' " %

/+"
 ""


,"
&
/
,

/
 
/"
&#

"
$
& %&0
 
 /0
 


'/"


/
1"% "




3
!"/
" 
 "
/"
'/"


#

%$"% ! /
"%%,&%/
:% 
$" /
"

,/

/
 
&&0
 


&//#
 

!


&&0
"/
/"
%,
 
 /
"
 " ,

$
 
&////

1
/+" /
,"
+""%
 "
'/"


"
/"% 
"
 
" / /
 

3
!"/
 
" 
 "

  8

#
'/"


%  ""



/ 
"
!
 0
"
+"<
&"&/


$"<""","
+ 
 

$


"&"%
"$


#
!

!"/
&/
 #
 ""




/ 
 
/",

1!$#
"
 '/"



 
$"<""","
"
%+0


/ 
,

/+"

3
!"/
" 
 "

 /
!"0#
'/"


#

%$"%
!

/
"%%,&%/
"


,/"&&&"
 
&
"

"%% 


"
 /
%% ,/"%/#

/+"
%,,
/ %

5

 "0
!"/
,"

"<
"%
"

"/
'/"


"
/
"%%,&%/  3"0#
23
!"/
 /

%/
 =

6
3 ( 
$/ "#
'/"


!"/
"/
"
+"/

/ /%/ 
/",#

,
"%% /
9"/$


/

'"",


!"/
"/

%/
4 8#
4 #
4 #
45#
47
"
45
3

!
" 

 



 
%"/

",/

!///
!
%

%



3
!"/
 
 "



"

,/
"
4 



"$ 

!""


&>
"
 7


"$ 


) &"


>
"
"



"$ 

<<"


"
+ :% 

.


%
%% 
 "

%"/
!"/
,"
 
"

"/
/" !""


&#
) &"


"
<<"


"
/
 0 !
&"%

% ,

 
% "">
!

"/
"
&
 %
5

!"/


&/% 
'/"


"
9"/$





%/

%/
 #

6#
4 8#
4 #
4 #
45#
47
"
45

3 4 ( 
"
"

"/
'/"


"
9"/$


#
, 1"!
"/#
%,&""
 
%"/
!"/
:",
"/
?



3
/,0
 : 
#
" 
23
$/#
/ 
&/
 " 
"%% /

'/"


"
!



&&0
"/# ",0#
9"/$


#
) &"


#
<<"


"
!""


$/
 
 /
"
 "
 ,

 /
 
/"

"

 
 "
 ,

$
&////
 
&


% 
/",

?

,
1"!
'" # &/% 
,$
"
"&&%"

%
 8
#
!

!"/ "!
+0
 
"
 
$
,& 

"

/ ,,
&
!""


#
+//
) &"


"
<<"




$
"%% /

"0
% ""
'/"


"
9"/$ 

>
"
&
"
!
) &"


"
<<"


! 
% 

  5


%/
 #

6#
4 =

6# 8=

6#
4 =

6#
45=

6#
47=

6
"
45 =

6
3   "  
"

/"
/#

/
%
+0
" 

 


% /
 "
 
&
!"/
 
",

 
23

"0
$
"% !"/
"+ 

,
3
!"/
 
%
 "
%,&""
"/ $
"#
$"


"
,+ /
" "/

"
",&

! 

+0
&

 
&//
%  
&


 #
 /
%
 "
 
&

"%
/
$%,
 
%,
"/

"

!
 
&"/
"/
+
 &#
"/
&%&"
"%% /
"

 "

,

/
! ,

.


"

,

/
! 
& !"/
:% 

4 

"
 /#

/
! ,
"
!
 /#
 "

" 
!"/
"&&"0
&"0
"

/

 /
"/
 "
 0
! :"
+0
 
3$/ "

%0

3
/
 
 
%


"
% /
 "
!


:%/
/
&!/

%
 #
 
"
"
 


"$

 
"

"!
" !
+0
1@+
 &,
 #
"/
&
!

/ ,,

& "/
"
""
"%% /
%"
+

0

/
"
%,&

%% ,/"%/
"
 /#
&"",/

"!
"$

+
! 5 A"
% /

 
&
"/
"/
+



 %
 /
 
 "
"


%  
"%% /
%  &#
&/% 
"/
""0
%% 
/
$%
+0
!
" /#
%"/
/
"
 "

 7 A"
% /

 
%,&""#

 
 
"#
"/ / &&
 
,& 

"
/ +,
 "
"


"&&%" %#
&
"
!
 /
"$
+


0
/ ,,
.

"
"
 /
%%
 "
3$/ "

%0
" :"
 
&
"
!
 /
+ 


/ &&
 ,& 

 
"
  8 3
"$
%/
/ +,///

+ 
//
"
"$ 
4
 


"&&"/
 
%
3

  

         

 !" #

!"/

+0
1@+  &,
 
 "
"
&/
!


/
/ ,,
"/
""
"%% / 
%
 8
#
%"
/<
/% 

%



?


 /
&&/

"!
!"/
% 

" % /

 
&
"
 
,
/"

#
"
% /
 
    $%&'  (  $"  %""     

)*) *+"

,

!

&,
* %"
$!
 

 %
 8

"
% /
",

 
+"//
 
/ ,,


+0
"&&0 
 "
,":,


   

,"/
 "
 "
+
,$#
/ % =
!<
"/

% 
&
"
&

% " 
 

&"//

%
 
!

"/
 

",
% /
!"/
"
%/; "
/&

 / ,, #
  #
 /
 
$

"

 8

"
 
&

+
,"""+

$!

(  $"  %""- . %/ 

,

 
,& 

&"//
+0
 
"
  
%
 8
#

 +
 "

 
23#
&
/
 ",

"0
$
"%
/
"+ 

,#
+ 
"
 
/",
,#
!   ", 
&#

"/
+
" 
 "
'/"


"
/ "%%,&%/#
"
:% 
 
"

,/

/
!



&//# 
"
/"
%,

  /
 
%"/
"
 " , 
$
 
&////#
!

,"
,
/
/
,"
+""%
" %,&
,

%,,
/ %

(  
/,0
"/
?

%,&""
1"!
'" 
"/
/&% %"0
",
 
& 

 


!""


#
"&"
,
9"/$


#
) &"


"
<<"



"
!
'/"


"
/"
$/  /

%"/ "
 " ,

 /
 
/"


 
",
"

$ 
&////
 
&

3
/
,&"


 "
"&"
,
%
 
3# &

"
!
!
 /#
"$

"/
+
/ ,,



%/ 
%/
4 8#
4 #
4 #
45#
47#
45
3
"
"


"&&"/ $%

%#
% 
 
$%
"/
%%
 

$/ "#
 
"
 

0
% 
 
&
"  /

 
&$//

%
 
3
+ 
"/

%

6
3
"

%/
4 8#
4 #
4 #
45#
47
"
45
3
" !
%

6
3
.


$%
%%
 
$/ "# % 
 
 
"

,

/#

 ,
+
"
4 


"$ 

&
!""




3
/
0

+
&$
 
"
"/ 
!

 
 "
"

,

/
!"/
  
"

,

!

 
/",
!"/
&% 

%,& /
,
 
%"/

!

 
 !"/
"
 
"

,

!

 
 
/"
"

,
!"/



"%

!

+"//#
&
"
!
 /
!"/
$/  / 
%"/
"
%,& ,

:% 
 
/"

"
$ &////

/
"/
+
 ,

 /
 #
/% 
"/
""0 %% 
/
$%
"
 /#
"
/
"
 "


 
%"/

 .


// 
 " 
/%&
"

:



&!
  

"" 
"0
&/
"/
"
"%% /
 

 
% /


; 0 

"

:%/
 
&!

/%
 8

"/
+
/
" /
+0
"
/ "
6%

1B+
 &,
 

43 +

-.0& + $ 12*:;

:  <

;)
! 

 


+0
" 
& %,

!22. !.

<2.   !

=.

 

.0& + $1 4 .&*:;

:  <

;

:+ ;89

4


$!
$" /
&%/#
1B+
&:
  / ,,"C
 
 "
&/

43+

-.5&%&:% 4&3;
 !
!/D  

 





 

 





   

 

     !





"   " "  

"

  

# 

   "

$! "   % ! 

"  

"   " 



  !

 

"

 

&

"  

 ! '   

!   

  " '      "   " "

  "    



 



' 



("
 "  "

" !"

 

    "

  " '      "  





"  '

  )   * "

 ! '   "

  

"

 

("  " "

  

 ""

   "



     " 



"!
 " 

 



 " " '  


!    

  '

"  

"

  "   " 

 

 

  

 









 


"

/"
"  0


/ "

6% #
1B+
 &,
 


!22.  !.

<2.

=.

5&%&:% 4&3;
"/
D 



"

 

  

" 

 



 ""

 

"

!" "' 



  

 "

  



 "





 

"

 '! ! 



"  

" 
5
 


 ' 

" 

" '    

 " 

&

"

!

 

 ' +  







"


"

 ' " " !"

" 



         " "

"

 !

, 

"

   +



   "

!

 

 



"

  "

"!"  ",
$!
"/
+
"
 +.

>=&.'

&.>& + $

4&.8:9;

:  <

;8)

 3
 




 "
&/
"/
"

/"
"
"&&0 /",

"%/
"
%% ,/"%/
 
&/
%"/
"
"/
<&
 $!
 
&/
&/
 "
"
"/
"% 
 
/"


 "

 "/, %
"/
&/% 
"/
""0
%% 
/
$%#
 /
  /


"0
"/

 

"0
 
,& 
/
 
/ ,, 
&

%
 8

"
 
 %  
&

/
/ % #
 
&/
$/
/
+0 /,// '()*  :" 7  ;






























" ?

 
"/=/&"< E/= ?

 
&"+D E/=

7