← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/26348/2024dismissed

Birsa Purty v. State Of Punjab

2024-09-10Mr. Justice Sandeep Moudgil8 pages

SHAM SUNDER 2024.12.02 11:02

          

 

"! # 

!!!!! $##

#   !!!!!#  %& !

# # &!

 

   

  



   

# &'

(  

     " # $

%&

 

%&

 # (  )   # 

 *   #

( $ +&

,  )% )+- 

). ,#    #



.

 

,  )% )+-

/ 





,



  "

 /

"  "

 

45( $ %6  ++ &% -&-2

+7 $  ' 

 

  +37% 8  

9$'

:;

-3



  ; 



" $   '

$



  45( 

)     

        

   

          

    !

  ""#$ ! %

&  '( )

*

& '(( ! ,- .

 / 0

!$ ))

(1  - 

   ' !   + 2     & &  &   -   2   & 3. 33



    &   *  !*    

   &*

 

/ ,*%% &*2 3&  0 023*&0*&  .

+* 1 5114 - 0 3&0 &

0

 *

6.+ 2 !

   . &



0.   +

 

  * )+  +*   /  ,*%% &*   

  + 020*

2 +  * +* 

  - 0 3&0 & 0.3.3 

*     

2 

  *

% 0 *     3 &  3*&0 2*- 0 

. && .   &30) .&

2 . +*     0  ! * 3

*    3/

     



    !

   6 0  8 +*.9 + : 2   3*&0 3   -   +% 0   ;0   *+     & + 020*

2 +  0

* & .

& 0   '

<<) '

<<3 =.

! 

3.

 +*   3 0  &   >*  

    , ?

  330      &  3  

0  3

&& & +   +* 1 14 *   6  ! 9@A: 

 !





0 &    33330 0 !  3.

. +*   3 0  &

&*0 && & ! *    020*2 + + 3 6 +6 + 2

&& & +*    

0  ! * 3

*   3/ 7  



!

 6 0 8 +*.9 + : 2 6 +  .

B 0 * *&

2 * 

B!

*   6 +   .

 

C 2 &* *% +3 +* "1 "

 *0 &

* 

+  * *% +  6 +3.

! *  +*    

 B*   .& 6!9@A:



! 

., ?

330 3 *% +,- .

  *3.3.

2

0  &

3.

  *&03 -  ;0 *+  *&  020*

2 +  0* *&  * * + 020*

2 +  0* * &   + 

0 +*  *    

3 *

   *0 - *

0 

03+ 0* 

 2  +   0   *   *  &    & 3 4  

   , ?

330 

  3  .0 + 0  &  *   * 020*

2 + 0 + + 3   3 .B8 *&! *   6 +  B  

  - 

0 

03+ 020*2   0    *   .

 &     &  3 

 

   , ?

330  3*3  

* *0  .

+ 020*2 + 

0 

*& B6 + 0  .

.

  -     ;&      .      

 *   . 0  .

. 0 0 

 *    

!

  ""#$ !   *

   !

3 

06 +  0 * 

60  ! *     B+ 3 *

0



03 *+ 020*

2 + 3 *

*0 

0.

.

&0 & *+ 330

 0 3  *+   0- 3. * * +

B3 

*   

 0     B 

  

0 * *&0

& *330 - 0 B!

  0     *    

        ""#$ !     *  

    36 +   %

    3  &*+0     &0  &  + 3  

0  +*

+ ;&   &   0) *

&

'(( !

   / ,*%% &* %

& &  &0 &  0 02

+*  1  .*            0*    3 

&  &       3   .        2 8 *&

0   + 020*

2 +

0

* & 3! * & 3 6 + 0) .&

3. 0 + 020* & 0  

 0-  0

 -

  & 0  3. 0&*. 0-   

      0-   &*.    0 0 

 0   .

 3 0- &*.

   &  0   +  

  3*    +  1(  C 6*

03! * = 11 ) 0* 

0- 3. &02 3&   + . 1(C&*. & 0   0- 3.

!  *  

  &*      &  0  +;    & 0  

& & 

  +-   & 0 3&  0 +;0 1(C&*.  .

 .&.&  0  &  .& 

 

0& 3 *  - .

 .&   

 6 +

  +-   & 0 3&  0+;

0   1(  C  &*.  

 

     .

  .& .&    .&.& 0  & .& 

 

0& 3 .& 

3 *

6   +  2 &     .&     .  = 0-   0

&&  & 0 3&  0+;0 1(C&*.

  .&.&   .& 

  02  0*  2  +   =  11 )   0*   0-  * &   

0 3 00*  !  * 

&0 0*   .

.6 +      

    !

      ""#$ !   *  .

.     !

*  &*0 0  & .  &  & 0  2

&1(C&*.& ! * 

( 2

&1(C&*.&  0.. 33 &* * "()<")"'( 60  3  =*  +    

 +

    3  )  *

&      '(( !  3     3  A=    +-  .

    !  *  * +-    0  *.+ +  .

    3  A=  & 0    &   +       

 

 +  330  .

+ -

0 .  0) .&

.-   

&  ) - 33

  6 0  

  !   

  6

 ""1 $ 

&  

3/ ,*%% &* 15 14 

&0  5)  & 3=* &0   A=  * +-    0  =*  0& 3A=+   +  3 0.) *

& '(( !   - <$ & & 0  &  & &

   

4  

 330 +

3  4*2 C*.

'"' !  .

 - 0 .D 5

 

  

< !

# .

/   =    .  

.  >  # 

 . ##  .  

%&

 )# 5 

  45(

? =  

  

 

@. 

#

 



 ## .    

    



 # 

  A 

   B =

   



 

##

 



 

2C

0   

  

% @      

 

'



     



##  .   / )  !



# #

 

   #

      



< 

  #

#  .

 #   

 

     .)



#     , 5  < #  # #   

  

 ? 



   

5 # ##  .

 



/    . 

     /



   #    .



 #    / 

  #    /  

 

  D   #   < / .   

 ?   





  



, 5       /  



!

 #

#    # 

   #

 #    /  . 

 

 



# # 





 #   

).  # 

  / 5 

 " 

 # 



2C

  

   

 



 

 

 .    / ##

 .

 

 2C



. 

 $#  33     +  0?

  )+  E9":

   0     3. 0 * "'#$9 3"'#:E9 : 33 &*

*  0  + 0?

F9+:& 00* 3 33 &* 3$G33 *  0 "' 0 

 0  # 333 --0..

0 >*   H +

+  +* E 9:  *+0 0*  +

- && *   && &&0 3*0

 9: *+0 0* &&   &&0  

0*     3       

  *  3  -    * 3*033     2  0..  33  +  : .   3+ & 03 0 * 9+:3 *+) 0 9":      . *   

3. 0 * "'#$9 3"'#:   

3  .

30   3+ D



    

    



2C

 

?

)

+&  # . B = ##

 

  # 



   

# 



#    

   +6  .  . 

 

 . 

 , #   "   

@       

 

++ 5 

  

 



 .*&   .



    

#   # +- @ #  # .  



# &

"!   8 &

2 

 I 8  &

I